10 Major Controversies That Killed Great Video Games
Hope you like loot boxes and IP disagreements in your video games!
Nobody, not even a game developer, is perfect. Mistakes can happen to anyone, and lapses in judgement can lead to some serious 'egg on your face' moments regardless of how calm and composed an individual is. Gaming history is littered with instances of decisions and moments that have gotten everyone talking for all the wrong reasons.
And whilst the gaming community is known for their ability to conjure up debates and division out of practically anything, they've also got an unrivalled ability to come together in unison when a controversy arises.
There's no understating just how powerful a united fanbase can be either when it comes to making or breaking the success of a video game, with plenty of titles feeling the full force of criticism from the ground and living to tell the tale.
So, from obvious cash-grabs to messy lawsuits from competing companies, here are some of the most major controversies that helped cast a black cloud over already established great titles, or games with all the potential in the world to become great, and killed off any hopes of them establishing themselves as truly legendary.
10. The Office Create IP - Cooking Mama: Cookstar
Cooking Mama is undoubtedly the definitive cooking simulator franchise in the gaming world, and its bright colours and overly happy presentation makes it one of the most inoffensive titles going for the most part. Cooking Mama: Cookstar was developed by 1st Playable Productions and published by Planet Entertainment, but its release remains one of the most speculated and controversial in recent times.
There's a lot within Cookstar that fans of the franchise can get behind; it has that casual arcade feel that is perfect for a handheld, the recipes are more detailed than most that had come before and it utilises the Nintendo Switch's controls very well for the most part.
Its controversial release ensured that there will always be a black cloud hanging over all of this promise however.
Originally released in March 2020 without any public announcements or high profile press statements, the game was pulled from the Switch EShop after just a couple of hours due to disputes between Planet Entertainment and the owners of the Cooking Mama IP, Office Create.
Rumours began to circulate that the game was a secret crypto miner, but it turned out that the dispute came from Planet Entertainment selling the game despite terminating their licence with Office Create prior to the game's release. The game was heavily condemned by Office Create when it did release in April 2020, no doubt impacting the review scores from critics, and the planned PS4 release of Cookstar has, at the time of writing, still not come about or even been acknowledged by Planet Entertainment.
9. Marlboro Adverts - Super Monaco GP
Released in 1989 as the sequel to the classic 1979 Monaco GP arcade hit, Super Monaco GP was Sega's foray into the world of racing simulators for the 1990s.
Whilst the original release for the Sega X Board only featured the one race across the famous grand prix circuit in Monaco, later ports on various consoles would bring with them new courses and challenges centred around the Formula One World Championship, giving gamers one of the best instances of an immersive simulator based on real world competitions.
Remember, this was way before the likes of Fifa came to the party.
The game's groundbreaking potential was seriously stunted however by a decision to include Marlboro (renamed 'Marlbobo for copyright sake) advertisements in the game. This proved to be the biggest obstacle for the game when Philip Morris, the makers and distributors of Marlboro cigarettes, filed a trademark lawsuit against Sega for using tobacco advertisements in a game that was readily available for children to pick up and play.
Ultimately the trademark dispute was nothing more than a slimy publicity stunt used by Philip Morris to try and appear as a morally conscious brand, but it did harmfully affect Sega and Super Monaco GP with the Japanese company forced to settle up, redevelop aspects of the game to remove the Marlbobo adverts and even pay arcade operators $200 and supply them with chips of the new version of the game to use.
8. Being Released Despite Not Being Ready - BattleCruiser 3000
First released back in September 1996, Take-Two Interactive's Battlecruiser 3000AD is a game that has established a legacy for its long and troubled development that ultimately killed what potential it might have had.
Set far in a future where humanity has managed to fashion together intergalactic spaceships, Battlecruiser features three unique modes: free flight, advanced campaign mode and xtreme carnage combat simulator, all of which feature players strapping in to these ships and fighting through hordes of oncoming enemies.
Development for the game began in 1992 after Three-Sixty Pacific acquired the rights, but it would be shelved when the company went bust just a year later. That was the first warning sign of the poisoned chalice reputation the game would garner before its final release hit the shelves, with Battlecruiser 3000AD going through a whopping three more companies: Mission Studios, Intracorp and finally Take-Two Interactive.
