10 Things You Didn’t Know About Video Game UI
For the love of U and I.
UI doesn’t get enough love.
Every time you hear someone commenting on how incredible a game’s graphics are, the chances are they’re referring to the character models, or the environments, or even the particles/effects. But hey, I can’t be too mean to you lot - who’s going to be sat there ogling footage for the next Resident Evil and shout “Whoa! Look at that ammo counter!”?
But therein lies part of the problem. Even some gamers who've been playing their entire lives struggle to determine just how many elements in a screenshot are UI or not.
I can’t count the amount of time I’ve mentioned to people that I used to work as a User Interface Artist and they responded with “so, you do like... the pause menu and the life bar, then? Is that all you do?”
Though I’ve worked on UI for a few AAA games (and for countless smaller titles), I still get asked the same questions. What even is UI, and why would anyone want to do it? Well, here are some things you probably didn’t know... about videogame UI!
10. How A Game Forces You To “Read The Screen”
One of the first things you learn when starting out a specialism in UI is the rather craply-named “screen real estate”, which makes it sound like the art of building student halls on top of your TV.
But it’s the priority and flow of how you read the screen, because each part has a different level of importance.
Here in the west the highest priority radiates from the centre of the screen outwards (dead centre being most important), with top-left corner being most important, and bottom-right being least (we read from left to right).
This means you should always put the most important UI in the centre, then work your way down the priority list. If your character has an important resource you need to manage from second to second, don’t put that information in the bottom-right, you toerag!
Interesting point - in a fighting game, player two gets a mirrored UI - we instinctively expect the information to be read in reverse (and most of us can do so without any problem) - and that’s why in fighting games the bars deplete into the centre!
9. Hidden Tricks Of A Health Bar
The health bar is pretty much as ubiquitous as UI comes, but I bet you didn’t know that we design them with a few sneaky tricks in mind!
The chances are, if you’re like me when playing a game, you tend to be a bit more daredevil-like when you’ve got a full health bar when compared to being at death’s door. But have you ever noticed that, when you’re on your last legs, you tend to totally go ham, ekeing out that last 1HP and you get out by the skin of your teeth like a badass?
Well, sorry to let you in on a secret here, but that last bit of health?
That’s usually artificially inflated to make you feel like you could die at any moment for just a bit longer than you expect, and by contrast, the start of your health bar sometimes depletes a bit faster so it’s more obvious that you’re damaged.
Next time you look at a health bar, think of the raw numbers. 100-90 HP will deplete in a flash, 89-2HP will deplete at a normal rate, and that last 1HP might actually be more like a hidden 10-20%.
Best trick, bar none.
8. That Red Outline When You're About To Die In EVERY Game
Y'know when you take too much damage in a game, and now the screen looks like you’re drowning in a jam factory? That's the most imposing use of a screen-bordering vignette, but they're also used for more subtle purposes, a few of which you may not be aware of.
If you’re a fan of VR, you’ll know full-screen dark vignettes are used to limit field of view to stop people puking their guts up. Similar effects are used in standard FPS to very slightly dull your field of view too, placing focus on the centre of the screen, or creating a sense of speed in a racing game. In a game like Overwatch, in addition to a text pop-up, a unique vignette is used for almost every status effect, too.
The next time you’re playing a modern game, take note of how many screen vignettes are used, and which purposes they’re used for. You might be surprised - they’re more than just watery ketchup.
7. Why That One Type Of Skill Tree Is EVERYWHERE
It can really suck when you start a game and have absolutely no idea what you’re supposed to do, or where you’re going. Believe it or not, it’s one of the jobs of the UX designer to ease that confusion (and I’m not just talking because we’re the guys that make the mini-maps!)
But how do you teach the player where they’re going or what they’re doing without just... telling them outright?
Well, you can give them a hint... with "progression paths".
You might notice that progression trees look like roads or literal pathways, and that’s to signify the path the player subliminally understands themselves to be on. And, as you get to see all of the abilities you might potentially unlock, it gives the players clues to how they might tackle the game ahead.
For example, you might have a late-tree unlock which allows your player to climb up vine-covered walls, which tells the player “oh, the vines aren’t just for show, then?”, which subsequently becomes “well, I guess whatever’s up in those vine-covered high-up areas must be really important - that should be my goal”.
And, voila - suddenly, just reading a progression path/tree has given the player an immediate narrative.
6. The Trick To A Good Video Game Menu
Have you ever thought about menus? No, I’m not talking about picking your bread at Subway. (Although, of course, in that instance, the correct answer is Hearty Italian.)
I’m talking about game menus. Have you ever stopped to think how much effort goes into them?
One of the things user experience teams indulge in, are flowcharts (you know, crack open a few beers and just make a night of it). For such a low-tech, simple process, you’d be surprised how often a flowcharts are used to map out pretty much every aspect of the user experience.
This is because even a basic-looking menu can have up to tens, even hundreds of different permutations - how do you highlight each option? Does the cursor change when you choose your option? Does the screen change? Do you need to hold the button, or just tap it?
You can see how the information starts to get out of hand - and that’s before you even consider adding graphics. That’s why the humble flowchart becomes your best friend, and soon a six-tier start menu starts making a bit more sense to build.
