The Batman: 10 Actors Who Should Replace Ben Affleck

Who will play the Dark Knight for Matt Reeves' DC movie?

By James Hunt /

Warner Bros

It's once again time to find another Batman.

Advertisement

Five actors have played the character since Tim Burton's Batman in 1989, but with Ben Affleck now definitely out of Matt Reeves' upcoming solo film on the character, there now needs to be a sixth.

In fairness, this has been a long time coming: the writing for Affleck's departure has been on the wall since he stepped down as director in January 2017, with Reeves replacing him just a month later and looking to put his own spin on things. Since then there's been a lot of hearsay about what Reeves wants and whether Affleck would be involved, but now we at least know the Batman v Superman star won't return.

Advertisement

As for what Reeves wants, that's slightly murkier. We do know for certain that he's planning on a noir-ish tale that really puts the focus on Batman as the World's Greatest Detective, a key aspect of the character the movies haven't really gotten into. It's also been widely reported he wants someone a fair bit younger than Affleck (who's 46), and most like ranging from 25-35, so we're mostly sticking to that sort of age range here. Other than that, anyone is under consideration to don the cape and cowl.

10. Jake Gyllenhaal

Warner Bros.

Instantly breaking the age rule, but then who wouldn't break rules for Jake Gyllenhaal? The actor has been linked to the role of Batman for a long time now, and while that may or may not go anywhere, the casting is lodged in the brain and remains one of the best options on the table.

Advertisement

Gyllenhaal has proven himself as an actor able to fit into just about any role over the last decade or so, from the unhinged Lou Bloom in Nightcrawler to his haunted turn in Prisoners, but he's also got charm to spare too. He's no stranger to comic books either, having agreed to take on the role of Mysterio in Spider-Man: Far From Home. That movie may be pretending he's a good guy in its trailers, but he should actually be one in The Batman.

Far from just a conventional good-looking leading man, he's shown how adept he is at jumping between different genres and character types, always finding something interesting and new to say with each one, while he'd be capable of imbuing Bruce Wayne with that slight otherness necessary to go against his ridiculous handsomeness.

Advertisement

As seen by Southpaw, he can bulk the f**k up if required to be a physical match for just about anyone, but he'd also be a great fit for a more nuanced, introspective detective take on the character too.

[James Hunt]

Advertisement

9. Liam Hemsworth

Amazon Studios

With Chris Hemsworth playing the God of Thunder in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, it's only fair that his lovely brother Chris Hemsworth gets a look in on some famous properties at some point, with his previous roles in films like Independence Day: Resurgence and The Expendables 2 being the perfect warm up to the sort of blockbuster franchise Batman would offer.

Advertisement

Dark, mysterious, and a pretty good dupe for a young Ben Affleck, Liam embodies Bruce Wayne's looks to a tee, as well as having the action experience on the set of The Hunger Games' dystopian future. His feature as Gale proved his capabilities as a brooding, troubled individual with a lenience towards violence, something that can be channelled perfectly into his take on Batsy.

And if he does get cast, that's the whole Hemsworth family sorted for massive, blockbusting roles that will define their careers forever. Wait, what? There's a third one? Never mind...

Advertisement

[Ashleigh Millman]

8. Timothée Chalamet

Sony Pictures Classics

Timothee Chalamet is one of the hottest stars in Hollywood today, and I’ll be the first to admit that, at a glance, nothing about him screams “he should be the next Batman!”. But, if WB are indeed attempting to break the mould a little bit, casting a younger actor in the role and focusing more on the character’s intellect and development into a superhero, then Chalamet has the ideal amount of outward confidence and charm, yet ability to channel demons bubbling under that exterior, to bring that version to life.

Advertisement

His role in Beautiful Boy, as a troubled drug addict living under the veneer of a perfect life, is proof he can expertly walk the fine line between dual identities. The way he plays both halves of a personality in that film, one a junkie completely absorbed in his own vices, and another an outwardly happy, smart young man with his whole life ahead of him, acts as the narrative backbone of the whole thing. He’s great at showcasing the moment when the mask slips, where his true personality shines through the false image of himself he’s constructed.

Also, don’t tell me he wouldn’t be fantastic as a cocky young billionaire. Just look at him, there’s already such a precocious air around Timothy Chalamet the actor that’s perfect for a younger Wayne dealing with his parent’s death and coming into his fortune.

Advertisement

And yeah, he might not have the Batman jaw, but if he got the role, all we'd be talking about from there on would be Batman’s cheekbones.

