The Grudge Review: 2 Ups & 8 Downs

A traditional January dumpster fire.

By Jack Pooley /

Sony Pictures Releasing

Though January is a traditionally torrid month for new movie releases, 2020 has actually been surprisingly solid so far.

Advertisement

In addition to awards season straggler 1917 blowing us all away, Guy Ritchie's new gangster film The Gentlemen and Bad Boys for Life were both unexpectedly enjoyable romps.

But with The Grudge now out in UK cinemas, we're back in more typically tawdry territory for the "dump month" of January, because this horror franchise reboot nobody asked for is precisely as listless and lazy as its early US reviews implied.

Advertisement

It's not unexpected, though disappointing all the same given the involvement of not only a massively talented cast, but also promising rising director Nicolas Pesce, whose 2016 directorial debut The Eyes of My Mother went down quite the storm on the art-house circuit.

But The Grudge 2020 couldn't feel more opposite: a generic, soulless, predictable horror dud created only to shock a dormant franchise back to life, though given its disappointing box office performance, it seemingly couldn't even manage that...

Advertisement

Downs...

8. It Wastes An Incredibly Talented Cast

Sony Pictures Releasing

One can only assume that The Grudge amassed such a talented cast off the back of Pesce's cred alone, because it's tough to imagine what any member of the film's oddly distinguished acting line-up saw in the script alone.

Advertisement

Andrea Riseborough and Demián Bichir are able to escape with the most dignity in tact as our detective protagonists, yet despite the marketing playing-up his presence as a major character, John Cho has a far smaller and more forgettable role than advertised.

As his screen wife Nina Spencer, the talented Betty Gilpin scarcely gets anything worthwhile, horror legend Lin Shaye has maybe one scene to do something interesting, and celebrated character actors such as Jacki Weaver, William Sadler, and Frankie Faison are just left stranded in the middle of the movie.

Advertisement

The cast is an embarrassment of riches, honestly, but as a piece of storytelling or even a purely stylistic genre exercise, this film completely squanders them.

7. The Frustrating Narrative Structure

Sony Pictures Releasing

Much like prior iterations of The Grudge, this version unfolds in non-linear fashion, with the modern-day detective story intercut with the various grisly tragedies which befell victims of the titular curse in years prior.

Advertisement

Unfortunately this time it adds nothing to the story contextually or atmospherically, beyond letting the audience more-or-less know what happened to the poor saps before we finally see it for ourselves in the barmy third act of the movie.

Ultimately the structure proves more confusing than intriguing, especially given the vague rules of the curse itself and the fact that two of the victims - those played by Betty Gilpin and Tara Westwood - bear a strong physical resemblance to one another.

Advertisement

Above all else it feels like a desperate attempt to make the film seem more dynamic and interesting than it actually is.

6. It's Full Of Lazy Jump Scares

Sony Pictures Releasing

Despite Pesce's horror debut featuring little in the way of jump scares, his first foray into more traditional studio genre filmmaking is a depressingly generic affair where the "frights" are concerned.

Advertisement

The Grudge is jam-packed with obnoxious and predictable jump scares which even casual genre fans will likely see coming from miles away.

These jumps are aggressively forced enough that one suspects they may have been studio-mandated, especially given that the film actually wrapped shooting over 18 months ago, and a round of re-shoots was ordered last summer.

Advertisement

Whatever the reasoning, they strip away any slight sense of atmosphere the movie musters, ensuring the impression it leaves is one of a tediously formulaic, lazy horror jump-fest.

5. The Ugly, Flat Cinematography

Sony Pictures Releasing

Considering how utterly ravishing Pesce's debut was, it's a real shame that his first major studio movie is so utterly hideous from a visual perspective.

Advertisement

From the first scene alone, it's clear that most all colour and vitality has been stripped out of the film, creating a washed-out, dull aesthetic which does nothing to make the airless narrative any more interesting.

But the weirdest decision has to be the odd yellow tint applied to the vast majority of the movie.

Advertisement

While it gives the film a vaguely distinctive look from its genre competition, it's extremely unappealing to look at for prolonged periods, and not in the way Pesce likely intended.

Whether this is the fault of cinematographer Zack Galler or an ill-advised choice made in post-production, The Grudge is one of the ugliest studio horror films to get a theatrical release in recent memory.

Advertisement

4. It's Intensely Boring

Sony Pictures Releasing

With a skilled director and game cast, it's entirely possible for generic horror fare to be fun and entertaining, but the biggest problem with The Grudge? It's just too dull and self-serious to be enjoyable.

Advertisement

As much a boring detective story as it is an apparent horror film, the script bogs the cast down in tell-us-a-story expository dialogue, snooze-inducingly overlong "suspense" sequences, and the aforementioned predictable jump scares which don't even begin to get the pulse racing.

Had The Grudge indulged a more campy, self-aware vibe to compensate for its otherwise generic nature, perhaps it could've been enjoyable trash on par with the 2004 American remake. But instead, you'll likely be left checking your watch before the first act is even over.

Advertisement

At least it's only 94 minutes long, though you'll certainly feel every minute.

3. The Insanely Choppy Editing

Sony Pictures Releasing

Given the film's lengthy post-production period, it's not much of a leap to suggest that The Grudge was significantly re-worked in the editing room, which might explain why the editing feels so thoroughly messy throughout.

Advertisement

Even if you can accept the tricky narrative structure, the cross-cutting between time periods is sudden and erratic to the point of frequent irritation, to say nothing of the weird, off-rhythm cuts between scenes and especially choppily-edited jump scares.

This feels like a film which was hacked up and taped back together after test screenings and intensive executive workshopping, all in the hope of claiming the biggest opening weekend box office possible from undemanding genre audiences.

Advertisement

2. The Hilariously Bad Ending

Sony Pictures Releasing

No spoilers, but the end of this movie is sure to leave audiences groaning and sighing in disbelief.

Advertisement

Though there's a promising final showdown somewhere in this closing sequence, it attempts an ill-advised rug-pull that's far too predictable to actually work, complete with some unintentionally goofy visuals that provoke more laughs than gasps.

But what's really likely to rankle viewers is the final shot which, without giving it away, seems like a trollish provocation to audiences more than anything else.

Advertisement

It is, ultimately, a whole lot of nothing, and destined to have viewers heading home wondering why they even bothered.

1. Yes, It's The Worst Film Of 2020 (So Far)

Sony Pictures Releasing

It's been a relatively quiet start to the year of film so far, and also a weirdly decent one for the most part, but all the same, The Grudge is absolutely the worst theatrical release of the year to date.

Advertisement

While we're only a few weeks into 2020 and there are sure to be some dreadful competitors to its crown in the coming months, it's highly unlikely that The Grudge isn't on a lot of critics' worst-of lists come December.

Granted, Dolittle doesn't hit UK screens for a few more weeks, so The Grudge might get pipped to the post soon enough.

Advertisement

The Grudge sucks, then. But like (almost) any film, it's not all awful. And so, here are the few things it gets right...

Ups...

2. Andrea Riseborough's Solid Performance

Sony Pictures Releasing

Andrea Riseborough is an extremely talented and frequently under-appreciated actress, and while she's absolutely wasted in this film along with the rest of her co-stars, she does nevertheless manage to give a compelling performance all the same.

Advertisement

As worn-down protagonist Detective Muldoon, Riseborough aptly conveys the stress and emotional exhaustion that both her job and the supernatural events in her midst cause.

She's good enough, in fact, that she somehow manages to emerge pretty much unscathed, bringing a pathos and plausibility to a film that's otherwise largely bereft of it.

Advertisement

Hopefully the next time she shows up in a major studio movie, though, there might be a more fittingly fruitful part waiting for her.

1. The Occasionally Brutal Gore

Sony Pictures Releasing

Horror fans were somewhat optimistic that The Grudge hit screens with an R rating, compared to the previous 2004 US remake, which bafflingly touted a tween-friendly PG-13 rating.

Advertisement

And though the first two acts of this movie are frustratingly restrained with the red stuff, the third act finally lets loose with some genuinely nasty and revolting gore sequences.

Without giving much away, a scene involving Lin Shaye and a knife is sure to have audiences squirming, largely thanks to Shaye's demented performance and the surprisingly strong practical effects work.

Advertisement

Another sequence in which a character damn-near explodes into a bloody mess after jumping to their death is also sure to entertain, as it's one of the few moments where The Grudge truly seems to embrace its inherent trashiness.

The film could certainly have done much more on the blood 'n guts front to make itself more watchable overall, but what's here hits the visceral mark at least.

Advertisement