10 Great Video Game Sequels NOBODY Asked For
Sequels are often a foregone conclusion, unless they aren't.
As more high-budget games hit digital and physical storefronts it's increasingly harder for new games to stand out.
Capturing lightning in a bottle is tough, so when developers do so it's almost always assumed that a sequel will be greenlit. Sometimes they prove to be runaway successes, paving the way for a franchise to flourish, and other instances the follow-up can do away with what made the first so great. Conversely, there are some games that few expected to receive a sequel, but got one anyway.
Be it because the story ended so neatly not warranting another or the first title simply didn't blow players away, unexpected sequels can be used to further add lore and context to the first game, or reinvent a franchise in a desperate attempt to stay relevant.
In a time when sequels and threequels are nothing new, it's all the more curious when a self-contained experience ends in a way that doesn't justify another entry. When a sequel emerges anyway and improves upon --or upholds the standards of-- its predecessor it's often cause for excitement, showing that the idea has more to give, and any renewed interest is justified.
10. Final Fantasy XIII-2
While the Final Fantasy series is known for its wonderful storytelling, now-iconic characters and immersive world-building, there have been a few entries that failed to uphold the standards that Final Fantasy 6, 7, 10, and 14 have made the norm.
Final Fantasy XIII was one such instance, with boring linear levels, a story that was nothing to write home about, and a forgettable battle system. Not only is it a blemish on Square Enix resume, but it's also seen by most as the lowest point in a JRPG franchise that is known for quality.
Its successor, the aptly-titled Final Fantasy XIII-2 moved Lightning's story in a positive direction, with less linearity and more improvements in the gameplay department refining the edges to make a game that is underrated because of its association to the game that came before.
It's rare that any mainline Final Fantasy game receives a direct sequel, and fans would be chomping at the bit at the idea of a follow-up to some of its best entries. However, XIII was poor, and in dire need of salvation. It got it with XIII-2, and while the while saga isn't well remembered, the second game in the trilogy at least tried to save its reputation.
9. The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
With the dual screens and emphasis on stylus-based gameplay of the Nintendo DS, it was always going to be a struggle to find inventive ways to bring beloved pre-existing franchises to such an obscurely designed handheld system.
Mario 64 DS was a launch title that showed how that character could make the leap gracefully, but Nintendo's other masterpiece was a lot harder to make work. The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass was what came of such efforts, wielding clunky controls, frustrating level design and polarizing visuals.
However, the magic of Zelda was not lost, and while it has its issues, Phantom Hourglass is delightful. Its perfectly balanced difficulty, charming story and quirky characters make the game truly shine, and though it's restricted by its hardware, Phantom Hourglass is a relative success both critically and commercially.
The Zelda franchise has a tendency to bring an all-new experience with each new entry, so it was puzzling when Phantom Hourglass turned out to be an immediate sequel to The Wind Waker. People always ask for a new Zelda game, but not usually like this.
The Wind Waker doesn't need a sequel, and few were chomping at the bit to return to its world, but Phantom Hourglass does so with the utmost respect for what came before.
8. Knack 2
Nobody asked for Knack when it arrived in 2013, so Knack 2 was even less desired. It did, however, improve upon the first in many ways.
Knack 2 was haphazardly announced at PlayStation Experience in 2016, which was a shame given the immense expectations Sony had of its predecessor. Knack was in line to be the next poster child of the company, much like Sackboy and Little Big Planet was to the PS3, but the sales weren't particularly strong and the critical response was even less consistent.
It has since been ridiculed, and it's undoubtedly deserving of some light-hearted jabs fired its way, but the sequel did well to develop upon the ideas that the first game had. The combat has been greatly expanded, strategy is required to get the best out of the enemy encounters, and the story is charming enough to overlook some of its uneven writing.
The biggest problem that Knack 2 couldn't seem to overcome was that there simply wasn't a demand for it. The PlayStation 4 had been around for years, so nobody felt the need to play a game that has such a stunted legacy.
7. Ni No Kuni 2: Revenant Kingdom
Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch released in 2011 in Japan but made its way over to the west in 2013. Developed by Level 5 and published by Bandai Namco, it told the story of Oliver, an unassuming boy with a love for motoring and adventure. Tragedy strikes early on in his story, and Oliver's grief has him venture to another world.
The landscape of Ni No Kuni is simply magnificent, wielding a fantasy-inspired world that has its fair share of dangers as well as moments of genuine beauty.
A sequel arrived in early 2018, taking place hundreds of years after the first game, but enough of Wrath of the White Witch's footprint was left to make its sequel yet another hit.
Focusing its story on Evan Pettiwhisker Tildrum, the tale the game told was charming, and a change in combat direction made it a more fluid experience overall.
Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch is a stand-alone experience, and only seemed to capture a small but passionate fanbase in the west. It was a surprise when a sequel was greenlit, but Revenant Kingdom does enough different while honouring the past to forge a truly great game.
6. Destiny 2
Before its release in 2014, Destiny was subject to anticipation unlike any other game release in history. Huge promises and fan hype would prove to be its downfall, however, and while it became a decent product, Destiny was quickly replaced by a sequel.
Many players asked for a Destiny experience that was better than the one at launch, but the game's 10-year plan was well documented, and the demand was for the base game to improve, offering more content and reasons to take advantage of its stellar gameplay loop.
