10 Perfectly Crafted Video Games That Never Need Sequels

Some stories are best left alone, regardless of the millions that could be made.

By Matthew Fisher /

Some games are simply built with multiple entries in mind, whether it's the yearly onslaught of Call of Duty and Assassin's Creed titles or games that are tied to the creative vision of their director over a period of several years. Over-saturation is a real problem in the video game industry, as the countless recycling of old properties on a yearly basis only serves to diminish the quality over time. Indeed, the first game in the Thief series is a moody, calculating experience that seems to be slowly diluted with each subsequent release. The creative fire seems to fizzle out with each new game in a successful series, running the severe risk of franchise burn out. It is infinitely better to give the first game a satisfying conclusion than continue to warp the ideals of the series over time. To that end, there are certain games that produced a title that was so contained within itself and executed in such a precise manner, that a sequel often seems like a cash grab. Be honest with yourself, is a sequel to The Last of Us really necessary? And do you really want to see another game set in the Heavy Rain universe? These are games that told such a complete, satisfying story, that another entry seems completely pointless and mundane. So hit that next button, and let's take a look at ten games that we hope never get a number two next to their name.

10. The Swapper

In so many ways, The Swapper is a flawless experience. Combining the mind-bending puzzle trappings of Portal with a Moon-esque sci-fi story, The Swapper puts you in control of an astronaut that is armed with a cloning device used in the solving of puzzles. The puzzles are insane, often leaving you staring at the screen in utter confusion for what seems like ages as you push your brain to the limit. What is perhaps even more mind-blowing about The Swapper is watching your little clones die off as you sacrifice them for the sake of victory, which is only the start of the meta journey it takes you on. To perform the feats achieved in The Swapper a second time around wouldn't just be difficult; it would be impossible. It's a glorious, albeit short, experience that could never be topped by a sequel. It stands on its own as a premiere example of the indie game scene, where ideas and free thought are more important than familiar IPs and multi-million dollar budgets. There's no reason at all to start working on The Swapper 2, as the freshness would be eliminated and replaced with something that would only be compared to what we've already seen.

9. Alan Wake

While you probably identify Finnish developers Remedy Entertainment with Max Payne, they also produced a quirky little Twin Peaks-influenced survival horror game known as Alan Wake in 2010. It was supremely entertaining, filled with all the usual self-awareness and pop culture oddities that Remedy is famous for, but it was still fresh enough that it was able to distance itself from their usual beat on the streets of New York City. The use of light and shadows to convey combat was expertly done, and the sense of mystery that the game presented gave it some distinct personality. Alan Wake is a massively entertaining game to play from start to finish, presented in a fun TV series-style format and a deeply lovable cast of characters that all have secrets of their own. The open-ended nature of the conclusion was trademark Remedy, yet the very nature of an Alan Wake sequel just doesn't ring authentic in any way. Alan's story isn't one you want to drag out, as it's such a bizarre concept to begin with, that stretching it out over another game might leave us with a bad taste in our mouth. There was a piece of DLC released in 2012 known as Alan Wake's American Nightmare, but the less said about that, the better.

8. Ikaruga

Ikaruga is a frighteningly addictive game, but it's also a game that will drive you completely insane with its punishing difficulty and make you beg for mercy. As a very clear tribute to the 80's space shooters, Ikaruga excels on every level of game design imaginable. It's infamous for its difficulty, but it also isn't completely unfair in the way it dissects you with incredible precision to leave you a puddle on the floor. If you're a member of the Dark Souls crowd, you'll find yourself right at home in this brutal world of high-stakes action. Perhaps the reason why Ikaruga 2 hasn't been made is that gamers are still trying to get over ripping their hair out; a preemptive measure to preserve the blood pressure of the gaming industry. In all fairness, an Ikaruga sequel wouldn't be the worst thing to happen to the world, but the first game is presented with such unflinching pride, that a sequel would undoubtedly be lacking that same devil may care attitude. These days, it's all about the mass audience and how developers can hook the mainstream gamer, so it's likely that Ikaruga 2 would be extremely watered down. No thanks.

7. Another World

It's a good sign when a game that is nearly 24 years old can get a Steam re-release and still be as captivating as it once was, bypassing the fear that it may not hold up. Another World not only holds up, but is perhaps even better than it was all those years ago. It's a stirring adventure game, wrapped up in a distinct world of fantasy creatures and environments, showcasing some absolutely gorgeous animation. Another World is a game that stands so well on its own merits, that doing another one would simply be unnecessary. It's one of the very few games in this world that tells a complete, compacted story that doesn't even open itself up for multiple entries. As it stands, Another World sits you down to tell you a compelling story that will leave you breathless. It's more likely that Another World 2 will just tell you a story that makes you want your money back.

