Star Wars: 7 Perfect Performances & 7 That Sucked

From the Oscar-nominated, to the career destroying.

By Jake Kell /

LucasFilm

It's almost hard to believe at times that there are now eleven live-action feature length Star Wars films when for so many years we were used to only having six. The iconic franchise has been around for over forty years and has delivered some of cinema’s most treasured characters. With so many hours of film, there are actors giving great performances, while others give not so great ones. The range of literally varies from the Oscar-nominated, to the career destroying.

Advertisement

The franchise has a history of turning absolute unknowns into household names, whilst simultaneously managing to get the worst performance possible from an Oscar-winning actor. There always seems to be a huge risk when being cast in Star Wars, as the performance an actor gives could make or break their career (and has on several occasions). For better or worse, there's a long list of actors who will be remembered for the rest of their lives as the character they played in Star Wars.

Actors have managed to elevate the material and truly deliver something special while others are chewed up and spat back out by the franchise. Here's a look at some of the very best and very worst of their performances, ordered from the best to better and the bad to worst.

Advertisement

First, the perfect performances

7 Perfect Star Wars Performances

7. Donald Glover As Lando Calrissian

Lucasfilm

If the name Baron Landonis Balthazar "Lando" Calrissian III is mentioned, the actor that generally comes to mind is Billy Dee Williams who introduced the character in The Empire Strikes Back. But, he is of course not the only one to play the character, as actor/rapper Donald Glover was cast as a younger version of Lando in Solo: A Star Wars Story.

Advertisement

Recasting Billy Dee Williams was no easy feat, but it's fair to say that with Donald Glover they absolutely nailed it. Glover brings all his smooth charm and more to this younger interpretation of the character. Everything down to his delivery, mannerisms and even voice just screamed Lando, while also being able to avoid coming off as a cheap imitation of the famous character.

Glover gave audiences a peek of the Lando in his dashing prime fans have always fantasised about as he travels the galaxy in his immaculate Millennium Falcon playing Sabaac. While the jury is still out for many fans on Alden Ehrenreich's take on Han Solo, it is widely accepted that Donald Glover excelled as Lando Calrissian, giving a performance to make Billy Dee himself proud.

Advertisement

6. Ian McDiarmid As Emperor Palpatine

Lucasfilm

Ever since his first appearance in Return of the Jedi, Ian McDiarmid has made this role his own. In the film he plays master to Darth Vader and Emperor of the galaxy; the big bad who has been pulling the strings behind the scenes all along. The classically trained theatre actor McDiarmid wore heavy make-up and spoke with a chilling voice to bring The Emperor to life in a way that could have quite easily come across as over-the-top, yet he makes it work to huge success.

Advertisement

Cut to 1999 and The Phantom Menace where Ian McDiarmid returns to the franchise to play the politician Palpatine, but also the shadowy Sith Lord, Darth Sidious. His work on the prequels is even more impressive than Return of the Jedi as he effortlessly disappears into these two very different characters who come together to make one during the climax of Revenge of the Sith.

Emperor Palpatine goes down as one of the most memorable characters to ever appear in Star Wars, all down to McDiarmid's performance. The actor even returned in J.J. Abrams’ conclusion, The Rise of Skywalker, and despite not having played the character in a serious capacity for over a decade, once again he nailed it as the chilling Sheev Palpatine.

Advertisement

5. Anthony Daniels As C-3PO (Perfect!)

Lucasfilm

The voice, the movements, the comedic timing - all perfect! Anthony Daniels has appeared as C-3PO in a total of ten Star Wars films (more than any other actor) and has nailed his performance of the character in each and every one.

Advertisement

Although his face may be hidden and his body encased in golden metal, that doesn't take anything away from how successfully Daniels brings this droid to life. Star Wars was actually Daniels' first major role in a film after being educated in theatre and initially not being a fan of the Sci-Fi genre. The pressure was on Daniels with a lot of the opening act of A New Hope hinging on his performance as the campy droid.

Whether he's bickering with his counterpart, R2-D2, being shouted at by Han Solo, or even being carried around in pieces on Chewbacca's back, Daniels manages to be humorous, heartfelt and entertaining. It is worth mentioning that a large majority of Daniels’ screen time is shared with a dustbin on wheels who communicates in a series of beeps.

