10 Baffling Oversights In Otherwise Great Video Games
How did it take seven games to let you crouch in Assassin's Creed?
Every player on the planet has been there; firing your way through a new favourite game only to suddenly stumble across something that makes you put the controller down, step back from the screen and just go “Huh?”
For as much as any pre-release trailers and hype would have you believe, games rarely manage to fine-tune every single mechanic and feature, and often miss the mark entirely on one significant aspect of gameplay. As a result, even in good games players can end up running across a half-baked idea that just doesn't fit in with the rest of what's on offer.
Often these oversights are a case of dissonance between gameplay and story; for instance, didn't it always feel a bit weird to be robbing stores as good-guy John Marston in Red Dead Redemption? A character isn't really being being redeemed by pillaging and murdering everyone they see, yet Rockstar gave you the freedom to do so despite it being entirely at odds with the character and story shown in cutscenes.
Small oddities like this can serve to completely break the immersion of any given title, and often end up be nagging frustrations that pull back otherwise good games. And even bad video games come out all time, it's always hurts more to see a title that's so close to reaching greatness get dragged down by of one simple lapse of judgement.
10. L.A Noire's Interrogations Turn Cole Phelps Into A Psychopath
830942Just about everything in L.A Noire was ground-breaking for its time; from its stunning facial animations to its meticulous crime-solving structure, the 2011 title was unlike anything gamers had ever seen before.
Unfortunately though, the detective thriller had a few tonal oversights that made the whole experience feel a little, well, unstable. For starters, your character, Cole Phelps, is given the able to interrogate people in order to find out information that could prove to be invaluable to whichever case he's currently working on. Likewise, the game gives you the option to analyse whether the character being interrogated is telling the truth or lying, with different outcomes based on your different accusations.
A brilliant concept on paper, in execution these dialogue choices are flawed to their very core, thanks to some very random-feeling animations from Mr. Phelps. The options are left vague, with either "lie", "truth", or "doubt" providing no real signifier as to what your character will actually do. While "doubt" in one context could be nothing more than a stern look, in another it could result in Cole loudly threatening an undeserving suspect.
Even worse, after such a misjudged outrage, the character would always slip back into his reserved demeanour and the game would carry on as if nothing happened, resulting in some of the weirdest interrogations ever seen in a video game.
9. Metal Gear Solid 3 Revises The Series' Iconic Stealth. Breaks It.
Stealth for the first two games in the Metal Gear Solid franchise was simple. Shockingly so, even. With the whole experience boiling down to essentially whether or not your character was in the small field of view of an enemy (signalled by a cone of vision on the mini-map), these early games were able to create an accessible yet incredibly fun game of cat and mouse.
That is, until Metal Gear Solid 3 overcomplicated things. Removing the simplistic cone of vision approach of previous titles, this third entry in the series added a wealth of new features to aid you in sneaking your way through levels. As a result, enemies became smarter with a long range equipment, meaning patrols could spot you from as far as halfway across the map.
Which would have been fine, if the game actually explained how you were supposed to evade them. Giving you a new camouflage editor, the title had players matching their camo in accordance to their environment, with their stealth rating being indicated by a percentage.
However, this percentage told you virtually nothing about how hidden you were in terms of how close guards could get before being alerted, how fast you could move without being seen or whether or not they could spot you off-screen - reducing the whole thing to an endless exercise in menu-cycling trial and error.
8. Hitman: Absolution Ruins Its Own Disguise Sytem
One of the silliest, yet most iconic features in all of the Hitman games is the ability to disguise Agent 47 in the most ludicrous outfits and have him somehow get into almost anywhere undetected because of it. However, for obvious reasons, this perhaps wasn't the most realistic way to treat disguises in what's otherwise a very deep and intricate stealth game, so for the last iteration, Hitman: Absolution, the developers at IO Interactive decided to shake things up.
However, in doing so the developers almost entirely ripped out the entire charm the feature had in the first place. Instead of being able to slip into any disguise and call it a day, the costumes were now split into types, which meant that any other NPCs sharing the same outfit as you would become instantly suspicious if you aroused their attention, regardless of their proximity to you.
Although not a terrible change up, in reality this essentially made disguises entirely useless, but more importantly, completely eliminated the fun they posed to be in the first place. In other games you could murder a waiter and steal his clothes, slipping into any kitchen completely undetected, all with an air of dark humour about it. However if you tried the same thing in Absolution you'd be spotted instantly by 10 cooks standing on the other side of the level.
7. Deus Ex Renders One Of Its Playstyles Pointless
A staple of the Deus Ex franchise has always been the ability to play the game any way you see fit. However, although the latest entry into the franchise, Human Revolution, boasts the same ability, it actually makes gamers' favourite past-time of murdering faceless guards with the biggest weapons available detrimental to the overall experience.
For no real reason, killing people in Deus Ex gives you way less benefits than passing them by. There's no real reason as to why the game favours a stealthy approach - it just arbitrarily awards you less experience points for being a creative psychopath, which makes it entirely frustrating as a player to see a game series based around freedom basically directly condemn one of its own playstyles. As a result, a majority of gamers just ended up not playing the title this way, because the RPG would actively punish them even if they decided to go down this route.
Annoying, this rendered a good portion of skills useless also, and stopped players form using the game’s most visually enjoyable weapon. Seriously, Square Enix, if you give players a protagonist with swords for elbows, let us actually use them.
