Star Wars has a prestigious pedigree of cultural influence that most franchises never see, and despite being tarnished somewhat by the prequel films, love for the series is still as strong as ever. In terms of its footprint within popular culture it is the king of science fiction/fantasy, to the point where it is near heresy to criticise it... well, at least the original trilogy, anyway. And yet, while Mass Effect may be a relative newcomer to the sci-fi genre, it more than holds its own against the competition, including Star Wars. The writers and artists at Bioware have taken classic elements of the genre to create a compelling work all their own. It may be a video game, but Mass Effect can easily be considered one of the best science fiction universes around. In fact, it could be argued that it is better than Star Wars in a lot of ways. Is it blasphemy to say this? Perhaps, but thanks to advancements in technology and the advantage of its medium, many of Mass Effect's accomplishments within the realm of science fiction outshine what the Star Wars films have done. Both series are great and have their own strengths and weaknesses, and in some areas Mass Effect is just better. If Star Wars helped lay the groundwork for contemporary sci-fi, than Mass Effect evolved it to new heights. It should be noted that it would be all too easy to get bogged down in the extended fiction of both franchises. So for the sake of simplicity only the core three games of Mass Effect and the six Star Wars films will be compared. With that disclaimer out of the way, these are some of the things Mass Effect does better than Star Wars.
10. Space Magic
One of the more blatant similarities between Mass Effect and Star Wars is that both have their own form of space magic. Star Wars of course has the Force, a mysterious power that flows through all living beings and can be used for good or evil. Mass Effects equivalent to this is biotics, in which certain people are able to create mass effect fields through the manipulation of element zero. Both are pretty far out there concepts, but where Star Wars faults is in its explanation. Everyone knows the whole midi-chlorian explanation in The Phantom Menace and how it ruined the magic of the Force for many fans. Mass Effects biotics at least has a solid explanation behind it through the incorporation of technology integral to the function of its world, so the explanation didnt come out of nowhere like midi-chlorians did. Biotic powers also offer a more diverse set of abilities than the Force does. Sure, the Force has lightning and mind control, but biotic powers allow one to create singularities, augment their strength and speed, or rip their enemy apart at a molecular level. The fact that they are based on compelling and believable science fiction concepts only makes them more fascinating. Basically, while the Force is more mystical and fantastical, biotics are rooted in science, at least as explained in the world of Mass Effect. And science is always cooler than mysticism.
9. Romance
Lets be honest here, neither Mass Effect nor Star Wars would win any awards for best love story, but when it comes to romance, the Mass Effect series maintains a more consistent quality throughout than the six Star Wars films. Both Star Wars trilogies have one love story at their centre. The original trilogy had Han and Leia, and it felt believable. Who can forget Hans classic response to Leias confession of love for him? The prequel trilogy had the tragic romance between Anakin and Padme and it still remains one of the most awkward and uncomfortable romances ever put on film. Its debatable whether any of the romantic relationships in Mass Effect come close to Han and Leias, but at least the series never veered into the utterly unwatchable. Regardless of which character the player romantically pursues, all of them have at least some emotional hook. Garrus is hilariously awkward. Thane is fueled with inner turmoil. Jack is really a scared little girl. And so on and so forth. All of the characters in Mass Effect have quirks and issues that form the basis for which the romance blossoms. Depending on the characters involved, they can be sweet, sexy, tragic, or funny. At their worst they are incredibly bland (see Jacob or Kaidan) but none of them ever feel like two people being forced into a relationship because the writer insists they do against their will. And as evident by the emphasis that so many fans place on these romantic plots, it's obvious that they connect with players. So while the love stories in Mass Effect can admittedly be a bit melodramatic and cheesy, the fans can't get enough of them, something that can't be said about Star Wars.
8. Technology
A major difference between Star Wars and Mass Effect is they way in which they incorporate their technology into the narrative. For Star Wars, faster than light spaceships, lightsabers, and droids are simply a means to an end. The details of how they work are deemphasized and unimportant in relation to the story. The intricacies of the Millennium Falcon dont matter; its how it functions within the narrative. This has always been what separates it from its nerdier counterpart Star Trek. Mass Effect, on the other hand, strikes a perfect balance in the way it integrates techno-babble with the story. It doesnt risk alienating casual fans like Star Trek does while still giving hardcore fans plenty of details to chew on. Advanced technology like drive cores and mass effect fields are explained sufficiently within the core narrative, and if you want to know more the options are there in the Codex and dialogue wheels. All this is to say that the technology in the Mass Effect series is more fleshed out than what is presented in the Star Wars films. While it has the same operative effect, the choice to understand how it works is always there. Its part of what makes Mass Effect such a great sci-fi series regardless of medium. It incorporates the science and the fiction perfectly so that, no matter what kind of fan you are, there is something to enjoy.
