10 Incredible Characters Wasted In Terrible Video Games

The characters who give 110% even with nothing to work with.

By Christian Higley /

One critical thing video games and movies have in common is how many disparate elements need to be brought together, cohesively, to make something great.

Advertisement

Just like we see a lot of movies with bad scripts but great performances, we see games that are total train wrecks on a technical level, but packed with quality writing and great characters. Heck, Obsidian has practically built their whole brand on this.

Sometimes, all of a game's pieces come together to make an instant classic, like, say, The Last Of Us. Other times, the developers end up in something of a square-peg-meets-round-hole situation designing the technical elements of a title while, one office over, the writing team is hitting a perfect game of unique and compelling characters to fill it with.

A really good character can make suffering through an otherwise catastrophic experience worth it. Just dial the difficulty down to the easiest level and enjoy the ride as smoothly as possible. And hope that, like some entries on this list, your beloved character returns later in a better sequel.

Until that wish comes true, here are some of the characters who carry entire games on their backs.

10. Hawke - Dragon Age II

Bioware has fallen hard in recent years. Both in terms of game quality and the troubling stories about the treatment of their employees. In hindsight, we can see how Dragon Age II spelled the beginning of the end for the formerly beloved studio.

Advertisement

Dragon Age: Origins began development in 2002 and wasn't released until 2009. In that time, Bioware was bought by Electronic Arts, justifiably worrying everyone. So when its sequel was released just two short years later, it confirmed most of our fears.

Dragon Age II was a stripped down version of the original - largely linear, not nearly as complex or challenging, and threadbare in terms of content. The game often had you returning to the same areas repeatedly, just with different enemies.

DAII also dropped the backstory options of the original in favor of a single protagonist - Hawke. But surprisingly, Hawke quickly became the game's best selling point.

Over the years that pass in-game, we get to guide Hawke from naive refugee to prominent political figure and a total badass, champion of the people. This is a role playing game, so your experience may vary, but one thing every Hawke has in common is undenyable swag.

9. Lincoln Clay - Mafia III

Mafia III released as a glitchy, practically unplayable disaster. After numerous patches, it isn't a bad game. But it is way too generic for its anything-but-generic protagonist, Lincoln Clay.

Advertisement

Clay is a veteran returning home from the Vietnam War. Shortly after reuniting with his former, modest criminal outfit, they're (unsurprisingly) used and betrayed by the Marcano crime family. The only survivor of that treason, Lincoln uses the unique, violent skills he perfected as a covert special forces operative to take the mob down one big hit at a time and unite the various minority communities into a kind of criminal federation.

It's an approach to this kind of game protagonist we haven't seen before. Clay is a man on a mission, stalking prey, inciting insurgence, and using psychological tactics to intimidate his enemies.

Unfortunately, that feeling only lasts for the first few hours of the game before it turns into just another repetitive open world grind. Even as a criminal mastermind, Clay is still jacking cars and robbing stores personally. So nothing you do feels tied to the character outside of cut-scenes.

Hopefully we see the series return to Lincoln and do him justice.

8. April Ryan - Dreamfall: The Longest Journey

The Longest Journey is a true classic that's fallen into relative obscurity over the years. Released in 2009, TLJ is a point-and-click adventure game about a young art student (April Ryan) who finds herself traveling between two worlds - her world of technology, called Stark, and a parallel world of magic, called Arcadia.

Advertisement

The sequel, Dreamfall: The Longest Journey, is a victim of its own ambition. Not content to be another point-and-click title, it introduced frustrating and completely unnecessary combat and stealth mechanics that dragged down the entire experience.

Set several years after the events of the original, April had made a life for herself in Arcadia until it was upended by the invasion of the human-supremacist Azadi Empire. She joined a resistance of mostly non-humans and became their most infamous agent and spy.

This April is determined, but jaded after years of being forced to live in the shadows of her new home. The resistance is losing and she's well aware of that fact. But she still charges forward, giving 100% to the fight for freedom. This April is a warrior and a fascinating, surprisingly natural evolution of the character.

7. Atton Rand - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic II

Star Wars: Knights Of he Old Republic II is infamously glitchy and unfinished, with an ending that consists entirely of an exposition dump. However, while a technical train wreck, its story and characters are some of the best Star Wars has ever had to offer. And one of those characters is the deceptively complex Atton Rand.

Advertisement

Introduced as the resident Han Solo knockoff we see in a lot of Star Wars expanded fiction (we see you, Dash Rendar), you'll come to learn that it's all a Don Draper-style act he's been putting on for years.

In actuality, Rand was a fiercely loyal servant of Darth Revan, pre-redemption. Trained to hunt down and abduct Jedi for Revan to torment and turn to the dark side, Rand was molded into a tool for violence. But after discovering his own Force sensitivity, he went into hiding. And what better cover for a grim professional kidnapper than that of the charming rogue?

Like other characters in the game, Rand can eventually be trained in the Force, leading him to redemption as a Jedi or embracing his violent past as a Sith, depending on the player's choices. Hopefully the former. The latter is very sad.

6. Nines Rodriguez - Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines

Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines is mess that earned a devoted cult following thanks to its excellent writing and characters. Not only is Bloodlines glitchy, but it also lacks anything resembling balance. It's impossible to finish the game with certain character builds, which is the main thing you should be able to do in an RPG.

