10 Genius Ways Video Games Punished You For Killing
Got an itchy video game trigger finger? Well you won't after playing these.
Murder is the bread and butter of most video games. While there are of course great non-violent titles that have achieved huge success, shooters and action games still dominate the market, and that means players will do a lot of killing over their gaming career.
Of course, developers have ways of making sure you're only killing the people who truly deserve it - whether that's a monster trying to eat your face off or something else entirely. In fact it's standard that if you try to shoot your squad mates in Call of Duty, say, the game will hit you with a fail state and punish you for friendly fire.
More imaginative developers, though, find inventive ways to punish players for killing, with unique game overs or even unique set-pieces.
These scenarios can be used to drive home a narrative point through the mechanics, keep you role-playing as a character with a specific personality or more flippantly break the fourth wall and directly address the player. No matter the reasoning though, each one makes you think twice about pulling the trigger on another unsuspecting NPC.
10. A Demonic Visage - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
The Metal Gear solid franchise has always had a few tricks up its sleeve when it comes to telling players off for giving in to their more bloodthirsty impulses. So, with this entry you get two for the price of one.
The first genius punishment for leaving a trail of bodies in your wake comes in Metal Gear Solid 3, a game which, well, literally confronts you with that trail of bodies. In this beloved Big Boss prequel you encounter The Sorrow late in the game, a supernatural character who haunts you on a long trek through the spirit world. Here you're confronted by the souls of the people you've killed, who show up as ghostly figures. If you've been trigger happy previously, this can turn into on laborious sequence.
MGS V similarly punishes players for killing people by awarding them with Demon Points. The more kills you rack up, the more demonic playable character Venom Snake becomes. I mean this literally, as the devil horn on your head (in-lore this is a bit of lodged shrapnel) grows with the amount of evil actions accomplished.
9. Chaos Events - Dishonored
Arkane games are always subtly keeping track of player behaviour, and most even alter the experience to accommodate the kinds of choices - moral or otherwise - players make on a moment to moment basis.
In the original Dishonored this was kept track of via a chaos meter, which made the game more difficult the higher it went. If you kept this ticking up you'd end up having streets teeming with plague rats and having to deal with more human enemies stationed around maps. And the best way to increase your chaos rating? You guessed it: indiscriminate killing.
Dishonored accommodates a whole bunch of playstyles, and gives you the tools to ghost through levels without being seen by guards, as well as non-lethal weapons to knock out anyone in your path. You also have guns and swords that'll just take heads clean off as well though.
So the choice is yours: you can edge towards the bad ending and encounter tougher enemies (justified in game as being a response to so many people turning up dead), or keep it holstered when you can.
8. Insanity - The Sinking City (And More)
The Sinking City isn't the first game to have an insanity meter. From Eternal Darkness to Amnesia, horror titles often put the playable character's sanity at the forefront of the experience, with encounters with monsters and the supernatural taking their toll on the hero's mental wellbeing.
However, nothing in The Sinking City depletes that meter quite like killing an innocent human being. As an open world game, you spend a lot of time exploring this Lovecraftian environment and interacting with people who aren't monsters out for your blood (they might just be your regular ol' nice monsters). Whipping out a gun and shooting these people (or battering them with your shovel, whatever you fancy), will cause a temporary madness.
Not only does this impact gameplay by shaking the screen and making the visuals blurry, it also increases the chance of spawning in creatures that, unlike the poor civilians you've just offed, will fight back.
7. "Child Killer" - Fallout
Even in games that stress complete freedom, killing kids is still a no-no. In your sprawling sandboxes and kill-a-thons today, the younger NPCs all force you to put your weapons down, and you can see why. With the increased realism of games, it's a disaster waiting to happen if someone can go out and start gruesomely picking off the young'uns - no matter how fake they may be.
It wasn't always like this though, and in older RPGs like the original isometric Fallout titles, you really did have 100% freedom. That doesn't mean that the devs didn't pass judgment on your actions though, and if you did strike down a child in those titles, you'd be branded for life.
After a couple of kills in Fallout you'll be branded "Child Killer", and understandably will be shunned by most NPCs. You can keep playing, but your karma tanks, you'll be hunted down by mercenaries in the wasteland seeking revenge and some vendors will become off limits.
Despite these in-game penalties, the title still ended up being banned in Europe until the developers removed the child NPCs entirely.
6. Straight To Jail - Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
It's not entirely novel for games to punish you for killing as you'd be punished in real life: by being sent straight to jail. However, in a lot of titles this is treated as more of a nuisance than a real consequence. In GTA for instance, if you get caught, you just lose some money and are immediately kicked back onto the streets.
