10 Awesome Things Sleeping Dogs Does Better Than GTA V

There is no doubt in anyone's mind that GTA V was a monolith of gaming. However it isn't perfect, and there are other open world games out there that do better in certain areas.

By Thomas Broome-Jones /

There is no doubt in anyone's mind that GTA V was a monolith of gaming. The record-breaking and critically-acclaimed masterpiece has comfortably succeeded GTA IV's place in the all-time great seventh-generation of games, and will be a testament to what the Xbox 360 and PS3 are capable of years down the line. But as excellent as GTA V is, it isn't perfect and there are other open world games out there that do better in certain areas, such as Sleeping Dogs. Sleeping Dogs is a 2012 game that was originally supposed to be the third game in the True Crime series. After the series was discontinued it was eventually picked up again and repackaged as Sleeping Dogs, a game in which the player must infiltrate the Hong Kong Triad and bring them down internally. This article isn't to suggest that Sleeping Dogs is a superior game, it falls short in a fair few areas, but there are 10 things that it managed to execute in a superior way to GTA V.

10. Less Reliance On Satire

Everyone knows that the Grand Theft Auto franchise exists solely to rip American culture a new one and expose its flaws in an over-the-top and borderline offensive way. The satire in GTA V was superb, but it's almost as if it was too heavily relied on to tell the story, every character existed to lampoon some aspect of American excess, with very little identity of their own. Michael and his loved ones were the dysfunctional family and an ironic take on middle-America, Franklin was poverty and Trevor was a flaw in the system. They never really broke these assigned roles and the story was just unfurled through their interaction with each other and the clear intention of them being a hilarious satire of America. Sleeping Dogs tells its story much more like a true narrative, with less humour and more of an emphasis on loyalty and the consequences of criminality. It felt highly similar to something like Infernal Affairs, a film about undercover Hong Kong cops, the plot very rarely used satire and preferred to use characters with clear goals and ambitions. There was a healthy number of double-crosses, mature development and much more seriousness. GTA V's satire is great, but the plot took a back seat to it one too many times.

9. Clothing Bonuses

GTA V offered an enormous and highly varied range of clothing options for all three of its protagonists. Franklin especially had some really cool styles and could rock formal just as well as street wear. Sleeping Dogs may lack the range of clothing that GTA V possesses, but it makes up for it with the inclusion of clothing bonuses as well as unlockable outfits. Wearing the right combinations of clothes will present the player with some highly useful benefits, such as discounts in stores or bonus Triad points earned in each mission. But the real icing on the cake is the range of unlockable costumes that are afforded to the player, a particular costume of note is Bruce Lee's yellow and black tracksuit from Game of Death. GTA V doesn't really have anything across these lines and whilst it arguably has better clothing that Sleeping Dogs, it doesn't have bonuses and it doesn't have Bruce Lee. And Bruce Lee beats everything.

8. Moral Conundrums

There isn't really any kind of moral restriction in GTA V, it's not hard to embrace the fact that your character is a criminal without a care in the world so you can just go on a killing spree without the guilt. The problem this presents is when the game tries to make us feel like the characters are in a moral dilemma and we can't empathise, as has always been the issue with these games. In GTA IV, for example, Niko almost always turns down alcoholic drinks in cutscenes, but the player can get him incredibly drunk whenever they like. In GTA V, when cutscenes try and present the characters as thinking human beings with actual hearts, it's a difficult pill to swallow if you've just been gunning down a crowd of people five minutes earlier. Sleeping Dogs encourages the player to think about their actions and engage in the protagonist's situation. As you're an undercover cop and not really a triad, it kind of puts you off murdering citizen after citizen because that isn't what a cop does. Even though in GTA V, Franklin was supposed to be the "moral" character, it's still not hard to shoot a few people out of boredom when controlling him.

7. Stronger Story

Don't get me wrong, GTA V has an outstanding story that a lot of care and love went into, but the premise is just so uninspired, ex-criminal needs money, ex-criminal teams up with old friend and new guy, they do a few robberies and get rich. There's no human element to this story, it's just motivated by greed. I feel like GTA IV's story was much better and I feel the same way about Sleeping Dogs. The deeper the player found themselves infiltrating the Triad, the more and more dangerous missions became, there is always a kind of uncertainty that maybe the protagonist is starting to side with his criminal family and will betray the cops. This suspense is kept right up until literally the very end, it's nerve-racking. It was easy to see how GTA V would pan out right from the start and regardless of the fact it was cool how they got there, there was very little suspense. Sleeping Dogs never fully reveals itself to the player until all the dust has settled.

