Robin Hood Review: 2 Ups & 7 Downs

One of 2018's most epic trainwrecks.

By Jack Pooley /

Summit Entertainment

Though you'd be forgiven for not noticing, the latest attempt to build a cinematic empire out of Robin Hood is in cinemas now, as the new Taron Egerton-starring film arrives with...pretty much no hype or expectations at all.

Advertisement

Early reviews have torn the film apart, while current box office tracking points to a colossal $100 million flop for Lionsgate.

It's rather reminiscent of last year's King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, though Guy Ritchie's film at least had some sense of gritty inventiveness behind it, whereas this dreadfully cynical effort is an almost total creative flatline.

Advertisement

It goes without saying that this is easily the worst of the major Hollywood live-action Robin Hood films to date, with even Ridley Scott's underwhelming 2010 effort proving a far more competent and engaging sit than this basement-level slop.

To the surprise of precious few, Robin Hood sucks, and it's enough of a catastrophe that it's sure to end up on countless "worst of 2018" lists in a few short weeks. Keep your eyes peeled for that...

Advertisement

Downs...

7. It Tries Way Too Hard To Be "Modern"

Lionsgate

From almost the very first moment of this film, it's hilariously over-eager to fashion itself as a "hip", contemporary re-imagining of the Robin Hood myth, with grating voiceover narration literally telling the viewer, "Forget what you've seen of this character before."

Advertisement

The 115-minute movie that follows is a disastrous hodgepodge of things a studio executive somewhere thinks the kids want to see these days.

There's the ridiculous anachronistic clothing worn by, well, everyone - Marian (Eve Hewson) even wears a distractingly out-of-time leather jacket at one point - not to mention the at-times borderline steampunk aesthetic, and an historical context desperately reaching for relevance to the current political climate.

Advertisement

As for Robin Hood himself, he basically gets the now-typical Batman Begins treatment, attempting to make the character a sexy sneak, but almost 15 years (!) removed from Christopher Nolan's movie, it's hard to look past the aggressive cynicism of it all.

6. Taron Egerton's Surprisingly Dull Performance

Lionsgate

Perhaps the most surprising negative of the movie is Taron Egerton's oddly charmless performance in the title role.

Advertisement

Literally his first lines in the movie are mumbled with an unfussed enthusiasm, and throughout the remainder he never really seems comfortable in the role.

We all know he can be charming and boast plenty of swagger, as evidenced by his work in the Kingsman movies, but his performance here is weirdly lacking in energy, perhaps in a misguided attempt to appear brooding.

Advertisement

The idea of a young Robin Hood isn't inherently awful, but jeez, Egerton's enthusiasm level rarely rises above that of an actor contractually obligated to appear.

Above all else, his work is proof that studios love to jump on trends and actors while they're "hot" rather than actually stopping to consider their suitability for a given role.

Advertisement

5. The Awful Action Sequences

Summit Entertainment

As made obvious by the trailers, the action in this movie is bad. Like, really, really bad. For some reason Lionsgate trusted TV director Otto Bathurst with this monstrously-budgeted tentpole, and unsurprisingly he's evidently in way over his head.

Advertisement

Bar a few practical moments that nail an acceptable level of excitement, the busy, annoying set-pieces feel pulled right out of the mid-2000s, with Bathurst overdosing on speed-ramping visuals and needlessly frantic editing.

As a result, almost none of the action lands with the required impact - that is, any at all - and the film feels positively dated right out of the gate.

Advertisement

Ultimately grounding the action in a greater sense of realism might've served Bathurst better, because he clearly isn't ready to tackle this brand of high-concept chaos.

4. It Ruins Several Iconic Characters

Lionsgate

If you're a huge Robin Hood fan, you're best advised to steer well clear of the movie if only because it does such a terrible service to so many of the iconic characters.

Advertisement

Robin Hood himself is a dullard as mentioned, but most of the supporting characters don't really fare much better.

For starters, Marion doesn't have much definition as a character beyond being the eye candy and an object for Robin and Will Tillman (Jamie Dornan) to fight over.

Advertisement

Tillman is meanwhile a renamed version of Will Scarlet for reasons unknown, though you'd barely know it for all the resemblance the character bears here.

Dornan's snoozy performance does nothing to aid the baffling decision to reinvent Scarlet as an aspiring politician who comes to blows with Robin.