The Elder Scrolls series has always treated crime and punishment a little differently though. Here, if you're caught for a crime you'll be given a bunch of options: sometimes you have to pay a fine, but other times you're confronted with a guard who wants to take you straight to jail. The thing is, this isn't just a fail state, and in the case of Oblivion you really will be dragged to the cells, and need to figure out a way to break yourself out.
It's not that hard to escape and steal your stuff back, but it definitely provides a bigger consequence for being a criminal, and can result in some pretty interesting playthroughs.
5. Locked Out Of... Everything - Dark Souls
Dark Souls is obviously a punishing series, however what makes it so challenging is that it finds ways to mess with players even outside of combat.
See, friendly NPCs are few and far between in this series, and as a result it's probably not the best idea to start fighting the few allies you have.
If you do decide to, say, behead the vendors, blacksmiths and quest-givers around the Firelink Shrine though, be prepared to pay a hefty price. See, these deaths are often permanent - and while you might nab yourself a cool trinket or item from their cold dead, corpses - you'll also be unable to court their services or further their quests.
You're only robbing yourself of content if you kill them then, and the loss of some of these characters can be felt massively as the game progresses.
4. Krampus' Revenge - Don't Starve
Don't Starve might be the most charming horror game you'll ever play. In it you, well, try not to starve by surviving day to day in a harsh, spooky wilderness. During the day you need to scavenge supplies and make sure you're ready for the sun going down, as deadly monsters come with the darkness.
You're not entirely alone though, as the environment is littered with a variety of animals similarly trying to just get on with their day (some do transform into monsters at night, though you can't hold that against them). The game classes these creatures as innocents and, as such, killing them will increase a "naughtiness" meter. If you ask me, bludgeoning a pig to death is a bit more than "naughty", but it is what it is.
Kill too many of these animals and you'll be put on the naughty list of one Krampus, who won't punish you by dropping coal down your chimney, but instead pay your camp a visit and steal all your s**t.
Now, you can fend Krampus off from throwing all your tat in his sack, but why would you want to go to the trouble when you could just be nice instead of naughty?
3. Bovine Defence Force Initiative - The Witcher 3
For the most part, The Witcher 3 doesn't really care who you do or do not kill. You're playing a Witcher after all, someone raised specifically to slay monsters first and ask questions never (unless it helps kill monsters more efficiently).
Like a lot of open world games, this acclaimed sequel also has something of a hunting system. It's not too in-depth, but you can set out into the wild to stalk the animals you find, using their hides and guts as resources.
Big or small, passive or hostile, the game doesn't really pass judgement either way - with the exception of the cows.
That's because some players found themselves in White Orchard surrounded cows, and suddenly had a realisation: they could cull the herd, sell their hides, and then repeat the process as soon as the animals respawned, giving them a cheeky money exploit.
The devs cottoned onto this tactic and introduced the Bovine Defence Force Initiative - a system where a high level Chort monster would appear and attack you should you kill too many of the cows in the area.
This avenging demon wasn't easy, especially for low level players just looking to make a quick buck.
2. Voidouts - Death Stranding
Death Stranding's entire point is human connection. Unlike most AAA blockbusters, this was a game where you simply delivered parcels to people, with your biggest enemies being rocks you might twist your ankle on.
Of course, there were still enemies - including psychopathic Porters so obsessed with deliveries that they'd attack you for your cargo on sight - but the game provided you with a genius in-universe explanation for why you shouldn't simply put a bullet between the eyes of these guys.
When the titular Death Stranding delivered the apocalypse to the world, it also resulted in humans now going through a necrosis process when they died. Essentially, this meant that dead bodies became atomic bombs, and if not disposed of properly via incineration, would voidout (aka detonate) within 48 hours. Even a single necrotised body could wipe out an entire city - which is what happened to Manhattan in the early days of the Stranding.
Consequently then, while the game allows you to kill anyone you see - and even gives you shotguns and rocket launchers to do so if you wish - you'll have to haul those bodies a long, long way to an incinerator if you don't want them to turn the landscape into a crater that'll make your deliveries even tougher.
1. EXP & LOVE - Undertale
Undertale is one sneaky devil of a game. The side-scroller subverts your expectations every step of the way, right down to your assumptions of what its basic stats stand for.
See, as you play through the title and battle the various monsters along the way, you'll have the choice to not kill your enemies. The twist is, this is much more difficult than just killing them, and it also means you don't get EXP points and, in turn, don't get the chance to increase your LOVE (HP in this game).
So, the more you kill, the more you level up, the stronger you get - it's pretty basic video game logic. That is until the end, where it's revealed that there have been real consequences to your murder spree. See, it turns out the EXP doesn't stand for "experience" but rather "execution points", while your LV has been keeping track of your "level of violence".
All those monsters you've slain? Yeah, turns out they didn't deserve it, and these meters are now a constant reminder of how careless your slaughter has been.