10 More Shameless Video Game Rip-Offs (That Were Actually Great)

Palworld is FAR from the first.

By James Egan /

As we've mentioned on a previous list, the success of a video game is destined to spawn a slew of imitators. Doom gave birth to an avalanche of first person shooters. Every fighter owes their existence to Street Fighter. Dark Souls is responsible for popularising a whole new genre of gaming.

Advertisement

Although it's understandable why gaming studios create their own version of a lucrative title, this strategy can backfire. If a platformer, RPG, or a beat 'em up replicates the style and mechanics of a recognised game, it can easily come across as a lazy rehash.

Games like these sound like they're guaranteed to fail, especially when they brashly admit they're a carbon-copy of a well-known IP.

Against the odds, some rip-offs have enough positive qualities to stand on their own. Not only that, there are certain clones that surpassed the very game they were imitating, (which must be a real kick in the teeth for the original creators).

Nobody is going to pretend the entries on this list are bringing anything new to the table. Having said that, it doesn't change the fact they're fun as hell.

10. Simpsons Hit & Run (Grand Theft Auto III)

Since The Simpsons is a titan IP, it's no surprise Matt Groening's cartoon has birthed a myriad of video games. But even when The Simpsons was in its prime, most of the games ranged from okay to terrible. (Seriously, how did they screw up Simpsons Wrestling that badly?)

Advertisement

Although it sounded odd to create a Simpsons title inspired by the hyper-violent Grand Theft Auto franchise, The Simpsons: Hit & Run turned out great.

Like Ubisoft's South Park games, the creators worked directly with The Simpsons' writers to ensure Hit & Run invoked the spirit of the show. The town of Springfield is so vast and detailed, players feel like they're in a Simpsons episode.

Of course, none of this would matter if the gameplay wasn't up to scratch. Though Radical Entertainment bungled the driving mechanics in The Simpsons: Road Rage, they worked out most of the bugs this time around. Although the odd glitch still occurs, it's not enough to ruin the gaming experience. (And if it does, we can always blame Flanders.)

It may not give GTA a run for its money, but Simpsons lovers were more than satisfied by what they got. Thanks to Hit & Run, fans of the iconic tv series can finally say they have a Simpsons game they truly love.

9. Guitar Hero (GuitarFreaks)

Rock Band got a bit of stick upon release for copying Guitar Hero, despite the fact both series were made by the same company.

Advertisement

Also, it's Guitar Hero which should be labelled a rip-off, since it plagiarised Konami's GuitarFreaks, which was released six years earlier. Red Octane and Harmonix didn't just steal the concept, but specific aspects of the game, including the guitar-shaped controller, the coloured plastic buttons, the style points system, and the scrolling fretboard.

However, it's understandable how Guitar Hero blew its predecessor out of the water. Harmonix's rhythm game put more focus on visuals, fine-tuned the mechanics to perfection, and made the core gameplay accessible to the most tone-deaf gamers.

Most importantly, Guitar Hero had songs from the biggest rock bands, giving it a huge amount of brand recognition. With gamers able to play music from Metallica, Nirvana, Queen, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, and many other rock legends in their own living room, it's easy to see why Guitar Hero went on to earn a monumental $2 billion.

Props to Konami for coming up with the idea, but there's no question who did it better.

8. Diddy Kong Racing (Mario Kart)

Mario Kart copycats started cropping up almost immediately after the Italian plumber took to the track. Over the years, companies have churned out their own imitations, including Crash Team Racing, Disney Speedstorm, and a gaggle of Sonic racing titles.

Advertisement

However, one of the best Mario Kart clones also happens to be among the earliest, Diddy Kong Racing. As can be expected from a Rare title, the cutesy racer has creative levels, sharp controls, accessible gameplay, and catchy tunes.

But Diddy Kong Racing is more than a reskin. Rather than just driving karts, Diddy and his friends can take to the skies in planes or zoom through the ocean in hovercrafts. Each vehicle works very differently, giving the gameplay a great sense of diversity.

Rather than collecting randomised items on each race, the power-ups are colour-coded, each offering a specific item. Repeatedly picking up the same power-up upgrades the item, forcing drivers to heavily rely on strategy in each race.

Also, don't let the adorable aesthetic fool you. Diddy Kong Racing is tough as nails, offering a real challenge to anyone.

