10 Devastating Video Game Deaths That Came Out Of Nowhere
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the Game of Thrones of video games.
Considering it's a medium pretty much built on the art of murder, it's kind of surprising how few effective deaths there are in video game stories.
Sure there are still memorable ones - enough to do plenty of lists on them in the past - but considering how much death is dealt out in the average release, only a small percentage of them leave much of an impression on the player.
After wasting so many nameless bad guys, it makes sense for fans to get a little numbed to virtual death, but one easy way to grab their attention is to whack a main character completely out the blue, with little warning and even less fanfare afterwards.
Sure, occasionally this is done purely for shock factor, but there's no denying that a swift drive-by of a death works wonders in slapping the player in the face and making them pay attention. Hell, Game of Thrones pretty much made its living off this brand of brutality.
10. Kaiden/Ashley - Mass Effect
Mass Effect prided itself on being about player choice, and nothing summed that up at the time more than the decision to save either Kaiden or Ashley.
By that point in the game you will have made a couple of decisions that shaped conversations or small parts of the narrative, but nothing too substantial, and certainly nothing which prepared you for the sudden role as judge, jury and executioner.
Likewise, nothing in the narrative really suggested that one of them had to die. Sure, Shepard and his crew were put in an impossible situation with not enough hands on deck, but when the commander starts ordering around his team you assume that no matter how perilous the situation might look, this is only partway through the game and everyone will be fine.
Of course, that's not the case.
Admittedly, you might not be too emotionally affected by the decision, as you either have to condemn the space racist or The World's Most Boring Man to death, but it still came outta nowhere.
9. Fabiana - Max Payne 3
Proving he's the world's worst bodyguard, a drunken Max Payne completely fails at protecting Fabiana, the wife of a notorious Brazilian real estate high roller, from being kidnapped early in Rockstar's third game.
With a renewed purpose, the rest of the title plays out with Max battling against his own history of self-sabotage in order to chase her across the city and rescue her from a brutal gang. It's all relatively standard shooter fare, a 'the princess is in another castle' story but with way more headshots and drug use.
However, it's not quite so simple, and while you expect Max's quest to save Fabiana to be his driving force for the rest of the experience - his own way of ensuring he could protect a family after failing to save his own - that's not the case.
In fact, when you finally catch up to her, she's brutally executed before you even have a chance to make a move, leaving both Max and the player wondering what the hell the remaining half of the game is going to be about.
8. Booker - Bioshock: Infinite
The original Bioshock became defined by its subversive storytelling, boasting major twists and turns forcing players to re-think how video game stories could be told. Consequently, by the time the third game, Infinite, rolled around, everyone was expecting to be surprised.
The most impressive thing about the sequel, then, is that even with everyone prepared for a bunch of mad reveals, it was still shocking when they arrived.
From Booker also being the villainous Comstock to the reveal that "there's always a man, there's always a lighthouse", the developers kept the twists coming right up until the final moment, where the player themselves was killed.
It's shocking, but it's a moment which makes sense. Booker also being Comstock means you can't have one without the other, so while you might have stopped the dictator in one timeline, there's always going to be another where you didn't.
The brutality of the moment is surprising as well, as Elizabeth - your companion throughout the game and your own daughter - coldly drowns Booker to stop the horrors to come.
7. Abigail Marston - Red Dead Redemption
It was tempting to put John Marston on this list, because he's by far the most memorable death from Red Dead Redemption and easily the saddest, but there's actually one that has far fewer fireworks and hits just as hard.
After John's death, the game jumps forward in time to pick up with an older version of his son Jack. However, not only is this a character who's lost his father, but we pick up with him standing over the graves of both parents, as Abigail Marston has also died at some point in the time jump.
It's tragic, because it means that John died in vain, as the rest of his family only encountered even more misery following his legacy being put to rest. Likewise, the reason for Abigail's demise is left a mystery, and is doubly emotional considering she was only 37.
Red Dead Redemption 2 makes this even more heartbreaking, as Abigail plays a much bigger part in that story, and is the person you root for the most to escape a life of robbing and killing - all in the knowledge that it would never last.
6. Sergeant Paul Jackson - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare
It's a pretty tired trope at this point, but it's impossible to understate just how shocking Call of Duty: Modern Warfare's approach to death was back in 2007.
Most military games at the time had you controlling the sole hero capable of saving the world, but COD took the opposite approach, making you part of a team, a cog in the machine of eternal warfare.
Of course, when you're not the chosen one, it means you're expendable.
The original MW made that perfectly clear in the Shock and Awe mission, where upon extracting from a battlefield, player character Sergeant Jackson's chopper is caught in the blast wave of a nuclear explosion.
