10 Rejected Video Game Ideas Literally EVERYONE Would've Loved

A Metroidvania Dark Souls game sounds AMAZING.

By Psy White /

Creating a video game tends to be a damn long process.

Advertisement

Before a game finds its way into the hands, or hard drives, of consumers it goes through stages upon stages of development. Before that even, it is merely an idea in the minds of the core team. Watching documentaries on our favourite games allows us to watch a game go from concept art to something truly brilliant.

But what about the games that don't make it to that final moment of glory? What about the rejects?

For every pitch that gets approved and, after the long process of development, becomes a finished video game there are no doubts dozens more than don't make it. Every idea for a game has it's own life. Some are merely just a thought, some get test builds, some even get approval before they eventually die off for whatever reason.

This list will look at video games that were either picked up and then dropped or outright shunned from the off-set that, despite everything, have sparks of greatness in them.

10. Zwei (Resident Evil Creator's Cancelled Horror)

When Resident Evil creator Shinji Mikami announced his return to the world of horror in 2012 alongside some concept artwork of a dark and unsettling locale there was a collective rubbing together of hands within the games industry. The Godfather of survival horror was back and promising big things with his upcoming title, at the time codenamed “Zwei”.

Advertisement

The product this became was The Evil Within which, whilst a perfectly adequate game, was quite unremarkable. Mikami, in later years, regretted that he went back to his roots too much rather than pushed the game into new avenues of terror.

Especially because the original designs for Zwei may well have just done that. The name, German for “2”, refers to the fact the story would’ve been led by a man and a woman chained together, attempting to survive some no doubt horrible situation in their pursuit of hunting down a vampire.

Who out there can say that doesn’t sound awesome?

In general, vampires are somewhat weirdly under-represented in the horror space of video games thanks to their often kitsch and over-the-top presentation in media (be that the high collars of Dracula or the sparkling of Edward Cullen). Better yet, this would’ve pre-dated the success of co-operative focused titles like A Way Out and It Takes Two.

By walking the road more travelled, Mikami sadly left behind a exceptionally exciting idea.

9. Gotham By Gaslight

1989’s Gotham by Gaslight is important in comic books because it’s considered to be the first ‘elseworlds’ story in the DC Universe. It’s also awesome because it sees Batman clashing with Jack the Ripper. Set in Gotham City in 1889, it gives the Caped Crusader an his dark world and even more gothic twist.

Advertisement

This beautiful nugget of an idea was deliciously turned into a video game pitch around 2009 by developers Day 1 Studios. A very short amount of test footage of this exists which gives a good idea of the dark, foggy aesthetic that the title would’ve produced. For a game nowhere near finished, it looks incredible and the mind begins to fill with the promise of seeing steampunk Batman gadgetry.

Sadly, this pitch never got the green light from Warner Bros Entertainment. There could be any number of reasons why. Most likely that Warner didn’t want two different competing Batman video games and preferred to focus on the guaranteed success of an Arkham Asylum sequel. Sadly, this meant blowing out the candle on Gotham by Gaslight.

At the very least, Batman’s 1889 look got a DLC costume in Arkham Origins but… it’s just not the same.

8. Maverick Hunter

It’s hard to imagine that at one point, Mega Man was a gaming icon. He was essentially the mascot for developers Capcom. Now, he’s a hazy nostalgic memory.

Advertisement

In 2010, six months after the release of Mega Man 10, creator Keiji Inafune announced he was leaving the company to, in his words, “start his life over”. Capcom, in a panic, cancelled the four Mega Man titles that were in development. Unlike Mega Man 9 and 10, these weren’t just nostalgic 8-bit platformers. One of these was a new game in the Legend series and one, most bizarrely, was a gritty first-person reboot.

That phrasing might well make your stomach turn but consider that Maverick Hunter was being worked on by Armature Studio, whose founding staff had worked on Metroid Prime 3 and it suddenly makes a lot of sense. Furthermore, to design X’s new suit the company somehow tapped Adi Granov, the man who had recently redesigned Iron Man for the big screen.