Reports and files from Take-Two revealed that Battlecruiser 3000AD made up over 14% of the company's entire budget for 1996, with certain sources saying they had spent north of $618,000 for the title. With this being just one of the companies stung by the title over the 1990s, it's safe to say that all of these development controversies ensured that fans weren't too focused on the gameplay when Battlecruiser 3000AD was finally let loose.
7. Alien Anal Probes Making Co-Operative Impossible - Saint's Row IV
The Saints Row franchise has made a name for itself for being one of the wildest series of games going, and the fourth instalment in the series is certainly no different. Developed by Volition and published by Deep Silver in 2013, it puts the player at the head of the infamous 3rd Street Saints gang where they become the President of the United States and must fend off an army of invading aliens.
The game featured a unique sense of humour, a vibrant open world filled with plenty of side missions and storylines, and managed to incorporate the superhero and supernatural aspects originally planned for its predecessors. It sold over a million copies in its first month and garnered some pretty solid reviews from fans and critics, but would find itself stunted by a high profile ban on the game in Australia.
Saint's Row IV featured drug use and an in-game alien probe weapon which made the game the first under the Australian Classification Board's new rules to be denied a rating. Volition removed these two features in order to push through the ban in response, but this only made that game's particular co-operative version unplayable with every other one around the world, going a long way to spoil the fun for Antipodean players.
6. Leaks Ruin The Game's Story - The Last Of Us Part 2
The Last of Us was one of the games of the generation when it was released in 2013, with its themes, visuals and storytelling helping to reshape what made a successful video game going forward. Its legendary legacy helped make its sequel, The Last of Us Part II, one of the most anticipated games ever released and, for the most part, it's managed to live up to that hype with improved mechanics, complex themes and some seriously gripping performances.
However, for some hardcore fans off the franchise, things were ruined before they even had a chance to play the game thanks to a series of controversial leaks surrounding the game's storyline.
Not only did these leaks spoil some of the biggest and most tragic elements of the game's storyline for plenty of players yet to even make it through a single loading screen, but the negative criticism it drew from the fans that did stumble across them put the game on the back foot before its release. What's more, some of the leaked developments which garnered the most ire seemed to be confirmed in a lot of the game's trailers, which only threw more fuel on the fire for those affected.
5. Easter Egg Controversies - Devotion
Released in February 2019 by Taiwanese game developers Red Candle Games, Devotion is a proper back-to-basics first person psychological horror game whose fantastic potential was marred by controversy. The game follows Du Feng Yu, an unstable screenwriter and his family living inside their apartment during the 1980s.
The developers of the game wanted to put Taiwanese culture in front of people, and Devotion is filled with folklore references that really help sell the tension that comes from the ability to keep players sucked in.
However, upon release Devotion was bombarded by critics from China that took issue with a particularly unflattering reference to the Chinese leader, Xi Jinping, within the game. The game's reviews on Steam went from 'overwhelmingly positive' to 'mostly negative' almost overnight, and Red Candle Games suddenly found themselves drawn into a messy battle against China's infamous online censorship.
The Taiwanese vice Premier, Chen Chi-mai, stepped in on the game's behalf and spoke about the importance of allowing freedom to criticise in a democratic country, but Red Candle proceeded to pull the game from Steam entirely and remove the offending reference.
The controversy sparked outrage online, but Red Candle's Sina Weibo account remains blocked to this day and the #Devotion trend on Twitter has continued to be heavily censored in China.
4. "Do You Guys Not Have Phones?" - Diablo Immortal
When Wyatt Chen, Principal Game Designer at Blizzard Entertainment, stepped onto the stage at Blizzcon in 2018 to unveil a brand new Diablo game to thousands of fans, he could never have imagined that he would be stepping off as one of the most memed and controversial figures in the world of gaming.
Diablo Immortal is an upcoming game that has become one of the most fiercely ridiculed and controversial titles on the market, opening up that infamous can of worms to gamers about whether mobile gaming can be put in the same category as PC.
Tensions around the game began to mount following Chen's announcement at Blizzcon that the game would strictly be available on mobile only, prompting jeers, boos and one audience member to ask if the decision was an: 'out of season April Fool's joke.' Ouch.
