10 Most WTF Video Game Reboots

Radically altering a classic game series isn't always a bad idea... but it usually is.

By Christian Higley /

Ever since game and movie companies struck a chord rebooting old franchises, the gold rush was on.

Advertisement

Soon every major entertainment medium realized they could wring every drop out of their old properties, either through the nostalgia felt by existing fans or targeting a whole new generation.

Occasionally, reboots are allowed to become more than cynical cash-grabs. A good reboot can breathe new life into something dead or dying, take a chance to truly challenge its audience, or modernize old ideas for today's youth.

However, that usually is not the case, and quality reboots of beloved media are few. But even worse than the Quick Payday Reboot is the WTF, But Why Reboot: the reboot that come so far out of left field that they may as well have just been a new property.

Here are ten such reboots. Good, bad or even unreleased, these hot, spicy takes on old games can't help but beg the question, "What were you guys on when you thought of THAT?"

10. Prey (2017)

Prey has a storied history. The original game, released in 2006, spent about a decade in one form of development or another. It was well on its way to becoming the next Duke Nukem Forever, another game made by then-publisher 3D Realms that spent over a decade in development limbo only to finally release as one of the worst games ever made.

Advertisement

Prey focused on protagonist Domasi "Tommy" Tawodi, a young Cherokee man who has to save his girlfriend from aliens. Outside of a few novel features, it was a completely straight-forward shooter. Guy with gun shoots aliens - you know: video games!

A very promising sequel also spent a fair amount of time in development hell, before being purchased from 3D Realms by current publisher Bethesda, and promptly canceled.

That brings us to Prey (2017) - a first-person shooter/RPG/survival horror hybrid that sees protagonist Morgan Yu creeping his way through a human-made space station, confronting or avoiding the phantom-like alien Typhon. There's emphasis on player choice, various forms of upgrade currency, crafting, skills trees, and survival elements more common among modern-day Rogue-Lites.

To TLDR it for you: It's basically System Shock 3.

So what ties it back to the original Prey? Well... there are guns and aliens, and... um... space, I guess. But that's about all the two have in common. Them and almost every other video game.

9. XCOM (2010)

X-COM was a beloved sci-fi strategy game series made for the PC during the '90s. Infamous for its difficulty, it was, in fact, later (and faithfully) rebooted as XCOM: Enemy Unknown in 2012, to much praise from fans of the original.

Advertisement

However, during that XCOM-less gap in time, we almost got a very, very different return to the classic franchise, in the form of - you guessed it: XCOM. Only this time it was an FPS set in early 1960s American Suburbia, made by some of the developers of BioShock.

We only got to glimpse it through trailers at E3 2010 and 2011 prior to its cancellation, but it appeared to involve a gameplay loop of detecting, fighting and capturing aliens disguised as innocent-looking suburbanites. Presumably, it would have expanded from there, but we'll never know, as the game vanished from the public eye before Enemy Unknown was announced just a short time later.

The game technically did see a release in 2013 as The Bureau: XCOM Declassified, a tactical, third-person shooter (also set in the '60s) that served as a more faithful origin story for the alien-fighting organization. But this new spin-off seemed to share little in common with the FPS version outside of the setting.

8. Star Fox Adventures

If you asked anyone in 2002 what the next Star Fox game would look like, and they told you it would be about Fox fighting dinosaurs with a stick while looking for magical stones, you would have slapped them all the way downtown.

Advertisement

And then you would have done the same to yourself when they turned out to be right.

To be fair, Star Fox Adventures never hurt for fans. It received mostly positive reviews at the time and GameCube owners embraced its Ocarina-Of-Time style, as it echoed the classic game in progression, level design and combat.

But even its biggest supporters can't help but wonder, "Why?" How does an on-rails shoot-em-up become a reskinned Zelda game? Well, there's an answer for that.

Dinosaur Planet, originally intended as a Nintendo 64 game, had been languishing in development for quite a while. With the GameCube out and now competing with the Playstation 2 and Xbox, an original IP about cartoon dinosaurs on a system with a reputation for being "kiddy" probably didn't seem like the best idea.

As it so happened, the Star Fox series had also been left on the back burner for several years. So leave it to visionary developer Shigeru Miyamoto to suggest to developers Rare that they make it a Star Fox game, thus building upon a preexisting fan base that had been itching for more Star Fox for five years.

7. Bomberman: Act Zero

One of the most infamous and baffling video game reboots ever, Bomberman: Act Zero took the tiny, adorable mascot character and transformed him into an edgy, grimdark Iron Man with a giant hand.

Advertisement

To be fair, he does resemble the American cover art for the original NES game, but this was 2006. We had been laughing at those ridiculous western NES game covers, that in no way resembled the game they were advertising, for over a decade.

I mean, look at this guy. What even is he? A guy in a suit? A robot? A cyborg? Well, I have good news: there's lore!

It turns out all answers are correct. Because the bomberpeople (yes, there are also bomberwomen) are "Artificial Human Weapons," created underground and pitted against each other in a battle to bomb their way to the surface and be the last bomberperson standing. Why? Who cares.

Sure, that's about all the story you need for an online-only multiplayer game (oh, did I forget to mention that this re-imagining of one of the original couch multiplayer games was online-only?). But, again - and I can't stress this any more without pulling a muscle - we're talking li'l cutie-pie Bomberman being re-imagined as the monstrosity you see above.

