10 Horror Video Games That Broke All The Rules
Horror games that broke all the rules! Boogeyman, Darkwood & more.
There are certain things we’ve just come to expect from horror games. It’s always dark-backstory this and body-horror that, and we fans drink it up. However, due to the years of regurgitated stories and tropes, we sometimes naturally set the bar quite low for our expectations.
Micro-budget indies and huge studio outputs can fall victim to the very same temptations, leaning into lazy cliches rather than trying something innovative in horror. If you know that a few jumpscares and a dirty haunted house setting are going to scare people, then why bother thinking of something else?
Every now and then, though, a developer will come out with something that takes us by surprise. It takes bravery to disregard all the tried-and-tested approaches, going out on a limb and seeing if players are going to vibe with something new, and you’ve got to applaud that!
Well, these games did just that: acknowledging all the unspoken rules of horror and turning them on their head.
So, go ahead and throw your expectations out of the window, because these games raise you a whole new kind of experience.
10. Stories Untold - Getting Rid Of Jumpscares
One of the oldest tricks in the book when it comes to horror movies or games is the jumpscare.
When used sparingly, they can be an effective way to raise a player’s heart-rate and make them feel a little more on edge. The key word here is sparingly, of course, because when over-done jumpscares can absolutely kill a game’s atmosphere.
If you rely completely on the threat of a screaming monster flashing up full-screen to lend your title some tension, then you’ve not made a very good game. Similarly, if it’s happening every few minutes then it stops being scary.
Luckily for the jumpscare-averse, games completely devoid of this staple do exist!
Stories Untold tells its story through four episodes, in which you slowly uncover the player-character’s situation, mainly through playing games inside of the game itself.
By virtue of its style, the title doesn’t lend itself to the classic scares of monsters hiding around corners. Instead it uses atmosphere and intrigue to build tension and drive the narrative forward, with the final episode giving you the satisfying ending you’ve worked towards.
9. Among The Sleep - No Saving The Kids
A very common motivation for characters is that of saving their family, often specifically their children. It’s something about their innocence and helplessness that makes the stakes that bit higher. In Among The Sleep though, you’re not going out to save your kids - you are the kid!
Playing as toddler David, you must navigate the scary world around you that is tailored for much larger people. With his companion, a sentient teddy bear, David has to find certain memories to get himself back to safety and reach his mother, Zoey. Navigating several surreal environments and strange entities, David really is living every kid’s nightmare.
It’s a fun angle to play as the kid saving themselves, and all the mechanics that come with that given the limited abilities of a child. For example, David can only run for so long before he falls over, and in order to progress and move at all he needs his teddy with him.
Over the years we’ve seen more games taking on the perspective of a child, some popular ones include Little Nightmares or Limbo. When done well, it’s a refreshing new approach to an old trope.
8. The Vanishing Of Ethan Carter - Binning The Gritty Aesthetic
So often we’re served the same gritty, dark art-style in horror games. Even when it comes to big-budget releases, the problem remains that every location has to be overtly grotesque. Some of the realest horrors in life occur in very normal spaces, so why do no games seem to reflect that?
One title that saw all the ugly game environments and raised us something beautiful is this 2014 adventure.
Set in the fictional town of Red Creek Valley, Wisconsin, the open world allows the player to explore a genuinely beautiful area. The aesthetics were based on the stunning areas around Poland’s Karkonosze mountains, with certain areas bearing striking resemblance to the real places that inspired them.
Playing as paranormal investigator Paul Prospero, you discover the story behind the disappearances of Ethan and his family. The discovery mechanics encourage exploration, with the game doing very little to guide you in the right direction.
Whilst it's agreed that the title has its problems, it has been almost universally praised for its stunning visuals, proving that you don’t need a dark, blood-covered aesthetic to make a good horror game.
7. Strobophagia - Strange Locations
Leading on from Ethan Carter’s highly praised aesthetics and setting, we need to give some credit to other games that thought outside the box with their locations. It can just be a bit lazy to lean back on a typically ‘scary’ setting but if you start with an interesting location, a certain amount of intrigue is sure to follow.
We’ll throw some honorable mentions to games with almost comically specific settings, like Betrayer (colonial Fort Henry in the 17th century) or Narcosis (an undersea methane-mining complex in the wake of an earthquake), but for this entry we’re going to praise Strobophagia.
When was the last time you played a game set at a cursed rave? Set at the site of a psychedelic rave gone wrong, you find yourself running for your life trying to escape the dark forces at play. With some really trippy visuals and a fun smartphone mechanic to help you navigate the story, this 2020 release promises something different from the norm.
Whilst players have complained of some issues with bugs, overall it has been praised for its fantastic atmosphere and setting.
6. Never-ending Nightmares - Realistic Running
If you actually think about it, there’s no good reason for the average horror protagonist to be an Olympic-grade runner. Even in scenarios where your character may be badly injured, they seem to be able to morph into Mo Farah when the situation calls for it.
Lots of things make Neverending Nightmares a really interesting, genre-bending game, but a small one that adds to its depth is the player-character’s limited sporting abilities.