All thanks to some bubbles and arrows! And... about six pints of lager. That helps, too.
5. Why Dead Space's "Menus" Were So Special
The chances are, if you’re picturing a HUD, you’re thinking about non-diegetic UI.
This is UI that exists "outside" the game universe, elements that are only visible in the player’s world, in the HUD, not the characters'.
The health bars in Street Fighter 2 Turbo, for example - you didn’t think Ryu and Dhalsim could look towards the screen and see two enormous hovering health cylinders, did you?
But what if the HUD exists in the game world, and the player characters are aware of it? Things like the pop-up display used in Dead Space (with that ultra-neat spine-centred health bar on Isaac’s suit), or all of Artyom’s vital information displayed on his watch/clipboard in Metro: Exodus. These elements are existent and present in their world, and so the information is shared between both worlds (game and player).
Depending on the context and genre of game, it’s the UI specialist’s job to determine which of these two is most suitable, as both have pros and cons.
For example, non-diegetic might be better for immersion, but not so good for immediacy (as UI displayed on a watch, for example, will not always be displayed to the player - not ideal if you need to watch your health like a hawk!).
What about you? Do you have a preference?
4. Fonts, Localisation & Legibility
Okay, this is the trickiest bit to sell, because fonts aren’t very sexy (unless you count New Helvetica, Oo-boy, that’s some hot stuff), but fonts become not just a necessity, but a passion when you get into UI.
And that’s because of a number of reasons - for starters, you just spent weeks working on a clean, legible, sexy text box (I... I keep saying text stuff is sexy, I think I might need to go back to the counsellor) - and you're not letting anyone slam some 36-point Papyrus monstrosity in there.
Secondly, it’s also the responsibility of the UI specialist to think about some super-important stuff like localisation, and not every country uses the same alphabet.
So it’s up to you to check - are all the characters in your chosen font set supported in Cyrillic? Have you considered the increased character size when looking at Hirigana and Kanji (because your sentences might fit into that text box in the ROMAN alphabet, but that doesn’t mean it’ll fit when characters are double the width)?
Oh, and it goes without saying but... Comic Sans is for 1997, and Boomer Minions meme content. Nothing else.
3. The Basic Principle Behind Loot & Unlock Icons
Feedback to the player is one of the facets of UX that seems simple, yet can be extraordinarily tricky to get right.
Do you trickle-feed your players lots of lovely scrumptious bites of reward-y goodness, or do you hold out on them and give them one enormous, explosive, giganto-reward?
However you do it, you need to make those rewards worthwhile. And, unsurprisingly, one of the simplest ways of conveying value is to use imagery that the player associates with a sense of wealth.
You probably didn’t realise how often you’re being manipulated this way, but colour-coded items always have purple (the regal colour) to signify “important” items, and gold (the... well, money colour) to signify the “best”.
Icons that signify progress/winning are almost always rosettes, coins or trophies (and even other, less obvious stuff like stars are always made of gold, of course) - hell, PlayStation charts your personal value in tiers of trophies, whilst Xbox has its own currency (signified as G, or Gamerscore).
You may THINK you’re earning a new special power, or secret attack, or even just EXP., but the next time the big flashing lights start - look at how much is all about the money.
2. Legibility First, Aesthetics Second
They say there’s a real overlap between graphic design and UI creation, which is absolutely true in one key area - legibility always comes first.
It sounds so simple, yet bad UI is quite often bad because it forgets this fundamental principle. A player should be able to read the UI’s information with the most rapid of glimpses. If the player has to stop to ask, “is that a one, or a seven?” for even a second, the UI designer has failed.
Have you ever played a game with UI that’s just... bloated, overly-ornate, and draws your attention in the wrong way?
Maybe it’s a gothic game where the HUD has beautifully-painted gargoyles on it, and you can’t stop ogling at their fantastically-rendered claws, even as your character is getting absolutely slaughtered in-game. Or maybe it’s just outrageously large or gaudy.
UI is in service of the player, and good UI doesn’t need to be invisible, it should merely feel invisible.
In that regard, it should be graphically subtle, practical, and elegant, and the more you can strip it back to its essence - the essential elements - the higher chance you have of having a readable, clear, efficient UI.
1. Spatial Awareness
One other type of UI that’s become indispensable in recent years is Spatial UI.
Unlike the HUD types (mainly diegetic and non-diegetic), spatial UI exists within the game world to serve the player, but is completely unknown/non-existent to the in-game characters.
Spatial UI tends to be very prevalent in open-world games - anything from big shiny arrows pointing you to your next objective right through to icons above treasure chests.
Spatial UI tends to get a bad rap these days, with one of my friends telling me that he can’t play Assassin’s Creed nowadays because “the screen looks like icon soup”, but have you ever tried to do one of those goddamned “follow the important bloke through the market without him seeing you” missions without a mission marker? Without markers showing sight lines? Without big red chevrons telling you not to go that way, because it’ll insta-fail the mission?
Okay, so sure, nobody likes escort/follow missions in the first place (and designers need to stop implementing them, because I legitimately know nobody that enjoys these, or on-rails shooter sections), but if you have to do them, it’s better to have the lovely UI assistance.
“UI Specialists: Helping Escort Missions Remain Borderline Tolerable Since 1993”