Top 5 Superman vs Batman Movie Casting Rumours

By Kyle Murphy /

Unconfirmed rumors - or hearsay, speculation some may claim- have exploded across the interwebs that actors have been cast in the Man of Steel sequel, which will not only feature Superman as played by Henry Cavill, but will also introduce a new Batman as well. Warner Bros. surprised the world by announcing Ben Affleck would throw on the cape and cowl as the Dark Knight in the 2015 superhero romp. As soon as that casting was confirmed, wave after wave of "scoops" and "exclusives" (mostly emanating from cosmicbooknews.com) alleged more parts were cast, filling out roles for lead villains and supporting characters. While the gossip and fan outcry have generated page hits for the rumor mills, they have gone beyond the stuff of fanboy wet dreams and into the mainstream. Legitimate news sources have picked up on some of these stories, and word has actually gotten back to the actor in question regarding the role. Interestingly, the interconnectedness of our times with social media gives this idle talk more oxygen to breath and grow into the question that's on everyone's lips, begging to be confirmed. While none of the following casting has been confirmed in any way, shape or form, let's take a look at the latest tittle-tattle on who may round out the ensemble cast with the Dark Knight over Metropolis.

5. Matt Damon - Aquaman/Martian Manhunter

After Ben Affleck was confirmed as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Man of Steel part deux, distraught fanboys joked his long-time buddy Matt Damon should come on as Robin. While that made little sense and was created out of antipathy to Affleck's casting, later rumors asserted Damon was being considered for a part in the superhero epic, just not as Robin. Who, then? Allegedly, Damon is being looked at for the roles of Aquaman and Martian Manhunter, no doubt stacking the deck for a Justice League team up. While this is likely the most ludicrous of casting rumors on this list, they should all be consumed with a couple grains of salt.

4. Mark Strong - Sinestro

Arguably the best part of 2011's Green Lantern, Sinestro made the entire affair watchable and Mark Strong - who played Lantern's antagonist - stole nearly every scene he was in. When the mass hysteria over the rumor of Cranston being cast as Lex Luthor hit the net, Mark String was also thought to be in the running for the "greatest criminal mind of our times". So when Cranston was speculated to have been cast, the reason given for passing over Strong was because he had already recently portrayed a DC cinematic villain ... and they may want him to again! If true, this could mean Strong returning as Sinestro in subsequent films to challenge the heroes of DC, perhaps lining up a Justice League film later on?

3. Timothy Dalton - Alfred Pennyworth

Usually too often portrayed as a stuffy man-servant, Bruce Wayne's butler has the potential to be so much more in a new version of Batman. Caretaker, father figure, protecting guardian are all titles a new Alfred Pennyworth could also assume. In recent comics, Alfred has been made out to be a former military medic, serving during battle and seeing war. This adds a better reason for Alfred standing by Bruce while he wages his, along with explaining how a butler could be so good at triage. Who better to take on this more cunning version of Master Pennyworth than James Bond himself? Rumors are suggesting - so they must be true - that Zack Snyder is strongly considering the former 007 for the role.

2. Justin Timberlake - Robin/Riddler

With speculation surrounding the new Batman on film would be influenced greatly by the wildly popular video game series Arkham Asylum, combined with a more grizzled, experienced Dark Knight led many to think Robin would be a sure bet in the Batman/Superman film. This drove many to throw support behind the pop-singer/artist Justin Timberlake to take on the Boy Wonder. This rumor did not last long as Timberlake was asked by radio station Fresh 102.7 and came right out and declared: "I ain't playin' Robin. I have no aspiration to ever be a superhero in a movie. I just don't." Well, that settles that. But, wait there's more from JT on the Man of Steel sequel: "Now villain! I'll tell you the villain I want to play more than anything because I grew up loving Batman, funny enough, is the Riddler. The Riddler is my favorite villain. The Riddler was like a sociopath. He was proper crazy. So if I'm gonna play crazy, I'm wanna play like proper crazy. I'm ready. The Riddler. Give me a call." Timberlake also heaped praise on newly anointed Batman, and fellow Runner Runner co-star. "Ben Affleck as Batman, I like it," says Justin. "I worked with Ben last summer and I've seen his process. I think he's a brilliant filmmaker. I think he's an extreme talent so he could surprise a lot of people." Let the games - and cropping Justin Timberlake images into green Riddler garb - begin!

1. Bryan Cranston - Lex Luthor

Stemming from the confirmed casting of Ben Affleck as Batman, rumors began churning that Bryan Cranston, who plays the bald Breaking Bad anti-hero, had been selected to portray Superman's arch-rival, Lex Luthor, according to cosmicbooknews.com. While rumors suggested that the casting had already taken place with Cranston winning out, they also claim the official announcement would be held off to dovetail with the finale of Cranston's hit television drama. Rumors also suggested Cranston signed on to play Luthor in a blockbuster six-picture deal, similar to Samuel L. Jackson's Nick Fury character in Marvel's cinematic universe. While none of this has been proven, rumors did make their way back to Cranston, who had this to say in an interview with Metro: "Give me a call. I like Lex Luthor. I think he's misunderstood. He's a lovable, sweet man."The gossip, the quote from the man himself, along with a fan-made trailer throwing together Man of Steel footage with Affleck in between, book-ended by a villainous looking Cranston shaving his head - ala Luthor - have sent fans into an even higher tizzy over the possibilities of Cranston wielding the green rock of Kryptonite in Man of Steel 2.