7. A Sense Of History
The Star Wars universe has a very rich history, but you wouldn't know it from the film series. The films simply don't have time to delve too deep into the history of its civilizations and cultures beyond the recent events they depict. If you want to learn more about events that happened long ago, you have to consult the extended fiction, which is a shame because there is lot of rich backstory to explore in this franchise. Hopefully the new spin-off films will rectify this. This is not the case with Mass Effect. Because the core of the story is about the conflicts and motivations of the various alien species, you learn about the history of their societies. You learn about the tragedy of the Krogans, the ascension of the Asari, and the exiling of the Quarians by their own creations. And through interacting with members of these societies you get so see how their experiences shape their cultures, beliefs, and behaviors. It all comes together to make every alien civilization, every planet, and every location feel rich and believable. Even the history of the galaxy itself is explored, reinforcing the fact that we are small and insignificant in the grand scheme of things. There is so much to learn about the galaxy in the Mass Effect series that you'd think that the plot might get drowned out amidst it all but it never does. Everything has a story, and Mass Effect never lets you forget that.
6. Politics
Politics plays an important role in both episodes I-III of the Star Wars films and the Mass Effect trilogy. The difference, however, is that while the politics in the Star Wars prequels were dull, with many fans arguing that it took away from the fun, it is integral to the enjoyment of the Mass Effect series. The Star Wars prequels failed in getting audiences emotionally involved with the political dealings of the galaxy. Sure, there were trade negotiations and senate meetings, all of which ultimately led to civil war, but it was all presented in a cold and detached style that inspired little interest from audiences. This is where Mass Effect has the advantage. There is a ton of political turmoil going on between various alien species, none of which you would care much about if it werent for the alien characters you grow close too. By having Shepard develop relationships with characters like Wrex and Tali, they become the face of an entire species. You fight for Krogan freedom from the genophage because Wrex does. You fight for peace between the Quarians and the Geth because Tali does. Most importantly, the political plots arent separated from their moral ramifications. What is politics if not a debate about what we feel is the right or wrong thing to do? Mass Effect never forgets this, and it explores this through high stakes drama and action. This makes the political machinations within the galaxy incredibly personal, something which the Star Wars prequels, with their dry political dialogues, failed to do.
5. Artificial Intelligence
Artificial intelligence is a large aspect of the Star Wars universe. Droids, including major characters like C3PO and R2-D2, are used as tools to fulfill various functions throughout the galaxy, despite how obviously intelligent they are. And yet, the greater implications of this fact have never been explored. In fact, it's kind of disturbing that characters like C3PO are thrown around and treated like objects even though it is obvious that they are able to feel emotions . It is a fascinating concept that the series never dives into. In contrast, the dynamic between artificial intelligence and organic life is inherent to the core story of Mass Effect, and so is explored in depth. From the very beginning of the first game all the way until the final minutes of the third, the question of whether artificially created beings like the Geth and EDI can be considered alive is presented in differing and fascinating situations. Even better is how it challenges our inherent distrust towards them. Star Wars isnt interested in exploring these issues; its representation of artificial life is simplistic, and thats fine. Star Wars is, after all, more about adventure and fun. But Mass Effect does explore these issues, and does it well, while still retaining a sense of adventure and fun. Its one of the games greatest strengths.
4. Villains
Star Wars has had the advantage of time, and with time Darth Vader has become one of the most iconic villains in film history. He began the first trilogy as the antagonist, but by the end of Return of the Jedi he is revealed to be a more complex character. But with the exception of Darth Vader, the cast of antagonists in the Star Wars movies are simple and one-dimensional. Emperor Palpatine and his Galactic Empire are pure evil in both intentions and design, while Jabba the Hut is vile and disgusting. Darth Maul and Count Dooku are barely given anything to work with, and the Trade Federation is portrayed as incompetent goofs. Compare this to the villains of Mass Effect, all of which are complex and incapable of being reduced to pure evil. Saren, the antagonist whom you chase throughout the entirety of the first game, turns out to be a tragic character who has lost himself while trying to save the galaxy. Even more complex is the Illusive Man, a man with the noble intention of advancing mankind but is willing to sell his soul to do it. The Reapers, who are thought of as genocidal machine gods to their victims, are actually trying to save the galaxy from itself, despite how illogical their reasoning may seem. Even the smaller scale villains, like the obtuse Udina or seductive Morinth, have understandable reasons for doing what they do. In its attempt to resist reducing people to simplistic representations of good or evil, the Mass Effect series ended up creating a great roster of villains for the player to go up against. Star Wars may have Darth Vader, but one classic villain cant compare to the consistent quality of Mass Effects multifaceted villainy.
