10 Flawed Video Games That Are Actually Masterpieces

Look past the occasional bug and spotty AI, and you can still find an incredible game.

By Robert Zak /

Sega/FromSoftware/Remedy

It's often the case that great visionaries aren't fully appreciated in the time that they're alive. Plato was seen as a bit of an outsider back in the classical days, HP Lovecraft's stories were just seen as oddities in his time, and who knows, maybe in 100 years time people willlook back on Donald Trump and think we were all idiots for ever thinking he was a horseman of the apocalypse.

Advertisement

A similar tendency can be seen in video games. Many titles confuse or disappoint us on release, only for their latent brilliance to be uncoveredandappreciated years down the line, once we'vetired of complaining about their many flaws.

These games usually dare to do things differently - whether by implementing punishing mechanics that don't feel quite right, or by being oddly paced experiences that don't really fit conventional ideas of fun, but offer some of the most captivating gameplay around once we spend some time with them.

Advertisement

Here we run through 10 brilliant-yet-broken games that, for all their flaws, are masterpieces that you owe it to yourself to play.

10. Far Cry 2

Existing in a weird limbo between the groundbreaking first game and the blockbuster,hallucinogenic playground that was Far Cry 3, this understated adventure in the African savannah has been too easily forgotten.

Advertisement

It could've been to do with the emptiness of the huge map, which saw you spend way too much timedriving across the world with few side-activities to catch your attention. Or it could've been the enemy outposts that respawned as soon as you turned your back on them, or the repetitive gunplay, or... well, any number of things really.

But Far Cry 2 was also the most ambitious one of the lot. It doesn'tforce astory on you like its successors, nor posit you as some kind of local hero.Instead, the Heart of Darkness story feelslike it's there if you wantto engage in it, and if you do,then you'll berewarded with something that'ssurprisingly intelligent and grounded in reality.

Advertisement

The savannah setting is unique and immersive, and there are plenty of excellent gameplay flourishes - such as aphysical in-game map that doesn't pause the action, malaria, a solid 'buddy' system, and awesome fire mechanics that can be used to you strategic advantage - that make this one of the most ambitious shooters of the previous generation.

9. Alan Wake

Remedy

Running around the formidable forests and vertiginous heightsof the American Rockies and shining your flashlight into the faces of lumberjacks - it sounds more like anannoying pastime that pesky mountain teensget up to rather than a AAA video game, butit really is better than it sounds.

Advertisement

Alan Wake follows the titular writer as he retreats to the sleepy Washington State town of Bright Falls to try and overcome his writer's block. But whena mysterious dark force begins to take overthe area, kidnaps his wife, and is seemingly bringing to life a nightmarish story of Wake's that he hasn't yet written, Alan takes up his torch and heads out to face the darkness.

The gameplay - which sees you softening enemies up with a torch before shooting them with regular guns - doesn't have much variety, but the game is oozing with a nocturnal atmosphere that feels like one of those high-intensity nightmares, and the story is a memorable mind-bender that you can spend hoursdissecting.

Advertisement

Alan Wake is a game that breaks with convention, and while it doesn't always do so successfully,it's damn near sublime when it does.

8. Pathologic

Gambitious Digital Entertainment

Slow, suffocating and uneventful are three adjectives that you can easily apply to this Russian-made psychological horror, which sees you control three different protagonists over 12 days, attempting to discoverthe source of an illness that's tearingthe town apart.

Advertisement

You wander around the town, speaking with its strange, poorly voice-acted denizens and picking up side-quests thatbring you closer to solving the mystery. Could it be something to do with the surreal Polyhedron building just outside town? Or maybe thelocal cult? And why is everything in town named after body parts?

It may not be pretty by today's standards, but Pathologic is a rabbit-warren of great ideas, where the more you get into it the more youget captivated and intrigued by its unique, grim world. The fact that you have 12 in-game days to complete the game and thatthe story continues even when main characters are killed off gives an urgency to the experiencethat not many games would dare to try.

Advertisement

With so much brilliance beneath its crude facade, it's no wonder Pathologic is getting a remake later this year.

7. Dragon's Dogma

Capcom

The fact that the romance system in this game is so indiscriminate that you can end up in the arms of a midget court jester -or a ten-year-old child -isn't a sign of some kind of perversion on the part of Capcom, but rather their willingness to be so experimental with RPG systems that the results are sometimes completely bonkers.

Advertisement

Dragon's Dogma throws you into a noticeably Japanese take on a western RPG world, where you create a fantasy hero from several different classes, and head out into the world with a trio of party members to try and retrieve your heart, which was stolen from you by a dragon... or something.

While the world is nowhere near as interesting as something like The Witcher, the combat is remarkable - even revolutionary. Similarly to Dragon Age: Origins and older RPGs, you can set behaviours for your party members, though the tough, intense real-time fighting is reminiscent of a more flashy Dark Souls.

Advertisement

The feeling of your tactically-perfect party blasting away at an Ogre while you dynamically climb it and stab it in the eyes is a rush that you won't find elsewhere, and the gruelling difficulty at the higher levels will keep challenge-seekers hooked, despite its flat story and general weirdness.

6. Dark Souls 2

FromSoftware

There's no denying that Dark Souls 2 lost something without Hidetaka Miyazaki at the helm. The labyrinthine level design of the original game - where the world felt so geographically consistent and beautifullyinterconnected - was replaced with a more linear, more gamey structure and a more confused story that left fans of the original a little cold.