The event was being streamed live at the time so there was no hiding away from it either, and Blizzard's overall stock fell by a whopping 7% after they retorted back with: "Do you guys not have phones?" It had felt like the company had sold out to the mobile gaming craze at the time and hardcore fans of the franchise were understandably frustrated that they had essentially been told a lie once they dug past the flashy trailers and promises of a 'new Diablo game announcement'.
The truth is that Diablo Immortal looks like a good game in the making, with flashy trailers and clearly lots of love going into it from experienced and passionate developers. It just doesn't really stand a chance with all this negative publicity hanging over it anymore.
3. Transphobic Content - Ion Fury
You can probably imagine where some of the controversy arose with this one.
Ion Fury was developed by Voidpoint and published by 3D Realms in 2019 as a prequel to the 2016 release, Bombshell. A cyberpunk-themed first person shooter, the game won a Player's Choice Indie of the Year at IndieDB in 2019 and received a series of pretty solid ratings upon release thanks to its Doom-esque look and slick controls. Metacritic gave it a score of 78/100 and PCGamesN's Chris Capel called it "probably the best Build engine game ever".
Despite all of its promise however, Ion Fury was blasted away by a plethora of controversies before it was even launched.
The game was subjected to intense scrutiny following the leaking of Discord conversations between developers who were overheard making trans and homophobic remarks. This forced 3D Realms into an apology, donating $10,000 of sales to the Trevor Project, as well as going back to the game and removing two lines of dialogue that implied a similar sort of offensive speak. They beared the brunt of criticism from fans and critics on all sides of the debacle.
This undoubtedly cast a black cloud over the release of the game, putting plenty off. However, the revelation that only one of these offensive snippets had been removed by the developers firmly buried Ion Fury's chances of being a mainstream success.
On top of this, the famous rock band Iron Maiden took issue with the game's original name, 'Ion Maiden' and the striking similarities between it and the game 'Iron Maiden: Legacy of the Beast', and filed a lawsuit against the developers.
The lawsuit would cost the company over $2 million and led to the game being given the name it has today.
2. The Blitzchung Controversy - Overwatch
Lauded as one of the best first person shooters ever released when it dropped in 2016, with over ten million players flocking in for the open beta version of the Blizzard title alone, Overwatch was well on its way to establishing a dominant legacy in the FPS world, but suddenly found itself in the middle of a messy political controversy in October 2019.
The controversy kicked off when a professional Hearthstone player known as Blitzchung from Hong Kong was banned by Blizzard for openly supporting the pro-Democracy protests in his homeland at an official event. Overwatch was suddenly pulled into the controversy when gamers began posting memes online using one of the game's heroes, the Chinese native Mei, to voice their sympathy to Blitzchung and their frustration at Blizzard's ruling.
Though Overwatch's director, Jeff Kaplan, did openly express that he thought the ban on Blitzchung should have been taken back, it didn't stop the world from continuing to see the game as a part of Blizzard's repressive set up. AccessNow.org, a human rights advocacy group, urged Blizzard to rethink the ban, but Blizzard's immediate response was to continue censoring events and broadcasts for their games, including the Overwatch League, and shut down the subreddits for all of their properties going forward.
1. Loot Boxes - Star Wars Battlefront 2
Following on from the threadbare disaster that was Star Wars Battlefront in 2015 was certainly no easy task for EA. However, in its sequel, Battlefront 2, they actually came pretty close to really turning their fortunes around.
Released two years after the original in 2017, Battlefront 2 was a game designed with the fans in mind. The prequel era planets and characters were playable, a story and various new modes were introduced and the visuals continued to look absolutely stunning for the time.
However, it also drew in plenty of controversies for its microtransactions and pay-to-win format. The likes of Darth Vader were unplayable without thousands of credits and hours invested, and it soon became clear that the game's rewards weren't going to the best performers in the server.
EA are of course well known for their love of microtransactions in all their games, so their obsession with hoovering up the in-play purchases through loot boxes shouldn't have entirely been a surprise to players. Nevertheless, their response to this criticism was really what killed off any hopes of Battlefront 2 making a success of the franchise.
Their response to one query around the obvious pay-to-win model became the most downvoted comment on Reddit for a time, forcing EA to change strategies and release a plethora of free content in order to try and salvage their reputation when their stock dropped a whopping 2.5% following the controversy. Whilst the game enjoyed a brief revival for a time, there's no denying its potential and image was ruined by being just another EA cash grab.