3. Moral Complexity
Star Wars has always been about the classic battle between good vs. evil. It is very effectively told in the original trilogy, and that is one of the reasons those movies connected with so many people. However, it is also very simplistic. There is very little nuance on either side. The good guys are wholly good, and the bad guys are wholly bad. There are some exceptions, but for the most part there is no question of who you are supposed to be rooting for in the Star Wars movies. Of course the real world isnt so easily reduced to such black and white standards of morality, and this is where the Mass Effect series is leaps and bounds ahead of Star Wars. In your Shepards quest to unite the various civilizations of the galaxy, you are forced to involve yourself within their conflicts, and in doing so discover that every one of them is more complicated than you thought. There is no thoroughly good or evil enemy, and every side has its reasons for doing what they do. The series also brilliantly challenges your preconceived notions at every turn. The best example of this is the Geth, a race of synthetics you are led to believe are bent on destroying all organic life, until you eventually learn that the majority of them just want to be left alone. Even the main villains, the Reapers, arent as purely evil as you thought they were. So while Star Wars is great at creating a gripping story of light against dark, Mass Effects more nuanced look at conflict is more emotionally satisfying because it forces you to confront complex and potentially uncomfortable issues head on in a fascinating and compelling fictional universe.
2. Aliens
Both Star Wars and Mass Effect are populated with all kinds of unique aliens, but Mass Effect has the distinct advantage of actually treating its various alien species as real characters. Despite being set in a galaxy far, far away, Star Wars is a mostly human affair, as most of the main characters across all six films are humans. Aliens are usually relegated to the background. Any aliens that are major characters, like Chewbacca and the insufferable Jar Jar Binks, are either side kicks or comic relief. In contrast, the majority of the cast of Mass Effect are aliens, and they are all given the same level of depth of character as any human. They are not defined by their species, but by their role in the story and their relationships with other characters. Garrus isnt just the Turian, he has personal beliefs, goals, and character flaws that go beyond that. The same goes for Wrex, Liara, Tali, Mordin, and a host of other great characters that are too numerous to list off here. All of the major alien characters are given this same quality of attention, and the result is one of the greatest casts of alien characters in any sci-fi series. Mass Effect's aliens are also better designed than Star Wars. They never veer off between being too strange or too familiar; they strike just the right balance. You look at them and can instantly believe they could exist. Their civilizations, history, and relationships with each other are fascinating and complex. This makes them feel believable. They are the reason you fall in love with the galaxy and want to save it. They are the heart of Mass Effect.
1. Characters
Quick, name the best characters in the Star Wars movies. There are the obvious ones, like Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, and Han Solo. Others include Obi-Wan Kenobi, Yoda, Lando Calrissian, Chewbacca, and R2-D2. Dont forget bad guys like Darth Vader and Jabba the Hut. But Star Wars also has stinkers like Mace Windu, Jar Jar Binks, and Qui-Gon Jinn, among many others in the prequel trilogy. Now consider Mass Effect. Youve got Commander Shepard, Garrus, Tali, Liara, Wrex, Thane, Miranda, Mordin, Anderson, Jack, Joker, Grunt, EDI, Legion, and the list could go on. Just in terms of sheer quantity Mass Effects cast takes the cake. But quantity alone doesnt matter; its who they are that counts. And in this regard Mass Effect also beats out Star Wars. Mass Effect has a larger and more charismatic cast of characters throughout its three games than all six of the Star Wars films. Nearly all of the major characters are well-developed and provided with fascinating backstories and motivations. One of the pleasures of experiencing the games is seeing how the characters evolve throughout the series; many of them change drastically by the end. Sure, Mass Effect also has its share of mediocre characters, like Jacob and James, but they are few in number and don't impair one's enjoyment of the story. Even the characters with limited amount of screen time, like Captain Bailey, Dr. Chakwas, and Aria TLoak, are developed just enough to make you like them. And all of them, whether big or small, are written and acted with the same level of care as a film or television show. Despite the vastness of Mass Effects plot, even the smallest characters never get lost in the shuffle. In truth, it's kind of unfair to compare the characters of Mass Effect to the Star Wars films, as it has the advantage of being a game series of 100+ hours. It can devote a lot more time to developing a large cast. Nevertheless, when comparing this relatively new franchise to the untouchable and much beloved classic, its quite apparent that Mass Effect excels in creating a huge cast of consistently interesting, funny, and lovable characters when Star Wars is more hit or miss much of the time. Agree? Disagree? Which sci-fi series do you prefer? Let us know in the comments.