The Conjuring 2 Review: 6 Ups And 2 Downs
James Wan steps it up.
Rating:
Exorcist II: The Heretic. Look What's Happened to Rosemary's Baby. I Still Know What You Did Last Summer. A horror movie can't be called a proper hit until it's got a sequel. And now those illustrious examples are joined by The Conjuring. The difference here is, in a turn that feels more ghoul-inspired than anything in any of those films, that this is the rare horror sequel that's actually better than the first.
James Wan's 2013 chiller was a massive success, bringing in $300 million on a $20 million budget (hence the follow-up), although I did find all the hype a bit too much; it was certainly solid, bringing together all manner of disparate horror tropes into one harmonious whole, but there was no escaping how it completely lost itself in the final act, where convention trumped innovation.
Normally being so financially motivated would hurt a sequel, exacerbating those previous problems. And yet, while the plot of "The Enfield Haunting" (the film's little-used subtitle) is somewhat similar to the first - a family (this time in England) are haunted by some demonic spirit, bringing in supernatural fighters the Warrens for help - and key elements return (the film has great fun again with a zoetrope), this is altogether a better movie than the first.
The film's a rollercoaster, a incredibly fun ride with such ingenuity its flaws can be overlooked; even when the final third ridiculousness returns, it's refreshingly less extreme. Here are six ups and two downs from The Conjuring 2.
The Ups:
6. The Warrens Are Great Franchise Stars
Like The Conjuring before it, The Conjuring 2 has a good grasp of the distinction between story and plot - the main narrative of the film is the Enfield Haunting, but the emotive, character-based side of the film is firmly focused on the Warrens. It's a very smart choice: keeping things focused on a loving couple with a strong history and clear morals, played by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga no less, elevates what could have been a little shlocky.
Obviously the real-life ghostbusters were at-best delusional, but the film doesn't make any allusions it's a true historical account. There's a scene early on with the pair attacked on a talk show by a sceptic that gives rational audience members the armour they need, but after that you're just expected to take this as fantasy (and even if you do, for some reason, believe in things that go bump in the night, this is fictitious - the Warrens' part in the Enfield incident was very different).
The strong characterisation and dealing with reality is make the couple the core of the film and The Conjuring as a wider series - there's no need for recurring villains or even replicated scenario - which makes this one horror franchise that may have real legs (now just watch The Conjuring 3 end up being a total pile).
5. There's A Balance To The Horror
The Conjuring 2 is 134 minutes long. Many 2016 movies have inexplicably wearisome runtimes - despite not having a second act X-Men: Apocalypse is two-and-a-half hours - but this one seemed the most ridiculous. And yet it doesn't hurt the experience at all thanks to the excellent balance between the horror and other tonal elements.
There's a tendency for horror films to be dominated by an overbearing gloom from the off, with whatever terrible events are to come foreshadowed heavily in a victim's life. But, just as a serious drama can have moments of comedy, there can be a variety to the tone of a horror movie, and the best ones do find a way to balance all this. The Conjuring 2 does that, with Wan's playful style injecting a sense of fun.
In fact, there's quite a few genuinely chuckle-worthy comedic beats that're well placed and break up the horror, as well as some sillier that almost invite the audience to laugh at the film.
4. The Amityville Subversion
The Warrens are best known for their involvement in the Amityville Horror - the pair proved essential in the media blitz around the scandal - so I completely expected for this to be where the series would eventually go (and because of well-worn rights issues Wan would be totally OK to do so); have a trilogy building up to their most well-known case.
It's pretty impressive, then, that Amityville is relegated to a tight, scene-setting opening for the sequel. Instead of trying to do a show-stopping remake, it establishes key themes, character fears and imagery in a neat fashion that subverts expectations and also gives the film an "untold" feel; despite the Enfield Haunting being adapted for Sky a couple of years ago, there's a bigger air of mystery surrounding it.
