10 Mistakes Nintendo Got Away With (Because They're Nintendo)

Times when Nintendo played with power and lost.

By Justin Avery Smith /

Nintendo has unquestionably remained one of the most beloved and revered companies in gaming history since the industry's infancy in the 1980s, with the best games and systems one could ask for to this day, and no signs of slowing down any time soon.

Advertisement

However, Nintendo, like any company, isn't perfect and is prone to a misstep or two. They may be great, but they're people just like you and me, and people make mistakes, but the people at Nintendo - unlike the rest of us - have multimillion dollar franchises and quality assurance to fall back on, no matter the blunder, as this list proves.

Whether it be the performance of their titles, an ill conceived piece of equipment, or poor business decisions, Nintendo has that special ability to make decisions that might end any other company, but for them is just minor hiccup in a cornucopia of success.

With this in mind, let us now go through Nintendo's history together and explore the mistakes they somehow got away with (because they're Nintendo).

10. Nintendo 64 DD

Despite what its name might suggest, this isn't a failed foray into lingerie, but actually a CD add on for the N64, with the "DD" standing for "Disk Drive". A magnetic add on that could be attached to your N64 for added power.

Advertisement

On top of the added storage and memory that comes with disks as opposed to cartridges, this was also supposed to let you download games, create movies and animations, and even play games online.

Despite all of these features that surely would have gotten any N64 owner excited, they seemed to have lost heart for it at some point, and basically made true their prediction that it would be a commercial failure.

Nintendo didn't really do themselves any favors when trying to sell it, however. It was only available via mail order, and only in Japan at that. Resulting in only 15,000 of 100,000 available units sold, and its production was canceled a mere 14 months after it was released, condemning it to join the recesses of Nintendo's many other failed extras, but more on that later.

9. Censoring Mortal Kombat

Nintendo has always been considered the most family friendly of the major gaming companies, for better or worse. Whether it's the amount of party games on its consoles, or the purple lunchbox design of the Gamecube, it was certainly for worse when the Mortal Kombat series' controversial, over-the-top violence first reared its decapitated head all the way back in the early 90s.

Advertisement

With such violence not seen in games before, it had many parents and politicians scared out of their wits and calling for the blood and gore to be either toned down, or removed altogether, for both the SNES and SEGA Genesis versions of the game.

Nintendo, not wanting to ruffle any feathers, removed the graphic content as instructed. SEGA also obliged, but in a cleaver bit of sneakiness, made the previously censored content unlockable with a cheat code.

When word of mouth caused this to spread, the Genesis version left the SNES version in the dust, as players flocked towards the copy they knew would let them perform those glorious fatalities in the bloody spirit they were intended.

8. Wii Mini

Had this been released as a prelude to the actual Wii, it could have served as an exciting way to build hype, but alas, that is not the case.

Advertisement

Supply certainly met the demand here, because Nintendo was supplying something nobody was demanding. And the need to know who this was for only amplifies the more is learned about it. A system that was released after the Wii U was already on the market, and with online features now an industry standard by this point, a system like this that does not have internet is just mind boggling. It was also packaged with Mario Kart Wii, which contained online features, so why not just play it on the Wii as intended?

There was also no backwards compatibility, limiting its appeal even further. Did Nintendo just have scrap parts they needed to sell, or something? At this point, that seems like the only logical explanation to justify something so redundant and useless. Honestly, even at its $99 retail price, it still feels like too much.

7. Turning Its Back On Sony

While many probably know about Nintendo's spurring of Sony helped inadvertandly create the Playstation - and by extent titles that would go on to define the console generation like Crash Bandicoot, Tomb Raider and Metal Gear Solid - not many probably know that what they were working on was a disk peripheral for the SNES.

Advertisement

This was to be known as the 'Play Station', before contractual disagreements caused the two companies to part ways and caused Sony to create the 'Playstation'.

While it is kind of sad to think that these two rivals were at one point partners, it is also sad to think of living in a world without Uncharted, Horizon Zero Dawn, or God of War.

Luckily, thanks to the two brands successfully finding identities for themselves and releasing console exclusives distinct enough to co-exist with each other, neither company seems to have suffered any long term effects and both have titles to look forward to to this day, like Breath of the Wild 2 and The Last of Us Part 2, both slated to come out next year in 2020.

6. So Many Peripherals!

Honestly, this entire list could have been taken up by the accessories they have made for their systems, so let's do our best to keep this short and sweet.

Advertisement

The Wii Zapper, the R.O.B, the 3DS circle pad pro, the Wii Fit balance board, Gameboy Camera, N64 voice recognition unit, the super scope, the Gameboy Advance e-card reader AND the Gamecube modem adapter. Each as useless as the last, and there's still probably a few missing from that list.

Each was marketed as new, more exciting and immersive way to play, but alas, they all pretty much ended up being little more than gimicky pieces of plastic that ended up doing the opposite of their intended purpose, or did so little you might as well have been playing with your standard controller.

