Which Suicide Squad Movie Is Better?
How does James Gunn's new take stack up against the 2016 version?
With James Gunn's much-anticipated The Suicide Squad now hitting cinemas around the globe, it's inevitable that critics and fans alike are going to be comparing it to David Ayer's highly divisive 2016 iteration.
It's no secret that Gunn's film has received decidedly stronger reviews than Ayer's, though in complete fairness to Ayer, his film was chopped up by Warner Bros. during post-production.
But beyond the simplicity of an aggregated critical consensus, how do the two films hold up when comparing every single aspect of their filmmaking?
It's time to examine the 2016 and 2021 movies with a fine tooth comb and break down their individual strengths and weaknesses, before determining which film succeeds in which area - and an overall winner, of course.
It surely won't surprise many to see which movie comes out on top overall - and in most areas, to be honest - but James Gunn's movie doesn't win by a triumphant landslide in every category, and it's worth noting that Ayer's film isn't without its underappreciated merits.
From writing to direction, acting, music, and general audience appeal, this is how both Suicide Squad movies stack up against one another...
11. Direction
The 2016 Suicide Squad was directed by the talented David Ayer (End of Watch, Fury), whose experience working with ensemble casts made him seem like a snug fit for the material on paper.
But with Warner Bros. ultimately taking the edit away from Ayer and transforming the film into something he didn't authorise, it's tough to even really consider it a full-hearted Ayer-directed work. For his part, Ayer maintains that his own cut of Suicide Squad would've been very different.
On the other hand, James Gunn seemingly had total freedom to deliver his intended vision. In addition to this, he's a superb actors' director, which is demonstrated in spades throughout the film, alongside his knack for delivering imaginative, visually enticing action sequences.
Winner: Ayer got a raw deal here, but there's no way the winner isn't 2021's The Suicide Squad.
10. Characters & Performances
The 2016 movie had some genuinely solid character work via Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie) and Deadshot (Will Smith), but it ultimately fails to make the audience buy the familial bond between the members of the Suicide Squad.
The bar scene ahead of the final battle could've been iconic, but the film takes such a skittish approach to most of its roster that it's tough to care much about most of them.
Performance-wise at least Robbie, Smith, and Viola Davis gave their all.
But James Gunn's new take just feels so, so much more genuine from start to finish. In two hours, Gunn makes us care for most of these characters, such that when many of them inevitably die, we actually feel something.
The ensemble cast is also stronger than in 2016, with even the more minor cast members typically getting something interesting to do. There's not a single weak link.
WINNER: 2016 had so much potential, but in execution the 2021 Suicide Squad decisively takes it.
9. Narrative
This is a weak point for both movies, admittedly, because each is understandably more concerned with focusing on its characters than on dense, nuanced storytelling.
But there's little denying that the 2016 movie's story isn't just basic - it's a mess.
Even in the Extended Cut, Enchantress' (Cara Delevingne) plan to resurrect her brother Incubus (Alain Chanoine) is ill-defined and insanely dull, leading to a disappointingly typical beam in the sky, end-of-the-world finale.
Gunn sensibly keeps things simpler and less-convoluted, with a typical men-on-a-mission story which takes an amusing left-turn into a monster movie later on. It's hardly the most inspired narrative, but it's elevated significantly by the strong character work and creative action.
Thematically Ayer's film is meanwhile pretty empty - not that every superhero movie needs to be about something - but Gunn's offers up some unexpectedly cutting political commentary on American foreign policy of all things.
WINNER: Again not a strong suit for either movie, but Gunn has a much firmer handle on his story, keeping it streamlined in order to serve the characters and set-pieces.
8. Music
Steven Price's score is certainly one of the strongest aspects of Suicide Squad 2016, though it's ultimately drowned out by the grating overabundance of pop music featured throughout the film - a decision made by Warner Bros. and one that Ayer himself didn't approve of.
Gunn's new film uses a lot of existing music itself, but the placements feel more pointed and meaningful, rather than the result of a studio desperately trying to inject emotion and energy into scenes that aren't quite working.
John Murphy's original score is hardly the most memorable superhero soundtrack you're ever going to hear, but it appropriately amps up the energy of the mayhem Gunn commits to the screen.
WINNER: Considering that Warner Bros. went out of their way to shoehorn as much pop music into the 2016 movie as possible, this is another easy W for Gunn.
7. The Villain
One of the biggest complaints about Suicide Squad 2016 is its utter non-event of a villain.
Enchantress could've been an intriguing antagonist in theory, but she's treated here as a generic, annoying, hip-shaking weirdo, unaided by wonky visual effects and Cara Delevingne's flat performance in the role.
And that's without even getting into the hideous CGI horrorshow that is Incubus.
The 2021 film meanwhile has the one-two punch of Starro and Gaius Grieves aka The Thinker (Peter Capaldi), and it goes without saying that a gigantic murderous extraterrestrial starfish is infinitely more fun than anything Ayer's villains had to offer.
WINNER: Neither film offers up particularly nuanced villains, but Gunn knows to have fun with his ridiculous baddies, while Ayer's movie treats them with self-serious reverence yet does little to make them interesting. 2021 wins again.