The thing is, he doesn't die outright, and the next mission picks up in the wreckage.
The implication is you can survive, and somehow you'll be able to crawl to victory. All you're able to do, however, is pick yourself up and observe the destruction on display, before succumbing to your injuries in the most horrific way.
5. Sarah - The Last Of Us
Yes I know, it's another list about deaths that prominently features The Last of Us, but it's not my fault the game is so good it demands to be mentioned every single time this topic pops up.
The opening to Naughty Dog's opus is one of the most instantly affecting in gaming history, as it initially subverts expectations by putting you in control of Joel's daughter Sarah, rather than Joel himself. From there, you experience the beginning of an apocalypse from a child's perspective before control eventually switches to the father, as he carries Sarah to (what we hope is) safety.
Of course, it's not to be, and despite shielding her from incoming gunfire, Joel's daughter is shot dead in the opening prologue. You expect tragedy to strike, but just how visceral the scene is, and how there's hope that Joel might have done enough to save her, makes it a real shock to the system that keeps you on edge for the next 15 hours.
4. Caroline - Wolfenstein The New Colossus
Wolfenstein: The New Colossus has such a weird opening. The original game essentially ended with hero B.J. Blazkowicz bleeding out after a brutal final battle, content in the knowledge that if his wounds wouldn't cement his fate, a nuclear strike was on its way to finish the job.
It was set to be a poignant send off for the long-serving hero, but the sequel picked up immediately after the original cut to black, revealing that B.J. was saved by fellow resistance members, including leader Caroline, who spearheaded the victory at the end of the first game.
5 months pass, but the game quickly gets into the action as the resistance HQ is attacked, and you and Caroline are taken prisoner by Frau Engel. Though B.J. may have once been able to get out of a sticky situation like this, his injuries have left him powerless, and neither he nor the player can do anything as they watch Engel hack off Caroline's head.
The leader probably had to go at some point so B.J. could step up and adopt the same role, but nobody expected it this early on, especially after an already oppressive opening.
3. Aunt May - Spider-Man
I don't think anybody went into 2018's Spider-Man expecting to cry, but there were no dry eyes by the time the credits rolled. That's because Insomniac decided to make the ballsy move of killing off Aunt May at the end of the game, adding real consequences and stakes to what was expected to merely be a fun superhero romp.
Even when May gets sick with the biological weapon that's been dispersed all over NYC, you as a player don't really take it all that seriously. Sure, it sucks that she's sick, but in your head you can do the storytelling math and see how this would be a great motivator for Peter and the player, and the reward of seeing her pull through in the end will result in one of those fist-pumping moments of heroism that makes games like this so satisfying.
But, of course, she doesn't pull through.
Instead, Peter is given the choice to be a hero in a scenario that can't be won by beating the bad guy to a pulp. Instead he has to choose, between his aunt or the entire city, and he bears the burden that only a real superhero could.
2. Cole Phelps - L.A. Noire
Unlike a lot of the characters on this list, there was never any guarantee that Cole Phelps would make it out of LA Noire alive. After all, the kind of stories the game was sending up revelled in surprise deaths of protagonists and subversive, downer endings that saw corruption, crime, and politics all win out in the end.
With that said, it still didn't prepare anyone for how Cole would actually bite the dust. The finale of Rockstar's troubled title had ambitions that exceed its reach, and for a chunk of the final act you actually play as a new character, Jack Kelso. When you pick back up with Cole it's for the final mission, where you hunt down an old army buddy who's been manipulated into burning down houses and then... get drowned in the sewer.
It is jarring to say the least, and totally unsatisfying. You half expect Cole to show up again - the water having not killed him - but he never does, and instead he goes out like a chump.
1. Sean/Lenny/Kieron/Everyone - Red Dead Redemption 2
I mentioned Game of Thrones in the introduction, but the only game that's really come close to aping that show's approach to death (even taking into account the ones actually based on the series) is Red Dead Redemption 2. By nature of being a prequel, fans already had an inkling as to who would make it out the game alive, who needed to make it out the game alive, and who was locked in to bite the dust.
Even then, the way Rockstar offed its cast of outlaws was surprising at every turn. The bloodshed truly started with Sean, who enjoyed a bullet to the face out of nowhere during a robbery in Rhodes. From there on, all the supporting cast was killed with little warning or build up, whether it was Kieron's headless body being ridden into Dutch's camp or Lenny taking a couple bullets to the chest during a particularly bad heist.
It's all purposefully cold to showcase just how cruel the Old West is, and even though you know most of these characters are destined to die, you never know how or when and it. is. devastating.