Sicario 2: Soldado Review - 5 Ups & 4 Downs

Entertaining yet underwhelming.

By Jack Pooley /

Lionsgate

Sicario 2: Soldado - or as it's known internationally, Sicario: Day of the Soldado - is out now in cinemas worldwide, and while far from the surging sequel some fans were optimistically hoping for, it is nevertheless a solid, flawed piece of entertainment.

Advertisement

How much you'll enjoy Sicario 2 will depend largely on how easily you can divorce it from what came before. It is, for all intents and purposes, a standalone sequel that makes just a few scattered references to the events of the first film.

Though that's a pretty safe move in order to open up the possibility of a wider Sicario franchise - yes, there's definitely room for a third film by the end of this one - the emphasis really should be on the word "safe" there.

Advertisement

Indeed, Sicario 2 will at least mildly entertain most who saw and enjoyed the original, though the law of diminishing returns is in effect from early on, and the film never quite ratchets into the same tenacious gear that the 2015 original did.

If you go for the visuals, the thrills and the performances, though, it'll steer you just fine...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. The Script Is Messy & Convoluted

Lionsgate

By far the most surprising disappointment about this movie is how hit-and-miss Taylor Sheridan's script is. Given the terrific screenplays he's written previously, this felt nowhere near as water-tight and far more keen to rely on contrived plot mechanics.

Advertisement

For starters, the narrative is frequently propelled forward by convenient events and character interactions, without which the entire movie would basically fall apart.

The main issue is with the central kidnapping narrative focused around Isabela Reyes (Isabela Moner), the daughter of a drug lord. She's pushed and pulled in so many directions over the course of the movie that it becomes borderline comical by act three, and the film doesn't sufficiently explain why that had to be the case at all.

Advertisement

It hurts to say this about a Sicario movie, but you'll honestly have a far better time with it if you just switch your brain off and accept the silliness for what it is.

3. Catherine Keener Is Completely Wasted

Lionsgate

The brilliant Catherine Keener appears in the movie as a high-up CIA official named Cynthia Foards, and though her Oscar-nominated acting chops make her a fine fit for the no-nonsense world of these movies, she's disappointingly wasted in what's basically a nothing role.

Advertisement

She has just two significant scenes in the entire film, though calling them significant is in fact pretty generous. She gasses with Matt Graver (Josh Brolin) for a few scattered moments and that's pretty much her entire underwhelming contribution to the movie.

The same could also be said of Matthew Modine, who appears briefly as the Secretary of State, but Modine's not exactly on Keener's level.

Advertisement

Given the void left by Emily Blunt's absence this time around, it's a shame Keener wasn't given a fleshed-out, steely female role to sink her teeth into.

2. The Third Act Falls Pretty Flat

Lionsgate

Sicario 2 is unquestionably at its strongest in its first half, when the various plot strands are slowly building up to what appears to be all-out war between the Mexican cartels.

Advertisement

Disappointing it is, then, that act three doesn't pay off most of its threads in particularly satisfying fashion. The attempt to connect the A-plot to the B-plot - the latter involving human trafficking - feels forced and clumsy, and several major characters end up behaving rather out-of-character from what we expect.

That's to say nothing of a final scene that's sure to be incredibly divisive among fans, depending on how you decide to read into it at least.

Advertisement

1. It's Nowhere Near As Good As The Original

Lionsgate

This shouldn't be terribly surprising to anyone, but yes, Sicario 2 is nowhere near as enthralling, dread-soaked or straight-up entertaining as the Denis Villeneuve-directed, Roger Deakins-lensed original.

Advertisement

While it certainly hasn't just been lazily churned out for a quick buck, it nevertheless lacks the finesse and smooth control of its predecessor, and therefore feels unarguably inferior.

It certainly can't have been easy for Sheridan to even consider writing a sequel to such an aggressively standalone movie, but it's tough to believe that this is the best he could come up with.

Advertisement

With all of these gripes in mind, however, here's everything Sicario 2 got right...

Ups...

5. Josh Brolin & Benicio Del Toro's Riveting Performances

Columbia Pictures

No matter the movie's issues, Josh Brolin and especially Benicio del Toro once again give splendidly slimy performances as the CIA's Matt Graver and operative-for-hire Alejandro Gillick respectively.

Advertisement

Brolin continues to be delightfully stoic and ruthless as a man who will do whatever it takes to get the mission done, while del Toro again brings the ambiguous gravitas and grizzled grit that made Alejandro the easy highlight of the original movie.

Even when the script falters, they're fully committed to their roles here, and manage to make even the film's wonkier moments at least somewhat captivating.

Advertisement

There won't be any awards considerations this time around, but it's remarkable work all the same.

4. The Thrilling Action Sequences

Lionsgate

Sicario 2 is a more action-packed affair than its predecessor, and while the set-pieces lack a little of Denis Villeneuve's precision - an early assassination sequence feels a tad rushed, for instance - replacement director Stefano Sollima mostly does thrillingly kinetic work all the same.

Advertisement

The shootouts in particular have a propulsive, unnerving quality to them tailor-made to keep the viewer on edge, bolstered by dynamic camerawork, atmospheric cinematography and blistering sound design (the gunshots are especially fantastic).

The action definitely feels more perfunctory this time and less in service of the focal drama, but at least it's sharply crafted and always entertaining to watch.

Advertisement

3. Isabela Moner Is A Compelling Female Lead

Lionsgate

Isabela Moner plays the movie's most pivotal supporting role, as the aforementioned daughter of a drug kingpin who becomes a vital pawn in America's war on so-called "terrorism".

Advertisement

Moner came to prominence after starring in last year's Transformers: The Last Knight, and naturally, that movie didn't give any indication that she had much to offer as an actress.

But now that she's appearing in an actual movie rather than an expensive fireworks display, she's given the floor to demonstrate acting wisdom far beyond her 16 years.

Advertisement

Given the tendency for child characters to stink up serious thrillers, it's impressive that her character actually adds an interesting wrinkle to the narrative. Moner makes all the right choices with how she decides to play Reyes, and on the basis of her work here, she just might have a bright future ahead of her.

2. It's Shockingly Grim At Times

Lionsgate

It would feel like an absolute betrayal if Sicario 2 was anything but depressing and grimly violent, and at least in that respect it certainly lives up to the tone of the original.

Advertisement

There's one especially upsetting sequence early in the film that's sure to haunt audiences long after the credits roll, and plenty more unpleasantness to follow over the remaining 100-or-so minutes.

While it arguably never quite reaches the soul-rattling heights of Alejandro murdering two children from the end of the first movie, it nevertheless feels wince-inducingly consistent with what came before from beginning to end. You won't come out of the cinema grinning, that's for sure.

Advertisement

1. Hildur Guðnadóttir's Moody, Intense Musical Score

Lionsgate

And finally, though the late Jóhann Jóhannsson did not return to compose Sicario 2's score - though that's completely unrelated to his sudden death - his replacement, Hildur Guðnadóttir, does a remarkable job living up to Jóhannsson's legacy.

Advertisement

Naturally, much of the movie recalls Jóhannsson's droning leitmotifs from the original film, but Guðnadóttir also expands on it with his own array of anxiety-inducing ticking clocks and pounding drum beats.

In honesty, you might not even know it wasn't composed by Jóhannsson without being aware beforehand, and much like the first film, the music here feels like a character in of itself. It contributes so much of the movie's unease and atmosphere that it just wouldn't be the same without it.

Advertisement

What did you think of Sicario 2? Shout it out in the comments!