10 Times Publishers Screwed Over A Video Game

Turns out EA puts money ahead of quality... who knew?!

By Stacey Henley /

Like it or not, video games exist to make money. You can tell that some games are passion projects and some even deserved to be recognised as pieces of art the way movies and TV shows are; generally though, these are the exceptions.

Advertisement

The publishers, as the moneymakers with little creative input, are usually seen as the bad guys. They push tight development schedules, they pressure developers into crunch time, they meddle in things they don’t understand and they force the microtransactions.

We’ve been so conditioned by microtransactions that those alone wouldn’t qualify a game as being screwed over. FIFA is full of them with Ultimate Team yet still flies off the shelves, while GTA is notorious for them but receives universal praise. Overwatch is even frequently lauded for sticking to cosmetic only lootboxes, such have we been Pavlov’s Dogged into accepting microtransactions in our games.

It’s not just the money grubbing that comes under fire here though. Either by insisting on in house uniformity, constant meddling, ripping out a game’s personality or setting deadlines which proved massively detrimental, these games have suffered more than most at the hands of publishers.

10. Haze

What a game Haze could’ve been. Developers Free Radical has just put out the Timesplitters trilogy, and Haze was set to be another groundbreaking game with an original premise and insightful features. Unfortunately, Ubisoft wanted the game to compete with Halo, so the game was shorn of any uniqueness and booted out limp and buggy to an undignified death.

Advertisement

Originally, it was set to tackle the horrors of warfare before any game had ever examined them. Spec Ops: The Line would not come out until four years later.

Haze had you playing as super soldiers who used Nectar to enhance their combat abilities. The Nectar caused hallucinations though, stopping the soldiers from seeing the true destruction and bloodshed they were causing. Hugely ambitious, it essentially needed levels to work on at least two planes at once.

Free Radical asked Ubisoft for more time to work on these distinctive features, but the response was worse than just a simple ‘no’. In addition to not delaying the game, Ubisoft pushed for more sandbox style features, without granting extra time to fix the game’s core issues.

Ubisoft eventually drafted in their own team, kicking Free Radical off their own game, and the end result was deeply disappointing.

9. Middle-Earth: Shadow Of Mordor

Middle-Earth: Shadow Of Mordor is a solid game in the Middle-Earth mythology which doesn’t stick to the safe Frodo/Bilbo/Gandalf narratives. However, publisher Warner Brothers’ push for microtransactions almost completely derailed it.

Advertisement

The Star War: Battlefront II microtransactions disaster could have made the cut here too. However, that game felt like a vehicle for microtransactions more than anything else, so it was really the consumers who got screwed over more than the game.

With Middle-Earth though, it was a good game which just had microtransactions crammed in. Thankfully, the backlash was so severe they were eventually removed, but they initially let a huge cloud gather over the game during its first few weeks of release.

The Nemesis System, where enemies who defeated you rose through the ranks of the Orc army, was hugely praised upon release. It hasn’t been as influential as some speculated, but was a brilliant feature which brought the game to life.

However, if you so wished, you could buy various Orcs in this army to possess and turn traitor. It undermined SoM’s greatest asset, and before long developers Monolith removed it prior to the first DLC release.

The sequel, Shadow Of War, doubled down on microtransactions, proving they hadn’t learned anything.

8. Titanfall 2

Titanfall 2 recently featured highly in the list of 10 Games Released At The Wrong Time, but it’s the only one there to make the journey to here as well. You might say it’s representing all of them then, as publishers are the ones who control release schedule, but with Titanfall 2 it goes a bit deeper.

Advertisement

After the first Titanfall was middling, the sequel needed to make a massive step up. In the end, it did exactly that, delivering one of the best first person shooter campaigns in years. The time travel level especially deserves praise.

However, at the time that praise was hard to come by as it was released either side of Battlefield 1 and Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare.

There’s some who claim developers Respawn actually pushed for this window, wanting to take on the FPS titans. Others though go in for the conspiracy theory angle, that EA pushed it out at a bad time deliberately, tanking Respawn’s value so they could buy it just over a year later.

If the conspiracy theory is indeed true, Titanfall 2 was royally screwed over by its publisher, with money proving to be the most important thing yet again.

7. Conker

It didn’t feel right to put Conker’s Bad Fur Day as the title here, seeing as that was a brilliant game with no real publisher nonsense. However, just singling out one post Bad Fur Day version of Conker felt wrong too. It was the very character himself who was bastardised and focus grouped into a husk of his former glory.

