10 Bleak Game Over Screens That Crushed You

Kicking you while you're down.

By Rob Cain /

Games have always been a tricky time balancing win and fail states. The constant push towards beating the story or reaching an objective is their central hook.

Advertisement

When you succeed, it's euphoric, but when you fail it can be punishing.

Starting off with the old style game over screens, titles used simple messages to tell the player that they'd run out of lives or time. Considering how difficult video games were at the time, a game over was the last thing you wanted to see. Having to do the whole game again was your punishment.

When technology pushed forwards, developers started getting more ambitious and the unique fail states followed suite. With an increased focus on complexity, games are now able to go much bleaker. Losing can now come at a much higher price, depending on genre and context.

Going beyond simple death scenes, these horrific ending sequences reinforced the weight of the player's failure. They were either creepy, punishing or a combination of both.

If nothing else, many a gamer was seriously creeped out or deflated when these games came to an abrupt end.

10. Mass Effect 3

The highly anticipated final chapter to the wildly popular Mass Effect trilogy boasted many high moments, but became more widely known for its contentious endgame.

Advertisement

As Commander Shepherd, your world is put on the line as the Reapers invade the Milky Way. Death and destruction are rife and you're tasked with solving problems that have plagued the setting for years. It's a desperate bid to rally the many species behind you to take on the deadly synthetic foes.

Mass Effect 3's ending was widely controversial and divisive amongst fans, so much so that Bioware would release an extended cut to address many of its shortcomings. Alongside all the ending slides and new scenes, a fourth ending found its way into the mix.

To the dismay of some players, it didn't provide a way to beat the Reapers conventionally.

Refusing to use the catalyst, your efforts throughout the entire trilogy were effectively wasted in this specific conclusion. With everyone and everything dying at the hands of the metallic monsters, we immediately cut to a future world. Buried beneath the ground, series favourite Liara T'Soni relays your failure to win the war as a downbeat score plays.

So much for all those war assets you built up...

9. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots

An icon of the stealth genre, the Metal Gear franchise has maintained a strong fanbase to this day. From their winding stories to the little details added in by their creator, the series is well established across the board.

Advertisement

Metal Gear Solid has always been known for its mission failed screens. Characters would often chime in over the radio, desperately trying to raise the protagonist and realising what has happened with horror. Yet for the fourth entry Kojima went a step further.

As a very downbeat and unusually depressing tale, Guns Of The Patriots features the icon of the series slowly withering away. Old Snake's final mission tasks him with saving the world before bowing out for good, battling accelerated aging and stiff joints all the way. The world itself is on the verge of total chaos, having been planted under a state of endless war between PMCs and rebel groups.

Triggering an alert and knocking your life gauge down to zero brings a grim conclusion. As Old Snake passes, Otacon's horrified yells over the radio and the memory flashbacks hammer home that all is lost. With different themes and images for each of the game's five acts, dying is something you really want to avoid.

8. System Shock

As a pioneer of the immersive sim genre, the System Shock franchise is known for its unique style of sci-fi horror. Taking place in 2072 in one of the early takes on cyberpunk action, the player takes on the rogue AI SHODAN and its sinister plans for humanity.

Advertisement

Where System Shock and its sequels really excel is in atmosphere. This a dark and often bleak vision of the future where humanity is unknowingly placed into the service of technology it cannot control. Setting the game from a first-person perspective only enhances this tone.

Through the use of various tools, weapons and cyberware, you're able to craft your character to handle any situation. Be that as it may, your enemies are vicious and relentless. A legion of unfeeling machines hellbent on sabotaging your mission. The sense of isolation is equally palpable as there are no NPCs to interact with.

Matching its sinister vibes, the title's game over sequence is no different. It only lasts a few seconds, but in terms of creepiness, it maintains a razor edge. As opposed to simply dying, your protaganist's body in System Shock serves the host for a sinister automatron. The body hangs limp from the centre as the mind is enslaved forever.

7. Resident Evil 2

The Resident Evil franchise has, for the most part, relied on a deep undercurrent of misery to sell the survival horror genre. With the exception of the more action-focused releases, the games often leave the player feeling trapped, hopeless, overwhelmed or a combination of the three.

Advertisement

Low ammo supplies, resource management and hideous foes hunting you down are the guiding focus of the original trilogy. Overcoming these odds and slogging your way through mark the greatest reward for fans of the series. Fail and you're treated to some nasty death sequences. One game goes a step further however and that's Resident Evil 2.

Most Resident Evil games simply fade out or show the character lying dead. For the second entry, their bodies get mangled up by the enemy who killed you. Against a black screen, you'll watch Leon, Claire and other playable characters get piled on by zombies, decapitated by plant monsters or impaled by the boss creatures.

These gruesome deaths alongside the words "You Died" put Resident Evil 2 a step above other entries in the franchise, hammering down on the player far more than its contemporaries. It drags out the punishment of getting a game over and twists the knife even further.

6. Metroid Prime: Trilogy

As one of Nintendo's most iconic franchises, Metroid has always maintained high popularity. Its 2D outings on the NES and SNES created some of the finest side-scrolling action on both platforms.

Advertisement

Once the series arrived in the third dimension with Metroid Prime, the franchise was upgraded in every way. Thanks to its immersive qualities and utmost respect for Metroid's focus on exploration and discovery, Retro Studios had taken the series to the next level. Through much of the 2000s, this new take would go from strength.

Exploring the reaches of Talon IV, Aether and the wider galaxy respectively, players were treated to a dazzling series of first-person adventures. Of course, being in this perspective, the death sequences also rose to the occasion, pulling the player in to a much more intimate degree. It's certainly a lot more personal than watching the bounty hunter pop out of her suit on a 2D plane.

