Video games, like other works produced to entertain the masses, aren't perfect; we as gamers know this. We know that there will be tiny hiccups in game mechanics, a plot point here or there that just doesn't fit, and/or pointless missions we must do just because it fills in the story (escort missions are particularly frustrating). But we put up with it - and I suppose "putting up with" is the wrong phrase: deep down we enjoy these little foibles of gaming because most of the time the other aspects of the game make up for it. Thus, what could be looked at as a "mistake" or "screw up" by the developers becomes nothing more than a little quirk they're known for. But not all the time. Sometimes games just suck, in every way possible - from game mechanics, to storyline, to pointless missions, to one dimensional characters - and the worst part is that sometimes these games make a cr*pton of money (Note: cr*pton is a precise term). Somehow these games sell, and sell a lot. The following list is just that: horrible games that somehow churned out millions of dollars. Prepare to be baffled.
10. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (NES)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles for the NES falls under the "Action" genre, which amazes us because we thought falling into sewers over and over again constituted "Things We Can't Believe We Bought" genre. It was a good idea, NES, as Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles couldn't have been more popular at the beginning of 1990, but you had us fooled. We were expecting a great game and what we got was sloppy controls and game mechanics - especially for the computer: you literally couldn't get past one level; you had to use cheat codes to skip it. It wasn't like Battletoads. Battletoads was difficult, but the mechanics were okay and the levels, though not probable to beat on the first time (or second or thousandth), could actually be beaten. Battletoads was awesome. Go Battletoads. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was so damn frustrating at times you wanted to set your Nintendo on fire and punch your Donatello action figure in the face. How many copies did Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles sell? Brace yourselves... Over four million. And though most critics found it too difficult and most fans found it to be one of the most frustrating NES games of all time, it still made millions for Nintendo. You have to hand it to Nintendo: they capitalised on a rising cartoon/comic knowing no matter what they thew together, it would make a whole bunch of money for them.
9. Pac-Man (Atari 2600)
It was 1982, Pac-man was the greatest thing since sliced bread and Betty White. For the arcade, it was a king, so it was only logical that Atari would want to bring the game onto a home-port system where joys could be had and food to be gobbled. The thing was, Tod Frye, the game's programmer, was given a limited amount of time to complete the game; coupled with this were the major differences between the Arcade version and the Atari console - hardware, mainly, and the amount of available memory to run the game efficiently. The result? Frye had to condense the shape of the maze and used less complex patterns, sprites were animated in a different pattern, and the ghosts would create a flickering effect when they were on screen that would last longer than their actual frames. In short, shoddy gameplay. The critics slammed it and so did the fans, comparing the arcade version of the game to it's drunk, washed-up brother on the Atari 2600. It wasn't Frye's fault, really: he did the best he could with the time he had - even Frank Ballouz, the marketing manager at the time, informed the CEO of Atari that gamers would not be pleased with this version of the game. Still, Atari went on ahead and released it. It sold over 7 million copies and it is, and will forever be, the best-selling video game for the Atari 2600. It was the anticipation of it all. This was the biggest game of the 1980s and to be able to play Pac-man at home was a dream come true for most kids - of course parents were going to shell out the money. Still, you have to wonder what Atari thought of its fans to just be willing to put this game out there when the CEO was informed it was cr*p...
8. Tomorrow Never Dies
A mediocre movie followed by a less than mediocre game. Could we blame them? I mean after the genius that was Goldeneye for the N64, publishers and developers could have released any Bond game and it would have made money. Why did everyone hate it? It was everything Goldeneye wasn't. And I suppose we can't blame the creators for that, because it's hard to follow in the footsteps of the greatest multiplayer shooter ever. Tomorrow Never Dies changed from first-person shooter to third-person, had no multiplayer mode at all, had a short story/mission mode, and at times had awkward gameplay mechanics. Still, it ended up being in the top 5 best selling video games of 1999. It could have been that the departure from everything that was Goldeneye was necessary, and that Tomorrow Never Dies creators were saying, "Hey, we know Goldeneye was amazing, but we can't replicate it. We will try and do something different." They did, but there were too many changes. No multiplayer mode was one thing, as gamers were still throwing proximity mines in Goldeneye, but to switch it to third-person and shorten the storyline turned this game into a disaster.
