Skyscraper Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
Die Hard without a brain.
Dwayne Johnson's new big-budget action romp Skyscraper is out now in cinemas worldwide, and to the surprise of just about nobody, it's scored decidedly mixed reviews from critics so far.
An uneven if mildly amusing child of Die Hard and The Towering Inferno, Skyscraper coasts off Johnson's easy charm and some knowingly absurd set-pieces, even if a far smarter and more ambitious film was clearly possible with this cast and these considerable resources.
It sadly doesn't ever reach the loony highs of Johnson's prior summer blast earlier this year, the dementedly dumb Rampage, but it's still easy enough viewing, even if you probably won't remember too much of it in a week or two.
If you're craving disposable popcorn entertainment you could do much worse - for one, you could see The First Purge instead - and if nothing else it delivers basically competent yet not particularly inspired thrills.
You pretty much know what you're getting with this one, so act accordingly...
Downs...
5. The First Act Is A Total Mess
The movie certainly gets off to a rough start, with a jumbled, messy opening half-hour that tries to do too much too quickly while racing towards the fiery spectacle everyone paid their money to see.
It's as though writer-director Rawson Marshall Thurber realised in post-production that he front-loaded his film with too many subplots, characters and scenes, and so shaved as much time away from each as he could without removing any of them entirely.
The result is a first act that inundates the viewer with an unnecessary flashback prologue, a ton of excessive exposition, dull family drama, outrageous techno-babble, double-crosses and death, and this is all before the actual disaster scenario properly kicks off.
This is all so frantic and sloppy that viewers might feel exhausted before the main attraction even begins, which is rather offputting.
4. Neve Campbell Is Disappointingly Wasted
Neve Campbell recently claimed that she stepped away from Hollywood post-Scream because she wasn't offered any interesting scripts, so there was at least a mild hope here that she'd get something interesting to do as Will Sawyer's (Johnson) wife Sarah.
Sadly that's not really the case at all, and it's clearly just a paycheck role for the actress. Her performance is absolutely fine, but she doesn't do much more than play the wife and protective mother role, spending decent chunks of the movie totally off-screen while The Rock's doing his far more exciting thing.
She's not entirely a helpless damsel-in-distress, but she also doesn't have a ton of her own agency and is just kinda...there. Campbell sells the material well enough, but it's a shame she doesn't have more to do.
3. The Wildly Inconsistent Visual Effects
Skyscraper has a sizeable $125 million budget, and given the VFX-heavy nature of the end product, that's not terribly surprising. It is a tad disappointing, however, that the visual effects are so ridiculously inconsistent throughout the film.
CGI fire is the main culprit, with some of the digital flames looking surprisingly decent while in other sequences it wouldn't pass muster in a video game.
Elsewhere more ambitious effects are applied to the skyscraper itself, especially in the movie's climactic showdown, though the quality of the CGI can't always measure up to the inventiveness of the action.
There are very few shots in this film that didn't require use of a green screen, and the effects range from relatively convincing to distractingly false without much rhyme or reason.
2. The Insanely Stupid Script
By far the worst thing about Skyscraper is its script, which is often so lazy and idiotic it feels like it was scribbled together on some napkins over the course of a lazy weekend.
It's incredibly cliched and contrived from start to finish, with stuff happening...just because. If you think about it for even a moment, the questionable logic and straight-up plot holes quickly become apparent.
Perhaps the most baffling plot point involves the skyscraper's security systems being linked to The Rock via facial recognition technology.
Considering how easily the terrorists subvert this measure, wouldn't it have made far more sense for the tablet to read the user's fingerprint for every input they perform? You'd think a building that cost a few billion dollars to build could hook that up.
That's just one example, and though you have to suspend your disbelief "because movie", the film as a whole makes little effort to have a coherent logic or actually string together a remotely creative or intelligent plot.
It's all supremely basic, algorithm-designed narrative beats intended to appeal to as wide a market as possible, and while that's not terribly surprising, it's still a bit of a shame.
1. There Are Way Too Many Characters
There are so many characters in this movie, and no real reason why. Considering the fairly swift pace and brief runtime, there are so many faces and names crammed into this thing, while very few of them have even cursory character development or names you're actually going to remember.