Early footage of the game exists and is a teasing glimpse into what might’ve been before the project was shut down after just six months of work. Maverick Hunter would’ve definitely been a risky release but anything is better than the nothing the series has had in the last 12 years.

7. Prince Of Persia Redemption

Sometimes, in order to internally pitch a title to publishers, a studio will develop a pre-rendered cinematic as an approximation of what the gameplay would look like. Typically, these stay private. Sometimes, us adoring fans get a look at what was being proposed.

Advertisement

In 2020, a YouTube video that was originally uploaded in 2012 - presumably for part of a presentation - was unearthed, that showed a new entry for the Prince of Persia series entitled Redemption.

Former Ubisoft Montreal employee Jonathan Cooper confirmed that it was legitimate. He also estimated that the reason the pitch never got any further was that Jordan Mechner, the Prince’s creator, still held licensing rights and that Ubisoft tended to make less money on the franchise due to his fees.

Redemption itself is high energy and features classic Prince staples like parkour, wall-running and time manipulation. It also has an intense combat system that looks a lot like Arkham Asylum, which isn't surprising considering the impact that game had on single player brawler experiences.

Prince of Persia fans would’ve taken any drop of water in the desert that the abandoned franchise became for the last decade but, more than that, Redemption looks truly thrilling. We can only wonder what could’ve been.

6. Donkey Kong Racing

During their time working under Nintendo, Rare produced a lot of classic titles across both the Super Nintendo and the N64. During the holiday season of 1997, they followed their success with the Donkey Kong brand by releasing Diddy Kong Racing.

Advertisement

Whilst the title did eventually get a DS remake, it was (at one point) meant to have an out-and-out sequel.

At E3 2001, Nintendo revealed that Rare were working on Donkey Kong Racing for the Nintendo GameCube. Instead of karts, boats and planes, DK and friends would go for something far more true to the series and instead ride wild animals like rhinos, swordfish and wasps. These could be “upgraded” by collecting food on the track and even swapped out mid-race for something else.

However, Donkey Kong Racing was a victim of Rare’s buyout in 2002. When the company agreed to be bought by Microsoft, they did so under the pretence of finishing Star Fox Adventures before moving to the black and green side. As a result, Donkey Kong Racing was rebranded into original IP Sabreman Stampede before, eventually, being cancelled.

And what became of Donkey Kong’s hopes to race? Well, he did get Barrel Blast for the Wii in 2007 which might well be the lowest point in the ape’s adventures.

5. Dark Souls III Metroidvania

Aside from being one of the most popular franchises in gaming today, Dark Souls has firmly left its mark on the industry as many franchises take influence from it or craft their own “Souls-like”.

Advertisement

In November 2022, artist Thomas Feitchmeir revealed a single screenshot that got the mouths of many gamers salivating. It was an image created for a direct pitch to Dark Souls IP holders Bandai Namco for 2D pixel art Metroidvania adaptation of Dark Souls III.

Feitchmeir is no stranger to the genre having worked on the excellent Blasphemous which released in 2019 and would’ve gone into development likely after this pitch was sadly shot down.

Which is a shame because it would’ve been a nice full circle for the inspirational FromSoftware franchise which has clearly had an impact on games like Dead Cells and Hollow Knight. More than that, Dark Souls is quite a self contained series which certainly has room for experimentation and spin-offs.

That may well be why Bandai Namco turned the idea down, to perhaps protect the purity of the brand.

Whilst it’s nice that other games have nestled into the space that this adaptation could’ve fit, it’s a no brainer that Dark Souls officially entering the Metroidvania realm could’ve been huge; transforming the genre most often associated with indie developers into a more seriously taken prospect.

4. Scalebound

In a sense, Scalebound was Platinum Games’ dream title. They had attempted to pitch it to publishers in two different years before settling on other IPs like Bayonetta and The Wonderful 101 before, finally, Microsoft snatched up the concept.

Advertisement

Platinum and Microsoft was certainly a unique and surprising collaboration.

As such, it allowed the studio to try to get out of their comfort zone. Scalebound was to have more emphasis on roleplaying elements, a first for the developers, as opposed to straight forward action. Players would receive experience for caring for their draconic friend as well as exterminating enemies as they explored the game’s beautiful environments.