7. Thief
When Thief: The Dark Project came out, gamers were loving it. There was stealth, a cool medieval steampunk city to crawl around in, and challenged the first-person shooter market with its emphasis on evasion and not confrontation - light and sound were your enemies, not mountains of bullets. It was the first 3D stealth game for the PC and influenced such games as Splinter Cell and the Hitman series. The game was brilliant because it made your experience stealthing around terrifying, and more importantly, real; it was the first time the idea of NPCs became suspicious about noise or a flicker of light - Metal Gear Solid and Half-life were also forerunners in these categories. In short, Thief: The Dark Project was an amazing game that inspired and innovated every facet of the gaming community. That being said, Thief for the PS4/Xbox One isn't the same. Many fans are disappointed at the return of the series to be such a downer. With new engines and mechanics, we expected something more than what we got. Though graphics are, of course, phenomenal, as well as the stealth play and level designs, the story is sub-par, the city layout is confusing, and the change is voice actors portray Garret not the way we'd hoped. But despite all this, the game is currently at the top of the charts in sales and continues to rake in the money.
6. Max Payne 3
Max Payne 3 could have been a good game - if it wasn't continuing Max's story, that is. Max Payne 3, developed by Rockstar, produced stunning visuals, seamless mechanics, and a beautiful environment that detailed every aspect of Sao Paulo to perfection. It got the "Bullet Time" right and it even incorporated some new editions to the Max Payne mechanics that were innovative and enjoyable - multiplayer and duel weapons. But it failed on story. Anyone who is a Max Payne fan knows that. Max Payne is the definition of noir storytelling in video games. That means we get dark dialogue that pokes fun at itself - cliche and cheesy to the point that we know that's what the writer is going for. That means we get snow, New York, goons with hilarious banter, Dick Justice, Lords and Ladies, and an intriguing story that's plausible. We didn't get that. And none of Max's past events were ever detailed in full to the gamer in Max Payne 3. It is never revealed what happened to Mona Sax, and why it make sense for Max to leave New York at all. Fans aren't asking to recreate Max Payne 1 or 2, but they were asking to stay true to the Max Payne character - and they didn't. Sam Lake didn't write Max Payne 3 and that should tell gamers something. Regardless, Rockstar sold over four million copies of the game. They got their money's worth.
5. Just Dance
Does anyone even remember the first Just Dance video game? The video game series has gone on to sell millions and millions of copies but if you can recall first in the series, you may scream in horror at the memories it conjures. As of December 2010, Just Dance (the first one) sold 4.3 million copies. Think about that for a moment. It was a brilliant idea to begin with - having players mimic dancing movements from a silhouette dance on screen to tunes that we can all get jumping too - but on its first run it didn't hold up to the hype. First, there were no unlockable features on the game; there were no new additional songs, no new dancers. You couldn't even progress that much: you had the specific list of songs and the one dancer, and that was it. Second, and worse than the first, were the gameplay mechanics and the scoring system. Critics slammed it for its ridiculous arbitrary scoring system and a horrible way of detecting player movements. And even worse than that was, you had to dance to Who Let the Dogs Out and Womanizer. However, the game was the fastest selling third party game for the Wii ever. The creators capitalised on this and continued to make more Just Dance games with more horrible songs, but with upgraded mechanics and unlockable features.
4. Final Fantasy 13
Final Fantasy 13 was a departure from previous Final Fantasy games. The developers did a wonderful job on creating a unique storyline, an innovative magic system (still can't get over the paradigm shifts) that made battles challenging, and an even more unique world in which these constructs were set in. However, for a Final Fantasy game, it fell short. The game was too linear. You couldn't roam towns they way you normally would. You couldn't interact with NPCs on a whim and ask them about their day. Worse, they never let the player think for him/herself. Due to the linearity of the game, puzzles and figuring out which paths to take and what party members to take with you, were, frankly, predetermined. You went from one point to the next, to the next. The point at which the gamer reached Gran Pulse almost made up for it, almost. It isn't a terrible game, just like Max Payne isn't a terrible game in and of itself, but it is terrible in the context of the franchise. Toriyama head creator of FF13 stated that these criticisms of the game came from a Western world point of view and that "becomes very difficult to tell a compelling story when you're given that much freedom." Perhaps, but that doesn't explain great games like FF6 and FF7, where the players can do all those things and the story is still gripping and plausible. So how much money did this one game make? Let's put it this way: within the first day it sold one million units in Japan. That's not including North America. As of January 2013, supposedly 6.6 million copies were sold worldwide.
3. Pokemon Snap
First, we understand that this is a children's game, created for children, but we can't help think it was created by children. Pokemon Snap is one of those concepts you say to yourself, "How is this even marketable?" But it was (and is). Pokemon Snap puts the gamer through a series of levels where he or she has to snap the best pictures of the Pokemon within that level; for instance, there is the Volcano level where you mainly find fire-based Pokemon; there you take pictures of Charmander (seen depicted above). The game is short and it is a great diversion from regular Pokemon games that we were used to. Some liked it, others found it annoying. But it's so rudimentary. Despite the mechanics of Pokemon Snap being somewhat interesting, taking picture after picture of Pokemon becomes boring to even the most enthused Pokemon fanatics. Simple game. Simple levels. Yes, it's for children, but so was Pokemon Red and Blue - and the rest of the Pokemon franchise. So how much did it sell? By the end of 1999 (over 10 years ago), Pokemon Snap was the sixth best-selling video game in the U.S., selling around 1.5 million copies.
2. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)
Produced in commemoration of 15th anniversary of Sonic, this game was rushed. It was supposed to revive Sonic as a character so the younger generation could identify with, love, and enjoy the inconic blue hedgehog. Released for the PS3 and Xbox 360, Sonic The Hedgehog followed Sonic as he attempts to rescue Princess Elise after Dr. Eggman captures her. In the game you play as several primary and secondary characters such as Sonic, Silver, and Shadow. It sounds good on the surface, but the game got mostly negative reviews. There were long loading times, a messed up camera system, glitch after annoying glitch, a horrible plot, and no sense of direction whatsoever. It was just a downright horrible game. So how did it compare? It sold 400,000 copies in North America. That's not much, you say? Well, that was enough to get it re-released, which caused it to reach platinum level status.
1. E.T. The Extra Terrestrial
Oh Atari. You always seem to outdo yourself in the worst way possible. We knew this had to be number one; on every list that includes "video game + worst" you will find this game. So how can this game, one of the primary reasons Atari eventually fell into a financial disaster, have been a commercial success? We don't have the answer, but it did. Initially, the game sold 1.5 million units, which, relatively speaking, meets the criteria of "successful." However, production costs were high, so were buying the rights to the game, and in addition to all this, they had a surplus of copies that weren't getting bought. It was the 3 to 4 million that were returned or not bought that buried Atari, not the actual copies sold. E.T. The Extra Terrestrial goes down as one of the highest-selling video games for the Atari system. The irony. Like Sonic the Hedgehog (2006), it was a mess of plot, gameplay, and visuals. And who could forget the joyous memories of falling down hole after hole after hole. The sad realization? This game could have been somewhat decent if given the time. They forced production, skipped audience testing, and did not predict sales correctly. If given the time, E.T. The Extra Terrestrial could have saved Atari, not killed it.