What?

6. Syndicate (2012)

Syndicate was a 1993 RPG/strategy game that was truly unlike anything released before or since.

Advertisement

In a world run by mega corporations, the player controlled a small team of agents enforcing the interests of their parent company. Missions took place on open maps that involved a variety of objectives, from assassination, extraction, recruitment, riot suppression and more. The player progressed through the game by claiming new territory and managing funds to pay for upgrades. The series vanished after an expansion pack and one sequel.

That is, until 2012, when Syndicate finally made its glorious return!

As a linear, story-based, first-person shooter.

Syndicate (2012) wasn't a bad game by any means. Developed by Starbreeze, it was actually an excellent shooter, packed with style. But other than guys in black coats killing each other in the the future, it didn't share anything with the original Syndicate that it doesn't also share with every other piece of Cyberpunk.

The multiplayer did skew a tiny bit closer to the original formula, as four players had to work cooperatively together to achieve certain objectives. But that was still a very far cry from what fans wanted.

For all this had to do with the original game, they could have made just about anything and slapped the name Syndicate on it.

5. Mega Man Legends

Mega Man Legends is a widely beloved spin-off of the classic Mega Man franchise. But even its biggest fans can't help but wonder how a side-scrolling 2D platformer/shooter became an exploration-based, third-person, 3D adventure, RPG-ish, sort of free-roaming... thing.

Advertisement

Taking place in the far, far, really far future of the Mega Man world, Legends follows MegaMan Volnutt (yes, first name "MegaMan"), who travels around the world with his adoptive sister and grandpa, and their pet robot monkey. This is all real.

They fly around in an airship, excavating ancient robot ruins, hoping to eventually strike it rich. Along the way, they are continuously hounded by the pirate Bonne family and their army of Lego men. This is the real, actual story of these games.

So yeah - just a bit of a departure from the classic series, which is basically a super difficult version of rock, paper, scissors.

4. Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

Thank God for Resident Evil 7: Biohazard, a drastic reboot that actually saved and reinvigorated the dying series.

Advertisement

By the time RE7 came around, the series had gone completely off the rails. As every sequel upped the stakes from the previous game, it was almost inevitable that the series went from careful resource management and puzzle-solving to, by RE6, uppercutting monsters with super karate.

Resident Evil had been so extreme for so long that, just because of its first-person perspective, RE7 seemed like a much more drastic reboot than it actually was. After all, it once again saw a desperate, lone protagonist struggling to survive and solving more puzzles than fighting enemies.

On top of that, it was actually as scary as all the marketing claimed the original was.

3. DmC: Devil May Cry

If you're reading this article at all, then chances are, you were probably not a fan of DmC: Devil May Cry.

Advertisement

While DmC was developed by proven action game developer Ninja Theory, and lived up to their reputation in terms of high-quality action gaming, fans considered every other aspect of the game a betrayal, largely due to the extremely western take on the Japanese property.

Dante went from a cool, white-haired anime action hero to Morrissey by way of Twilight. Instead of a deeply mythology-based lore, the series took on a tone of social commentary, the evils of demons and such representing the ills of modern western consumerism and pop culture. There was even a Fox News level.

Fortunately, fans can breathe a deep sigh of relief as the series has since returned to its roots, even throwing out the concept of a reboot entirely and continuing the original story.

2. SSX

We should honestly be grateful for the SSX (2012) reboot. Yes, it completely failed to capture the joy of SSX: Tricky, and it wasn't even that good on its own merit, but it was a lot better than what we almost got.

Advertisement

Originally unveiled as SSX: Dark Descents, EA showcased just how hilariously out of touch they were with their audience by nearly releasing a dark and grim take on the classic snowboarding series known for its over-the-top jubilance

Thankfully, EA did backpedal on that one to deliver a game more in line with the SSX tone. In the end, the game featured a more nuanced, but rewarding, take on the controls, as well as an excellent soundtrack that remixed itself based on your tricks.

Too bad the game was gimmicky as hell. Aside from the wingsuits - which were really fun for speeding over cliffs and obstacles - the game also introduced extremely high-altitude levels where you would freeze to death if you didn't spend enough time in direct sunlight, or suffocate if you didn't collect enough oxygen.

What was once a joyful snowboarding game became an exercise in micromanagement, where we had to choose between awesome tricks and resource management.

Why?

1. Fallout 3

Fallout fans had no idea what to expect when Bethesda dropped their Fallout 3 gameplay trailer all the way back in 2008. The beloved, turn-based, isometric RPG was now a shooter? Some people were not happy, to say the least.

Advertisement

It didn't help that the trailer itself focused almost exclusively on real-time action and cinematic kills, showcasing all the bullets, blood and explosions and none of the classic RPG mechanics that the final game would, in fact, keep mostly intact. Worst of all, the trailer spent all of one second showing off VATS, the brilliant system Bethesda implemented to replace turn-based combat but maintain the tactical elements of the older games.

It was a relief that the final product turned out be a fairly faithful implementation of the original systems into a 3D world. Combined with the skill for world-building Bethesda had already honed over several games, it set a whole new template for many RPGs to come. Once the initial shock wore off, fans realized how much more rewarding it was to explore the Fallout world up close.

It's too bad those same fans had to witness all their worst fears come true in Fallout 4.

Advertisement