10 Golden Commandments All RPG Games Should Follow

By Salvador Polanco /

I love RPG's very much: in fact, I'd go so far as to say that I love them more than a good majority of the experiences that life is capable of offering. While consuming a varied diet of video gaming goodness is essential for a healthy & balanced lifestyle, there is nothing quite like a good role playing game. The epic nature of your quest, the huge world full of secrets to discover, the satisfaction of witnessing your character(s) slowly become stronger - gaming just doesn't get any better than that. As a child of the 80's who has been hooked on the genre since the first time he fired up Dragon Warrior on the NES, it remains this author's opinion that the best RPGs easily rank with the highest tier of entertainment in any medium. The quintets of Miles Davis, the novels of Haruki Murakami, the films of Stanley Kubrick, and great RPG's: they all stand on the same pedestal in my world. So, why is it that some RPG's are fantastic, memorable experiences, and others can feel like a chore? First, it would help to back things up a bit: what type of game exactly are we talking about here? For the sake of simplicity, the focus of this article will remain on single-player games that primarily embody the traditional characteristics of video role playing games: character abilities determined by statistics, character growth through leveling, focus on narrative and exploration, and menu-driven interfaces. Specific styles of RPG's such as MMORPG's (World of Warcraft), loot and level action RPG's (Diablo III), and first person dungeon crawlers (Etrian Odyssey) will not fall into this discussion. After nearly a quarter of a century spent playing these games, I have come to believe that there are certain guidelines that an RPG should follow in order to effectively deliver a substantial and meaningful experience. Likewise, if an RPG stumbles in more than a couple of these areas, the game more often than not will wear out its welcome long before the end credits roll. So with that said, here are... (**Summons Bahamut, who drops through clouds and delivers 2 stone tablets **) ...the 10 Commandments that all video game RPG's should follow! Click next to begin...

10. Give Us A Protagonist We Want To Spend Time With

RPG's are typically not short games: I don't believe I've spent less than 25 hours playing any RPG to completion anytime in the last decade. So in asking a gamer to dedicate this much time to their game, it is essential that the designers and writers create a protagonist that the player will enjoy spending this time with. One word can be used to describe a sure fire way to make this happen: charisma. The example of Commander Shepard in Bioware's Mass Effect series is one of the shining examples of this in recent times. Whether you choose to play as a male or female, and whether you play the game as a full on Paragon (good) or Renegade (evil), Commander Shepard is so well-written and well-developed, that guiding him/her through that universe is always a pleasure. You will cheer for Shepard when he/she is recovering medicine for sick refugees as much as you will when he/she punches a news reporter out cold. Shepard is a true hero, and even when he/she is deciding between the fates of entire civilizations, Shepard is a character that you will stand behind no matter what. This is someone you want to spend time with. Even if the game doesn't give you a charismatic hero, giving that protagonist an identifiable plight is an effective way to get the gamer the behind the protagonist early on. Final Fantasy IV, a sprite-based Super Famicom game that released long before the days of voice acting and detailed facial animations, brilliantly sets this up and remains a fine example in drawing the gamer in to the character's plight. During the game's opening sequence, Cecil, Commander of the Red Wings and the game's main character, violently steals a crystal that a group of innocent villagers were protecting. As he leaves with the crystal, he pauses, lowers his head for a few seconds, then picks it up and keeps moving. He is morally conflicted about the actions he's being forced to commit, and it is this conflict that drives his quest for the remainder of the game. It is a situation almost everyone can relate to on a human level, and we want to help Cecil break free of these chains that bind him. Bethesda's Fallout 3 also does a great job with this. Despite playing as a character-created protagonist that never speaks, the gamer relates to Fallout 3's character because of the father-child relationship that is established as the game begins. Your father is there at your birth, he's there when you take your first steps, and he's there at your birthday parties. So when he goes missing once you become a young adult, you want to go out there into that broken world and find him. Even as you get distracted by many subplots taking place around post-apocalyptic Washington DC, the true reason you are out there is never forgotten. Party-based RPG's have it a bit easier, as even if the protagonist isn't the most likable character, he/she can usually be redeemed if the supporting cast is strong enough to carry the weight. Tidus, the protagonist of Final Fantasy X and arguably one of the most annoying characters in video game history, is ably supported by some of the finest supporting characters the series has seen. And even the wooden, emotionless Grey Warden of Dragon Age: Origins was made to look good by the game's brilliantly-written and diverse cast. But whether we are playing as a single character or as a character leading a party, making these characters ones that we enjoy being around is crucial. It often makes the difference between the game feeling like an epic, memorable journey to somewhere special, and long slog that can feel like work.