Although the multiplayer pales compared to Mario Kart, the single-player is phenomenal. Due to the elaborate hub-world, dozens of races, rock-hard boss battles, imaginative challenges, secret levels, and the grand prix mode, it's hard to think of many racing titles that put as much effort in their main campaign as this gem.

7. Streets Of Rage (Final Fight)

At a glance, it's obvious Sega used Capcom's Final Fight as a canvas for their own beat 'em up, Streets of Rage. Not only does SOR have the same look, structure, and enemies, the protagonist's wardrobe is identical to FF's Cody, down to the same blue wristbands!

Advertisement

But since Streets of Rage had more varied attacks, a balanced combat system, and Yuzo Koshiro's head-bopping soundtrack, Sega's brawler was clearly the superior of the two. Also, SOR's heroes can summon a rocket-launching cop to kill all on-screen enemies... how was Final Fight meant to compete with that?

And when Streets of Rage 2 was hailed as one of the best games on the Mega Drive, it wasn't long before Final Fight was perceived as the poor imitation.

Capcom kept pushing, churning out multiple sequels, but sadly, none of these follow-ups made much of an impact. Let's be honest, did you even know Final Fight had sequels until now?

With the success of 2020's Streets of Rage 4, the series has continued to maintain relevancy, even after four decades. Final Fight, on the other hand, has become a forgotten relic of the past.

6. Dino Crisis (Resident Evil)

Can Dino Crisis be classified as a clone of Resident Evil, considering both properties were made by the same company and director? Well, since the Jurassic title is often dubbed "Resident Evil with Dinosaurs," calling it a rip-off is understandable.

Advertisement

Be that as it may, Dino Crisis is anything but a cheap doppelgänger. Rather than dealing with plodding zombies, our red-headed heroine is up against lightning-fast velociraptors and screen-filling T-Rexes, forcing players to constantly think on their feet. Since ammo is incredibly limited, strategy is critical, forcing our heroine to stun or trap the primeval creatures, rather than blasting everything in sight.

Rather than churning out more of the same, Dino Crisis 2 is far more action-oriented, and offers more diverse gameplay, including first-person boss battles and an elaborate underwater section. (Also, shooting overgrown lizards with a tank never gets old.)

The gameplay of the sequel is more dynamic, since points are rewarded for killing enemies in rapid succession. These points can then be used to buy and upgrade gear. (This concept was later implemented into Resident Evil.)

Dino Crisis 3 may be trash, but the first two instalments deserve far more credit than they ever recieved.

5. Prodeus (Doom)

After Doom redefined first-person shooters during the 1990s, many games in the genre were referred to as Doomclones. This is unfair, since plenty of FPSs of that era stood on their own merits, including Quake and Duke Nukem.

Advertisement

With that said, Prodeus is totally a Doom clone. Bounding Box's shooter boasts the same structure, style, pixelated art, enemies and weapons as Doom, to the point where the crowdfunded title feels like a spin-off. Rather than trying to dress itself up as something different, Prodeus never shies away from where it drew its inspiration.

However, Prodeus is an absolute triumph, boasting well-designed levels, addictive gameplay, challenging enemies, and creative trial modes. It also offers an easy-to-use level editor, allowing players to devise their own hellish landscapes from scratch.

As hard as it is to believe, Prodeus is superior to Doom in some ways. While getting lost is a regular problem in id Software's iconic IP, Prodeus solves that issue by programming demons to spawn near the next destination. If the player doesn't know where to go, they can follow the enemies like breadcrumbs to reach their goal. (How come Doom never thought of that?)

Also, the creators should be commended for making the 3D characters resemble 2D to maintain the feel of a retro shooter. Even though it would've been dramatically easier to make the 3D enemies look...well... 3D, the developers stuck to their guns. That's proof Prodeus isn't just an imitation, but a passion project.

4. Metal Slug (Contra)

Metal Slug is a run-and-gun side-scroller where players must blast through a wave of enemies and colossal bosses, using a myriad of creative weapons, explosives, and tank-like vehicles.

Advertisement

Although the developers incorporated elements from their previous work, GunForce and In The Hunt, it's clear Metal Slug stole most of its ideas from Contra. (The sequels threw in aliens just to make the comparison more apparent.)