Advertisement

But how easy it is to criticiseanything thatcomes out after the original Dark Souls, whicheasily ranks among the greatest RPGs of all time. Despite its design shortcomings, Dark Souls 2 refined the already near-perfect gameplay of its predecessor, making it sharper, more responsive, and cutting down on the series' infamously oversized hit boxes.

Areas such as the Majula hub, the Shrine of Amana and the Dragon's Aerie are among the most visually stunningin the series, and the average enemy has a more diverse and challenging moveset. Arguably more steps were taken backwards than forwards, but for Dark Souls 2 to best its predecessor even in just a few areas is already an incredible achievement.

Advertisement

Suffice to say, if the original didn't exist, we'd be talking about this as one of the greatest games of all time.

5. Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines

Troika Games

Following countless dev team changes, game engine issues and a slew of publisher problems, Bloodlines was spewed out onto the gaming scene in an unfinished state - sort of likea half-dead vampire victim who was dumped in the street.

Advertisement

The thirdgame in the Vampire series, Bloodlines was a hugely ambitious RPGthat kind ofoverstretched itself. At first, the sheer number of upgradeable stats and possible clans to join can be overwhelming - if only because it's rare to see so much choice in a game - but the brilliance of the story and visionof an intriguing futuro-Gothic world soon shine through (in moody dark red and neoncolours)

While RPGs today continue to struggle to implement a meaningfulsense of choice in how youapproach quests and challenges,Bloodlines tackledthis adeptlyway before its time.So look beyondthe bugginess (which has been ironed out by numerous unofficial patches over the years), and sink your teeth into this taintedgem of a game.

Advertisement

4. Rule Of Rose

Sony Computer Entertainment

There's a good chance you never heard of this psychological horror for the PS2, which did actually get a European and North American release, butwas bannedin several countries and is now one of the rarest, most valuable games for the console.

Advertisement

The censors' concerns were understandable, as Rule of Rosehints heavily at sexual abuse and underage eroticism.With that in mind, it's not easy to make a case for this game being a masterpiece, but look past the controversy storm and it's one of the most unsettling, ingenious horror games ever made.

You play asJennifer, a 19-year-old girl in 1930s England who finds herself marooned on an airship, and must gather giftsfor a creepy group of girls who torture herfor hertroubles. It's an incredibly haunting, unsettling talethat feels like abarrageof childhood bullying taken to horrific extremes.

Advertisement

Rule of Rose is, errr, wilted by its stiff, clunky gameplay, but tells a daring, disturbing story that's sure to leave a lasting impression.

3. BioShock 2

2K Games

While the 'flawed masterpiece' labelcould equally be applied toboth Bioshock 2 and Infinite (the original earnsthe 'undisputed masterpiece' accolade), it seems that the former received much less critical love and attention than the games it was sandwiched by.

Advertisement

Taking place in Rapture, the same subaquatic setting as its predecessor, it's easy to dismiss Bioshock 2 as 'more of the same'. Butalthough the story takes a while to get going, it eventuallybecomes a sharp, thought-provoking critique of utilitarianism in much the same way as the original was of individualism. Sure, it couldn't possibly recapture that haunting sense of wonderment we all felt when first heading down to Rapture, but gameplay-wise it patched things up in all the right areas.

The combat is more varied and more tactical, and the maniacal utopian visions of Sofia Lamb come damn close to matching the terrifying brilliance of Andrew Ryan. Once you look past the fact that it's not as ingenious asthe original game and it's a bit too focused on being a shooter (and that damn multiplayer), Bioshock 2remains one of the most narratively inventive games around.

Advertisement

2. STALKER: Call Of Pripyat

GSC Game World

I don't know if it's something to do with quality of life, the cultural history of the region, or just 'something in the air', but there's something about games coming fromRussia and Ukrainethatmeans they'reexcellent at conveyinga bleak, hard-hitting atmosphere in a way equivalent western games just can't.

Advertisement

Open-world survival shooter STALKER is a case in point - a game that could be called the granddaddy of today's trending shooters like DayZ and Rust. It incorporates RPG elements, with a degree of choice to your actions and plenty of side-quests to complete, though the core gameplay entails sneaking, shooting, and being utterly terrified as you tiptoeamong the ruined factories and ghost towns of an irradiated Pripyat.

Call of Pripyat is the best game in the trilogy overall, with far fewer bugs that plagued its predecessors and a foreboding atmosphere that ranks among the most powerful in video games, butmisses out on true greatness because ofa rickety game engine that was outmoded even when it first came out in 2009.

Advertisement

1. Alpha Protocol

Obsidian

An RPG made by the great Obsidian (Fallout: New Vegas, Baldur's Gate II) set in the world of high-tech gadgetry? Sign us all up, right? Hmmm, not so fast...

Advertisement

Even in an era when it's seemingly acceptable to release games in buggy states then patch them up later, Alpha Protocol was a technical disaster - marred by glitches, impotent AI, and shoddy stealth gameplay. In fact, as a third-person stealth shooter, it barely works at all.

But, this being Obsidian, there are plenty of redeeming qualities in the story and RPG side of the game, which is filled with eccentric characters and a fantastic narrative choice system which makes you feel the weight of your decisions more than just about any other RPG out there. As (probably psychopathic) field agent Michael Thorton, you have almost complete control over who lives and dies in the game, and the impact this has on the story is brilliantly convincing.

Advertisement

You almost wish you could just skim through the gameplay and play around with the RPG mechanics,which give this tarnished gem a fiendish level of replayability.

Which games have you played that manage to shine despite their abundant flaws? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement