10 Overhyped Video Game Storylines That Actually Went Nowhere

Don't fall the hype! There's nothing to see here, folks!

By Michael Fincher /

Hype can be a dangerous trap that video game fans fall into. Usually, the term is associated with game announcements and trailers that build up unreal expectations only to disappoint, but also, weirdly, overhyping things can happen long after a marketing cycle has wound down - it can happen in-game.

Advertisement

There are plenty of stories in games that the writers build up to hint at something grander, only for all of it to go nowhere.

An intriguing character arc, a major plot twist, or a revelation that could potentially alter the course of a title's history may all appear like they're going to lead to an amazing development in the game's story. In reality, though, only some of these plotlines get resolved, while the others are either dropped or simply forgotten.

Worst of all, these types of setups usually build up a lot of expectations within the playerbase, which, by the end of things, is left with nothing but regret and frustration.

Finding out a story element you were really excited about was just a fluke can be a huge disappointment, so if you want to avoid being let down by your favorite game's writers, make sure not to get your hopes up about the following storylines.

10. rA9 - Detroit: Become Human

Detroit: Become Human poses a lot of interesting questions about the nature of AI and our relationship with technology that are ultimately resolved in a somewhat underwhelming fashion. However, if there is one plot point that has left the players especially disappointed for its complete and utter lack of resolution, it's probably the teased RA9 plotline.

Advertisement

RA9 is the teased "god" of the deviant androids who is consistently referenced throughout many points in the game. The story makes it seem as though rA9 could serve as a point of discussion about androids' relation to spirituality or some intriguing plot twist that will play an important role in the final act of the game, but once the deviant revolution starts, rA9 is pushed aside and completely forgotten.

At one point, Detroit even teases that the deviant god could actually be a virus created by CyberLife to make their androids gain sentience, but this is never brought up again, and the only thing you're left with is a basic story with predictable endings and a ton of questions that will never be answered.

It seems the greatest mystery was why we even bothered to care about rA9 at all...

9. Stretch's Villain Arc - Grand Theft Auto V

One of the more questionable things about Grand Theft Auto V's story is its lack of a proper villain. Aside from the choice Devin Weston throws at you right at the end of the game, there isn't really any antagonistic force that looms over the three protagonists throughout the story, despite the fact the writers seem to have tried to hype up several of them, most noticeably Stretch.

Advertisement

When you first meet Stretch, it becomes pretty obvious that he's meant to be an antagonist in Franklin's story. He sets him and Lamar up during a meeting with the Ballas, and from then on, the game makes it seem like he is going to bring even more trouble into Franklin's life, becoming a more prominent villain in the future.

However, aside from one mission where Lamar is kidnapped, this doesn't really seem to be the case, and Stretch becomes easily forgettable among the more pressing matters like the heists and the feud between Michael and Trevor.

His role as a villain doesn't really go anywhere, which is why even though the game makes you kill him in the Deathwish ending, most people don't even remember (or care to remember) who he is.

8. Lady Shiva's Brief Cameo - Batman: Arkham City

While the recent release of Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League brought plenty of controversial developments to the Arkhamverse, the Batman: Arkham series has suffered quite a bit of damage to its storyline.

Advertisement

This said, unsatisfying conclusions have been a part of the franchise for much longer than Batman's underwhelming death on a park bench, and this is best evidenced by one of the most lacklustre uses of a villain in the series - Lady Shiva's brief appearance in Arkham Origins.

Despite being an incredibly skilled, intelligent, and dangerous foe that the series even hints was partially responsible for the events of Arkham City, Lady Shiva leaves next to no impact during her time on screen.

The game builds her up to be a force to be reckoned with, but after a short and unremarkable fight, she simply disappears, never making another cameo and ending things on a pretty anticlimactic note.

Fans have long suspected that much of her side quest - like several other features in Arkham Origins, including the open world's train - was cut before the game's release. In any case, while the prospect of an Origins sequel would've cushioned this disappointment, with Warner Bros. Games Montréal having moved on to Gotham Knights and a currently untitled DC project, it seems unlikely Shiva's Arkham storyline will receive closure anytime soon.

7. Ethan's Blackouts - Heavy Rain

In true David Cage fashion, Heavy Rain is more about shocking plot twists than consistency in the story. The best example of that is the conclusion to Ethan's, one of the main characters, blackouts that has infuriated the players ever since the game came out.

Advertisement

Throughout the story, Ethan suffers from random blackouts that cause him to lose consciousness and awake somewhere else with no memory of how he got there.

The blackouts are deliberately placed throughout the game in a way that would suggest Ethan is the Origami Killer responsible for the kidnapping of his son Shaun.

The setup seems like an exciting twist that will explore Ethan's psyche and ultimately showcase how he transforms from a struggling father into a disturbed killer.

However, David Cage must've thought the twist became too obvious because, at the last minute, he pulled a switcheroo and revealed a different character to be a killer, not only making the blackouts lose all purpose but also creating inconsistencies in the overall storyline, placing characters in the wrong places at the wrong time, and making it impossible for the actual Origami Killer to do the things he's supposedly responsible for in the game.

Disappointing and plot-breaking! Just how we like it!

6. Zero's Origin - Mega Man X

Zero, the cool rival-turned-protagonist, is arguably one of the most beloved characters within the Mega Man series, perhaps even more so than its eponymous hero.

Advertisement

And yet, despite his overwhelming popularity among the fans, the series' creators seem to have completely forgotten about a peculiar bit of his background that they have hyped up for no reason.