Advertisement

Despite that, and the fact that Daniels himself was trapped in a metal suit the entire time, his performance does not suffer in the slightest. In fact, it is largely down to Daniels’ interactions with R2-D2 that sell him as such a real character.

4. Mark Hamill As Luke Skywalker

Lucasfilm

Perhaps the most impressive thing about Mark Hamill's portrayal of Luke Skywalker is the range that he shows while doing it. In A New Hope, Luke is an immature farm boy with a heart of gold, who is desperate to find his greater place in the galaxy - which Hamill played to perfection. As Luke matured during the original trilogy, Mark expanded on his performance as the character struggles with the revelation about his father and the pull to the dark side of the Force.

Advertisement

However, the absolute best of Hamill's acting shines in The Last Jedi where he brought to life a different side to a character we had known for forty years. The emotionally troubled Skywalker has become a hermit on the planet Ahch-To after blaming himself for failing his nephew, Ben Solo.

Mark Hamill delivered an absolutely staggering performance that makes it difficult to take your eyes off of him in each scene he appears. It is no doubt that he was cast perfectly as the character of Luke Skywalker and has proven it with performances in three different decades.

Advertisement

3. Alec Guinness As Obi-Wan Kenobi (Perfect!)

Lucasfilm

Sir Alec Guinness holds the current title of the only actor to be Oscar-nominated for a performance in a Star Wars film and it's not hard to see why. Although Guinness famously hated the experience of making A New Hope and would openly criticise the franchise afterwards, that did not stop him from delivering one of the greatest performances in the entire saga.

Advertisement

The veteran actor seemed to be made for playing the mysterious hermit watching over young Luke on Tatooine. Guinness made clear in interviews his disdain for the dialogue in the film calling it 'fairytale rubbish' and yet he speaks it so eloquently you would believe this man has lived his entire life as a Jedi Knight. Guinness carries an enormous presence with him throughout the film which is unparalleled.

His performance laid a lot of groundwork for Ewan McGregor's equally impressive take on the character during the prequel trilogy. Even with a resume as impressive as his, Guinness will always be known most of his role as Obi-Wan Kenobi in A New Hope.

Advertisement

2. Adam Driver As Kylo Ren (Perfect!)

Lucasfilm

Just to give a sense of the calibre of actor that he is, Adam Driver recently got his second Oscar nomination of his career for his performance in Marriage Story. Coming originally from a comedic background having previously appeared in the sitcom Girls, many raised their eyebrows at Driver being cast as the new major villain in the Disney trilogy. However, he quickly made a name for himself in The Force Awakens playing the son of Han Solo, grandson of Darth Vader, with his performance as Kylo Ren (Ben Solo to his family).

Advertisement

Complex, emotional, and chilling - that is Adam Driver's Kylo Ren. He gave a performance throughout the sequel trilogy that was absolutely gripping from start to finish. He was easily the most interesting character to watch on screen and often stole the show from costar and protagonist, Daisy Ridley's Rey (Skywalker). He shared some of the best scenes of the entire trilogy with both series legends, Harrison Ford and Mark Hamill - not an easy task.

Driver managed to deliver not only one of the greatest villains, but one of the greatest characters in all of Star Wars. He gave us the performance we all wanted from Anakin Skywalker in the prequels, showing a conflicted, vulnerable character. He will now no doubt go on to add to his already stunning filmography and win many awards in the process.

Advertisement

1. Carrie Fisher As Leia Organa (Perfect!)

Lucasfilm

Carrie Fisher is Princess Leia and Princess Leia is Carrie Fisher - something the late actor used to say frequently herself. Born of Hollywood royalty being the daughter of Debbie Reynolds and Eddie Fisher, Leia Organa truly was the role Carrie Fisher was made to play. First exploding onto the scene in A New Hope, the twenty-one year old instantly captured audiences and made her character a cinematic icon.

Advertisement

Carrie brought humour, wit and intelligence to the character of Leia, allowing many of her own personality traits to shine through. In a time where the industry is still trying to have equal representation, she managed to do it over forty years ago. A damsel-in-distress, yet she is the one who ends up saving the boys on multiple occasions.

After appearing in the original trilogy, Fisher returned to the franchise in 2015's The Force Awakens and the subsequent sequel, The Last Jedi. The beloved actress tragically passed away before the filming of the series conclusion The Rise of Skywalker, but unused footage from the previous films allowed Leia to get a fitting send off. Fisher will always be remembered for the character of Leia; most certainly her career highlight.

Advertisement

And now the ones that sucked...

7 Star Wars Performances That Sucked

7. Benicio Del Toro As DJ (Sucked!)

Disney

That's right, Benicio Del Toro did appear in a Star Wars film, although you'd be forgiven if like many people, you had forgotten. When his casting was first announced, the internet was set alight with rumours about who the actor could be playing, with a popular fan theory being that Benicio would be an aged version of Ezra Bridger, a character from the animated series Star Wars Rebels. This turned out not to be the case and in Rian Johnson's The Last Jedi, Benicio gave the completely forgettable performance as DJ (standing for Don't Join, not because of his radio profession).

Advertisement

Like several others on this list, it seems like another case of a wildly talented actor being unfortunately miscast. DJ was a Han Solo-type rogue mixed with elements of a character you might find in Charles Dickens' Oliver Twist. Benicio played DJ with a strange stuttering voice which comes across as unintentionally funny more than anything. Although Del Toro has shown his comedic abilities before in films such as The Usual Suspects, here it doesn't quite work for him.

It also does not help Del Toro's case that DJ appeared in the heavily criticised 'Master Codebreaker' subplot from The Last Jedi that many viewers argue is by far the weakest portion of the film.

Advertisement

6. Andy Serkis As Snoke

Lucasfilm

Andy Serkis is perhaps the most talented actor working today when it comes to Performance Capture Technology. He made a name for himself mainly from his roles in The Lord of the Rings and the Planet of the Apes trilogies. Serkis however, also has plenty of acting experience without performance capture, including his character Ulysses Klaue in Black Panther to name just one.

Advertisement

Therefore, it is no doubt that he is a phenomenally talented actor who pioneered the motion capture performance (after of course Ahmed Best did it first). Despite all of this, something just did not quite click for him as the Supreme Leader Snoke in The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi. First being introduced as a fairly mysterious character, the true identity of which was wildly speculated on by fans for years until he was revealed in fact to be just, Snoke.

If rumours are to be believed, the character of Snoke was not completely nailed down in The Force Awakens until fairly late in production, with some whispers even that they originally intended him to be female. Even the design of Snoke was ever-changing, so Serkis did not exactly know what character he was supposed to be performing. Perhaps due to this or other factors, Serkis' performance in The Force Awakens is painfully bland and generic; completely opposite to the style and charm brought to Emperor Palpatine by Ian McDiarmid. Rian Johnson took the character in new directions in The Last Jedi giving the Supreme Leader more personality and substance, but before Serkis truly got the chance to shine, Snoke was cut in half by apprentice, Kylo Ren.

Advertisement

5. Forest Whitaker As Saw Gerrera

Lucasfilm

When news broke that Oscar-winning Forest Whitaker was joining the cast of the first Star Wars spin-off project, Rogue One, fans were rightfully excited to see what this exceptionally talented actor would bring to the film. Things took an unexpected turn when it was revealed that Whitaker would be playing Saw Gerrera, a character who had appeared briefly in the animated series The Clone Wars. Whitaker's actual performance in the film was, well... strange.

Advertisement

Saw appeared in Rogue One as a rebel extremist with major cybernetic enhancements, who had partially mentored and raised the films protagonist, Jyn Erso. Whitaker spoke his confusing dialogue in an exaggerated, raspy voice and bounced between emotions making his character unintentionally comical during serious moments in the film.

He was then quickly dispatched by a blast from the Death Star which destroyed the city on Jedha as the rest of the gang made a swift escape. Like many actors on this list, there is a strong sense of wasted talent when it comes to Whitaker's appearance in the saga. Since Rogue One, Whitaker has reprised his role as Saw in Star Wars Rebels and video game Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order.

Advertisement

4. Samuel L. Jackson As Mace Windu

Lucasfilm

The 90s was a great decade to be Samuel L. Jackson. He performed some of his most iconic roles appearing in films such as Pulp Fiction, Jurassic Park, Jackie Brown, Die Hard: With a Vengeance just to name a few.

Advertisement

Unfortunately for Jackson, the decade did not end on a high with his performance as Mace Windu in The Phantom Menace. An actor known for shining in high intensity roles was cast as perhaps the most boring Jedi to appear in the Star Wars saga at that point in time. The majority of his screen time was spent sitting in his council chair, spouting dialogue so dull it makes you question if this even is the same actor who played Jules Winnfield only a few years prior.