3. No Jump Scare Fake-Outs
Modern horror is enamoured with jump scares. Why make the audience fearful of what's on screen when you can make them scared of being shocked? A good jump scare - see M. Night's latest or Lynch - can really help a film and make the audience more on edge, but more often than not it has the opposite effect; it acts as a release of all the built up tension, giving you a respite. Everybody jumps, laughs it off and the horror is reset.
A bigger problem on top of that is that a lot of movies go for fake-out jump scares - the hero walks around scared, tension mounts, then something jumps at the screen and there's a loud blare, except it's only a cat or some sh*t like that. You get all the tension-killing of a proper jump, but none of the scare.
Excitingly, The Conjuring 2 doesn't do this. There are jump scares and a lot of extended sequences that are built on your fear of something lurking in the background, but instead of tossing Whiskers at you, it just lets the scene play out. If there's no jump, there's no jump. And you're all the more on edge for the next night.
2. It's Meticulously Directed
So much of The Conjuring 2's success is down to James Wan. His camera floats around the characters like a ghoul, constantly moving at a creepy pace, and the whole movie is constructed with audience enjoyment in mind. He's a trope-loving horror director who takes conventions you know and twists them into something fresh.
I'm not going to lie, it can be quite obvious at points. When a dog is shown using a bell to ask to go outside you know the ghost is going to use that to trick someone the next night. And what happens? Exactly that. Everything is set up with the clear promise it'll be important later and, especially near the end, it's painfully in your face.
But that is the style he's going for. The film knows we're two cinematic generations on from the likes of Amityville and that audiences are weaned to all the clichs. You can have Scream-like knowing modernism, but what's wrong with having a bit of fun with them instead?
1. It's Genuinely Scary
The Conjuring 2 has one key purpose: to scare you. It could fail in every other department (it doesn't, but it could) and if you had a chill up your spine then could still be called a success. And boy does it succeed at that. Tension is carefully built up and paid off in suitably spine-tingling fashion masterfuly.
It's not crippling horror. You won't be spending nights staring at the end of your bed imagining a ghoul ready to possess you (although some images are pretty hard to shake). But it does shake you with its sheer inventiveness and relentlessness. In contrast to recent hits in the genre (think The Babadook and It Follows), The Conjuring 2 is popcorn horror. But what popcorn horror it is.
This is one to watch with an audience. In my screening there were assorted giggles to begin with, but as the film got its claws in a fearful silence fell over the crowd and by the end even the biggest cynic was shook.
The Downs:
2. Too Much, Too Fast
What is The Conjuring 2's biggest strength is also one of it's biggest weaknesses. Wan has so many ideas and throws them into the film that some of them come out a little undercooked.
Interesting concepts are ten a penny, but not all are carried through to fruition. That's not a massive issue in the grand scheme of things, but it means some beats that would be strong enough to power a whole movie wind up getting mere minutes of screentime (particularly odd in a movie this long).
Don't go to the toilet if you think you'll only miss a slight dialogue scene - people got up in my screening and by the time they were back were already in the middle of another night of demonic-induced terror.
1. The Failed British Trappings
In the requisite pre-screening intro, James Wan seemed positively giddy about the prospect of making a film set in England, playing a part in a pretty illustrious historical legacy. He really shouldn't have made such a point of it in a showing in London though, because where The Conjuring 2 really misses its mark is with its presentation of just everything to do with the British way of life.
After the moody Amityville opening, we jump to Enfield with London Calling blaring out over stock footage of red buses and it's all downhill from there. Rain comes in sudden bursts and everybody eats piles of biscuits before bedtime. The Hodgsons are in serious money troubles, yet their council house is incredibly spacious (and oddly of a similar layout to the house in the original). Incredibly tense sequences are derailed by some shocking deaf approximations of a cockney accent.
Some period and location flubs are permissable, but when the movie makes such a point of them, especially one so built on maintaining atmosphere, it weakens everything a little.
Are you excited for The Conjuring 2? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments.