10 2017 Video Games That Wasted Their Biggest Selling Point

Assassin's Creed "Origins"? Yeah, about that...

By Scott Tailford /

Ubisoft

As we wait with baited breath to see how 2018 is going to play out on a global scale (nothing like the looming threat of nuclear war to make you cherish the escapist charms of video games), it's worth taking a look back at just which titles really could've been better.

Advertisement

Naturally, the standout positives are your Zeldas and Horizons of this world, but even less marketed offerings like Hellblade, Night in the Woods and NieR: Automata provided experiences routed in the medium of video games, pushing the envelope and inventing a few of their own to boot.

That said, many 2017 games felt completely different to play when compared to how they were marketed. Rather like a film trailer cutting together the most bankable elements before you realise what you're watching is a bust (here's looking at you, Hostiles), no one likes being hoodwinked after the fact, or otherwise being misled as to what they were investing in.

Advertisement

Outside of straight misrepresentation is a game failing to remotely capitalise on its potential too - something that in the age of hype and viral marketing campaigns, can be disastrous for a franchise going forward.

What went wrong? Well...

Advertisement

10. Being The Next Burnout - Need For Speed: Payback

EA

In the run-up to launch it looked as though EA had finally accepted the obvious: No one wants Need for Speed anymore, as thanks to both the Fast & the Furious movies and early looks at Payback connoting an OTT tone, we were on course for a full-on revival of the arcade racer.

Advertisement

Sadly, all that potential comes crashing down the second you boot Payback up. The story and characters are try-hard to the point of being parodic (but nope, they're actually taking all this seriously), and car handling overall is markedly unresponsive. There's every chance that the latter is down to EA wanting you to embark on some meaningful progression, unlocking various cars and parts for hours upon hours - or it's because there's also a RNG grind governing what you unlock and when.

Got a slow car? Buy some spins of the wheel and maybe you'll get what you want!

Advertisement

It's truly terrible, a sad state of affairs for the franchise considering past glories, and a marked left turn from a game direction that we all would've loved.

9. Saving The Brand And Telling A Great Single Player Story - Star Wars Battlefront 2

EA

It should not be this hard to make a Star Wars video game the whole world falls in love with.

Advertisement

Remember the halcyon days of Jedi Knight, The Force Unleashed or Knights of the Old Republic? Lucasfilm knew exactly who to trust with the license, and exactly which games to pump out. Now EA are behind the controls, we get one uber-expensive, all bells n' whistles mess every couple of years.

Yes, there are mobile apps also bearing the iconic yellow and black logo, but come time for Battlefront 2 to right the ship and prove why EA deserve to hold the license in the first place, it dropped the ball in landmark fashion. Our old friend microtransactions was back, and not only was the game's entire progression tied to blind boxes dictating what upgrades you got, but you could actively pay to win by unlocking more whenever you liked.

Advertisement

All of this is without mentioning the single player story - one that was heavily marketed and showcased as being entirely Empire-themed. Introducing us to Iden Versio, an imperial soldier who hailed from the planet Vardos - a planet that happily marched to the beat of the Empire’s drum - we’d finally get a unique look into the lives and beliefs of the everyday soldier on the other side of the fence.

How did all of that shake out in the final product? By having an early plot twist shift Iden’s allegiances as she suddenly joined the rebels, was welcomed essentially with open arms, and set about gunning down her former stormtrooper friends as “Generic Star Wars Story #6315” played out.

Advertisement

What a waste of everybody’s time.

8. Taking The Franchise In A Bold New Direction - Mass Effect Andromeda

Bioware

Simply because it wasn't a numbered instalment, Bioware were in position to experiment with Mass Effect Andromeda. Clearly we were going to the Andromeda galaxy, but what crazy new alien species would we find? What otherwordly planets, biomes and extraterrestrial life could they think of?

Advertisement

Well, it turns out... the answer was, erm... next to nothing. Andromeda's new races were a load of armoured-up soldier-men and the rest were cat people. We DID hear about another race but... never saw them. Mass Effect Andromeda went from having a blank canvas to play with, to getting lost in a sea of beige - it was that generic, bland and forgettable.

From developer in-fighting between studios to publisher mandates telling various coders to focus on the game's multiplayer over refining, say, facial animation, the results spoke for themselves.

Advertisement

The second we pundits got a look at how Andromeda was shaping up, we laughed. And then we kept laughing, long into the year.

Electronic Arts

7. Focusing On The Nemesis System To Make A Truly Great Game - Middle-Earth: Shadow Of War

WB Games

Shadow of Mordor tends to be thought of as the best game of 2014, simply because that year was such a wash overall. However, there was real merit to Monolith's innovative Nemesis system, and its way of making any random enemy really matter thematically was the sort of thing next generations of video games should strive to show off.

Advertisement

As the years ticked by we saw nothing in the way of an immediate followup, lending weight to the notion that Monolith must be going all-out, incorporating fan feedback and pairing it with even loftier ambitions regarding dynamic A.I. interactions, to create a truly phenomenal open-world action game.

Cut to Shadow of War, and its orc interactions are this, but alongside is a truly off-putting loot system, complete with grind-heavy mission design and a blind box microtransaction storefront if you want to buy your way through. Elements of what Shadow of War SHOULD have been come through whenever an orc remembers one of your past interactions or responds to attacking them over and over, but overall this game's reception has been notably more sour than the original.

Advertisement

6. Having The Most Balanced Third-Person Combat Ever - For Honor

Ubisoft

Although Dark Souls is focused on being a "one character against the world" hack n' slash game with brutal difficulty, its multiplayer component has amassed swathes of hardcore fans perfecting which weapons, stances and abilities work against one another.