Advertisement

Moreover, the resolution of Tillman's character arc is sure to leave audiences raising their eyebrows if not straight-up gut-laughing at the silliness of it all.

The only character in the movie who really feels particularly true to the legend is Tim Minchin's Friar Tuck, who while a mixed bag of comic relief, at least isn't a random try-hard attempt at needless modernisation.

Advertisement

3. The Hilariously Bad CGI

Lionsgate

You'd probably never guess this movie cost a reported $99 million to produce, considering how absolutely shambolic the quality of the visual effects are for the most part.

Advertisement

Though some of the distant digital locations look passable enough, almost every CGI element during an action sequence looks laughably cheap and garish.

The most notably awful sequence in the entire film is a third-act horse chase, where almost every single shot features actors horribly green-screened into a background that wouldn't pass muster in the early days of the PS3.

Advertisement

Combined with the fetishistic use of slow-motion, the bad effects horribly date the movie from the outset, and if you didn't know better, you could easily believe this thing had been dumped in cinemas about a decade ago.

2. The Wildly Inconsistent Tone

Lionsgate

Robin Hood is fundamentally a movie that doesn't know what it wants to be.

Advertisement

On one hand, it's an achingly self-serious slog of a film in which it genuinely believes itself to be a gritty, hard-edged reinvention of the legend, but every so often, Friar Tuck will show up to drop a few goofy one-liners which clash harshly with some of the film's more brutal moments.

Similarly, the film doesn't really know what to do with Robin Hood himself. At times he's depicted as a chirpy charmer (though Egerton's performance is so flat you'd barely realise), while at other times he's so stoic and straight-faced it ends up unintentionally comical.

Advertisement

The end result is a film that, despite having only two credited screenwriters, feels like it was pushed and pulled in different directions by various creatives. There's no clear mood for the audience to cling to, so it ends up feeling rather schizophrenic.

1. Its Embarrassing Sequel-Bait Ending

Lionsgate

No spoilers here - though let's be honest, how much do you care? - but as predictably as the sun will rise tomorrow, Robin Hood of course ends with a sequel-baiting ending setting up a potential new movie and, yes, a Robin Hood Cinematic Universe.

Advertisement

The hilariously tacked-on final scene is a desperate attempt to establish a villain for the second movie that's never going to get made, and open up the possibilities of a universe nobody's especially interested in.

You almost have to admire their audacious optimism, really, even if it's going to date the film even more in the future, long after any prospect of a franchise has gone up in smoke.

Advertisement

So, Robin Hood is a terrible movie. A terrible movie with just a few bright spots keeping it from being decisively the very worst theatrical release of 2018...

Ups...

2. Ben Mendelsohn & Jamie Foxx's Ridiculous Performances

Summit Entertainment

If there are two actors in the movie who provide temporary relief from the relative blandness surrounding them, it's unquestionably Ben Mendelsohn and Jamie Foxx, who play the Sheriff of Nottingham and Little John respectively.

Advertisement

Mendelsohn is pretty much acting in a completely different movie to everybody else, devouring the scenery so voraciously it's surprising the film even has a set left to shoot on.

Straight out of the Gary Oldman School of Glorious Overacting, Mendelsohn's cartoonish performance is about as fun as the movie ever gets.

Advertisement

Though Foxx appears and disappears out of the movie semi-randomly at points, he also brings some agreeably manic energy to the role of Robin's mentor, selling John's fiery vengeance and honestly proving far more fun and interesting than Robin himself.

Their efforts sadly aren't enough to save the movie, but they at least seem the most in-tune with what the movie actually is, giving themselves over to the silliness and just having a laugh with it.

Advertisement

1. The Practical Action Has Its Moments

Summit Entertainment

Yes, the vast majority of the movie's action is visually incoherent digital nonsense, but when Bathurst actually slows things down a tad and focuses on Robin just firing arrows? It's not bad.

Advertisement

These brief asides provide some fleeting respite from the CGI-fuelled monotony, and as boring as Egerton's performance generally is, it's at least clear he put in adequate time training with a bow and arrow.

Watching him relentlessly fire off arrows at a fleet of incoming goons almost dares to be exciting, and it's as technically accomplished as the movie ever manages to get.

Advertisement

Again, this suggests a more stripped-down approach to Robin's heroism probably would've served the film much better.

What did you think of Robin Hood? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement