10 Demos BETTER Than The Actual Game

A look at ten games that suffered from "Star Wars Trailer Syndrome".

By Iain Taylor /

Gamers of a certain age will remember the rush of peeling the coverdisc off their latest magazine and inserting the humble demo disc into their PC/PS2/XBox, before spending a merry couple of hours blasting through a litany of upcoming digital treats.

Advertisement

Gamers of an even more certain age will recall inserting demo CDs into their PS1, while their elders will have fond memories of coming home after a hard day's mammoth-hunting to boot up Episode 1 of DOOM on the floppy disk lent to them by their cave-neighbour.

Sadly game demos (and game magazines) have become increasingly rare, to the point where a AAA game actually getting a demo is a newsworthy event. Which is a damn shame for us gamers because, as this article will show, the demo is sometimes even better than the game it's meant to be promoting.

This list is packed with demos that did their job a bit too well. Whether they spoiled the best part of the game, gave an unrealistic idea of what the finished product would be like, or included more content than the publishers intended, these 10 demos all wound up overshadowing the finished release.

10. Duke Nukem 3D

The early 90's were a golden time for game demos. Publishers and game developers released huge swathes of their games with reckless abandon, confident that the the 30% of the game they gave away was so good gamers would fall over themselves to buy the remaining 70%. DOOM was undoubtedly the most famous example of this marketing technique, but Duke Nukem 3D was another exemplar of the form.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, it was also an exemplar of the problem that came with it - a tendency to frontload the demo with the best parts of the game.

Duke Nukem 3D's first episode is by far and away the best, immersing the player in an (at the time) mind-blowingly interactive first person environment. Flushable toilets! Openable cupboards! Pixelated strippers! (Look, we said it was impressive "at the time", i.e. when we were younger and even more immature).

Duke's follow-up episodes, while decent enough, failed to match the impact of its opening set of levels - especially episode two, which swapped the streets of LA for a generic sci-fi setting. Players who forked out for the full game were essentially getting "The same, but slightly worse" - a double helping of diet soda that, while palatable, paled in comparison to the full-flavoured sugar rush offered by the demo.

9. Bravely Default

The Bravely Default series is a wilful throwback to the golden days of the JRPG genre, what with its crystal-obsessed plot, turn-based battles and baffling numbering system (this is a series that called its third game Bravely Default II).

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the first game went a step too far in its nostalgia act by bringing back the worse part of '90s JRPGs - grinding. Getting anywhere in the game required excessive amounts of trawling back and forth through a dungeon, bashing your way through cannon fodder until your stats received a big enough boost to overcome the boss at the end.

This was doubly frustrating because the demo didn't have this problem.

Bravely Default's demo sees your party gain new levels and abilities at a rate of knots, as the developers trip over themselves to make sure your party gain enough tricks to show off the game's battle system. Unfortunately, this generosity is nowhere to be found in the actual game, as the pace is slowed down to a rate that would make even the stingiest gatcha game blush.

Tip for JRPG developers - if the player makes it to the boss of a dungeon, having fought through every encounter along the way, they should be strong enough to win. "Hero fights through dungeon and beats big bad!" is a much better story then "hero fights through dungeon, gets arse handed to them, spends two hours thumping disposable minions, then beats big bad".

8. FIFA World Cup 2002

One of the most useful, yet undersung, services provided by game demos are helping customers decide what not to buy. Case in point - FIFA World Cup 2002.

Advertisement

It's amazing to see FIFA's current dominance over digital football considering how abysmally poor it was at the turn of the century. The years between 2000 and 2005 saw EA's routinely get played off the pitch by Konami's Pro Evolution series, with FIFA World Cup 2002 exemplifying why.

A hastily conceived cash-grab designed to squeeze an extra few dollars from the fans, WC (how appropriate those initials are) 2002 allowed gamers to play through the tournament with a team of their choice, or play a match against friends.

And that was it.

EA were essentially charging gamers to play a tournament mode they had very deliberately omitted from FIFA 2002, fleecing their fans more thoroughly than a scalper selling Champions League final tickets on match day.

The demo - a kickabout between Brazil and Mexico - showed that EA had put in the most minimal effort imaginable getting the game in working order and, given that it contained literally half of the game's two modes, represented much better value for money than the full release.

7. Lost Planet 1 & 2

Making a demo better than the game it's promoting - a trick so nice, Capcom pulled it twice!

Advertisement

The Lost Planet series is the definition of unfulfilled potential. Despite having a premise perfectly suited for video games - fighting giant monsters on foot and in anime mech suits - The Lost Planet games consistently shot themselves in the foot with frustrating design choices.

What's particularly galling is that the demos for Lost Planet 1 & 2 showed what the series could have been.

Lost Planet 1's demo was the perfect vertical slice of gameplay, encapsulating the game's appeal by giving the player early access to a mech suit and including two gigantic bosses to slaughter. Lost Planet 2's was arguably even better - a visually spectacular showcase battle against a gargantuan behemoth that dwarfed anything in the original game.

Sadly, the full games never lived up to the promise of their demos. Lost Planet 1 suffered by keeping the mech suits away from the players for frustrating lengths of time, and the majority of Lost Planet 2's boss battles wound up being tedious slogs of attrition against colossal bullet sponges.

We'd like to say Capcom learned their lesson from all this...

6. Resident Evil 6

...but we'd be lying.

Advertisement

Resident Evil 6 is one of the biggest disappointments in video game history (sorry, Mr. Pooley) which makes the demo all the more impressive. Capcom assiduously selected highlights from the game's three campaigns, making each seem better than it actually was.

Leon's demo took players through his opening level, conveniently the only part of RE 6 that remembers to include the "horror" part of "survival horror"; Chris' demo wisely excised the tedious, overly long boss battles that would blight his campaign; and Jake's demo did include a decent boss battle, but neglected to reveal you would fight this same exact boss on four separate (and increasingly tiresome) occasions.

Resident Evil 6's demo showed the proof in the adage that a little goes a long way, as RE 6's flaws only become more pronounced the longer the games goes on. Overuse of QTE's, belief-beggaringly long boss fights, horrendously dull vehicle sections - none of these game design sins are apparent in the demo, but become wearisomely familiar sights in the full game.

(On that note, whoever designed Jake's motorcycle excursion should be strapped to a Super Hang-On machine and forced to play until their eyes bleed).

5. Brütal Legend

Brütal Legend - simultaneously the most and least deserving flop in video game history.

Advertisement

The least deserving because when Brütal Legend is on, it's on. The demo perfectly showcases the game's appeal - a combat-heavy action-adventure through a heavy metal inspired fantasy land populated by legends of the genre such as Ozzy Ozbourne and Lemmy. Yes sir, can we have another!

The most deserving because, at the halfway point, everything changes. Brütal Legend's back half largely eschews the God of War-style adventuring and instead transforms the game into a deeply flawed and frustrating RTS - a genre switch the demo conveniently neglects to include.

This was, in a word: dumb. In three words: so, so dumb. In 38 words: Double Fine, what the hell were you thinking? Were you dipping into Ozzy's stash during development? Because that's the only reason we can think of for switching to a genre wholly unsuited to the game you were making.

Wielding a flaming axe and fighting evil? That's heavy metal. Directing underlings and juggling resources? That's middle-management.

4. Crackdown 2

The length of a demo is a tricky thing to judge - you want to give away enough to get people excited, but not so much that they're burned out by the time they reach the end. It's a balancing act Crackdown 2's demo pulled off with aplomb, as it lasted just long enough to rekindle the magic of its prequel, but finished before people realized Crackdown 2 was little more than a zombie-themed reskin of the first game.

Advertisement

The first Crackdown sold itself as a superhero fantasy, letting players bound around a terrorist-infested city as a super-powered agent. The Crackdown 2 demo successfully recaptured the giddy joy of Crackdown at its best, levelling your character at a vastly accelerated rate (similar to the trick pulled by the Bravely Default demo) so you could spend an enjoyable half-hour acting as a gun-toting, building-bounding mixture of Nick Fury and The Incredible Hulk.

Unfortunately Crackdown 2 - like its predecessor - becomes worse the longer you play it, as it simply lacks the variety needed to sustain the length of the campaign. Factor in the fact that it takes place in the same exact location as the previous game, and the magic fades away even quicker.

The Crackdown games are best enjoyed in short, sharp bursts, and the accelerated levelling of the Crackdown 2 demo provides the shortest, sharpest burst of the series' trademark formula.

3. Shadow Complex (Unpatched)

OK, this one's a bit of a cheat.

Advertisement

The full version of Shadow Complex - a 2009 MetroidVania released before the genre's cup ranneth over - is undoubtedly better than its demo. More guns, more enemies, more locations, and even more Nolan North make the complete version of Shadow Complex far superior to the somewhat anaemic demo.

Well, unless you factor in that the demo accidentally included the entire game for free. (To be fair, Shadow Complex isn't the only game in history to accidentally give everything away).

All players needed to do to unlock the full game was hammer the start button when the demo's boss was going through its death throes. The menu would pop up, you'd reload your last save, and presto! You've just saved 1200 Microsoft points. (Remember, this was back when publishers thought buying games with pre-purchased points was "fun", instead of "arbitrary" and "irritating").

Naturally, Microsoft caught on pretty quick and patched out the flaw. The game's developers -a little known company called Epic Games - never recovered from the embarrassment, and survive today by producing obscure, little-known indie games.

2. Final Fantasy VIII (PlayStation Demo)

After the staggering success of Final Fantasy VII, FF VIII was a huge disappointment. A broken, easily abused battle system and nonsensical storyline meant that the adventures of Squall and co. failed to get close to the bar set by Cloud and his companions. (Hey, "Squall" and "Cloud". I just got that!)

Advertisement

FF VIII's mediocrity was even more disappointing for those who played the PlayStation demo, which promised an action-packed war epic.

The demo in question showcased the Siege of Dollet - an early section from the main game in which your ragtag crew of teenagers storm a beach, sabotage a radio tower, then flee a giant mechanical spider. As that description implies, it's a rather hectic set-piece that sets an early peak the full game struggles to match.

FF VIII soon abandons the concept of child-soldiers forced into war for a more generic tale of amnesia and evil sorceresses, and the demo cleverly concealed just how broken the game's signature Junction system was by blocking you from customizing your characters. (In the full game, "Junctioning" allowed you to assign spells to specific stats, allowing for some ludicrously overpowered builds).

Final Fantasy VIII's demo promised a far more intriguing - and balanced - game than the one that made its way to shop shelves, and shows the pitfalls of creating an opening act the rest of the game fails to live up to.

And on that note...

1. Metal Gear Solid 2

God bless the Tanker.

Advertisement

Metal Gear Solid 2's legendary opening level was immortalized in one of the most sought-after demos of all time. People were literally buying copies of another game (Zone of the Enders) just to play the MGS 2 demo that came bundled with it. And frankly, it was money well spent.

The Tanker was a pitch-perfect introduction to Hideo Kojima's flawed masterpiece. A visually striking intro (those rain effects were jaw-dropping in 2001) led to a delightful playground full of guards to screw with, secrets to uncover and ice cubes to melt.

Unfortunately, the rest of the game failed to live up to the promise shown in the demo.

The majority of Metal Gear Solid 2 took place on Big Shell - a sterile, lifeless (and weirdly orange) oil rig with only a fraction of the Tanker's personality. The game also infamously swapped series lead Solid Snake for Raiden - a man so terminally uncool the only way to save him was to amputate all his limbs and replace them with cyborg ninja parts.

To this day, the Tanker demo remains a masterclass in level design and a great way to while away a spare half-hour. Metal Gear Solid 2 itself, however, is the gaming equivalent of losing your virginity - you're glad you did it, but the experience itself is messy, over-rated, and one that's much better the next time around.

Advertisement