You play as Thomas, a man plagued by horrifying nightmares. The game’s designer, Matt Gilgenbach, created it with his personal struggles in mind: using the game’s story and appearance to reflect his experiences of OCD and depression. Another bit of himself that he chose to put into it, however, is his asthma.
When you look at famous horror game protagonists, the thought of labouring them with chronic asthma seems kind of hilarious, in that it would almost definitely cause their deaths. We can come to rely on our player-character’s ability to outrun danger, so introducing a mechanic like this forces us to work smarter.
By taking away the ability to run endlessly, Gilgenbach added an effective layer of realism and tension.
5. Stifled - Scrapping Gory Graphics
Visuals are of course very important in horror. In lots of cases, body-horror and aesthetically repulsive villains are used as the main selling point. Think of the unnerving, cartoonish gore in Fran Bow or the all-too-real-looking mutilations in Outlast: your eyes drink it all in and tell your brain to be very, very afraid.
This is where Stifled took a hard left turn, deciding that instead of scaring us with visceral images they would build tension relying on another sense: hearing. The game is at its best when you are navigating the darkness, the simplistic graphics revealing the outline of your setting only when sound occurs.
In this context, you can see your enemies only in linework. There’s none of the gross-out factor, not even the subtle horror of the uncanny valley, but the game works regardless of this.
The story and the slowly unfurling mystery work well enough with the minimalist appearance that we don’t miss the cheap scares. Alternating between linework and 3D, none of the environments are fear-inducing by nature and work well nonetheless.
4. Darkwood - No Hand-holding
It is a bit of a staple of mystery and horror games to force you to complete a series of convoluted, overly-complex puzzles. Even when things get tough though, it can still feel a little off-putting when a game steps in to guide you through it when you just know you could’ve figured it out yourself!
One incredibly well-received game that lets you take the reins is 2017’s Darkwood. A top-down survival horror, Darkwood allows you to wander around a dark forest piecing together the storyline and scavenging to survive.
Your choices and relationships with NPCs influence the eventual outcome, and there are certain scenarios and mysteries that need to be solved, but even when the going gets tough you’re left pretty well alone. The puzzles are challenging and conducive to the storyline, driven by meaningful interactions and a forward momentum.
Filled with cool characters and locations, an air of mystery and a queue of awaiting surprises, Darkwood makes for a challenging and satisfying experience.
3. S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - Daytime Terror
Everything is scarier at night! It’s all dark and shadowy, and every snapping twig or creaking floorboard could be a killer sneaking ever closer. It’s easy to see then why the majority of horrors are set in the dark.
The S.T.A.L.K.E.R. series takes a different approach. Set in an alternate universe where Chernobyl experienced a second nuclear disaster in 2006, you assume the character of an illegal scavenger in the wasteland, lovingly nicknamed a ‘Stalker’.
You are rescued from the site of a vehicle crash by a fellow stalker, and set out a series of tasks. Referred to as The Marked One, your player-character has no memory of his past.
Out in The Zone, the sun cannot save you from the horrors that await. Ranging from mutated animals and humans through to terrifying ‘anomalies’ that cause glitches in Earth’s physics, the things that can kill you are just as potent and scary in broad daylight.
You can stock up on weapons and coat yourself with armour, but out in the nuclear wastelands you’re never quite safe.
2. Boogeyman - You Can't Run And You Can't Hide
Five Nights at Freddy’s really has been talked to death, we know, but part of its appeal was that as a player you could not run, hide, nor defend yourself with a weapon. In an effort to avoid recommending this game to you after years of coverage have pretty much turned it into a meme, let’s look at another, smaller game with the same kind of idea: Boogeyman.
In this game all you have to defend yourself is one measly flashlight. Playing as a kid, sitting in bed and paralysed with fear, you have to carefully monitor your room for any sign of movement, lest the Big Bad Boogeyman get close enough to snatch you away.
Empowerment in horror games frequently falls to one end of the spectrum: either you’re armed to the teeth and can blast away the monsters, or you have nothing to defend yourself and your only option is to hide.
Boogeyman falls somewhere in between, encouraging you to stay tense and alert at all times, knowing that you can never truly kill the enemy, but also allowing you to be on the offensive by shining your light.
It’s a hard line to toe but it can be refreshing to see a game take less of a hard-line approach to the offense and defense problem.
1. Sweet Home - Making The Rules
This one game has been cited countless times as one of the most influential in the horror genre. Released in 1989, Sweet Home served as a direct influence for many a well-loved horror title including the infamous Resident Evil franchise.
The game’s story is roughly the same as that of its namesake film, but with certain parts expanded and adapted for gameplay’s sake. It follows a group of documentary-makers who venture into a disappeared artist’s home, looking to locate his missing artworks. After entering they soon find that the mansion houses some dark secrets and that the past is literally there to haunt them.
Featuring many of the staples we frequently see today, this RPG was one of the first to use ‘note discovery’ as a way to reveal story. Despite its limited graphics and dated mechanics, it has been praised for achieving a haunting horror experience that could rival modern offerings.
The game broke all the rules and expectations at the time purely by virtue of being innovative; the countless homages to its concepts and wide acclaim by critics over the years are testament to its fantastic reputation.