War Machine Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs
Brad Pitt joins the Netflix gravy train.
War Machine is out now on Netflix, the streaming giant's latest effort to be taken seriously as a distributor of original movies, with the war satire boasting an all-star cast led by none other than Brad Pitt.
Though writer-director David Michôd's (Animal Kingdom, The Rover) effort certainly isn't bad, it disappointingly ends up settling for meme mediocrity, which doesn't exactly make it a ringing endorsement for the creative freedom Netflix reportedly affords its artists.
Still, you can watch it in the comfort of your bed right now without paying an extra penny, which should see it pull solid viewing figures regardless, and with that in mind, general audiences will probably be a lot easier on it than the critics.
With Netflix planning to roll out more and more original, star-studded movies throughout the rest of the year and beyond, War Machine is ultimately just a drop in the ocean. It could be better, sure, but it's definitely a start...
Downs...
5. The Supporting Cast Is Mostly Wasted
David Michôd has assembled quite the stellar cast indeed, though sadly, for the most part they're sparingly, forgettably used in favour of propping up Brad Pitt's oddball General Glen McMahon.
The likes of Ben Kingsley, Topher Grace, Anthony Michael Hall, Scoot McNairy, Will Poulter and Griffin Dunne appear intermittently throughout, though they're given pretty uninspired material to work through, and in the case of Kingsley in particular, could be cut out of the film entirely without it much effecting the end product.
It's clear that Netflix's collaboration with Brad Pitt's production company Plan B Entertainment resulted in a ton of money being thrown at the project, but where's the script that justifies hiring such a huge fleet of celebrated and well-liked actors?
4. It Lacks Satirical Bite
Despite being positioned as a war satire on the level of, say, M*A*S*H or Three Kings, War Machine is surprisingly light when it comes to the barbed digs at the futility of war.
Instead, it's more of a character study centered around General McMahon's crusade in Afghanistan, while occasionally peppered with tragi-comedic undertones. If you're going into this hoping for In the Loop levels of bite, you'll probably be left at least a little disappointed at its rather basic assessment of the War in Afghanistan.
That's not say that the film doesn't have its smart and hilarious moments, but for the most part Michôd's screenplay opts for the easy gags. It's clear that satire isn't his strong suit, and going by the bleak seriousness of most of his prior filmography, that's not too surprising.
3. There's A Surprising Lack Of Action
Three Kings proved that war satires don't need to lack in the action stakes, yet War Machine is sadly pretty malnourished when it comes to set-pieces.
There's actually zero action in the first two acts, and though the final reel does feature a squad of soldiers on maneuvers, it's pretty benign fare, shot anonymously and lacking any visual flair at all.
It's particularly frustrating as a pretty penny has clearly been spent on the production, which even flew real choppers in as opposed to Hollywood's usual deference towards bad CGI ones, yet there's absolutely nothing else remarkable about this sequence.
2. The Pointless, Lazy Voiceover Narration
Though voiceover narration can be a fine asset in a movie (The Shawshank Redemption, for example), it's often an indication of a lazy screenwriter who can't find a way to organically structure their story and so relies on a disembodied voice to spoonfeed the audience everything they need to know.
Such is the case here, as the movie is framed by the narration of Sean Cullen (Scott McNairy), a Rolling Stone writer who joins McMahon's outfit in order to write a story on them.
It's not simply that the script fails to make the voiceover funny or interesting, but that McNairy's delivery is so flat and one-note that one almost suspects he was dragged into a recording booth after the fact, perhaps in order to clarify certain plot points in post-production. It's really not good, not at all.
1. The Lack Of Strong Female Characters
Perhaps it isn't that shocking that a movie set in the theater of war isn't overflowing with female characters, but even the ones who do show up are mostly pretty shallow or fleeting figures.
The only remotely memorable women in the film are the Secretary of State, a 60 Minutes interviewer, and most prominently, General McMahon's wife Jeanie (Meg Tilly). Though the first two don't really touch the sides, Tilly absolutely does her best to give Jeanie some depth, but she's basically just a stereotypical long-suffering wife while her husband is off taking care of business.
There's no need to shove women into the scenario if it doesn't call for it, but particularly in regard to McMahon's wife, it feels like a lot more could've been done to emphasise a potent female presence.
Netflix's latest original film wasn't all bad, though, so here's what they got right...
Ups...
4. Brad Pitt's Entertainingly Bonkers Performance
Say what you will about the movie, but Brad Pitt hurls himself completely into the central role as the cartoonish but well-meaning and unexpectedly likeable General.
With his gruff voice, bizarre facial expressions and grey head of hair, this is Pitt's most outlandish performance in quite some time, and while it threatens to become too much on occasion, he just about lands on the right side of goofball.
His motives however remain fairly ambiguous by film's end, which helps emphasise the overall foggy nature of war. Pitt's peculiarly mannered turn may not work for all tastes, but if you're not able to laugh at McMahon's ridiculous jogging stance, which quickly becomes a running gag throughout the film, then there's probably something wrong with you.
3. It's Genuinely Interesting & Informative
Yes, the film serves as a pretty simple and piecemeal primer on the War in Afghanistan, but in its best moments it's actually a legitimately intriguing examination of one of the more contentious periods in America's recent military history.
For example, did you know that Afghan farmers were allowed to grow Heroin because the U.S. government wouldn't allow them to grow something legal, like cotton, out of fear it would compete with American farmers?
Elsewhere the movie reveals that U.S. soldiers could receive a Medal of Heroic Restraint for diffusing an intense situation without using their guns, and though this was ultimately only proposed in real life in order to curb civilian casualties, it's a fascinating (not to mention hilarious) idea all the same.
These compelling morsels may only appear intermittently throughout, but when they do land, they're golden.
2. Tilda Swinton's Incredible Single Scene
Tilda Swinton appears briefly in the movie's mid-section as a German politician who stands up to question General McMahon about his true intentions regarding the War in Afghanistan.
Her three-minute monologue is unquestionably one of the movie's best scenes, focused almost entirely on her as she asks McMahon about Al-Qaeda and the futility of invading people's homes and killing them.
Swinton totally knocks it out of the park, accent and all, and while it's a shame her appearance is so fleeting, she brings some much needed inquisitive energy to the movie just when it needs it.
1. There's An Awesome Surprise Cameo
And finally, credit to Netflix for resisting the temptation to spoil the deliciously fun cameo tacked onto the very end of the film.
Without giving the game away, it's a clever nod to the nature of Army bureaucracy, hurling an uncredited A-lister into the mix and hinting at an even crazier story taking place off-screen.
While this cameo could theoretically hint at a sequel, it's much more likely that it's just a cute final tag to give audiences a big laugh as the credits roll. To that end, it definitely worked.
What did you think of War Machine? Shout it out in the comments!