The most disappointing thing about Jackson as Mace Windu is the feeling that such a good actor was wasted in the role, due to a mixture of miscasting and poor writing. Things did improve slightly for Jackson in Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith where he debuted his trademark purple lightsaber and even engaged Darth Sidious in a duel before being killed by the fallen Anakin Skywalker.

Advertisement

3. Hayden Christensen As Anakin Skywalker

Lucasfilm

It's hard not to feel at least a little sorry for Hayden Christensen. As many have pointed out over the years, the material he was given to work with was hardly Shakespeare. As the stories go, at one point in time Leonardo DiCaprio was considered for the part of Anakin, but even for an actor of his calibre it's hard to imagine him successfully navigating those 'romantic' scenes with Padmé. In the end, George Lucas stuck to his trend of casting relatively unknown actors for the lead roles in Star Wars and hence newcomer Hayden Christensen entered.

Advertisement

Christensen appeared as Anakin in both Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith, with the majority of his criticism being levelled at his whiny attitude and monotone acting. He hardly channelled the same charisma as a young Harrison Ford or Mark Hamill had done years before him. Attack of the Clones was the worst of it for Christensen with a clear lack of chemistry between himself and romantic interest Padmé, played by Natalie Portman - even coming across as creepy towards her at times.

Credit where credit is due however, he certainly amped things up in Revenge of the Sith when Anakin finally became Darth Vader. But unfortunately, he will be remembered by most for his cringe-worthy dialogue about sand. Star Wars effectively ruined Hayden's career and since his appearances in the two films he has acted very little.

Advertisement

2. Natalie Portman As Padmé Amidala

LucasFilm

Natalie Portman sadly joins the ever-growing list of immensely talented actors who are completely wasted in the Star Wars saga. Portman has been delivering eye-catching performances ever since the age of twelve when she debuted in Leon, and it was only a few years later that she was cast in The Phantom Menace as Queen Amidala/Padmé. Her performance in the film, as well as in the following two, is unfortunately flat and leaves much to be desired.

Advertisement

As previously mentioned, the romantic chemistry between herself and co-star Hayden Christensen was sorely lacking. She stumbles her way through the cringe-worthy dialogue as best she can, but is ultimately unsuccessful. Not unlike Christensen, Natalie Portman manages to improve slightly in Revenge of the Sith, but even her death scene feels like a wasted opportunity and fails to pack the emotional punch that it should.

Luckily for Portman, she has not allowed the franchise to destroy her career and has continued to star in films over the years both dramatic and blockbusters. She won the Academy Award for Best Actress for her role in Black Swan and is currently scheduled to return to the MCU in Taika Waititi's Thor: Love and Thunder.

Advertisement

1. Jake Lloyd As Anakin Skywalker

Lucasfilm

They just can't seem to get Anakin right, can they? Now, it is extremely harsh to be overly critical of a child actor's performance, but young Jake Lloyd was just plain bad in The Phantom Menace. When George Lucas promised the origin of a young Darth Vader, seeing the kid from Jingle All the Way shout 'yippee' multiple times was not what the fans expected.

Advertisement

When making The Phantom Menace, George Lucas was very set on casting a younger actor for the role of Anakin rather a young adult, the likes of which he relied on in his original trilogy for Luke and Leia. Although Lloyd had plenty of boyish charm about him, his acting ability came up short in the film.

He was nominated for an infamous Razzie (Gold Raspberry Award) for Worst Supporting Actor, only being beaten by co-star Ahmed Best for his role as Jar Jar Binks. Like many actors in the prequel trilogy, Lucas' frequently criticised writing didn't exactly help. It's hard to imagine any young actor being able to successfully deliver lines such as ‘are you an angel?' or 'I'll try spinning. That's a good trick'.

Advertisement

What's even worse is that Lloyd suffered intense bullying for his performance in the film at his school and also from fans forcing him to retire completely from acting only two years later in 2001. Since then, Lloyd has been in trouble with the law after multiple arrests and his mother has confirmed he suffers from schizophrenia and spent time in a secure psychiatric facility.

Which other performances belong on this list? Share your own thoughts below in the comments thread.

Advertisement