Nobody asked for a direct sequel, as it was presumed by most that Bungie's decade-long commitment to the game would be upheld. Yet, a sequel arrived just three years later, and Destiny 2 improved upon the first in so many ways.
Never reinventing the formula, rather refining the edges, Destiny 2 is the game that so many still return to in 2022, with new content being added all the time. The story is solid and the gameplay is better than ever.
Bungie's acquisition by Sony will perhaps have huge ramifications for the franchise, but Destiny 2 is the sequel players needed, even if they didn't ask for it.
5. Deadly Premonition 2: A Blessing in Disguise
Deadly Premonition is a strange game.
Equal parts hailed as an all-time classic and a catastrophic failure, the game's legacy is so very polarizing. Its visuals were dated, even for the time and so many of its awful gameplay features seemed to be self-inflicted. However, those who liked it loved it, and consider the obscure conversations in the car, dark story, and weird enemy interactions to all be instrumental to its charm.
Nobody expected, or wanted a follow-up to the project, simply because of the low budget and poor sales. However, in September 2019 a sequel was announced at a Nintendo Direct, and stayed exclusive to the hybrid Nintendo system until it launched on PC two years later.
Deadly Premonition 2: A Blessing in Disguise maintained the eccentricity, and showed that it could be a decent, if unexpected franchise. It had significant performance issues on release that have been soothed somewhat over time, but the characters are lovingly recreated and the overall game design is good enough to satisfy returning players.
That's the most important thing, however, as Deadly Premonition 2 is unlikely to win new fans as it relies too heavily on a game that so many simply didn't want to understand.
4. New Super Mario Bros. U
Super Mario Bros is a franchise that isn't going anywhere. The character's foothold in the gaming industry is undeniable as Mario has been the poster child for the gaming medium since the mid-1980s.
From the near-perfect Super Mario World, to the revolutionary Super Mario 64 right up to Super Mario Odyssey, the franchise is never far away from a truly innovative experience.
However, such a storied history will naturally bring a few less-than-stellar releases. One series within the wider Mario franchise that many take issue with is the New Super Mario Bros collection; four games that attempt to rekindle the magic of 2D Mario games of old.
The fourth and final one is perhaps the best of all, taking all the best features from past games and bringing a game that is one of the few essential Wii U titles.
So few players asked for a fourth game in the New Super Mario series because the first three, while great, were all rather similar to each other. New Super Mario Bros. U is not drastically different to what came before, which is to its detriment, but it's a great game nonetheless, despite nobody really wishing it into existence.
3. God of War (2018)
Santa Monica has always been known for one property. With the exception of Kinetica in 2001, the Sony-owned developer has worked entirely on God of War, and while the original trilogy spanning five years was a runaway success and rivalled the likes of Devil May Cry and Dynasty Warriors in the hack-and-slash genre, there was always more it could give.
By 2013, franchise fatigue set in for many gamers and the release of God of War: Ascension came and went with little notice. It was by no means a bad game, but ultimately failed to offer anything new at a time when so many genre-defining titles were dominating the AAA space.
For all intents and purposes, Kratos' journey was done after God of War: Ascension. However, the 2018 reboot not only revitalized the franchise, but took the gaming world by storm.
Taking Kratos to the unforgiving lands of Midgard and Norse mythology was the restart he needed, and a more grounded tale did well to make his character feel new again. In 2014 nobody was asking for another God of War game, but little did we all know it was exactly what we wanted.
2. Guacamelee! 2
Now recently in the spotlight in 2022 thanks to the release of Nobody Saves the World, Drinkbox Studios has been innovating and providing players with hours of entertainment since its first game release in 2011.
Just two years later, the Toronto-based developer released Guacamelee!, a Metroidvania platform/brawler that sported a gorgeous visuals and a charming story. It was one of the often-overlooked PlayStation Vita's best games, and showed that a smaller studio could take such a tried-and-tested genre and still find new ways to create fun.
With Drinkbox moving onto Severed in 2016, it seemed unlikely that Guacamelee! would ever receive a sequel, but a follow-up was released in 2018 that improved platforming, presented a surprisingly engaging narrative and upheld the expectations of fans of the first game.
Drinkbox is a studio known for innovation, so returning to Guacamelee! for a sequel to refine the experience was a welcome surprise, if a little unexpected. It seems increasingly unlikely that the trilogy is completed anytime soon. Anything is possible, though, especially as Guacamelee! 2 brought new eyes to a developer that never seems to get enough credit.
1. Watch Dogs 2
Watch Dogs was the poster child for the next generation when it was announced at E3 2012, and promised ground-breaking graphics, a thrilling story and an exciting fictional city of Chicago to explore at the player's leisure.
When it released, fans were left disappointed as it was clear the game wasn't as polished as initially advertised. Visually it was nothing special, the narrative was weak and the city left much to be desired. It was, for all intents and purposes, a failure, and raised apprehension for new releases rather than built anticipation.
Nobody expected developer Ubisoft to give the franchise another chance but in 2016, just a few months before it hit shelves, the company announced Watch Dogs 2. Now set in the sunny city of San Francisco, it looked to be a stark difference in tone but maintained the hacker-based story and gameplay that was expected.
After the disappointment of the first game, Watch Dogs 2 had it all to prove, and moving to the Bay gave Ubisoft's contemporary open-world series new life. The positive strides that the project made only heightens the immense frustration of Watch Dogs: Legion, which seemed to revert back to type.