6. NBA Jam

Whether you are a fan of the sport of basketball or not, it's hard to deny the simple charm of NBA Jam. It's addicting, "one more game" kept gamers up for countless bouts of insomnia and it took precise skill to master. As challenging as NBA Jam was to master, it didn't matter, because playing it is such a joyous experience. The movement from one side of the court to the other feels exciting and fast-paced, matched with the desire to pull off the craziest dunks imaginable. While there was an attempt to bring NBA Jam into the modern day with an upgrade to the graphics and dunks, it lacked the simplicity of the original game and could never be identified as a true "sequel". It speaks to the raw fun of the original, as fancy new graphics wasn't what NBA Jam was ever about. It was about pure, unfiltered fun, and you'll never find a more complete package than the original NBA Jam. Leave this one be, developers.

5. Gone Home

The ongoing debate about what constitutes a "game" will likely never have a clear decision, and titles like Gone Home will be the contributing pieces of evidence as we go forward. Whatever prerequisites you believe a title needs to be considered a game, there can be no denying that Gone Home is one of the most touching and wonderful experiences of this generation. The entire experience plays out with such ominous dread, it seems to plant the dark seed of an obvious conclusion in your head from the very beginning. Taking that trip through the house is a deeply complex and eye-opening experience, as the mounting fear is presented in the background as a constant hum, egging you on to turn that next corner in fear of seeing the worst. It's such a captivating and personal time that you spend with it, that a sequel would ultimately distance you from the message that it presented about letting go of things we love. It's all about letting go, all about choosing your own destiny, that Gone Home 2 would come off more like a straight-to-DVD sequel of a blockbuster movie than a true sequel. And who needs more of those?

4. Heavy Rain

As another heavy contender in the concept of what truly makes something a video game, Heavy Rain was incredibly divisive among critics and fans. Whether you were in love with its characters and story or just considered it a crummy interactive movie, it's hard to deny that Heavy Rain has been one of the biggest examples moving forward of games becoming more than just run and shoot affairs. It tackled serious subject matter, coming off like a Hollywood blockbuster movie that you had control over. It also played with the concept of player immortality, as a main character death meant the game simply continued on without them and its narrative has been hotly debated in the years since its 2010 release. But no matter how you slice it, Heavy Rain 2 is simply a bad idea, as it would ultimately accomplish nothing for any of these characters. Depending on the ending you got, all of these characters had a very contained story to be told over a single game and revisiting this world is only a disservice to them. Thankfully, Quantic Dreams founder David Cage has sworn off a sequel, which means you can leave all your memories of Norman Jayden in peace.

3. Dear Esther

It's interesting to play Dear Esther and reach the end, only to realize that you literally did nothing but walk around an island for an hour. Even so, you come away from it with a lot of very interesting questions and ideas. It's an odd, unusual trip into a collage of narrative themes and story fragments, never allowing you to get a completely clear picture of what you just experienced. It's hard to pin down a concrete story, but everything that the developers don't tell you is exactly what makes it so charming to begin with. Dear Esther is not one for commitment, as it plays around fast and loose with the idea of who exactly Esther is and what she means to this whole thing. The ambiguity is what makes Dear Esther such a pivotal experience, so to decide that a sequel is the time to reveal the answers to all the riddles is a pretty bad idea. There's so many questions that you have coming out of Dear Esther, that even attempting to make a sequel to answer them is just asking for trouble. Doing it would undo every moment the player had in Dear Esther, so it's probably best to just leave all those questions where they belong; inside the mind of the player.

2. Shadow Of The Colossus

Shadow of the Colossus practically defined the sixth-generation of consoles, an incredible open-world experience that put you up against gigantic titans known as Colossi and tasked you with taking them down. It had tremendous scale, and watching your little guy ride on the back of one of these behemoths was truly thrilling. It also showcased that games can be more than just shooting up marauding space aliens, but rather an emotional journey of self-discovery and love. It speaks to the inner core of every gamer who plays it, asking them to leave their own world behind in order to completely embrace the fantasy within. To suddenly decide that gamers need to return to the Forbidden Lands would go against the clarity of the original game, which presented itself in such a finite manner, a return trip to fight again wouldn't exactly be the best idea in the world.

1. The Last Of Us

As Naughty Dog begins working with Hollywood big wigs to bring The Last of Us to the big screen, talk about a sequel to their 2013 apocalypse opus seems to be gaining some steam. But while that may be fine for the folks at Sony and Naughty Dog who want to be even richer, the idea of revisiting the world of Joel and Ellie is a bit distressing. The Last of Us went out of its way to tell a story that was set in the midst of the apocalypse, but was rarely about the monsters that inhabited the world. Instead, it was a character driven masterpiece that drove home all of the Naughty Dog game design principles; rich storytelling, believable characters and polished game play. So few games put as much care or attention to detail in their worlds as The Last of Us, creating refined characters that took you on a harrowing journey of survival and the struggles of raising a child in a brutal world. The Last of Us 2 is the most unnecessary sequel of all time, as Joel and Ellie had a complete character journey that ended with the clear implications of what is waiting for them. Though they exist beside each other now in a father/daughter relationship, there are obvious struggles ahead for them. The Last of Us told a purely perfect story over the course of its single-player campaign, so rehashing the characters for a sequel doesn't really accomplish much. But now it's up to you. What game was so perfect, that it simply doesn't need another entry? Sound off in the comments and let us know what game you never want to see a sequel for.