Each managed to fail in their own entertaining way, whether it be 3Ds circle pad pro's bulkiness, the Wii Fit Board not actually being a fitness tool, or the Super Scope chugging through batteries. Like many things on this list, each is worth your time to research individually if you ever need a good laugh.

5. Virtual Boy

Before there was the Oculus Rift, there was the Virtual Boy. And let's just say there should have just been Oculus Rift.

Advertisement

Nintendo certainly bit off more than they could chew here. Promising players a three dimensional virtual reality gaming experience all the way back in 1995, if your reality was one of monochrome red, then this certainly is the VR experience for you!

While the lack of a color palette already made it a hard sell, it could have been seen as an underrated gem had it not literally made players ill. Not to mention the very few games it had in its library, one of which was "Tetris 3D", and seeing how many people have that on their consoles and smartphones, you can tell how much that caught on. Any fun the players had was negated by their sore eyes, headaches, nausea, and stiff necks.

In fairness to Nintendo however, they have publicly acknowledged, and even poked fun at this misstep, even including it as a cheeky easter egg in Luigi's Mansion 3, and if you can't laugh at yourself, then who can you laugh at?

4. An Adversarial Relationship With YouTube

As one of the oldest gaming companies still going today, it makes sense that Nintendo can sometimes come off as that stubborn grandparent who refuses to change with the times. Online platforms like YouTube give their games a ton of free publicity through creators and streamers sharing Nintendo's games with their audience, but they don't seem to appreciate that.

Advertisement

Nintendo infamously established their 'Creators Program', which allows them to take a cut of the ad revenue content creators make from featuring footage and/or gameplay from their titles. Instead of conceding to this, many creators decided that they simply wouldn't cover Nintendo games.

Nintendo has even struck back at this, such as with Super Smash Bros creator Masahiro Sakurai even saying he didn't want an Adventure Mode in 'Super Smash Bros for 3DS and Wii U'. And all because he knew the cutscenes would be uploaded online, leaving many who enjoyed the stories in Melee and Brawl frustrated and disappointed.

Luckily, Nintendo seems to have wised up, as Super Smash Bros Ultimate released with its "World of Light" Adventure Mode, and many creators have featured Nintendo games without incident.

3. Weaker Technical Performances

If theres one thing that seems to be more true for Nintendo than any other member of the console market, it's inferior technical performances. Many games, even those developed for their own systems, don't necesarilly hold up to other games on the market in terms of graphical detail, technical capabilities, and high frame rate. This is especially true for Nintendo's last two consoles, the Switch and Wii U.

Advertisement

It's very rare, if at all, that you'll see a Nintendo game run at 1080p, 4K, or 60fps, like many AAA games do today.

For example, while many the Switch's launch title "Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild", for all its innovative gameplay, lacked graphical detail and a high frame rate of other open world or console exclusive games like "Horizon Zero Dawn", "Halo" or "Uncharted 4".

And when it comes to the Wii U, anyone who wanted to play a third party game on the system, because they didn't own a PS4 or XBox, was usually stuck with an inferior version of that title. Luckily though, the Switch ports of games like Doom (2016) and L.A. Noire seem to have rectified this somewhat.

2. Philips CD-i

As they say, the bigger they are the harder they fall. After the Sony debacle, Nintendo instead partnered with Philips and brought about what many consider the worst console of all time.

Advertisement

What makes this so much worse isn't that it failed, it's that it seemingly never had a chance to succeed. With the commercial failure of the SEGA CD, Nintendo decided it didn't want a CD peripheral for the SNES, backing Philips into a corner and forcing them to create their own system.

What came from this was a highly questionable console with a retail price of $700, unimaginative controllers, and focus on other media. The titles themselves that were released for the system also served little purpose other than to become fodder for memes in the age of the internet. Just Google "Zelda CD-i" or "Hotel Mario", and sit back while you enjoy hours of cringeworthy laughs.

Luckily, thanks to the stellar new titles on the SNES and the new ground broken with the N64, this horrific mistake was largely forgotten, and we're all the more grateful for it.

1. The Wii U

This truly is a shame to put the Wii U on here because it had the potential to live up to the monumental success of its predecessor, but seem to trip over its own feet at every turn.

Advertisement

So much so in fact, that the Wii U turned in a loss of $49 million.

Nintendo didn't do themselves any favors by having the reveal focus most of their marketing on the gamepad, and making it unclear if this was yet another accessory for the Wii or another console. Meaning that both retailers and gaming websites practically had to spell it out for customers that this was a new console, which is never a good look.

It also lacked third party games essential to the eighth generation, and lets not forget, this is the console that gave us the worst Sonic game of all time Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric, though it did have some killer exclusives like Bayonetta 2, Splatoon and the HD remasters of two beloved Zelda games.

And while the eShop did allow you to play Nintendo classics from its 30 year history on a modern system, it also featured half-baked likes of Meme Run and The Letter, showing a complete lack of quality control.

Thank goodness for the Switch.

Advertisement