The last year has been quite a rollercoaster ride for the Spider-Man movie property. After fans were expecting The Amazing Spider-Man 2 to deliver the first "real" Spider-Man movie since 2007's Spider-Man 3 (flawed though that was), ASM2 suffered a decidedly mixed critical reception and brought in the lowest box office grosses of all five Spidey movies to date. This caused Sony to re-think their strategy towards the web-slinger's movies, leading to the jaw-dropping announcement last month that Sony Pictures and Marvel Studios would be teaming up to bring Spidey back to the screen, starting off with an appearance in Captain America: Civil War (likely in a post-credit scene) before he gets his own solo movie released on July 28, 2017. Despite being one of cinema's more accessible superheroes to date, Spidey hasn't exactly had an easy time for the last 8 years or so. Spidey 3 was disappointing, the whole reboot business proved divisive, and then ASM2 fell far short of expectations, so hopefully Sony and Marvel will be taking all of this on-board when they give the character a soft-ish reboot. There are countless pitfalls to be avoided, all of which the studios need to keep in mind when working on the story for the next movie. Here are the 11 biggest mistakes Spider-Man 6 (apparently titled The Spectacular Spider-Man) desperately needs to avoid...
11. Having More Than One Major Villain
This problem began in Spider-Man 3, where Spidey (Tobey Maguire) was facing off against three villains, each of who needed to be brought into the fold, fight Peter and have their plot resolved inside of 139 minutes. There was Eddie Brock aka Venom (Topher Grace), Sandman (Thomas Hayden Church), and then Harry Osborn's New Goblin (James Franco). The mix didn't work for a number of reasons (such as the Uncle Ben retcon and Grace being totally miscast), but Raimi, who was vehemently against adapting Venom from the start, just couldn't juggle three villains in one movie. ASM2 struggled with the same problem: Rhino (Paul Giamatti) admittedly only appeared in cameo form at the beginning and end of the film, but Marc Webb still had to rush to flesh out Electro (Jamie Foxx) and the new Green Goblin (Dane DeHaan). Despite a lengthy 142 minute run-time, the characters felt strangely underdeveloped and the villain arcs just weren't interesting at all. Electro is a Spider-Man fanboy and Harry needs Spider-Man's blood? Yawn. While it's understandable that Sony wants to set up its new Sinister Six movie, hopefully Marvel can force them into a more restrained approach in which Spider-Man just faces off against one major villain this time. Sure, have a secondary baddie make a cameo or something, but just focus on crafting one good villain before trying anything more ambitious.
10. Hiring Anyone But J.K. Simmons To Play J. Jonah Jameson
Even in the widely-maligned Spider-Man 3, there was one constant brilliant performance throughout the Sam Raimi movies, and that was J.K. Simmons' magnificent turn as cranky Daily Bugle editor J. Jonah Jameson, who delighted in decrying Spidey as a menace at every errant opportunity. Jameson was absent from both Amazing Spider-Man movies, causing many to wonder when the character might next appear on screens. There will be much demand to see him back in the new Spidey movie, and a simple way to win a lot of fans back is to re-hire Simmons for the iconic part. While the actor's asking price might be a little higher these days, what with his recent Best Supporting Actor Oscar win for Whiplash, he's a quintessential part of Marvel, given that he has also lent his voice to various cartoon incarnations of the character. It's tough to read even the comics without doing so in Simmons' loud, gruff voice, and to cast anyone else in the role would be a major sacrilege.
9. Retelling The Origin Story...Again
Since 2002, Spider-Man's origin story has had two big-budget Hollywood tellings, first with Sam Raimi's version, and then, the hugely unnecessary one in Marc Webb's The Amazing Spider-Man a decade later. Though the reboot was largely praised by critics, even they took umbrage with the movie's repetitious first hour, which lazily rehashed all the same beats audiences saw ten years prior, such as the iconic spider bite moment and, of course, Uncle Ben's death. What should've just been Spider-Man 4 with a new lead actor was instead so eye-rollingly redundant and a gigantic missed opportunity. Some have begun speculating whether Marvel and Sony will fashion yet another origin story for Peter Parker given that the part is again being recast, and though this seems terribly unlikely from what's been said so far, it's possible that some sort of retooled origin story could be inserted in via flashbacks. Hopefully, though, they'll stop boring audiences with this repetitive nonsense and just focus on telling an interesting and original new story with Spider-Man already established, given how even the most casual audiences are well-acquainted with this prologue by now.
8. Trying Too Hard To Tie Into The Marvel Cinematic Universe
The idea of Spider-Man being a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe is a dream come true for pretty much every comic book fan, though at the same time, Marvel and Sony should be careful not to force Spidey's involvement too quickly. A cameo appearance in Civil War will be a good start, yet hopefully The Spectacular Spider-Man will for the most part operate as a standalone movie with merely tangential links to the MCU by way of a cameo appearance from an Avenger after the credits or something. Literally all that needs to be done to insert Spidey into the MCU is have Nick Fury or someone approach him at the end and say, "I'd like you to join the Avengers Initiative". No gimmicks needed: fans will accept it and just be happy that they'll be able to see Spider-Man in Avengers: Infinity War. If they instead are constantly name-dropping Marvel characters in the movie, it could end up irritating and detract from a movie which desperately needs to stand on its own before it can be linked to anything else.
7. Recycling Previous Villains
There will unquestionably be the temptation for Marvel and Sony to recycle some of the more iconic villains that Spidey has faced off against so far, namely Green Goblin, Doc Ock, Venom and Sandman. While it's understandable that previous villains will be appearing again in order to set up the Sinister Six movie, hopefully The Spectacular Spider-Man will largely feature villains who haven't been given the big-screen treatment before, like, say, Carnage or Vulture. Spidey has such an impressive roster of enemies to draw from that it'd be a shame if the new film just stuck to what's been tried and tested rather than pushing the boat out with something a little more daring and challenging. Does anybody really want to see previous plot arcs just rehashed again, much like how the origin story was lazily copied for The Amazing Spider-Man?
6. An Emo Tone That Drains The Fun
While it would be a struggle to call the Amazing Spider-Man movies as dark and somber as, say, The Dark Knight Rises, one of the major criticisms of the Marc Webb movies was that they lacked the sense of fun of the Sam Raimi films, with a feeling of mopiness taking precedent simply because it's a fashionable tone these days. There are far too many scenes in which Peter (Andrew Garfield) stares pensively out over the horizon, and it made each film feel like kind of a drag, while Raimi's films aren't completely innocent either: just look at the whole emo Peter subplot from Spider-Man 3. It's not that these movies can't deal with emotional issues, but can't they deal with it in a slightly less somber fashion? Most of the MCU movies manage a perfect tonal mix, so hopefully Marvel Studios will ensure that the mopey content doesn't get out of hand this time.
5. But Not Too Much Goofiness Either
At the same time, it's important that the new movie doesn't get too goofy. This is one easy complaint to level at Raimi's movies, which haven't exactly aged particularly well because they already look so silly and ludicrous. Keep the film funny, but don't make it too earnest, perhaps employing some of the sarcastic humour Peter became known for in the Amazing Spider-Man movies, and never, ever have Spider-Man dress up as a firefighter to save the day... Again, the MCU pretty much manages a perfect balance between seriousness when the time calls for it and a little silliness: now that Spidey's part of the MCU, hopefully he'll follow suit.
4. Including Too Much Romance
It's impossible to deny that romance is a big part of Peter Parker's life, and so his various love stories have been given substantial screen time throughout all five Spider-Man movies to date: Peter and MJ were on-off for two movies before Peter had a brief dalliance with Gwen Stacy (Bryce Dallas Howard), and ended up going back to MJ. In the Amazing Spider-Man movies, it's been Gwen all the way, and in fairness, Emma Stone's performance as the character was one of the new series' highlights...before she was unceremoniously killed off at the end of ASM2. Still, both Spider-Man franchises ultimately ran their romances into the ground through sub-Dawson's Creek dialogues that simply dragged each film's length out without adding much actual content. Peter will most certainly have a love interest in the new movie, but hopefully it will be downplayed and kept to the periphery, focusing instead on an awesome battle between the web-slinger and a new villain. Or better yet, just start the movie with Peter and MJ already being an item, so audiences don't have to suffer through anymore cornball love declarations.
3. Relentlessly Sympathetic Villains
One of the most consistently tedious elements of the Spider-Man movies has been how practically every significant villain has a tragic back story of some kind which makes them sympathetic, the most common being a dedicated scientist who ends up overrun by the very thing they created, as in the case of Green Goblin (Willem Dafoe), Doc Ock (Alfred Molina) and Lizard (Rhys Ifans). Then there's Sandman, who has the whole sick daughter sob story, Venom and Electro, both of whom were the result of a freak accident, while Franco's New Goblin was driven by understandable revenge and DeHaan's Green Goblin was a necessity to keep his illness at bay. In fact, the only semi-significant, card-carrying villain in all five movies so far has been Rhino, though that's almost certainly because his part has simply been an extended cameo and nothing more. A new Spider-Man film would do well to introduce a more insidious villain who can't be pawned off with simple excuses, because isn't an evil character that's evil "just because" so much more threatening than a poor sap?
2. Miles Morales
Miles Morales first took up the Spider-Man mantle in 2011 after the death of Peter Parker in Ultimate Fallout, a black hispanic young man whose portrayal was reportedly based on both Barack Obama and actor Donald Glover. The character has been extremely well-received for the most part, and as such when the new Spider-Man reboot was announced, many lobbied Marvel and Sony to consider replacing Peter Parker with a bold new take on the character in Miles. While a Miles Morales Spider-Man movie would be great to see some time down the line, it's just too daring for the Spider-Man movie that needs to be made right now. Given how the property is in something of a weak position after ASM2, this isn't really the time to change Spider-Man's race and risk alienating a portion of the audience due to racism or pickiness: it's absolutely best to stick to Peter for now, establish a firm base, and then possibly introduce Miles five-ish years down the line when the actor playing Spidey might want out anyway. It might be cynical to assume that audiences wouldn't respond to a black Spider-Man, but when hundreds of millions of dollars are at stake, it seems silly to take the risk right now. Marvel have indicated that Miles probably won't be in the movie anyway, but anything can happen...
1. Planning Sequels Before The First Movie Succeeds
If Sony's Spider-Man movies have made anything clear, it's that planning too far ahead based on previous successes can make everyone look foolish. The studio was so happy with The Amazing Spider-Man's box office grosses that they set release dates for the third and fourth movies in the franchise shortly after ASM2 started filming, seemingly confident that they had a winner on their hands. As it turned out, the movie underwhelmed in every way possible, and those plans were eventually scuppered following Sony's new deal with Marvel Studios. It's an exceedingly common practice these days for studios to prep release dates for projected sequels before the previous films land, but hopefully after the hubris Sony demonstrated with the property last time, the new collaboration won't be quite so sure that the Spider-Man property is critic-proof. Hopefully they'll focus on making one good Spider-Man movie first, throw him in the Avengers: Infinity War movies, and then look at making The Spectacular Spider-Man 2 around 2020/2021.