Following the shattering of Samus's suit, you'll hear her vital signs reach critical levels and finally cease. The player gets to bear witness to her life slowly ebbing out across the entire trilogy. It varies between games with Echoes showing the bounty hunter overwhelmed by the darkness and the Corruption seeing Samus destroyed by the Phazon coursing through her.

5. The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask

Often considered the dark horse of The Legend Of Zelda franchise, Majora's Mask has maintained a massive following nearly two decades after its release.

Advertisement

Taking a hard left turn, Nintendo's follow-up to its legendary predecessor. took a turn for the strange in 2000. Set in the sinister land of Termina, it's up to Link to prevent the apocalypse while staying one step of ahead of a ticking timer.

Across both the main quests and side quests, the player forms a strong connection with the inhabitants of this world and with only three days to save it, there's a constant pressure to hurry along. Using the returning Ocarina of Time can only get you so far as it also resets much of your previous efforts as well as the world's state.

Did you run out of time to stop the evil moon? You get to see it land and crush the land of Termina. In addition to the moon being especially creepy, you'll watch the three giants desperately try to hold it up, only to fail.

The explosion crushes the land and explodes Link along with it. When compared with previous game over screens, the one in Majora's Mask is by far the darkest of the franchise.

4. Banjo-Kazooie

Throughout the eighties and nineties, Rareware was at the forefront of the gaming scene. Their colourful and challenging releases generated much attention on the NES and SNES. Yet their jump to the Nintendo 64 was another big leap forward, bringing new franchises and projects.

Advertisement

With Banjo-Kazooie, Rare once again proved they were an immensely talented studio under Nintendo's banner. Yet despite being fairly kid-friendly by nineties standards, the studio injected their own share of darker moments. Up to that point, most platformers treated the player with a simple game over screen. You either started back from your last checkpoint or from the beginning in other cases. Banjo-Kazooie was different.

With 3D platformers becoming a massively successful genre, the team were able to add some additional elements to the experience. In addition to widely varied levels and platforming challenges, losing all your lives triggered an additional scene. What happened if they dynamic duo failed their mission? You were shown just that.

In a sinister twist for a kid's game, Banjo's sister is turned into a mutant as game over flashes on the screen. As Gruntilla uses her infernal machine to steal her looks for herself, younger players at the time were treated to the consequences of their failure.

3. Fallout & Fallout 2

When it comes down to depressing tones and unrelenting misery, few can match the Fallout franchise. Starting in 1997, it took the PC platform by storm at the time and one year later, the sequel expanded things further.

Advertisement

What made the first two games so engaging was their setting. Thanks to its unique blend of fifties culture and post-nuclear destruction, the series was able to reach strong popularity right out of the gate. Fallout's place in the gaming landscape isn't as strong as it was previously, but its identity in role-playing remains well known.

Fallout's unforgiving and sombre wasteland has always been one of its biggest stars. Few humans can survive the hellish wastes loaded with radiation, hostile creatures and violent factions. Yet in the first two releases from Interplay and Black Isle Studios, the atmosphere was piled on much more.

Dropping to zero health points, your character's skeletal corpse lies in the desert with the narrator highlighting a depressing end. In the case of Fallout 1, it's even worse.

Choosing to join The Master results in your character being transformed into a Super Mutant, followed up by your vault being savagely slaughtered by the monsters. It's a seriously bleak conclusion to an already downbeat world.

2. XCOM: UFO Defense

In amongst the regular turn-based strategy releases, we have titles that involve much micro-managing. XCOM is one of the biggest examples. Locked in an arms race against a hostile alien menace, the player must not only succeed in missions on the ground, but also manage their base and resources effectively.

Advertisement

Back in 1994, XCOM: UFO Defense was one of the most brutally difficult games ever made. It was merciless in battering the player with many defeats. Yet pushing through and overcoming the odds led to an incredibly rewarding gameplay loop.

Unlike other entries on this list, being defeated in XCOM is a tradition that punishes the player handsomely. Each mainline release is a brutal sequence in its own right, but the most crushing blow is right back in the first game. Lose the war against your foes and you're treated to a hellish endgame.

Blaring music enters the scene as the planet surrenders to the alien invaders. Earth is turned into a terrifying hellscape with mutated humans running amok. It concludes with "The Knowledge of the XCOM project is lost forever, you have failed to save the Earth."

Ironically, the limitations of technology of the time just makes the moment that much more creepy.

1. Batman: Arkham City

Finally, we come to the Batman Arkham franchise, which is widely regarded by fans and critics alike. Starting with 2009's Asylum, Rocksteady immediately set the standard for what a superhero game should be. In 2011, things got even better with Batman: Arkham City.

Advertisement

The game takes place in a sealed off section of GothamLed by Hugo Strange and his TYGER guards, the game played host to the Bat's finest interactive adventure. Everything about the game from scale to gameplay had received a massive upgrade. The developer also went the extra mile when it came to the little touches. Getting a game over got some extra layers as well.

In addition to the villains taunting Batman as he lies dying, Arkham City features a hidden conclusion. In the game's latter half, Batman is pinned down under rubble and left at the mercy of rampaging criminals. Switching over the Catwoman, you can choose to either abandon TYGER's money to rescue the Caped Crusader or simply walk out of Arkham City.

If Catwoman chooses to walk right and not rescue Batman, we cut to the credits with a heartbroken Barbara Gordon narrating. It's a haunting moment as the credits roll. Prisoners break out and quickly overrun Gotham with no Dark Knight to stop them.

Got any other depressing game over screens or bad endings that kicked you when you were down? Stick them in the comments down below...

Advertisement