Advertisement

It's this framework that made For Honor look so tantalising. Just you, another player, and an elaborate rock, paper, scissors sense of balance to everything thereafter. Larger battles were included too, but the real meat came from perfecting your skills and pitting them against other players, one sword-slash and perfectly executed dodge at a time.

Sadly, despite all of the above still providing Ubisoft with one of their most unique games in years, launch saw servers dogged with lag and repeated disconnects. Still, Ubisoft would apply many patches to the game's burgeoning community... until they went one too far, ruining the in-game economy by making it nigh-on impossible to unlock anything without relying on blind box rewards.

Advertisement

5. Delivering A Phenomenal, Halo-Rivalling Story - Destiny 2

Bungie

For some reason that seems continually impossible to parse out, Destiny has one of the most passionate fanbases out there, doggedly running and re-running the same missions over and over, attempting to get better gear. Simply because of that (the average player has an play-count of 500 hours), all eyes were on the sequel to, well, justify such devotion in a more obvious and accepted manner.

Advertisement

Sadly, the reality of Destiny 2 is that Bungie essentially released the same game again. Yes, there are scores of new items and weapons, but from character creation screens and menus to the general feel of gameplay in regards to power-ups and movement, there is VERY little to differentiate the two.

All of this might have been more acceptable, had the story of Destiny 2 delivered. Yet again though, Bungie dropped the ball, spinning a threadbare yarn of one giant evil alien named Ghaul, who was out to steal the Traveller (the giant orb above Earth), only to get taken out by the good guys.

Advertisement

That's it. That was literally all they wrote.

4. Being The Next Wii Sports - 1-2-Switch

Nintendo

Y'know Nintendo, you could've just released Switch Sports, though you have to give it to them for going for a new IP with a different set of gimmicks instead. Sadly, although 1-2-Switch was set up as the next Wii Sports - complete with family-friendly minigames and a stupidly positive aesthetic, the reality is that mainstream audiences were completely done with motion controls.

Advertisement

Of course, it didn't help that the minigames themselves were just a bit naff. Milking cows, trying to catch invisible swords, guessing the amount of ice cubes in the controller? All fine, but nothing anybody is ever going to pay £60 for.

Although back at the Switch's launch, many lamented Nintendo's decision to not include a copy of 1-2 with every system, in retrospect it seems to have paid off, being they've avoided getting the Switch associated with the sorts of things that killed the Wii U. Regardless, even if Nintendo didn't fully believe in its capabilities and the consumer didn't want them, 1-2-Switch being completely forgotten about is a huge missed opportunity.

Advertisement

3. Living Up To The Name - Ghost Recon: Wildlands

Ubisoft

Of all the Ubisoft properties to bring into the modern day, Ghost Recon has major weight as a household name. Advanced Warfighter helped shift enough 360s to make it that generation's dominant system, and yet... although the ground for an open-world instalment that rolled together Far Cry outposts and Watch Dogs tech sounded solid, the reality was something else entirely.

Advertisement

No, the reality of Wildlands came from it immediately being one of the most broken and "early access-feeling" releases the company has ever put out. From the get-go you're greeted with subpar animations, tons of clipping between vehicles, characters, environment etc., and a script that was so laughably bad, you weren't sure whether to take it seriously or attempt to laugh along.

Some fun can still be had by buddying up with friends online and raining down collective hellfire from a chopper, but unless you bring your own fun to the table, all Ghost Recon has is scraps of a better game that never feels fully formed.

Advertisement

2. Tell A Satisfying Origin Of The Assassin's Order - Assassin's Creed: Origins

Ubisoft

There's one specific scene where you can tell Ubisoft's writers weren't fully committed to telling the backstory of the Assassin Order. Coming right alongside main-man Bayek being given his own hidden blade, wife Aya mentions that she has been "given" the hidden blade from Cleopatra. She notes that it's an "ancient blade that killed the tyrant Xerxes", but that's all we get.

Advertisement

So much for a detailed origin of the Assassin's various codes and practices, weapons and garb. Bayek even starts the game animating and moving in much the same way as every other AC protagonist always has - yet a future plot-dump could've filled in the gaps never comes.

Instead, Origins waits until its final scenes before really hammering home - like so on the nose it'll knock you out obvious - that Bayek and Aya are becoming "The Hidden Ones", "operating in the shadows" and establishing the creed, but it feels like it carries on from assumptive information we never really get.

Advertisement

Where did the hidden blade come from? Why did the assassins become so adept at parkour, and did Bayek accidentally slicing off his finger usher in a few generations of copycats, not knowing it stemmed from a mistake?

So much potentially cool connective tissue to all the other games, mostly ignored.

Advertisement

1. Saving The Xbox One's Otherwise Disastrous Year - PUBG

Bluehole

All you had to do, PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds, was be playable. That's all you had to do.

Advertisement

Coming right at the end of the year - a year that for Xbox, was literally devoid of any first-party releases whatsoever - on launch, you were buggy as hell.

PUBG has improved a smidge since then, as Bluehole released a patch claiming it was a "first pass" at fixing the game's graphical issues such as pop-in, where entire buildings could materialise right in front of you. Seriously, a "first pass"? On a release that's not only exclusive to Xbox One, but on a build that was on PC months ago. Optimisation should have been the top priority - people were literally buying Xbox One X's for thing thing.

Advertisement

Imagine buying a grand's worth of new TV and console combo, then firing up a multiplayer game that has millions of concurrent players... only to find the houses don't load in, and it crashes one in every three times.

At time of writing (Jan 6th) the state of PUBG on Xbox is still a sham, and one made ever worse by the fact that you can experience another battle royale mode in Fortnite, for free. F R E E.

Advertisement