The most obviously unnecessary characters are Noah Taylor's security operative inside the skyscraper and Hannah Quinlivan's sexy assassin, the latter of whom just appears and disappears from the movie whenever it's convenient.
There are other examples: Pablo Schreiber's Ben feels like an afterthought and an utter waste of an incredibly talented actor, while a number of the Chinese police characters get a suspicious amount of time rattling off subtitled exposition, clearly aiming to appeal to the Chinese market.
Sure, it's set in Hong Kong and all, but these scenes still stick out like a sore thumb in a movie starring The Rock. By halving the sheer number of bodies in the film, it'd allow the remaining characters more time to breath and maybe, gasp, actually feel like real human beings.
Even with these big issues, the movie certainly isn't bad overall. Here's everything Skyscraper gets right...
Ups...
5. Dwayne Johnson's Rock Solid Performance
Pardon that pun, but yes, Dwayne Johnson gives a reliably entertaining performance as skyscraper security operative Will Sawyer. Though the script doesn't have him dropping hilarious one-liners every five seconds, Johnson does his damnedest to sell the intensity of the scenario and make the audience root for him.
Hell, Johnson's so magnetically watchable he even manages to make a sequence where his character holds together a wound with duct tape halfway convincing. Even when everything else in the film falters, he's the one unwavering constant: he has the audience in the palm of his hand and does the fine work his fans expect.
But seriously, Rock, would it kill you to be a little pickier with scripts in the future?
4. It's Guilty Pleasure Trash & Knows It
Skyscaper isn't really a film that winks and nods at the audience - which would've made it decidedly more entertaining, honestly - but it admirably knows what it is, accepts its limitations and presses on with a fairly earnest, shameless treatment of the B-movie nonsense it undeniably is.
There are no pretentious attempts here to say something about humanity and the sentimental family melodrama is actually surprisingly subdued for the most part, focusing instead on the high-wire suspense and Johnson battling an army of organised terrorists.
While few would call this film ambitious, even less would say it's trying too hard or embarrassingly trying to be something it isn't. It's pure cinematic junk food and embraces that enough that it's a difficult film to dislike too much.
3. The Amputee Action Hero Is An Interesting & Inclusive Touch
The least generic thing about Skyscraper is the fact that Johnson's protagonist is an amputee, having lost one of his legs in a hostage rescue gone wrong years prior.
While it's a pleasantly inclusive touch to have a big-budget Hollywood movie headlined by an amputee character - even if he's played by an actor of The Rock's incredible stature - what's more impressive is that it's not just a gimmick that the movie lingers on excessively.
The fact that Johnson's character has a prosthetic leg is barely ever addressed by any of the film's characters, and though a few sequences do involve use of the limb, it never feels like the movie is either making a joke out of it or trying to score easy PR points.
Basically, it feels like a natural facet of the character that isn't made a big deal of, and that's probably the most accepting and forward-thinking thing the movie could've done.
2. The Trippy, Visually Inventive Final Showdown
Skyscraper's final set-piece is at least a mildly ambitious attempt to diverge from a typical shootout or fistfight finale, taking place in a gigantic CGI hall of mirrors that ensures the battle feels different enough from the expected.
As mentioned, the visual effects can't always fully support and execute this vision, but it's at least an intriguing effort at something new, hurling the viewer into an entertainingly disorientating gunfight.
If nothing else, it allows the movie to deviate a little from all those Die Hard comparisons, with its visually elaborate climax steering in a totally different direction. Die Hard still did it better, though, of course.
1. The Snappy Runtime
Skyscraper clocks in at a lean 102 minutes, meaning the whole ride barely lasts 90 without credits, ensuring that for all of its many issues, it's a fast-paced ride that doesn't drag itself on any longer than it needs to.
In a time where so many blockbusters needlessly bloat themselves out to 2.5-ish hours, there's something to be said for high-concept tentpole movies that get in, get out and don't leave the audience checking their watches.
It may rush through that first act, but the last hour of the movie feels like a pretty tight disaster scenario, speeding through all the beats you'd expect and getting to the finish line without making the audience yawn. These days, that's an achievement. Bravo.
What did you think of Skyscraper? Shout it out in the comments!