The high points of the Mass Effect trilogy were never about shooting aliens in the face or exploring the galaxy, though those parts were important too. The high points of the series (and indeed, all BioWare titles) have been the difficult choices you have to make throughout your journey. Some choices you make will make you sigh with relief when everything turns out for the better (or as good as it can get anyway). Others leave you with regret. Sometimes there's no right answer, and you end up feeling like a bad person no matter what you do. With entire species hanging in the balance, it's important that you make the right decision. No pressure or anything. It could be said that most if not all of these tough choices are ultimately meaningless, and that may not be too far from the truth. Making hard-hitting choices with a palpable impact on the plot isn't really something most games can do. If every choice resulted in a Butterfly Effect split in the narrative, coding for that game would be a nightmare. The unfortunate reality of game development right now means all of your choices exist in a self-contained bubble, with the main plot remaining largely intact. This means that whilst you can deviate slightly at several point in the plot, you will return to a fixed series of events to arrive at the same conclusion as everyone else, with slightly different flavours at the end. Maybe it was all for nothing. Maybe everything you do is meaningless. Cheer up! Just because the universe doesn't care about the difficult and heartbreaking decisions you had to make doesn't mean they were meaningless to you! Whether or not you're satisfied with how much of an affect your choices had on the story, we can probably all agree that there were certainly some tough choices to make that tugged on our heartstrings a little more than we felt comfortable with. They may not have changed the galaxy, but these decisions can affect you as a player, at least in the moment.
10. Beat Garrus In The Bottle Shooting Competition Or Let Him Win
This one comes in at the very bottom for being the most heartwarming non-choice of them all. It's as if the game is outright asking you "are you a decent human being, or are you literally the worst person in existence?". In this optional bit of bonding time with Garrus, Shepard and his best buddy Garrus decide to have a friendly competition to see who has the best aim. It's a touching moment, and a welcome break from the bleak horror of the Reaper War. Your choice is simple: hit the bottle, or miss and let Garrus win. The right choice is very clear here. Let Garrus win. Just let him have this one thing. He lost his whole mercenary squad, his handsome face, his homeworld, and possibly even the love of his life if you decide to string him along for sweet turian lovin' and break up later. He has nothing but shooting things. His days are spent calibrating guns and shooting sniper rifles at your enemies, can't you at least let him have that? This moment goes from heartwarming to heartbreaking if you decide to win this friendly little contest. It doesn't matter if you're a heartless renegade or a goody two-shoes paragon, there shouldn't be any iteration of Shepard evil enough to take this from him. You have hundreds, if not thousands of kills under your belt. You've already saved the galaxy once, going on twice. You're a legendary galactic hero who will be remembered throughout space and time. Do you really need to win this? Seriously, just let Garrus win. You want morale to be high when the bottles revolt, don't you?
9. Save The Council Or Let Them Die
This is perhaps not the most gut wrenching decision in the series, but still worth noting regardless. The penultimate decision made in the original Mass Effect is still a powerful moment for Shepard. In the climactic final battle between the geth and the Alliance, Shepard is forced to make an order that will decide the fates of the entire council (as well as one of the most powerful ships in the galaxy) and a whole lot of lives. Your dilemma isn't too complicated. You can order the Alliance Fleet to save the Destiny Ascension and the council along with it, or hold back and leave the Citadel Council to die. Important to consider is the sheer size and power of the Ascension, which can be of use to the player in the third game. However, doing so comes at the cost of many human lives. Aboard the Council's ship are a crew of nearly 10,000, whereas the losses sustained when saving the ship include twenty turian cruisers (that's roughly 6,000 crew members) and eight Alliance cruisers. Either way, there's no ideal solution, so you'll just have to make a choice and live with it.
8. Save The Rachni Or Drive Them Extinct
Unable to communicate with their queens, the explorers who originally discovered the rachni deemed them a hostile alien race, sparking a galactic conflict in which the newly discovered insectoid species instinctively spread out to defend their new territory. In order to stop them, the salarians decided to bring up the war-loving krogan to stop their expansion and drive them to extinction, an act that would ironically result in the deployment of the genophage. Now in the year 2183, the fate of the rachni rests in the hands of Commander Shepard. Despite being nearly wiped out in the Rachni Wars, they managed to persist in the form of cryogenically preserved eggs. Finally meeting up with the last queen of their species, Shepard is forced to choose between allowing her to survive and endanger the whole galaxy as a result, or wipe out an entire sentient species. The latter isn't something that should be done lightly, but if they aren't driven extinct here and now, what's to stop them from wiping out the other races of the Milky Way? It's a tough choice, one that shouldn't be taken lightly. Or at least it would, if it mattered in the slightest. Other choices can affect characters and events on a small scale, but even if you decide to exterminate the rachni, they just come back anyway as an enemy type in the third game, undermining a lot of meaning behind this decision. Even though it was shown to be a fruitless decision, it was still one hell of a tough choice, at least for people playing in 2007.
