Star Wars: Rogue One - 10 Ways It Changes A New Hope

The original Star Wars takes on a whole new meaning with the release of this once untold story.

By Noah Dominguez /

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is an absolutely phenomenal film, there is no denying that. In addition, shortly after the movie's release, many have turned to the original, Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope, to see just how well Rogue One fit in, and it does so seamlessly.

Advertisement

Not only that, but Rogue One has actually opened up an entire new world of perspective in regards to the original Star Wars, filling in plot holes, creating wonderful tie-ins and all and all just making it all feel like one massive, continuous story.

After seeing Rogue One, A New Hope is a film that you will likely never look at quite the same way ever again, and these are just ten examples as to why.

This article contains spoilers for Rogue One. So if you have yet to see it, you have been warned.

10. The Boarding Of The Tantive IV

The iconic opening scene that kicked off the Star Wars saga nearly forty years ago takes on a whole new meaning, given how the events of Rogue One had literally just taken place.

Advertisement

Probably just a few hours to a day at most before this scene, Jyn Erso and Co. had just given their lives in a successful effort to steal and transmit the Death Star plans, which were now in the custody of Princess Leia. As a result, the entire scene now feels far more urgent than it did before. Leia's cover story of being on a diplomatic mission sounds even more like a last minute lie, as she obviously did not have much time to prepare for Darth Vader's arrival.

Speaking of Vader, it appears that he is far angrier in this scene than previously thought. He does come off as more reserved in comparison to the slaughter he committed in the final minutes of Rogue One, but that makes sense, as he appears to have gotten most of the initial anger out of his system.

Everyone in this scene, from Leia to the Rebel soldiers, to C-3PO and R2-D2 feel incredibly on edge. Which is understandable, considering all that had happened not long before. In addition, 3PO's line of; "There'll be no escape for the princess this time." suddenly fits in with everything much better, considering we now know he was referring to what had transpired only several hours beforehand.

9. The Empire's Competence

One of the most glaring (literal) plot holes that has bothered Star Wars fans for decades, is how the Empire, the ultimate military force in the galaxy, could allow such a potentially devastating flaw in their supposedly all-powerful super-weapon. Rogue One fills us in, as it turns out that the flaw in the Death Star was not naive oversight on the part of the Empire, but rather sabotage of the main reactor by Galen Erso, a traitor with the Empire's trust.

Advertisement

As one of the main designers of the Death Star, Galen was able to have the small exhaust port included with no issues whatsoever. As a standard exhaust port is something that no one would have any reason to take issue with. Even then, the exhaust port would be inconsequential, had it not been for his tampering with the main reactor, which is, in fact, what would cause the ultimate explosion a la Luke Skywalker's proton torpedo.

This was not incompetence on the part of the Empire, it was someone on the inside setting them up to fail right under their noses. Now, they now come off as a much more believable threat in regards to battle strategy given this information.

Also, as an added bonus, the Empire's decision to build a second Death Star in Return of the Jedi suddenly makes a lot more sense, since they knew that the only reason the first one failed was because of the aforementioned sabotage.

8. Darth Vader's Behavior And Musings

Despite his relatively restrained nature in the opening scene, Vader still appears to be very high-strung throughout the duration of the film. He's not going on an absolute rampage like he did at the end of Rogue One, as again, that likely served as a way for him to vent, but he still has absolutely no problem choking a rebel to death with minimal effort.

Advertisement

While it's not always overt, it now very much seems like Vader is running on an adrenaline high after the events of Rogue One. This is apparent by the aforementioned choking of a man to death during an interrogation, his merciless killing of Obi-Wan which was preceded by self-indulgent gloating, and his haste in taking to his fighter to put a stop to the assault on the Death Star himself. Vader is absolutely furious that the Rebel Alliance got the best of him and managed to escape with the plans, and is determined to not let such a defeat befall him again.

In addition, certain quotes and reflections the Sith lord has throughout the film now seem to feel much more at home. Most notably, his line similar to that of C-3PO's, in which he proclaims to an Imperial officer that "There'll be no one to stop us this time." We now know that he was referring to what had just taken place on Scarif.

7. R2-D2's Secrecy

Throughout the early goings of A New Hope, R2-D2 is something of a painfully stubborn little spy, not sharing his mission of delivering the Death Star plans with even his closest companion, C-3PO. In addition, he tricks Luke into turning off his projector to keep him from seeing Leia's message, as well as sneaks off in the middle of the night to search for Obi-Wan and complete his objective. All of this, of course, is much to the frustration of 3PO and Luke.

Advertisement

However, given the events of Rogue One, R2's behavior now feels much more logical, especially from his perspective. Given the countless number of rebels who had just died on Scarif in the effort to steal plans, plus the ones who were slaughtered like fish in a barrel by Darth Vader while trying to get them to Leia, it's understandable that he would rather nobody know that he was now their custodian. And that means nobody.

Re-watching A New Hope with this in mind makes R2's behavior come off as smart strategy (despite his phsyical limitations), as opposed to just obnoxious stubbornness.

6. Tarkin's Arrogance In Not Evacuating

Another point of criticism for A New Hope has been Grand Moff Tarkin's brash arrogance during the assault on the Death Star. Many have deemed this as foolish over-confidence, but Rogue One tells us that this is far from the truth. Was he over-confident? Arguably. But it was far from foolish. In fact, had it not been for Galen Erso's actions, he would have been absolutely justified in his refusal to evacuate the base.

Advertisement

As stated before, the Death Star's only weakness was a result of an inside job, something Tarkin was completely unaware of and could not have planned for. The only two imperial officers who knew of the sabotage, were Galen himself and Director Krennic, both of whom perished during the events of Rogue One before the information could get back to Tarkin.

Moreover, Tarkin's attitude towards the Death Star in Rogue One tells us a lot as well. The sheer amount of pride that the Grand Moff had, which we had only gotten a glimpse of in A New Hope (while he made an example of Alderaan), was now on display in full force. The Death Star was so destructive, Tarkin had both Jedha and Scarif fired upon on the station's weakest setting, and yet it still caused cataclysmic devastation. The Death Star created something of a God complex for Tarkin, and he refused to entertain the idea that it could be destroyed. And given what we saw in Rogue One, who could honestly blame him?

He truly felt that the Empire would win the day, a point driven home by his "moment of triumph" line, and had it not been for Galen Erso, they would have. The rebels discovered the port to the main reactor on their own, sure, but this information would have been utterly useless to them had they not learned of Galen's tampering through Jyn.

5. The Rebels' Will To Fight

Throughout their appearance in A New Hope, the Rebel Alliance seems willing to take the fight directly to the Empire, no matter what the cost. However, the first two acts of Rogue One tell a very different story. Many were disillusioned with the cause, disgusted with themselves and some of the heinous orders they've had to carry out, and were beginning to feel the apparent hopelessness of fighting the Empire. In short, they were just about ready to give up the fight.

Advertisement

It was the sacrifice of Rogue One that caused their change of heart.

The rebels' original motivation of simply wanting to restore freedom to the galaxy is all well and good. However, now knowing that they were doing what they did to honor those who gave their lives just to give them a fighting chance makes their drive and determination mean so much more.

Despite impossible odds, Rogue One made the ultimate sacrifice just to keep that one tiny spark of hope alive. Because of this, the surviving rebels were more than prepared to make the same sacrifice to complete the mission of their fallen comrades.

4. The Size Of The Death Star Assault Team

Continuing from the last point, the rebels having such a small team for the famous assault on the Death Star now seems much more fitting, given the fact that a sizable portion of their forces had just been wiped out during the Battle of Scarif. During said battle, we see an absolute fleet of X and Y-Wings, most of which would be destroyed while Rogue One fought below to retrieve the Death Star plans.

Advertisement

When it came time to attack the Death Star directly, thirty one-man fighters were all the rebellion had left to spare for the battle that would decide the very fate of them, and their cause. Worse yet, all but three ships (the Millennium Falcon excluded) would meet their bitter end over the course of the assault.

The attack on the Death Star truly was an all or nothing gamble for the rebels, sending what small amount of men they had left in a last ditch effort to get the job done. The job not being to win the war against the Empire, but merely to survive another day.

3. Stormtroopers' Inability To Hit Targets

Donnie Yen's character in Rogue One, Chirrut Îmwe, was nothing short of brilliant. In addition, his strange Force prayer that he recites throughout the film may just hold the key to justifying one of Star Wars' longest standing points of criticism.

Advertisement

For years, the stormtroopers' apparent ineptitude when it came to firefights has been the subject of mockery among fans. This, of course, all goes back to A New Hope, in which the Imperial soldiers were completely unable to hit the film's protagonists with their blasters, despite them having perfectly clear shots throughout the movie and our heroes being sitting ducks at times. So what gives?

Well, Îmwe's story seems to provide us with an answer. In Rogue One, despite his blindness, the swordsman is able to not only effectively dodge each blast that came his way, but walk through a chaotic battlefield without so much as being grazed, all while proclaiming "I am one with the Force and the Force is with me." He is only finally hit and killed after making it across the firefight unscathed and flipping the switch that would help make the rebels' mission a success. His dying words are "I fulfilled my destiny."

Provided this was the intention, this information changes everything. This tells us that, when the Force is involved, not even the most highly trained soldiers in the entire galaxy can keep someone form their purpose. How did Luke Skywalker and company mange to remain un-shot for so long? Because they hadn't fulfilled their destiny yet, and the Force was going to help make sure they did.

2. The Destruction Of The Death Star

Because of the information given to us in Rogue One, the ultimate destruction of the original Death Star in A New Hope retroactively becomes one of the most emotional moments in all of Star Wars. Rogue One gave everything, up to and including their lives, for a chance. A chance and nothing more. A chance that maybe what they did could help the rebellion succeed. They clung to the last bit of hope there was all the way to the bitter end, just to buy a little more time for everyone else... and it payed off.

Advertisement

It was because of the bravery and selflessness of Rogue One, that Luke Skywalker was even given the chance to go on his iconic mission. As it has been implied many times before on this list, had it not been for Rogue One's theft of the plans, the rebellion likely would have crumbled, and the assault on the Death Star would have never even been attempted.

The Death Star's destruction was not only Luke's moment of triumph, but also, and arguably more so, that of Rogue One. The last will and testament of those previously unsung heroes was what made the rebellion's finest hour a possibility.

The Force truly was with Rogue One, and you could bet that somewhere, they were smiling when the Empire's ultimate weapon, the one they had given their lives to stop, went up in flames.

1. The Title

When the original Star Wars film was re-branded as "A New Hope" four years after its initial release, everyone assumed this was referring to Luke Skywalker. And how could they not given the content of the film? However, after Rogue One, this title takes on a whole new meaning.

Advertisement

Throughout Rogue One, we are constantly reminded that rebellions are built on hope, and that everything the characters are doing are anything but a surefire success plans. They do what they do in the name of hope. This culminates in Leia's line that closes the film, in which she receives the stolen Death Star plans. When the rebel who gave her the transmission asked what had been delivered, she replied with simply "hope." The hope that one day the sacrifices made to steal those plans would be worth it.

Well, that day would come sooner than they may have thought, as the assault on the Death Star would come shortly after the events of Rogue One concluded.

This begs the question: Was this new hope really Luke, or was it what came of Rogue One's first and last stand? Sure, the obvious answer is that the content of this new film simply and deliberately played on the title of the old one, however this creates a brand new perspective and meaning to said title.

Rogue One is a film that feels so much bigger than itself. And the fact that this story was right under our noses this entire time, and that it creates an entire new point of view to look at the original Star Wars from, including its very title, makes it truly feel like a perfect story that was more than worth telling.

How has Rogue One changed A New Hope for you? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement