The Dark Truth Behind Heath Ledger's Joker

How The Dark Knight's iconic villain came to be (and what it cost).

By Simon Gallagher /

Advertisement

There's an assumed story to what really happened to Heath Ledger. The abridged version of the tragic story states, with some confidence, that Ledger lost himself to the intense process of becoming the Joker for Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight. He allowed the Joker into his mind too much and what stayed there even after he was done with the role broke him.

The reality is more nuanced, more complex. But then, talking in such absolutes feeds into the mythology of the movie. It's vulgar, but having that sort of emotional production story is the kind of thing Hollywood falls over itself for. It's not right, but the casual, indirect exploitation of tragedies like this and Paul Walker's death feed into a film's selling power. And when the news broke that Ledger's approach to the Joker might have had something to do with his death, it gave the performance a gilted edge before anyone had even seen it.

Advertisement

The controversy behind the performance became a currency to such an extent that it didn't matter how little Warner Bros or the Nolans played into it. The potential audience did all the work for them.

Ultimately, this is the story of how a young, talented actor on the verge of breaking into the very upper echelons of Hollywood died of an overdose in January 2008, a little under six months before The Dark Knight came out. It is one of profound tragedy, huge artistic skill and the commitment to a role that was so remarkable that it becomes difficult to discern whether it was responsible or whether it ought to be celebrated away from the context of Ledger's death.

Advertisement

Given the focus on how the Joker impacted Ledger's life and death, it's important to tie this story to the genesis of the character.

4. The Beginning

An Uncommon Image

Ledger was by no means an unknown when he was cast as The Joker. He'd already been in acclaimed movies and popular ones and his own performances in the likes of Ned Kelly and Brokeback Mountain confirmed him as a performer of some ability. To think of him as teen heartthrob solely for his role in 10 Things I Hate About You is to misunderstand his career entirely. Unfortunately, it's also exactly what happened in the fan communities who rejected his casting outright.

Advertisement

Christopher Nolan had been keen to work with Ledger earlier in his career. He told IGN at the end of December 2007 that the two had met "several times on projects in the past and nothing had ever come of it." The actor was even in the running to play Batman for Batman Begins but had rejected the idea of playing a superhero convincingly. By the time Nolan was seeking his Joker for the Batman Begins, who had been seeded at the end of that film, the director said Ledger got wind and put himself forward.

Other names were suggested for the role, like Christopher Eccleston, Steve Carell, Robin Williams, Paul Bettany and Adrien Brody and would become pillars for outraged fanboys to cling to while citing evidence of Ledgers unsuitability, but he earned it himself. In hindsight, the criticisms look ridiculous.

Advertisement

And while Jonathan Nolan was given specific tasks in writing the Joker - like turning to his earliest appearances in the comics and watching Fritz Lang's The Testament Of Dr Mabuse for instance - Ledger's input is what shaped the performance. He set out with a couple of agendas. First of all, he wanted to ensure his performance was different to what had gone before. He wanted to set his Joker apart from Jack Nicholson's from 1989's Batman.

3. Building A New Joker

Warner Bros.

The look was already different: Christopher Nolan has revealed that his Joker is designed to be a visual homage to the work of artist Franchis Bacon. The same Francis Bacon whose painting Figure With Meat is spared by the Joker during his museum rampage in Tim Burton's movie, in fact. But the difference for Ledger was more than skin-deep.

Advertisement

His director revealed how much Nolan brought to the performance, but back before the film's release, Ledger himself laid some foundation as to why he was so committed to the role and to making it his own.

In an exclusive interview with Empire, Ledger said he feared taking a role that every fanboy around the world would demands to see done right:

Advertisement

"Although anything that makes me afraid I guess excites me at the same time. I don’t know if I was fearless, but I certainly had to put on a brave face and believe that I have something up my sleeve. Something different...”

