10 Cruel Tricks Horror Video Games Played On Players

A Xenomorph never forgets.

By Jack Pooley /

As much as we all love horror movies, horror video games are simply on a whole other level.

Advertisement

Beyond the added terror of our own interactivity, which makes it impossible for us to be mere passive observers as while watching a film, smart and creative developers can stretch the medium to its limit to keep us on our toes.

The possibilities of video games are near-limitless at this point - with sufficient invention, horror games can keep throwing us off-kilter by subverting the conventions of the genre and what we generally expect from video games.

But beyond simply defying what's expected, these 10 video games all toyed with players in supremely devious and mischievous ways, going out of their way to play cruel, nasty, terrifying pranks on paying customers.

In each case it was in the stead of making the game more scary, and without exception that ended up being true.

From delivering all-timer jump scares to creating a false sense of security, blurring the lines between game and reality, and everything else in-between, these games pulled off brilliantly vicious tricks on unsuspecting players...

10. The Double Dog Window Jump-Scare - Resident Evil

The Resident Evil series has shown a downright sadistic penchant for toying with its own fans, but Capcom has never quite matched the brilliance of that opening jump scare in the original 1996 game.

Advertisement

Near the start of Resident Evil while you're exploring the Spencer Mansion, you'll walk through an L-shaped hallway and, as you pass the window, a zombie dog (aka Cerberus) will burst out of it.

As anyone who played the game without prior knowledge of this will attest, it's a positively pant-filling moment - a totally unexpected jump scare and still one of the most effective uses of the tired technique in video game history.

Worse still, once you've dealt with the dog and moved further down the hallway, another dog will jump through another window, assuring players they can't let their guard down.

And because this jump scare became so well known, for the 2002 remake Capcom ingeniously changed things up.

The first time you pass through the hall in the remake, the glass windows simply crack from the dogs' attempting to get inside, but when you go back through the area later, only then will the dogs successfully smash the glass. Sneaky.

9. Even Ladders Aren't Safe - F.E.A.R.

The F.E.A.R. series relished scaring the living doodoo out of players, and honestly, the clue's in the title.

Advertisement

But generally speaking, the liminal spaces between gameplay environments - ladders, doors, and so on - are safe spaces in survival horror games. Yet F.E.A.R. turned that notion totally on its head with its heart attack-inducing ladder jump scare.

In the game's opening section, you'll move to climb down a ladder and the game will shift to a cutscene, where as you start to descend the ladder, the shadowy, pint-sized antagonist Alma Wade will suddenly materialise in front of you, before turning to ash and disappearing.

And even once you've recovered from that and climbed down the ladder, upon reaching the bottom you'll be "greeted" by another sudden visage of a man who similarly turns into ash.

Two coronaries for the price of one, basically. As with Resident Evil's dog attack, it's a rare exception to the rule that jump scares are a lazy and unimaginative way to stress the player out.

8. Sanity Effects Constantly Warp Your Sense Of Reality - Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem

Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem may have been a commercial flop upon release in 2002, but its legacy as one of the most ferociously creative and slippery horror games of all time endures.

Advertisement

Its big selling point, and one which unfortunately failed to entice many GameCube owners at the time, was the "sanity effects" - complex and creative hallucinations intended to trick the player and throw them off-kilter. And that they certainly did.

Whenever the player's sanity meter drops low enough - through encounters with enemies - their reality will change. The effects can be as nutty as the player's body exploding, but the more "subtle" ones are typically the best.

Back in 2002, when players saw the game randomly changing the in-game volume, resetting the game, throwing up a "blue screen of death," or apparently deleting their game save, it was tough not to be freaked out.

These effects were integrated so seamlessly into the core gameplay that players - especially younger ones - had no idea quite what was on-the-level and what wasn't.

The fear and anxiety of triggering another reality-warping effect was real, in what remains one of the all-time best instances of a game smashing the fourth wall to pieces.

7. "They Looked Like Monsters To You?" - Silent Hill 3

We could write an entire list on the many different times the Silent Hill franchise has played cruel tricks on the player, from the opening fake-out death in the original Silent Hill to the various WTF endings across the series.

Advertisement

But perhaps the most twisted provocation of all occurs in Silent Hill 3, when protagonist Heather talks to Father Vincent about Silent Hill's monsters and he tellingly replies, "Monsters? They looked like monsters to you?"

The implication, seemingly, is that the creatures Heather has been battling throughout the game might in fact be the town's innocent civilians, and that the horrifying events have all been in her mind.

Even though Vincent follows up by telling Heather that he's joking, his sinister smile still leaves enough doubt that fans continue to debate the precise meaning of his words to this very day.

After all, if Vincent is telling the truth, it calls into question every single thing in not only this game but potentially the other Silent Hill games also.

Like so much of the series, it's left up to the player's interpretation, but to even put that suggestion out there, knowing full well that the fanbase would latch onto it and demand concrete answers, is low-key savage.

6. The Back Hall Is A Safe Room (Until It Isn't) - Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Even the most fierce horror games offer up safe rooms - designated areas where the player is safe from attacks, and where they can take a moment to catch their breath, save their game, and maybe even sort out their inventory free from harassment.

Advertisement

But Amnesia: The Dark Descent brilliantly used the notion of a safe room to only further toy with the player's sense of safety (or lack thereof).