9. Create A World Worth Saving

Advertisement
Just as important as the game's protagonist is the setting of the game itself. Every game developer looking to create an RPG should ask themselves two questions as they begin to design the game's world: Is this a place where the player will enjoy spending his/her time? Will the player feel motivated to become emotionally invested in this world? This is obviously something that has become a more significant issue with more modern games than it did with the RPG's from the 8 and 16 bit eras. As technology advances, so have gamers' expectations of fuller, richer, and more detailed game worlds, but this "detail" goes far beyond the uniqueness of village architecture, or how the sunlight looks as it breaches the canopy of the mystical forest. It's about creating a world that you want to save. A place that you think about when you're away from your gaming platform, and a place that motivates you to do everything you can to help. At the risk of being tarred and feathered by saying this, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion just didn't do it for me. I absolutely loved the openness of the world, the way everything looked, and the amount of freedom in finding my own way through the game. But after about 25 hours spent with the game, I found myself unmotivated to go any further, and realized that it was because I just didn't care about Cyrodiil or the people in it very much. The game seemed to lack a sense of humanity that all the guild quests and exploring just couldn't overshadow. On the flip side, The Witcher series is, to me, the ultimate example a modern RPG delivering a game world that delivers on all levels. You inhabit a world that is so dark, decimated, corrupt, and hopeless. Yet as you explore, learn the lore, and talk to the inhabitants, you see the world in the midst of a struggle that is very human and very relatable. It's not a pleasant place, but it makes you want to become a part of it with the hope that you can make it a little better. Just like with protagonists, whether or not a game's world engages a player is subjective. However, ultimately an RPG should never attempt to detract the delivery of a compelling game world with anything, be it mechanics or beautiful graphics. With the best RPG's, it's the places we go, the people we help, and most importantly, the reasons we did so, that linger in the memory for years, or even decades, after we put the game down. They become second homes for us gamers who spend dozens of hours in these worlds. And homes, even digital ones, should be where the heart is.

8. Effectively Communicate The Story

While video game stories have improved by leaps and bounds in recent years, they still have a long way to go before they can be thought of as a rival to the storytelling found in other entertainment mediums. For RPGs, this is an even bigger obstacle due to the complex, deep nature of RPG game mechanics that take center stage in these types of games. However, despite whether an RPG's story is concise and focused or as convoluted as the plot of "Lost", effectively communicating the story to the player remains an integral key to the overall quality of the game. Whether it is done through in-game presentation of lore, sequences of dialogue, cut scenes, narration, or any other method, it's so important that the player always be aware of how the story has progressed, as well as where they fit in to the overall narrative. A game I played recently, Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning, had fine examples of how to do this right, and how to do this wrong. KoA: R had some excellent lore, something that it didn't really get much credit for. The game's world is broken into "zones" - large, open areas that are interconnected by narrow paths. Tucked away in each area are a series of shrines known as Lorestones (see image above), as as you find each Lorestone, a narrated voice speaks to you, without pausing the gameplay, about the lore of the zone you're currently in, often in the form of a poem or story. Finding each set of Lorestones in each area not only gives you a wonderfully-presented history of the land you are exploring, but it gives you XP bonuses as well. It's an enjoyable and effective way to give the character context about what they're doing in the game. On the other hand, KoA:R butchers a key element of story delivery by presenting some of the most emotionless, poorly-animated dialogue scenes to be found in any modern RPG. A real shame, since the game had decent writing, and the voice acting was quite good as well. An RPG that has you pressing the "skip" button throughout scenes of dialogue has failed. Story should matter in a RPG, plain and simple. Every design decision should be made with the mindset that the game is reading an interactive storybook to the player. Especially since RPG's have more time to let their stories develop than most games in other genres: they should use that time wisely. If an RPG comes across as nonchalant or lazy about its narrative and the way it's presented, chances are that even if the game is played to completion, it will have a good chance of being forgotten. Please don't make me have to piece together the story by hiding everything deep within encyclopedia entries (**COUGH COUGH FINAL FANTASY XIII COUGH COUGH**), or have to sit through embarrassing cut scenes, horrible dialogue, or sub-standard voice acting. Game makers should take pride in their stories and in the fact that they have the privilege of telling a story through this beautiful medium.