7. Keep The Genophage Data Or Destroy It
Mordin's loyalty mission takes you to a very dark, ethically ambiguous place. Long ago, the krogan engaged in aggressive expansion across the galaxy, and were eventually stopped by the turians and salarians when they unleashed a crippling bioweapon into their homeworld known as the genophage that would allow only one in one thousand births to be successful, with all the rest being stillborn. It goes without saying that this has had profound impact on krogan culture, causing a ripple effect that threatens to drive them to extinction. Is this genocide, or simple pragmatism? Should this kind of genetic engineering be considered an atrocity, or a necessary evil? This is perhaps the most intriguing ethical quandary presented by the Mass Effect trilogy, and one of the most pivotal points of this story arc is Mordin's loyalty mission, in which the player has two options, each with two permutations, allowing you to finally voice your stance on the issue. At the expense of many innocent lives, Mordin's former protégé Maelon has gone off the deep end in his attempt to cure the Genophage, and undo the wrongs of his past. Mordin is caught somewhere in the middle, convinced that the Genophage - something he played a key role in engineering - was the best option. As time wears on, you'll be able to influence Mordin's conscience, and convince him that he did the right thing, or made a mistake. Do you agree with Mordin's cold pragmatism, or do you think Maelon's data should be preserved? Preserving the data could be beneficial to a cure, which could ultimately result in history repeating itself. If you do decide to go that route and deny the krogan a second chance, it means betraying your friends and even losing the people who care you about, but it's for the greater good, right? No matter what you choose, this is the most pivotal part in the Genophage saga. If you destroy the data and later decide the krogan are worth saving, you'll probably regret not coming to that decision sooner.
6. Bring Balak To Justice Or Save His Hostages
The Bring Down the Sky downloadable mission offers a classic moral dilemma for players to consider. Is it more important to stop the bad guys, or save innocent lives? What if stopping a dangerous criminal will save more lives in the long run? Is it worth bringing them to justice if you can't protect the lives of the innocent? This is the final choice the player will have to make in this DLC, and will force players to question their own priorities. After foiling his plot to destroy a nearby colony, Balak, the dangerous leader of a group of batarian terrorists out to repay humanity for their injustices, plays one last trick. In a final-ditch effort to escape, Balak threatens to execute a group of hostages unless you let him escape. Choosing to fight and kill him results in the deaths of several innocent people, putting you into a bit of an awkward position. There's no real way to know which answer is ideal, and it sucks no matter what you do. It's just not fair. Doing the right thing means giving up your chance for sweet retribution against Balak, who has more than earned it. Having a climactic boss battle with the main villain means killing a lot of innocent people, but perhaps that can be justified, if Balak can be stopped. After all, if someone threatens the destruction of a colony once, they'll surely do it again, right? At least, that's what you tell yourself at night.
5. Ensure The Safety Of Your Squad Or Save The Normandy Crew
This is a choice not all players will have to make, but anyone who tests the Collector IFF without being 100% prepared for the suicide mission into the Omega-4 Relay will be forced to make a difficult decision. When Shepard and all of his squadmates leave the ship (all at once, at the same time, because that makes sense), the crippled pilot Joker is left defenceless when the Collectors launch a surprise attack and abduct the Normandy crew. If you haven't done all of the loyalty side missions and fully upgraded the Normandy, members of your squad will die. At this point in the game, the longer you delay charging in and initiating the final mission to save the crew, the more crew members will die. If you aren't fully prepared, you'll have to leave members to a horrifying fate, or rush in to save them, and be prepared to lose some party members. This can be avoided altogether by being fully prepared before using the IFF, but for players unaware of this surprise attack, a harrowing choice awaits them. As contrived as it is, it's one hell of a curve ball that puts you into a tough situation with no happy ending for the Normandy, making it one of the harder choices to make, all without directly telling you that there's a decision to make.