[Josh Brown]

Advertisement

7. Robert Pattinson

Jordan Strauss/AP

Honestly, let's not pretend that Robert Pattinson wouldn't be perfect as Batman for his jawline alone. Long gone are the days of his sparkly skin and vampiric tendencies and he's now an indie film darling with a healthy, appropriately aged following, and a back catalogue of movies that prove he can handle nuance and variance. From intellectual adventurers, to small-time criminals, to a dynamic redneck, Pattinson has proven since his Twilight years he's got some serious chops. And again, a really nice chin.

Advertisement

Whilst he might need to shovel on the #gains for a role as the particularly hench Batman, Pattison has continuously proven his commitment to changing for roles - the likes of The Lost City Of Z as a great example - and his suave good looks and intensity would work well to young billionaire Bruce Wayne's favour, too.

Pattinson is even keen to play a superhero himself, having previously stated that “I’m desperately trying to get a superhero movie now.” Everything good is worth waiting for, and Pattinson has done a solid seven years of it whilst improving his brand in the process. Having had time to grow and develop in the industry as well as shake the baggage of 'that Twilight guy' from his name, Pattinson could be a perfect fit for Affleck's protege, if he's given the chance.

Advertisement

[AM]

6. Adam Driver

Focus Features

Ok, yes, there are a couple of points that stand in the way of Adam Driver being a 'typical' Batman pick. One is that, while he's far from ugly, he isn't considered handsome in the conventional movie star sense (and yet is obviously still more handsome than most people you'll see in the street), and the other is that he's usually been pegged for a comic book villain, from being approached to play Lex Luthor in Batman v Superman, to many having him atop their Joker wishlist.

Advertisement

But all of that simply works in his favour. The idea of someone more well-known as a villain portraying the hero is not only great, but somewhat embedded in Batman casting (Keaton and Beetlejuice, Kilmer and Heat, Bale and American Psycho, Affleck and The Town). The unconventional looks just add to that: he's looks different to anyone else we've seen in the suit, but can still pull off a tuxedo as Bruce Wayne.

More to the point, though, is that Driver is a generational talent. There are few actors who can match the range he has, from the tormented Kylo Ren to the thoughtful Paterson. Look at the way he portrays the inner-conflict of Kylo Ren - which is proof he can do action and lead a blockbuster - and imagine that darkness funnelled through a hero. The sexual prowess, intellect, and self-absorption of Adam in Girls also lends itself well to Bruce. The work undercover in BlackKklansman, and how he's so easily able to play both sides and remain incredibly charming throughout? Yeah, he can do detective work too. Adam Driver can do it all, so he can certainly do Batman, and at 35 he's still (just) within the right age frame as well.

Advertisement

[JH]

5. Riz Ahmed

Sony

Forgetting about Venom for a second (because, really, did anyone other than Tom Hardy come out of that movie looking golden?), Riz Ahmed has done nothing but deliver constantly unpredictable performances across his career. His America-breaking role in Nightcrawler was one built on nervousness and fallible likability, while he’s just as capable of putting in turns as seemingly ordinary people obscuring dark secrets.

Advertisement

Physically, he might not initially seem like an obvious choice for Batman. The character is usually envisioned as a hulking predator of the night, whereas Ahmed is lean and scrappy. That said, if it’s true that WB are planning on focusing more on the hero’s detective work and capabilities, Ahmed is more than right to embody a Batman who’d rather use his brain than his fists to solve a problem.

The image of Ahmed’s Wayne being on the trail of a killer, mulling over evidence and crime scenes can easily be envisioned based on the kind of dark stories the actor has mostly been a part of, and would be the kind of breakout lead role the always-stellar actor deserves.

Advertisement

[JB]

4. Nic Hoult

Matt Sayles/AP

Nic Hoult is no stranger to comic book movies, having starred in three X-Men movies and counting as the Beast, but it’s not a role that makes full use of his considerable talents, which have been on display ever since About A Boy.

Advertisement

Since his transition to an adult star, from Skins onwards really, he’s shown that he can do charming, and he has the good looks to fill Bruce Wayne’s line of tuxedos, but with a slight oddness to him too that would make him an appealing fit as the character, especially in his early years.

He’s got the range, too: he can be suave or nerdy, cool as you like, completely deranged, or the absolute banter merchant of his turn in The Favourite, which was horribly overlooked this awards season. His filmography isn’t extensive but it is eclectic, and shows he could give a quiet, thoughtful take on a younger version of Bruce just starting out, and impress in the suit too.

Advertisement

He’s got the height, and although he’d need to bulk up, there’s nothing to suggest he isn’t capable of doing so, and he might not even really need to either - a more slimline Bats could work perfectly for a noir-driven detective tale when the onus is on solving clues, not punching bad guys. He doesn’t have the same chiselled jawline you’d expect from a Batman actor, the work he could do with the expressiveness of his eyes under the mask would more than make-up for it. Hoult’s been on the precipice of becoming a proper movie star for a while now, and this role would cement it.