7. Make The Menus Simple And Navigable

If you ever find yourself sitting down for some gaming after a long day at work, and want clear your room of unwanted guests, fire up an RPG. The amount of time we RPG gamers spend in menus seems almost unnatural for a "game", and while it will certainly bore anyone else to tears, it is in the menus where some of the most important time we spend playing these games takes place. The best menu systems in RPG's strike a perfect balance between intuitiveness and depth, and navigating menus should never feel grueling. I recently revisited one of my favorite RPG's from my younger days, Dynamix's excellent Betrayal At Krondor, which was released back in 1993 on PC. The first thing I noticed while replaying the game was what a breeze it was to navigate through the menus. Everything, from character skill upgrades, looting fallen enemies, and buying/selling at shops was as clear and concise as can be. The design of the menu system was such that you were able to work through the various screens in an a way that was intuitive yet still gave you the sense of having complete control over your characters and inventory (the gameplay video above has some menu footage as well). The fact that Betrayal at Krondor was a party-based game as opposed to being single-character makes this even more impressive. A counter-example to this would be the console version of Dragon Age: Origins (Bioware, 2009), which made navigating through your party's screens and trying to get them all equipped with the best weapons and armor a time-consuming and tedious task. Something as simple only showing equip-able armor for your selected character, as opposed to always showing your entire inventory of loot on each character screen, would have been a simple and extremely effective way to streamline the process without sacrificing any depth. Skill trees deserve a special mention here, as well. If skill trees are going to be a part of the game's equation, the upgrade paths should be clear and and easy to understand. They should never look like this: (courtesy of Final Fantasy X)

Advertisement

6. Provide A Sufficient Level Cap

This is a trend that I've only noticed in more recent games. If this was issue in the past, then I here forth shall consider myself fortunate for not ever coming across a game with this glaring flaw, because this is something I simply do not understand. There's a lot to love about RPG's: exciting combat, progression of the story, exploring and discovering hidden secrets in the game world, but let's be honest here. There is nothing else in gaming that compares to that "Level Up" flashing across your screen. It satisfies a sort of primal urge that is difficult to put into words, and is the primary reason many of us play these games in the first place. So for a game to prematurely take this away from the player is like removing the wildlife from an African safari. The game can still be played, but it makes the experience feel somewhat empty. A recurring trend I've written about is how gamers expect more from their games as the medium advances technologically. As RPG's become grander yet more nuanced at the same time, keeping leveling mechanics interesting over a long period of time poses a new set of challenges. However, hitting an early level cap should not be an ultimatum for a completionist type of gamer who wants to see as much of a game as possible. Ridiculously high level caps are not always the answer to this, but at the same time, game developers need to create leveling systems that are consistent with the amount of content that they provide in their games.

5. Include Towns Or A Hub World

Having a place, or places, where the player can relax, recharge, and restock after an intense adventure is always a welcome sight. Who doesn't feel that rush of relief when you drag your battered self into a town, only to find a consortium of locals more than willing to get you patched up and back on your way? Places where the player can take a break and just experience some sense of normalcy is not only only a perfect compliment to the intensity of questing and exploring a dangerous world, but it is also a very important part of maintaining the game's sense of pace. That distinct ebb and flow that defines the best RPG gaming is due large in part to these oases and the sense of serenity they provide. Seeing the way these types of places have evolved over the years has been quite the treat. From massive, elaborate hubs like Mass Effect's Citadel, to the ragged, scattered settlements of Fallout 3, these locations in games have evolved into little self-encompassed universes unto themselves. They are often places that are bursting at the seams with stories to be told, mysteries to decode, and treasures to be found for those willing to take the time to really poke around. It isn't entirely uncommon for the best of these places to make you forget, for a while at least, how you even got there in the first place. RPG's are changing and evolving at a brisk pace, but these places where the player regroup, and even discover an amazing secret or two, will very likely be a staple of the best RPG's for a long time to come.

4. The Loot Should Matter

The other "L" word that every RPG-er loves, finding shiny new loot remains one of the supreme joys of RPG gaming. Whether it's finally getting that new sword that can easily cut down those foes who keep making your life difficult, or uncovering a valuable treasure that you can sell for more money than your wallet can hold, good loot makes RPG's more fun, plain and simple. Unfortunately, some RPG's throw SO much loot at you, that after time, it tends to water down the experience of finding loot in the first place. Worse yet, is when the overabundance of loot gets to a point of saturation where the only thing that matters anymore are the baseline stats. Similar to the way the best RPG's balance action, exploration, and down time, so too should they put a similar focus on loot delivery to the player. A game that doesn't consistently over-encumber your inventory with worthless garbage, while still finding a way to get the player that sweet piece of loot right when they need it most, is the game that has succeeded in this area. To go along with the "less is more" theory on RPG loot, an additional way to augment this is to continue and develop the trend that many modern games have followed: give the good loot a unique look, a history, and a way for the player to interact with it. Skyrim's 3D models of every piece of loot you find in the game serves this latter function extremely well. And think back to the early RPGs of the 90's. Many of them had you seeking, at various points in the game, a certain weapon, piece of armor, or treasure that you had learned about via in-game lore, and finding that special gear was truly a climax to an ever-increasing state of anticipation. RPG's that combine this classic quality of loot significance with the modern sensibilities that games like Skyrim bring to the table ultimately make that hunt for the next shiny all the more meaningful.

3. Provide Clear, Comprehensive Stat Comparisons

While we're on the subject of loot, here is a very simple one that a surprisingly large number of RPG's don't get right. When you find a new piece of equipment and are considering swapping it in to replace your current equipment, a clear and comprehensive statistical comparison of the two items should never be more than a single button press/mouse click away. This is something I notice is a much bigger problem in RPG's of the Western variety as opposed to those of the Japanese, which seem to get this right much more often. If you are equipped with multiple weapons, and/or have other similar weapons in your inventory to the new one that you find, the game should be able to logically recognize what weapon(s) the player would like to see this new equipment compared to. All relevant information should be able to be quickly accessed, and not buried beneath layers of menus.

2. Create Environmental Variety

With the amount of time us lovers of RPG's spend with each game we play, and how much of our gameplay consists of exploration and discovery, a game not having a wide range of environmental variety is a cardinal sin. A cornucopia of settings to visit is one of the key factors that keeps an RPG from feeling stale and tedious after a certain amount of time spent with the game. Variety provokes that sense of wonder and desire to explore that is unique to the genre, and failing to provide this is a crucial mistake. With RPG's increasing steadily increasing in size as the years go by, it is understandable that the re-use of some in-game assets may be necessary, which is fine if it is done selectively and with with tact. A textbook study for developers of how NOT to do this is Bioware's Dragon Age II, a game whose lack of environments almost single-handedly sank the entire ship (I wrote about this in more detail in a previous article, which I refer you to). The Washington DC sewer systems of Fallout 3 is another case that comes to mind. Explaining that sense of relief I felt when I finally emerged from those redundant tunnels would be hard to do in words. RPG's encourage you to spend more time out in the game world than any other genre out there, so developers, please do all you can to keep that game world fresh and dynamic. The fate of the (game) world may depend on it!

1. Give The Game Great Music

An excellent score or soundtrack on top of an epic RPG is icing on the cake. While this quality may not be as critical as the previous nine points I've listed here, great music in a RPG in a way feels like glue that binds everything together. It's one of the things you remember the most clearly when you reflect back on the game years after you played it, like a song from your youth that brings back fond memories. The best soundtracks capture the emotional arcs of games, giving individual characters, places, and/or events memorable themes that are impossible to separate from the game elements themselves. One of the supreme masters of the genre, Nobuo Uematsu, has blessed us with some of gaming's most definitive examples of musical works that are every bit as much a part of a game's foundation as the mechanics. His works on the classic Final Fantasy games from the Super Famicom and Playstation eras are among the finest examples of RPG musical composition, as is his most recent work on The Last Story for the Nintendo Wii. Other recent WRPG's have taken a more cinematic approach to music composition, using music in a more event-specific manner to enhance the individual moods of certain occurrences as opposed to having variations on similar themes like older RPG's would. While this method may sometimes result in music that is more in-the-moment as opposed to something that will last, it often results in powerfully effective work that enhances the game experience in significant ways (Skyrim comes to mind). And lastly, there is the use of preexisting works in RPG's. I've returned to Fallout 3 a multitude of times throughout this list, and I shall one more time here, as Fallout 3 gave us perhaps the finest example in all of RPG gaming of using preexisting licensed work to perfectly with the game content. Eternal Sonata's use of Chopin's beautiful piano music is another sterling example of this that comes to mind. Regardless of whether the music is created specifically for the game, or is taken from existing works, most of the best RPG's in gaming's history have a fantastic music to accompany the long journey taken by the character and the player controlling him/her. This should never change. RPG's are complex, multifaceted, deep video games that are capable of delivering experiences unlike anything else out there. Developers should always keep in mind these 10 commandments as they set out on the journey to create these amazing worlds that we so love to live in. As we approach the next generation of hardware, the possibilities available to RPG's is staggering to think about, but the core foundation of what has made these games great for decades will remain the same. Happy questing!