Mid-way through the game you'll arrive at the Back Hall, a hub-like area that acts as a safe room: it's decently lit, spacious, there are no enemies in sight, and the music is pretty calming. Even the presence of a creepy-ass fountain in the middle of the room can't ruin the chill vibe too much.

But later in the game, this apparent sanctuary will be invaded by the malevolent supernatural entity known as The Shadow. Flesh-like residue will fill the hall, and the water in the fountain will turn blood-red.

Though there's something of an unspoken agreement between developers and players that safe rooms are indeed off-limits, Frictional Games so ingeniously betrayed that trust in the pursuit of an intense scare - and it absolutely worked.

5. Open The Trap Door, Lose Your Head - Until Dawn

Until Dawn is a dew-eyed homage to the classic, schlocky horror romps of decades past, proving just self-aware enough of the genre's moldy tropes even while lovingly indulging in many of them.

Advertisement

When players are controlling Ashley in the game's ninth chapter, they fall into a series of tunnels and are given a choice - investigate the voice of what appears to be a scared woman, or rejoin the group.

Conventional wisdom would say that rejoining the group is the right call, but doesn't it seem a bit too obvious? It feels like Supermassive is laying a trap, and that the actual right thing to do is the least-intuitive - to follow the voice.

And so if you do that, you'll come to a trap door, which you're then given the option of opening. Again, one suspects that betraying horror movie instincts is actually what the game wants you to do - it's just too obvious that this will cause Ashley's death otherwise, right?

But alas, if you open the door Ashley will be brutally attacked by a Wendigo, which leaps out of the door and tears her head clean off. Oops.

The beauty of Until Dawn is that it both faithfully recreates classic horror scenarios and subverts them, yet you never know from moment to moment precisely which mode the game is in. In this case, players who thought they were too smart to be fooled ended up getting tricked themselves.

4. Glitching Players Get A Nasty Surprise - Slender: The Arrival

If all else fails and a game's getting too tough for you, why not resort to some glitching, right?

Advertisement

Yet anyone who thought they'd be able to use glitches as a crutch in Slender: The Arrival got an hilariously nasty surprise.

It's possible to glitch out of bounds while playing the game, and though you'd understandably assume that this would stop Slender Man from tracking you down, the developers in fact planned entirely for this.

If the game detects that you've left the bounds of the map, Slender Man will suddenly teleport to your location, complete with the taunting line of text, "Not even a bug in this game will save you from me." Game Over.

It's a brilliant-yet-maddening trick, to lure players into a false of security that they're untouchable while glitching, only to prove totally the opposite.

3. Ellie Saves Isaac AFTER The Credits Roll - Dead Space 2

The original Dead Space ended with a player-trolling final jump scare, so fans were primed to expect a similarly downbeat ending to the sequel.

Advertisement

Dead Space 2 ends with protagonist Isaac Clarke stranded on the space station The Sprawl as its reactors melt down and his life support system starts to fail. He knows his goose is cooked, and so he simply sits to take a front-row seat to the annihilation.

At that moment, the game's title flashes up and the end credits start rolling while dramatic music plays. Yet after around a half-minute, the carnage is interrupted by Ellie, who turns up in a gunship to rescue Isaac.

The player is then given control of Isaac one final time as he flies to keep up with the ship and eventually comes aboard.

Hilariously, the scene then lingers on Isaac as it appears that he's about to have another horrifyingly violent vision - just like the end of the first game - only for Ellie to look at him like he's a total weirdo and simply say, "What?". Cut to black, The End.

Well played, Visceral Games, well played.

2. The Xenomorph Remembers Your Hiding Spots - Alien: Isolation

Alien: Isolation is no typical stealth-driven survival horror game, because beyond the player's own inability to directly battle the Xenomorph, the alien creature's AI is programmed to give the impression that it learns from the player's behaviours.

Advertisement

Given that players will die a lot throughout the game, developers Creative Assembly wanted to ensure that the Xenomorph behaved like an actual living thing rather than a scripted creation, and so programmed a complex AI routine which saw its behaviours become increasingly complex as the game wore on.

And as we all learned the hard way, this included the Xenomorph remembering your favourite hiding places. Go back to the well too often, and you'll find yourself eventually caught short by the alien.

Though lockers can be extremely useful for hiding, rely on them too much and, after a beat, you'll see the nearby Xeno rip the door off and have its nasty way with you.

Given that most stealth-based horror games are built on fairly straight-forward mechanics with easily identifiable enemy routines, it was both shocking and refreshing that the Xenomorph proved so fiendishly adaptable.

1. Lisa Is ALWAYS Behind You - P.T.

Believe it or not, it's been a whole eight years since Hideo Kojima's mesmerising horror experience P.T. was released on the PlayStation Store as a teaser for his ultimately shuttered Silent Hills project.

Advertisement

P.T. remains one of the most unnerving and expertly crafted horror games of the last decade, if not all time, in large part because Kojima so inventively makes the player feel like they're always being watched.

While skulking around the focal haunted house, players will be periodically assailed by a ghost by the name of Lisa.

The game gives the impression that Lisa is ever-present, with the player often hearing her voice or seeing her shadow, only to turn around and find nothing.

Yet back in 2019, popular games hacker Lance McDonald dug into P.T.'s code and discovered that Lisa is actually programmed to attach herself to the player once they pick up the flashlight.

From that point, she's effectively tethered to the player's back, floating above them at all times and following them wherever they go. And so, that feeling of being constantly watched is far more literal than anyone realised back in 2014.

Advertisement