6. Far Cry 2 Makes Exploration As Frustrating As Possible
Although more of a precursory experiment to what would later go on to become Far Cry 3, this humble predecessor absolutely nailed a feature which would soon become a franchise staple: an absolutely gorgeous game world. From its sprawling map, extensive wildlife and regular garrisons of mercenary hideouts to find, the game absolutely begged you to explore its hugely robust environment.
Unfortunately though, the developers made one glaring oversight that made traversing the exotic landscape of this experimental title completely unbearable. Littered throughout the map - like in its sequels - Far Cry 2 featured gang hideouts and checkpoints that you had to fight you way through. However unlike what would come next, the game immediately re-spawned these defeated enemies as soon as you had left the general vicinity.
Which meant that to get anywhere, you’d have to destroy the same checkpoints and get chased by the same group of enemies again and again for the full length of the campaign. Unfortunately, this meant that fast travel was the preferred method of transport and as a result few players ever saw the full scale of Far Cry 2’s expansive map.
5. Wolfenstein: The New Order's Health System Ruins Firefights
One of the most interesting and enjoyable parts of the most recent Wolfenstein re-imagining was down to it’s reliance on old-school video game design. From the wide-open levels to the duel-wielding weapons, everything about the game worked as a call-back to older first person shooters, which paradoxically, made The New Order one of the most refreshing titles of last year.
However, not all of these older mechanics worked as well as they should have, and in fact, the way the game made you stop to pick up health and armour in the midst of combat completely went against the run-and-gun ethos of the whole experience.
This oversight is perhaps more disappointing because The New Order was an amazing franchise reboot, yet it would have felt so much more cohesive with the ability to stay on the move without having to search around the floor and under debris for hidden health kits and armour pieces every five seconds. Even something as simple as allowing players to store health packs would have done wonders to keep up the blistering pace of this otherwise pitch-perfect title.
4. Dark Souls' Final Boss Is Impossible Without A Specific Ability
Dark Souls is a one of the hardest games ever made, everyone knows that by now, but what’s more important than the game's difficulty is that the title is always fair with its challenge, never resorting to cheap or frustrating tactics in order to beat you to the ground over and over again.
That is, until you get to the final boss anyway. Unlike the other enemies in the game, this final encounter requires you to specifically perform one ability - the counter - if you even want to stand a chance of coming out on top.
Unfortunately for you, although the ability would indeed make your life a bit easier during the course of the game, it’s never an essential tactic to defeat an enemy before then, which means players tend to adopt a completely different fighting style which they learn and perfect over the 80 hour campaign – which annoyingly has to be entirely unlearned for the game's final bout.
3. Fallout: New Vegas Only Works With A Cowboy Hat
In a way, you could argue that everything about the initial release of Fallout: New Vegas was an oversight. Coming out the gates virtually unplayable, the title was riddled with bugs from beginning to end, providing players with one of the funniest, yet most frustratingly broken games of the last generation.
However, there was one oversight in the development of this game that was so specific and so ridiculous that it had to be featured on this list. Once you arrive at the titular strip of New Vegas in the original version of the title, you almost immediately encountered a game-breaking bug that would make your character unable to enter the most important area of the game if you weren’t wearing a specific cowboy hat.
For some reason, if you weren't equipped with this seemingly inconsequential piece of attire the game would refuse to work, crashing every time you attempted to enter the titular New Vegas strip. Every. Single. Time.
Fortunately, some time later a patch resolved this issue, however it didn’t resolve the biggest question left hanging from the whole debacle; just why was the game only programmed to work with that one, stupid hat?
2. Assassin's Creed Is A Stealth Game Without A Crouch Button
For a game almost entirely based around staying out of sight and keeping hidden, it’s absolutely ridiculous that until Assassin’s Creed: Unity - the franchises’ seventh entry no less - players couldn’t even crouch to keep out the view of patrolling enemies.
The lack of a crouch button would have been a fine, if a bit weird, design choice in any other game, but when the whole experience of a title is centred around increasingly elaborate ways to stay unnoticed in a dense open world, it always felt completely at odds that as a master Assassin you couldn't even do something as simple as this to avoid the wrath of incoming guards.
For the most part the omission of this simple feature proved to be only a small frustrating hindrance, however it occasionally made completing certain missions that required you to stay out of sight nigh-impossible. It wouldn't be so bad either if it was only the earlier games that didn't include this ability, but the fact that it took seven iterations before it finally made an appearance is completely inexcusable.
1. Watch Dogs' Police Are Afraid Of Water
Oh Watch Dogs, you just couldn't catch a break, could you? Within all the hubbub surrounding the game’s supposed graphical downgrade and the general feeling of disappointment that enveloped the game upon release, it was clear that the title wasn’t as ready as it should have been when this open world game first launched.
But the worst oversight in this half-baked adventure managed to render an entire portion of the gameplay experience completely redundant. In car chases between your hacker protagonist Aiden Pierce and the police, the game encourages you to use the wide digital arsenal at your disposable. But why would you bother when hopping on a boat and fleeing to the water would be ten times as effective?
See, the cops in Watch Dogs apparently haven’t been trained – or they just don’t get paid enough – to chase crooks over water, and as a result will turn around and leave you alone as soon as you hit any of the rivers located around Chicago.
So, whenever you'd find yourself on the receiving end of some particularly bad police brutality (and you always did, over and over again) you never had to worry, because there was always an easy way out of even the most hardest of chases.
What are your most egregious oversights for otherwise brilliant games? Let us know in the comments!