6. Presents A Real Challenge

GTA V wasn't "easy" by any stretch of the imagination, but it wasn't exactly a challenge either. Trevor's special ability, for example, was a sort of get-out clause if you were near to death, being able to dole out double the punishment and receive minimal damage, Franklin's special was fun but it made car chases way too easy and Michael's special, well, to be fair Michael's special wasn't that great, but more on that later. The ability to switch characters was an innovative and welcome feature, but you have to admit that it made heated missions much easier when you could just switch to a character with more health when your character was about to clock out. Sleeping Dogs tested the player's feel of the mechanics as it got closer to the end, many a time you would find yourself swamped with enemies of varying attack patterns with different strengths and weaknesses, forcing the player to be creative with their tactics. The fact that Sleeping Dogs primarily focuses on hand-to-hand combat means that killing your foes in an enclosed space isn't as simple as just gunning them down. GTA V struck a good balance in that it was fun and kept the player aware, but it wasn't actually that challenging a game.

5. A Likeable Protagonist

It's hard to really warm to any of GTA V's three protagonists, with the possible exception of Franklin. Trevor is a stone-cold psycho who is absolutely terrifying, and Michael is a selfish sociopath who can't control his personal or private life. Franklin may be the most "normal" out of the three, but he still has no hesitations towards murder and robbery in the name of financial gain, all three of these characters are motivated by money, that's all they care about, and whilst I'm sure we all agree that money is a nice thing, it can make them seem a tad one-dimensional at some points. Wei Shen is a different story, he's the kind of guy that you can really root for, the main reason being that he's a cop; one of the good guys. But there's more to him than that, he is willing to give up his livelihood to bring down organised crime in Hong Kong, almost costing him his sanity. He can take care of himself in a fight, is cool, calm, collected and respects the people around him. There's very little reason to hate him, he can seem somewhat cocky at times but that kind of humour adds a layer of humanity to him. Think of him as a Hong Kong Police Department version of Spider-Man.

4. Bullet-Time

As I mentioned before, Michael's special ability to slow down time whilst shooting in GTA V left a lot to be desired. We expected something akin to Dead Eye from Red Dead Redemption or the bullet-time mechanic of Max Payne 3, instead we got something that was hard to control and didn't lock on to targets quick enough. The bullet-time in Sleeping Dogs can't just be activated whenever the player so desires. Oh no, it's far cooler than that. In true John Woo style, bullet-time can be activated when jumping from vehicles and leaping over objects, allowing for Max Payne-esque mid-air shooting that feels and looks truly awesome. It takes some getting used to, but once you've fully upgraded your bullet-time skills and mastered the mechanic it will save your skin at crucial moments.

3. On-Foot Navigation

GTA V improved on GTA IV's on-foot navigation by quite a margin. Gone was Niko's turning circle of six feet and getting destroyed in firefights because you weren't able to work out how to move. But GTA V still didn't quite perfect it, the turning circle of the characters still wasn't great and whilst firefights were easier, it was still possible to confuse your sense of direction. Sleeping Dogs hit the nail right on the head with responsive movement and a free-running element. Whether you were in a chase on foot or just trying to get somewhere, there was definitely fun to be had in being able to scale various surfaces in a kind of GTA/Assassin's Creed hybrid. Seeing as the driving mechanics in Sleeping Dogs were barely functional, it was a relief that running was so fine-tuned.

2. Vehicle Storage

Vehicle customisation in GTA V was nothing short of excellent; the sheer amount of things you could modify your car with took me aback. But storing your vehicle was another matter entirely, garages were few and far between and if you splashed out a lot of cash to modify your car only for it to be destroyed, then you had to do it all over again. I appreciate that this is a more realistic approach but in a game where you can survive being shot in the head because you're wearing a bulletproof vest I don't think realism is the most important aspect. Sleeping Dogs didn't offer any vehicle customisation beyond different paint jobs, but the storage system was simple; you bought a car, it was in your garage forever. No matter how many times you wrecked your car, you were able to go to a garage and pick it up again. Also, garages were everywhere, you were never too far from one so if you needed your car quickly you could go and grab it. Simple, yet effective.

1. Hand-To-Hand Combat

Fist-fights in GTA IV were broken, no two ways about it. V improved them, but only to the level of being passable. Gunplay is the primary mode of combat in GTA V I understand that, but is it really so hard to implement a decent hand-to-hand combat system? You had a limited set of punches, kicks and combos that made melees more of an irritating chore than anything. Sleeping Dogs on the other hand has received high praise for its focus on hand-to-hand combat. Guns are available too but you're having the most fun when you're in a street fight. Imagine the free flow combat system from the Batman: Arkham games and replace the moves with traditional martial arts techniques and that's Sleeping Dogs' fighting mechanic. The more your character upgrades, the more moves you'll learn. The countering is smooth and brutal, allowing you to take on groups of 20 successfully, and making you feel like the toughest guy on the planet. Well, there you have it, the flaws in Sleeping Dogs hold it back from being superior to GTA V, but it still did some things better. Do you agree or disagree with any of my choices? What features would you like to see implemented in the next GTA or the next Sleeping Dogs? Let me know in the comments and follow me on Twitter @TBroomey to let me know what you think.