Advertisement

Nines Rodriguez is the head of the local faction of anarchist vampires, who call themselves, unimaginatively, the Anarchs. Having lived as a human during the Great Depression, he is also a loud voice of opposition to the other, much wealthier, vampire leaders in LA.

Not only does Nines save you from execution at the hands of those other leaders, he is also consistently one of the few people not planning to use you and throw you away. Throughout the game he remains a tried and true homie, offering advice and guidance, and never asking what you can do for him.

So it's a real bummer when he's ambushed and seemingly killed by a werewolf.

Until later, when you meet him laying low, having faked his death, with the bloody head of the werewolf laying beside him. Man you're cool, Nines.

5. Bagley - Watch Dogs: Legion

It might be cheating to include a character from a game whose cast consists almost entirely of interchangeable, algorithmically-generated silent protagonists, but that's what makes Bagley stand out.

Advertisement

Watch Dogs: Legion is one of those games that could have been so, so good. It was a solid proof of concept for the idea, in any case: the potential to recruit anyone you see to join hacktivist collective DeadSec. Unfortunately, the amount and variety of content when it came to these characters was drastically low, essentially consisting of a small number of different character archetypes with unique abilities. It didn't take long to see just about everything the game had to offer.

In a sense, self-aware AI Bagley is sort of a de facto protagonist. As the mission control of DeadSec, Bagley is always with you, providing objectives, hints and general chit-chat.

This character could have been obnoxious. Fortunately, he's well written and well cted enough to, ironically, be the only character in the game with any depth or personality. He's even the focal point of the game's most genuinely heartfelt mission.

4. Dr. Jonathan Reid - Vampyr

Vampyr is the perfect example of when a team with extremely limited resources, trying out a new genre for the first time, aim a bit too high by trying to emulate a Souls game. Maybe developer Dontnod - makers of the Life Is Strange series - should have opted for something a little less complex for only their second action title. But Vampyr shines in most other ways.

Advertisement

Jonathon Reed is a doctor and World War I vet who returns home to London, only to be turned, against his will, into a Vampire. From then on the player decides the extent to which Jonathan will give in to his dark temptations, right down to who to kill and eat; or to maintain your humanity entirely and feed only on rats.

As mentioned, Jonathan is a professional doctor. During the game you'll prescribe medicine and even perform emergency triage and surgery, all while trying to solve the mystery of who made you a vampire and why. It's refreshing to see a gentlemanly, scholarly protagonist in a bloody action game.

3. Anthony Higgs - Metroid: Other M

You'd be hard pressed to find a Metroid fan with anything kind to say about Metroid: Other M, Team Ninja's disastrous, confounding action take on the beloved series.

Advertisement

Widely criticized for turning protagonist Samus Aran from confident, lone-wolf bounty hunter into a self-conscious girl who couldn't even make a decision without permission from her male superiors, Other M especially didn't shine in the character department. But most players agree that Anthony Higgs deserved to appear in a much better game.

Anthony is Samus's best friend from her days in the military, before becoming a bounty hunter. Anthony is charismatic and laid-back - a perfect foil for the usually stoic Samus. He actually recognizes her ability and vocally acknowledges that she's way stronger than him or any other average Federation soldier. Even better, he isn't set up as a love interest. He and Samus have a genuinely respectful, close friendship - something you don't often see between male and female characters in fiction.

He's also shown to be very competent, tough, and clever in his own right. So if he ever does reappear, it probably won't be as an escort mission, thank the Chozo.

2. Decoy - Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure

Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure is a glitchy, poorly designed action game that's often a chore to play. It also has the honor of most needlessly long title for a brand new IP ever. Fortunately, however, the game's central conceit of being a graffiti artist turned rebel propagandist works beautifully, both in the mechanics of putting up your art and in a narrative sense.

Advertisement

Decoy is kind of like the Obi-Wan Kenobi of the game. He's a mentor character for protagonist Trane who dies before you can really get to know him, but has a huge impact on Trane's motivations going forward.

Through his art, Decoy challenges the government cover-up that resulted in Trane's father's mysterious death. You can see his art through the game, containing a number of political messages and military influences. And after his death, you can appropriate his art and continue to spread his message and keep his spirit alive as a symbol of resistance.

Also, OK fine, he's basically just Banksy. In the context of the game though, that's pretty awesome.

1. Rahm Kota - Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II

The Original Star Wars: The Force Unleashed wasn't perfect, but it was fun as hell thanks to the physics system that made using Force powers such a blast. Though it suffered from the odd cheap enemy or frustrating platforming section, it was still one of the better Star Wars games. And it sold well, setting a solid foundation for an inevitable sequel.

Advertisement

So what the hell happened?

The Force Unleashed II felt like a rushed, cheap, cash-in that squandered an interesting story premise, as well as everything its forbear had accomplished.

One of its few shining stars however was a returning character from the first game - General Rahm Kota. Having survived Order 66 thanks to his commando unit of loyal non-clone volunteers, Rahm waged a guerilla war against the Empire before the Rebel Alliance existed, performing hit-and-run attacks on Imperial infrastructure.

After being defeated by the player in the first game, Rahm turns up as a blind drunk who's in need of redemption himself. Fortunately he finds it, and in the sequel is the combat general of the Rebel military, leading from the front like the badass he is.

Rahm Kota is basically the Rambo of Star Wars.

Advertisement