Early looks at the game were exciting and the partnership between man and dragon was definitely something that captivated gamers. Decades of killing the flying lizards, now we could partner with and control one? It was almost too much.

In January 2016, the game’s end of year release window was pushed back as the team struggled to implement features like co-operative multiplayer. Then, eventually, the game was cancelled.

Scalebound is a shining example of a tantalising project that, like a rampaging dragon, became too big for its creators to get a handle on.

3. Heroes Of Hyrule

Despite being a franchise that has run for 35 years, The Legend of Zelda has rarely strayed away from Link in the starring role. Sure, it’s been many different versions of the green tunic wearing hero but, aside from Tingle’s Rosey Rupeeland, Zelda has rarely experimented with spin-offs in the same way that other long running franchises have.

Advertisement

However, there have certainly been attempts.

In 2022, DidYouKnowGaming revealed behind the scenes stories from Retro Studios employees and documentation about a pitch they made to Nintendo in 2004 about their desires to work on the Zelda series. The game’s leading character was a young boy reading a book about the defeat of Ganon and the player would play through the story in a Final Fantasy Tactics style tactical RPG.

With new Goron, Zora and Rito characters warring against the forces of evil, it would’ve allowed for new insights and stories set in the world of Hyrule as well as, clearly, a major departure gameplay-wise.

In recent years, until Breath of the Wild, Zelda suffered with the constraints of sticking too hard to its adventure formula. It’s hard not to think that something like this would’ve been a welcome change for fans and, considering Retro’s quality back catalogue, would’ve been a smash hit.

Alas, this storybook stayed shut.

2. Resident Evil 3.5

It might be hard to believe considering how universally beloved it seems to be but many long-serving survival horror fans were unhappy with aspects of Resident Evil 4 when it launched. Its gameplay and tone were a far cry from series norm and the story infamously killed off corporate antagonist Umbrella in the opening cutscene.

Advertisement

Furthermore, early looks at the game - dubbed Resident Evil 3.5 or “the Hookman build” - were closer to the franchise’s previous entries. Combining fixed and dynamic camera angles, it appeared to present a slower game with a focus on supernatural spookiness.

The trailers tell the story of a virus infected Leon searching through the castle of Umbrella founder Ozwell Spencer to find a cure as well as the origins of the t-Virus. He would be haunted by a mysterious black fog as well as what appears to be the hallucinations of a ghost wrapped in chains, brandishing meat hooks.

Now, whether or not one would prefer this over the actual finished product we got is a whole other debate but, if we can just be greedy for a second, why not both? Leon could’ve had his haunted foray into Spencer’s domain and perhaps Capcom should’ve sent an underloved character like Billy Coen from Resi Zero to Europe to do all the backflips and quips since he seems much more aligned to the character type.

Either way, as much as you might love Resident Evil 4, it’s hard to deny the intriguing pull of this ghostly prototype.

1. Star Wars 1313

The Star Wars franchise has been adapted into many great video games but few have been quite as eye-catching as one particular cancelled project.

Advertisement

Star Wars 1313 would see players take control of the badass bounty hunter Boba Fett as he explored the underworld of Coruscent’s Level 1313. Created in partnership with Industrial Light and Magic and with direct involvement from George Lucas, it was not just an exciting new narrative story for Star Wars but an exciting new single player experience period.

The game’s first trailer and gameplay tease were the topic of much delight in the Star Wars fandom… and then the source of much heartbreak.

In 2013, Disney’s acquisition of the franchise put 1313 on indefinite hiatus. Soon after, LucasArts as a developer was essentially gutted of employees - pretty much spelling out the end for the title in its infancy.

Aside from the likes of the microtransaction disaster Battlefront II, it seemed Disney was not all that bothered by Star Wars video games. Whilst the last five years has seen a resurgence with Jedi: Fallen Order and a few ports, 1313’s fate was sealed long ago.

New gameplay footage from the era actually found its way online this year, just to tease fans further, that this is a story that met a sad end a long time ago (in a galaxy far, far away).

Advertisement