In the same interview, he laid out some of his approach to preparing for the role too:

Advertisement
"It’s a combination of reading all the comic books I could that were relevant to the script and then just closing my eyes and meditating on it. I sat around in a hotel room in London for about a month, locked myself away, formed a little diary and experimented with voices — it was important to try to find a somewhat iconic voice and laugh. I ended up landing more in the realm of a psychopath — someone with very little to no conscience towards his acts. He’s just an absolute sociopath, a cold-blooded, mass-murdering clown, and Chris has given me free rein. Which is fun, because there are no real boundaries to what The Joker would say or do. Nothing intimidates him, and everything is a big joke"

Ten years on from the release of the film, Nolan explored the same part of the production and revealed how much of the Joker's performance was down to Ledger:

"A lot of what Heath did he would discuss with me. He'd sort of give me hints of what he was going to do, and we'd talk about it a bit and I would try to be an audience for him, sort of gauge with him what he was doing, but… I think he wanted to play his cards a little close to the chest."

Despite Nolan being the director, he revealed that Ledger would come to key decisions himself, gradually revealing his choice of the voice and the way he was going to approach parts of the performance, and there was an unpredictability to him on set that matched precisely the character's make-up.

Advertisement

After viewing the film multiple times - because that's how it deserves to be watched - those decisions become all the more clear. You can see where Tom Waits' various idiosyncracies were hungrily studied and appropriated, you notice that he barely looks at any of his victims, or the tongue-flicking and hand-clapping that were quirks added by Ledger. His physicality, the strange, not-quite-imitatable tone of his voice, the manic spectrum of his delivery of lines... All are artfully crafted. The idea that they are somehow reliant on a mind on the verge of destruction because of their creation is unthinkable. It's also confusing, but there is a point to explore about the psychology of the Joker.

Most interesting of Nolan's comments are the ones that seem to match that idea of the Joker somehow changing Ledger's mind destructively.

Advertisement
"We both had exactly the same concept in our heads of who that guy would be in this film in the way that we'd interpreted it. It wasn't specific to, "Oh, he's going to look like this or talk like that" at all. It was about a psychological concept. It was about a character concept. It was about the threat of anarchy. It was about anarchy being the most frightening thing there is. Chaos and anarchy in this day and age, and I think it is. It's certainly the thing I'm most afraid of."

That idea of approaching a role as a psychological concept has come up before. And when you combine it with the school of method acting that charges an actor with getting into the mind of their character through experience, you can see why there was some belief that it led directly to Ledger's death.

Ledger sought to capture what it would mean to play "someone with very little to no conscience towards his acts" and wrote the diary and temporarily chose to live the life of "an absolute sociopath, a cold-blooded, mass-murdering clown." Of course, there'd be concerns that some residual darkness haunted him.

Advertisement

2. Ledger's Method

Warner Bros.

Ledger's own words don't quite do justice to the process that he underwent to build his character. As well as the preparation Nolan had given him - everything from A Clockwork Orange to Sid Vicious were inspiration points - he had locked himself away, crafted the notorious Joker diary and basically used the experience as a cocoon from which The Joker would ultimately emerge.

Advertisement

There's some thinking that that transformation was total at that point: that he would refuse to drop out of character as Jared Leto was said to have done while filming Suicide Squad. But set reports from cast and crew contradict that. Ledger was very much still Ledger. It was still coming at a cost though, no matter how he'd look in set photos, posing happily with the crew when asked.

The greatest difficulty in understanding what came next, when Ledger was filming The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus comes when you marry that image up with Ledger's health and the physical toll the performance took on him. He spoke to MTV to reveal that it wasn't a wholly unpleasant experience, of course:

Advertisement
"It’s the most fun I’ve had with a character and probably will ever have. The movie itself is far exceeding my expectations. I think it’s going to be a really fun movie to watch."

But then almost in the same breath come the revelations about the cost of the performance. In his own words "it was an exhausting process" that would require him to take extended breaks:

"I actually had quite a bit of time off between scenes — weeks sometimes. But it was required because whenever I was working, it exhausted me to the bone. At the end of the day, I couldn’t move. I couldn’t talk. I was absolutely wrecked. If I had to do that every day, I couldn’t have done what I did. The schedule really permitted me to exhaust myself."

Knowing what would happen, his willingness to exhaust himself is troubling to read. So too is the apparent suggestion that there were signs that it was affecting him tremendously even as he was filming it. Building in respite from a performance fundamentally states there's something wrong with the performance experience.

Advertisement

Ledger would reveal to The New York Times, in an interview published in November 2007 that he often struggled with playing roles. The enormity of tackling Bob Dylan for I'm Not There stressed him out "a little too much" and tied him in knots. The same interview revealed that when he was throwing himself into a role, he typically struggled to sleep:

“Last week I probably slept an average of two hours a night. I couldn’t stop thinking. My body was exhausted, and my mind was still going.”

That fits with the 2015 Australian Actors’ Wellbeing Study that suggested that performers are twice as likely as the general population to experience depression. A higher than average percentage suffer from performance anxiety and report high levels of stress arising from work-related pressures such as low income and job insecurity. Adding that to what performing arts scholar Mark Seton hypothesises about the complexity of playing a character, which simply cannot be separated from the life of the actor and the pressures appear even more insistent.

Advertisement

The fact that in Australia there is now an Actors Equity Wellness Committee, expressly geared towards educating the industry about mental health and wellbeing while providing resources for those who may be at risk suggests how prevalent an issue it is.

Chillingly, the NY Times interview with Ledger also carries a line about him using drugs to try and sleep:

Advertisement
One night he took an Ambien, which failed to work. He took a second one and fell into a stupor, only to wake up an hour later, his mind still racing.

1. The End

Lionsgate

By the end of 2007, Ledger had moved on from the production, though Nolan's team were still filming the Hong Kong sequence as late as November 2007. For Ledger, the next step was making Terry Gilliam's fantastical The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus, an oddity and a strange film to make following The Dark Knight, but another big opportunity all the same.

Advertisement

Filming started in December 2007, but Ledger remained exhausted. His dialect coach on the film, Gary Grennell described him as “exhausted, emotionally and physically” and said he had been battling a lingering pneumonia-type illness, which would ultimately send him back to his New York City apartment. It was there that he died, thanks to a fatal mixture of prescription drugs

Grennell painted a picture of Ledger on-set that didn't quite fit with the happy professional experience he painted.

Advertisement
“He missed his girl (ex-girlfriend Michelle Williams) he missed his family, he missed his little girl — he desperately wanted to see her and hold her and play with her. He was desperately unhappy, desperately sad.”

He also mused that the actor was aware of what he was struggling with, and knew that he was spiraling in the weeks before his death:

“He said, ‘I got to stop, it’s not helping, I’m not well, it’s making me feel more upset. It wasn’t helping with the relationship issues, it wasn’t helping with missing his kid, it wasn’t helping his sleeping — and he knew that."

Grennell wasn't the only one to express concern. Ledger's Four Feathers co-star Djimon Hounsou told the film-makers for Ledger's post-humous documentary I Am Heath Ledger that he'd run into him when he was filming The Dark Knight and remarked that the change he saw in him concerned him.

Advertisement

There was still a contradiction though. His sister Kate told PEOPLE in 2017 that Ledger was a "happy boy" even though she knew he was struggling with illness. She warned him to be careful about mixing medication, which he shrugged off. Even their final conversation was upbeat, in her own words:

“I was cooking dinner … and we were laughing. Then he said, ‘I’ve got to go, and I’ll call you at 8:30 in the morning’ and that was it. That was our last conversation. I said ‘Okay, I love you.’ And that was it. It’s heartbreaking.”

Ledger's death completely changed the trajectory of The Dark Knight. It would probably have still made a huge sum of money at the box office, but it wouldn't have been as defined by his performance. It perhaps wouldn't have won an Oscar. How much the narrative of his tragic death played into that remains to be seen, but it's definitely part of the conversation.

Advertisement

Later, Christopher Nolan remarked on his experience completing the film in the wake of his star's death:

"It was tremendously emotional, right when he passed, having to go back in and look at him every day [during editing]. But the truth is, I feel very lucky to have something productive to do, to have a performance that he was very, very proud of, and that he had entrusted to me to finish."

The director presented Ledger's performance as he'd filmed it, avoiding digital effects in any way. What you see in that final film is the product of Ledger's commitment to preparing, his method approach and everything that exhausted him and set his mind on edge. Even now, it's difficult to watch it with the nagging suspicion that it played some part in the actor's untimely death.

Advertisement

Just as important is to remember what Ledger himself said. The Joker was "the most fun I've ever had, or probably ever will have, playing a character." For all the darkness and the troubling stories, that much is very much clear when you watch it back now.

For more content like this, subscribe to WhatCulture on YouTube. If you're in the UK and struggling with mental health issues, Samaritans offer a confidential emotional support service. Call them on 116 123.

Advertisement