[JH]

Advertisement

3. Steven Yeun

AMC

While he was always stellar on The Walking Dead, Steven Yeun has really proven himself as one of the best rising stars in Hollywood since he left AMC’s hit show. Enjoying success as supporting characters in critically-acclaimed flicks like Sorry to Bother You, Okja, and Burning, Yeun has been given the opportunity to explore larger-than-life characters and break free from the charming (but distinctly ordinary) Glenn Rhee.

Advertisement

There’ll no doubt be some who’d argue he’d be a better fit as a Robin or a Nightwing (which is fair), but it would be a waste to not see him as a younger Bruce Wayne. Mayhem showed that he can play an a-hole with ease, while retaining a sense of charm that makes him such a compelling actor to follow. It’s a trait that would allow him to perfectly embody the near-smarmy, public face of Bruce Wayne.

Also, if you’re not convinced about him being an action star, then that film (and even a few episodes of The Walking Dead) should be more than enough to sway you. He doesn’t look all that intimidating, but Yeun’s capable of unleashing a bottled rage in major set-pieces, all the while maintaining a human vulnerability and fragility that sets Batman apart from other heroes.

Advertisement

[JB]

2. Armie Hammer

Imagine Entertainment

Had things gone to plan, Armie Hammer would’ve already played a young version of Batman, which is particularly crazy when you think he's only 32 now(!), despite being cast as Bats in George Miller's infamously unmade Justice League: Mortal.

Advertisement

Hammer’s career has fallen and risen again since - there’s a reason he’s now regarded as one of the internet’s many boyfriends - but while his classic good looks make him an easy fit for Bruce Wayne, there’s something interesting in seeing him go a bit darker and really challenging himself further.

You can definitely see him as a billionaire with a hint of arrogance and a slight aloofness to his character that draws people to him but keeps them at arm’s length, and he has the frame for Batman too. He'd also be able to handle showcasing the kind of genius intelligence and deduction skills for the kind of World's Greatest Detective story that Reeves wants to tell.

Advertisement

With the right director - and Reeves is legitimately brilliant - there’s another, darker side to be brought out in him. He’d be a very different kind of Batman, but coming so soon after Ben Affleck - and being the third take on the character this Century - that’s to be welcomed.

[JH]

Advertisement

1. Sebastian Stan

Marvel Studios

Yeah, he’s best known as being Bucky Barnes in the MCU, but Sebastian Stan’s talent has kind of been wasted so far by Marvel. The actor himself hasn’t had all that much to do, mostly just assigned to look confused and tormented as the mind-controlled assassin.

Advertisement

Which is a shame, because in the moments where he has been allowed to let loose, particularly in Civil War and the final act of The Winter Solider, Stan has been able to convey so much inner turmoil by saying so little. There’s an intensity - not to mention fractured duality - that he brings to Barnes that would be perfect for both Batman and Bruce Wayne’s darker moments, while Stan’s inherent likability and charm sets him up for Bruce Wayne's public cover.

He hasn’t had many leading roles so far, but his transformation in I, Tonya in particular proves just how versatile the actor is. The physicality is obviously there to play someone with the presence of Bruce Wayne, but he also boasts the depth and versatility to bring to life the disparate, often conflicting parts of Batman’s personality.

Advertisement

[JB]

There is, however, one other option...

Advertisement

Bonus: No One

Warner Bros.

Right, look, I’m not deliberately trying to be difficult here, but is there not an argument to be made that… like… nobody plays Batman? Just for a bit.

Advertisement

Yes, I know, it’s Batman and Batman’s amazing and yes, I know, the film is already in production so we’re kind of stuck here, but what if we just didn’t do another Batman film any time soon? Would that be so bad?

Since Michael Keaton first donned the cowl in 1989 we’ve had 9 (nine?!) films featuring live-action Batman as one of if not the main character. I’ve not done the maths - nor will I - but that’s about one every 3 or 4 years. Ridiculous.

Advertisement

Given that the last few outings have been, for varying reasons, not massively acclaimed (either on an individual level or as part of a wider film) a few years away from the Caped Crusader might be the order of the day.

The 8 years between Batman & Robin and Batman Begins allowed the world to reset on the character, and his eventual return was all the better for it. With Batfleck still fresh in everyone’s minds, just… just let it die lads. Just for a bit.

Advertisement

[Adam Clery]

Who do you want to see play Batman next? Let us know down in the comments.

Advertisement