6. Visuals
A lot of people complain about Suicide Squad 2016's visuals being too dark and drab, and while some added splashes of neon would've absolutely been welcome, the film's 2.39:1 aspect ratio arguably makes it look more cinematic than Gunn's film.
It certainly resembles an expensive movie, and cinematographer Roman Vasyanov does his best to generate a gritty mood, though the deference towards goofy VFX in the third act is a real shame.
Gunn meanwhile opts for a tighter 1.85:1 aspect ratio due to shooting his film entirely in IMAX, and while this occasionally threatens to evoke a TV-like aesthetic, Gunn has a far looser and more energetic approach to his camerawork.
There's a real dynamism to Gunn's filmmaking, combined with fantastic CGI throughout - particularly for King Shark (Sylvester Stallone) and Starro - which ensure it pops visually in every single scene.
WINNER: They're both handsome, well-made movies to a point, though the 2016 version would've benefited from a more colourful palette and more creative VFX. Gunn runs away with this one.
5. Pacing
Pacing is an important part of any movie, to ensure the audience is consistently engaged with the story and not frequently checking their watch.
Though Ayer's film clocks in at a seemingly reasonable 123 minutes, Warner Bros.' final cut of the movie is a frantic, hyperactive mess, with the first act in particular trying to cram in a frankly obscene number of expository character introductions.
The whiplash-inducing editing makes the 2016 movie feel too hurried for its own good, though ironically the third act is conversely an interminable slog as the Squad takes on Enchantress.
Despite being almost 10 minutes longer, Gunn's film barely feels like it's 100 minutes long, let alone 132.
This is a great example of a movie that never sticks in one place any longer than it needs to in order to get the point across - no doubt aided by slick editing from veteran cutters Fred Raskin and Christian Wagner.
WINNER: This is one of the most egregious aspects of the 2016 version, while an absolute technical high-point of the 2021 film.
4. Action Sequences
David Ayer proved with Fury that he knows how to craft an exciting and intense action sequence, and it was expected that he'd bring a similar level of energy to his Suicide Squad.
But regardless of the film's post-production issues, it's tough to deny that the set-pieces just aren't very interesting.
The Squad spends most of the movie fighting Enchantress' generic zombie-things in bland, poorly-lit environments, and it's painfully clear that more time needed to be spend on coming up with creative action which showcased each character's abilities and personalities.
Gunn's movie is basically the polar opposite: every single action beat is distinctive and imaginative, making liberal use of its permissive R rating to deliver creatively deranged carnage that actually serves the characters themselves.
WINNER: 2021 by a landslide, and it's not even close.
3. Mass Appeal
It's easy to forget that, despite receiving predominantly negative reviews from critics and an underwhelming "B+" CinemaScore from audiences, Suicide Squad 2016 still made almost $750 million worldwide against a $175 million budget.
It clearly worked for a lot of people, and inarguably helped catapult Harley Quinn even further into mainstream pop-culture - she's been a Halloween costume mainstay ever since.
But there's also no denying the film's infamous reputation today, and while there's virtually no chance of Gunn's movie outgrossing Ayer's - due to the pandemic, its day-and-date HBO Max release, and its R rating - one suspects it's going to be enjoyed by a far broader swath of casual audiences.
Though Gunn's gory action might turn off a small portion of viewers, his more crowd-pleasing approach ensures The Suicide Squad is going to likely endure as a classic superhero movie for the masses.
WINNER: 2016 might've put more immediate butts in seats, but 2021 has the staying power to be fondly remembered years, even decades from now.
2. Fan Appeal
As maligned as Ayer's movie has been in the five years since its release, it does nevertheless have its passionate defenders, especially more hardcore DC fans who appreciated its place in the wider DC Extended Universe.
For better or worse, 2016's film certainly feels like it's part of a bigger picture, what with meaningful appearances from The Joker (Jared Leto) and Batman (Ben Affleck) setting up a future clash between them - albeit one that never actually happened.
Elsewhere, there's an amusing cameo from The Flash (Ezra Miller), and the story makes a few curious references to the outcome of Batman v Superman.
The Suicide Squad meanwhile, perhaps sensibly, feels almost entirely self-contained, making virtually no references to previous DCEU films and providing only a brief mention of Bloodsport (Idris Elba) having previously put Superman (Henry Cavill) in the hospital.
WINNER: The 2016 movie finally gets a point here, though it's probably for the best that Gunn's film didn't bog itself down with larger franchise concerns.
1. Overall
If you've been keeping score at home, the winner should be pretty obvious - winning in nine of our 10 categories, James Gunn's The Suicide Squad is the easy victor.
Though it's a shame we'll probably never see David Ayer's original intended vision of the 2016 film brought to the big screen - Warner Bros. has already rubbished the #ReleaseTheAyerCut campaign - it's not particularly convincing from the material we've seen that it was ever going to be a great movie.
Gunn's film conversely feels like a fresh air, improving upon the bungled 2016 effort in practically every way, and providing a welcome do-over for an IP which really should've been a slam dunk the first time.
Simply, walk don't run to see The Suicide Squad, because it's one of the most exciting and unpredictable superhero movies in years.