4. Save Ashley Or Kaiden
The choice to save either squad member Ashley Williams or Kaidan Alenko has become one of the most defining moments in the Mass Effect trilogy, and is one of the hardest choices to make. Either way, you lose a party member that has been with you from the beginning, which really stings. In a desperate attempt to stop Saren, Shepard and the STG must infiltrate and destroy his base, and nothing short of a nuke will get the job done. Just as the bomb is planted, geth begin pouring in, cutting Shepard off from his allies. With the bomb counting down to detonation, the player must decide between saving Ashley or Kaiden, resulting in the permanent loss in a party member. The hard part isn't choosing who lives, it's deciding who has to die. Maybe you're romancing Ashley. Perhaps you think Kaiden is cooler. No matter what you do and what your reasons are for doing it, you lose a vital member of your crew, and Shepard's journey doesn't get any easier from there.
3. Cure The Genophage Or Save Mordin
Mass Effect isn't exactly a series full of happy endings, but the finale of the Tuchanka arc in Mass Effect 3 is especially brutal. In the mission's final moments, Shepard can carry out the sabotage and doom the krogan, or allow them to be cured of the genophage. In the latter instance, Mordin Solus, if still alive, will be sacrificed for the greater good to redeem himself after coming to the conclusion that the genophage was a mistake. In the former, the entire krogan race is likely doomed to extinction, but it is possible to save Mordin, if certain conditions are met. I know what you're thinking. The life of one person isn't worth sacrificing an entire species, right? Well, that might be true, if that person wasn't one of the most badass side characters in video game history. Mordin is so cool, players are willing to commit genocide just for the chance to save him. Of course, genocide is really bad and stuff, so that makes it an almost even trade. How far are you willing to go to save your favourite character? Will you allow Mordin to heroically sacrifice himself, or betray the krogan people to keep him alive? Either way, it's not a decision to be made lightly. If you can't convince Mordin however, you should definitely not shoot him. Doing so means having to watch one of the most brutal and gut-wrenching scenes in any video game ever, designed to make you feel as horrible as possible. You bastard.
2. Destroy The Geth Or Allow The Quarians To Die
Once again, Shepard is forced to bring yet another race to extinction. If specific conditions haven't been met, you may be unable to make peace between the geth and the quarians, forcing you to choose which race survives and which is eradicated. If you're attached to Tali and Legion, you're not gonna like this one. If the weight of bringing an entire people to annihilation wasn't bad enough, you have to deal with the consequences of losing a current or former member of your squad right in front of you. This is a much harder choice to make than choosing between saving Ashley or Kaiden, because in this scenario, you're choosing which of your friends to betray. If you destroy the geth, Legion will attempt to kill you before being put down by Tali. If you eradicate the quarians, Tali will commit suicide to join her entire species in complete annihilation after Legion sacrifices himself. Guess you should have invested in more alignment points.
1. Decide Which Horrible Ending To Watch
Mass Effect isn't just a series short on happy endings; it's short on good endings as well. An entire trilogy's worth of world building and decision making all leads up to this moment in which you get to decide which colour-coded anticlimax ends it all! Here you won't be deciding which option is the best, but rather which is the least garbage. You could pick the ending that arbitrarily destroys all synthetic life, whatever the hell that means. Alternatively, you could always try the ending where you suddenly die to become Skynet and control the Reapers in what totally won't result in an oppressive dictatorship. Or, if you're feeling crazy, you could magically merge "synthetic" and "organics", two types of loosely-defined living things that are somehow altered on the genetic level by this super weapon you spent the whole game building despite knowing nothing about it. Then there's a fourth option added by the DLC where the story doesn't end, and just stops. Then they tell you that everyone died. There's simply no way around it: having to choose the ending that sucks the least is a difficult way to end Shepard's story. Nearly every line, word and character feels completely irrelevant not only to the rest of the series, but also to the other parts of the ending itself. The entire sequence is bizarre, out of place, full of poor logic, and is poorly written in general. Choosing which out-of-nowhere ending to finish out on is easily the hardest decision you'll have to make in the trilogy. It's as if the writer(s) sucker punched you with a scene from a different game and expected you to just roll with it. Without the Extended Cut, there are dark implications that nearly everyone dies no matter what you do, due to the lack of any exposition whatsoever. With it, you're stuck with a very tepid ending that nothing short of a full re-release could fix. It's dire, heart wrenching, and easily the hardest choice you have to make as Commander Shepard. Then again, maybe the hardest, most heartbreaking choice of all is choosing to finish a series that wasted its potential. What was the hardest choice you had to make in the Mass Effect trilogy? Let us know in the comment section below!