In Mega Man X, the story heavily hints that Zero might be the creation of the villainous Dr. Wily. These hints have led many fans to speculate on what Zero's nature might be as well as his potential role within the series, perhaps as a secret villain or a way to reintroduce Dr. Wily back into the story and reveal he's still alive, which is what Zero's origin seemed to be implying.

Ultimately, none of the fans' expectations were met, as in reality the X series simply moves on from the setup and uses it only a couple of times to establish the dynamic between Zero and the antagonist Bass.

The references are a wasted opportunity that doesn't really deliver on any of the amazing concepts it teases to come.

5. Diego's Potential - Far Cry 6

As is typically the case with Far Cry games, the most memorable thing about Far Cry 6 is its villain, Anton Castillo, the iron-fisted dictator of Yara.

Advertisement

However, as much as Giancarlo Esposito dominates every scene he's in, there is another aspect of the game that could've elevated its story beyond the usual Far Cry formula, had it not been completely nipped in the bud—the fate of Anton's son, Diego.

Diego plays an integral part in the story, being an heir to Anton's seat of power who slowly grows to sympathize with the Yaran revolutionaries.

You spend a lot of time watching as Anton and the main character, Dani, try to sway Diego towards their personal plans for Yara's future, and the game builds up the expectation that this back-and-forth will culminate with Diego becoming the new leader of his father's country and either change it for the better or become another cruel dictator.

However, in the end, neither version of the story comes to fruition, as Diego is simply killed off in the game's finale, and you just have to sit there and wonder why you even bothered investing your time and attention into his story arc.

4. Ares' Soul - God Of War

The God of War series has undergone a lot of changes between Kratos' crusade in Greece and his subsequent journey up north.

Advertisement

Due to this shift, the series has dropped several plot points in favour of developing a new storyline, and this includes one of the most hyped-up mysteries in the series.

Kratos' throne room in God of War 1 features an easter egg where the player can discover a secret phone number that, when called, reveals that the Spartan keeps Ares' souls within the chamber that, for some reason, is visible only to him.

At the time of the game's release, this revelation was the cause of a huge wave of speculation among the fans, who wondered if the mention of Ares' soul could mean the return of the Greek gods or maybe even their transformation into their Roman counterparts.

Unfortunately, this potential storyline was never picked up on in future instalments again, and with the two new titles separating themselves from the Greek pantheon entirely, it seems all the speculating fans will never see a resolution to their theories.

Well, it seems Kratos didn't lie when he said only he could see Ares' soul...

3. Harkon's Prophecy - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

As much as Dawnguard's main storyline is one of the most solid bits of storytelling in Skyrim, there is one part of it that irks anyone who's played the DLC—the underwhelming resolution to the prophecy that pretty much sets the whole Dawnguard story in motion.

Advertisement

The story of Dawnguard follows the Dragonborn as they try to put a stop to the vampire lord Harkon's plan of fulfilling the prophecy that will let him blot out the sun and usher in a new age of vampires.

The game hypes up this event as something truly catastrophic that would bring harm to both mortals and vampires alike, causing the destruction of life on the one hand and mass attacks on the undead on the other.

Both are genuine reasons to consider Harkon a madman, but the thing is, after you kill him, you can still block out the sun yourself by shooting at it with blood-cursed arrows, and let's just say the result doesn't live up to the hype.

Although the NPCs will act slightly concerned about the sun's disappearance, there are no worldwide raids on vampire lairs and everyone is still very much alive, which makes you question what the point of stopping the prophecy in the first place actually was.

2. Desmond's Death - Assassin's Creed 3

It is a universally agreed-upon fact among Assassin's Creed fans that the series' modern-day storyline just sort of sucks. The Desmond sections aren't very action-packed, and compared to the vibrant, historical settings inside the Animus, it's not much to look at either.

Advertisement

Still, after years of development and teasing some kind of twist throughout several instalments, you'd think Desmond's story would ultimately deliver on its hype and present a conclusion that would make it all worth it, right?

Well, no.

Desmond's artefact-hunting and fight with the Templars ends in the most anticlimactic way in Assassin's Creed 3, with the protagonist's rather unsatisfying death and a botched cliffhanger that never gets resolved afterwards.

Desmond releases Juno, a member of the oppressive First Civilization, to save the planet, the villain kills him shortly after, and then his sacrifice is swept under the rug, as Ubisoft forgets about Juno entirely and kills her off-screen in a comic.

The hyped-up moral choice Desmond makes and the years of setting up the lore of the ancient overlords of humanity never reach a proper conclusion, making it seem like we really could've just skipped the modern narrative of Assassin's Creed games entirely.

What was the point, Ubisoft?

1. Karlach's Soul Coins - Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3 has a ton of things for you to explore, but with a great variety of features comes a great variety of cut content, such as the so-called Soul Coins that, despite remaining in the game, offer far less functionality than the game hypes up for you.

Advertisement

When you first come into the possession of a Soul Coin, your infernal companion Karlach will make a huge deal out of them, claiming that they can make her stronger but that this power comes at a cost. At this point, it seems like the game puts an interesting dilemma before you, letting you choose between strength and your friend's safety. However, the payoff is anything but either of these choices.

For all the commotion around them, all the Soul Coins do is give Karlach an additional 1d4 fire damage to her attacks, and aside from a couple of new dialogue lines, there seems to be no consequence to using them whatsoever.

This disappointing outcome is likely the result of the Soul Coins being a part of a larger storyline that was scrapped in the final release of the game, but it does beg the question of why Lariat decided to keep them in any way.

Advertisement