However, there are enough differences in this bullet-hell shooter to justify its existence. The beautiful hand-drawn animations are stellar, especially the creative death sequences. The three-button control system makes the gameplay accessible to anyone. Although Contra has baddies coming from all angles, it feels tame compared to Metal Slug, with enemies pouring onto the screen every second.

Rather than receiving heavy weapons at random intervals, the heroes are rewarded for rescuing prisoners, putting more focus on strategy. Since powerhouse weapons have limited ammo, this further incentivises players to rescue prisoners, so they can maximise their arsenal.

On top of that, Metal Slug is hilarious. While shooting at mummies, robots, and giant enemy crabs, players are sure to be giggling to themselves due to the tongue-in-cheer humour.

3. Minecraft (Infiniminer)

Minecraft has sold over 300 million copies, making it the most successful video game by a significant margin. So, it's safe to say Mojang's blocky title has done pretty well for itself.

Advertisement

This is all the more impressive, considering Minecraft's premise was mined from another source. In Zach Barth's Infiniminer, players had to travel around a procedurally generated maps to mine for materials.

Despite coming up with the concept, Barth didn't see the project's potential. Though Infiniminer focuses on teams racing against each other to find precious material, players were more interested in building elaborate structures with their findings.

After Swedish programmer, Markus Persson, played Infiniminer, he believed the game would benefit if the building mechanics had more variation. Two years later, he crafted his own version of Infiniminer, which became Minecraft.

Now, there's no question the pixellated sandbox game is derivative. (It was literally built from the same art and code as Barth's work.) However, Persson's cube-oriented title was leagues ahead of the game it spawned from, even in its original state.

With Minecraft boasting more features than ever nowadays, it's clear why it's still going strong after a decade.

2. Saints Row (Grand Theft Auto III)

Don't worry. Saints Row made it onto the list this time.

Advertisement

Comparisons between Grand Theft Auto III and Volition's sandbox title were guaranteed, since Saints Row copied... pretty much everything from Rockstar's biggest IP. Even though the first two instalments received decent reviews, it looked like Saints Row might struggle as a franchise, since it didn't do much to distinguish itself from GTA.

Thankfully, that all changed with Saints Row 3. Hoping to carve out a distinctive identity for itself, the sequel's developers threw in OTT violence, cartoonish gameplay, slapstick humour, and wink-to-the-camera gags. Rather than taking place in a realistic setting, the later instalments had the protagonist becoming president of the United States, journeying into hell, and fighting an alien empire.

It may have started as a shameless rip-off, but Saints Row truly began to thrive when it moved out of GTA's shadow.

Sure, Grand Theft Auto is still the top-dog in the sandbox genre, but does it have a demonic dance number, shark guns, or wrestling legend Rowdy Roddy Piper, reenacting his iconic fight scene from They Live?

I rest my case.

1. Castlevania: Symphony Of The Night (Metroid)

Metroidvania is a sub-genre of platforming games, that centre around non-linear exploration in an interconnected world. Although certain sections are initially inaccessible, they can be unlocked when key items are obtained.

Advertisement

The term "Metroidvania" is an obvious portmanteau of Metroid and Castlevania, despite the fact the two franchises started off drastically different. Save for Castlevania II, the vampire-hunting saga was a pretty formulaic platformer for the first decade.

For Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, Konami decided to focus more on exploration, inspiring them to utilise the same non-linear structure Metroid was renowned for.

However, the developers went above and beyond to insure this PS1 title didn't come across as a mere imitation. Symphony implemented role-playing elements, including experience points, upgradable weapons, and stat boosting. It also put a huge emphasis on elaborate secrets, with the second-half of the game sealed away, unless players figured out how to find it.

Although Symphony was well-received, nobody could grasp how significant this genre-shift would be. Not only did future Castlevania instalments continue with this new style, it unintentionally popularised the Metroidvania genre.

With the benefit of hindsight, Symphony has been lavished with further praise, since it indirectly led to the creation of many great Metroidvanias, including Ori, Bloodstained, Dead Cells, and Hollow Knight.

Even though rip-offs are considered lazy, it's apparent Symphony of the Night did something right, since it fittingly spawned its own legion of rip-offs.

Advertisement