Advertisement

Originally made by British company Rare, Conker passed to Microsoft when they bought the development studio in 2002. The urban legend goes that Microsoft mistakenly thought Rare owned Donkey Kong, and thus thought they were getting one of gamings most iconic characters.

Given how they shafted Rare’s creations afterwards, that wouldn’t be a huge surprise if it were true.

Microsoft elected to simply remake Conker’s Bad Fur Day, censoring out the more controversial parts. Then, allegedly thinking the character was too cute for an adult game and too crude for a children’s game, sat on it for nine years.

When he reappeared, he was a goofy, squeaky clean squirrel acting as the mascot for Project Spark. Not the send off he deserved.

Banjo-Kazooie was another casualty in Microsoft’s acquisition of Rare, though with an appearance in Smash, the future looks promising.

6. Dead Space 3

Purists will argue that even by Dead Space 2, the game had moved away from its roots. However, both games focus on survival horror and a creeping sense of dread. Originally, this was going to continue into the third instalment, but publishers EA put paid to that idea.

Advertisement

Knowing survival horror was a niche market which likely wouldn’t bring in massive numbers, Dead Space 3 was contorted into an action shooter. Unsurprisingly, microtransactions were shoved in any which way they could too.

The conclusion of the trilogy was going to have protagonist Isaac suffer a full of psychological breakdown, with a co-op version of the game featuring Isaac and a hallucinated version of himself fighting alongside each other. This dramatic twist was to be saved for the climax, and each player would have seen different things across their playthrough, heightening the sense of paranoia and psychosis.

All of these features were shorn away in the end, with EA pushing for a shooter as generic and by the numbers as they could get. The problem was it wasn’t a game ever built for this, and those who might have enjoyed it avoided it, while those invested in Dead Space hated the new direction.

5. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

The game which drove a wedge between Konami and Kojima ended up with the eccentric developer leaving the company and setting up shop elsewhere, resulting in Death Stranding. Only time will tell if it was worth having a compromised Metal Gear Solid so that Death Stranding could exist, but one thing’s for sure: MGS V would have been very different without publisher meddling.

Advertisement

MGS V is still a fairly decent game, but it’s certainly not up to the quality Hideo Kojima had initially wanted.

With Kojima a perfectionist working without much oversight, the game was much bigger, would take much longer, and would cost more than initially anticipated. Konami viewed this as unacceptable, and forced Kojima into several compromises.

Things were so bad Kojima was separated from his team, forced to work in a different office, only communicating through middlemen. Clearly, these are ridiculous working conditions which hamstrung the game’s development process.

In the end, Kojima’s name was even taken off the official box art, despite his creativity being a huge selling point for MGS. Playing the game felt a little sour too, as you knew Kojima wanted to do so much more with it.

4. Need For Speed

Like Conker, it’s more Need For Speed overall which has been screwed over by its publisher. EA didn’t cut the heart out of this racer with a single mangled release; instead it was death by a thousand cuts.

Advertisement

The earliest releases merged car customisation, arcade style action and realistic racing simulations together with ease. They were brilliantly creative games which cornered the market with their own brand of racing sim. More focussed than Burnout, more fun than Gran Turismo, edgier than Forza... the game was in a world of its own.

The only game which tried to compete with it was Midnight Club, which ran out a distant second best.

However, with that success came extra pressure and interest. With EA steering, the games became less about innovation and more about mass market appeal. In order to secure frequent releases, the game was bounced from developer to developer, with no cohesion or identity.

Any attitude it once had was gone.

As is typical of EA, the playthroughs became overloaded with microtransactions. Any sense of progress was stripped away, lootboxed up, and sold back to the player at a premium.

Need For Speed: Payback was the final straw, and may as well have been called Pay Up.

3. SimCity

The sixth SimCity game was simply titled SimCity, suggesting it was designed to reboot the series into something fresh. However, unless that something fresh was supposed to be a recently set on fire pile of garbage, it’s safe to say they failed.

Advertisement

It came ten years after SimCity 4 and six years after SimCity Societies, so there was a lot of anticipation. It’s impressive just how quickly SimCity blew all of their momentum. Within a week of the game being released, Amazon suspended sales to limit the amount of customer complaints they were getting.

Bad decisions on a publishing and development level mixed with it being released way before it was ready combined for one of the worst launches ever. EA were forced to issue a statement calling their own decisions ‘dumb’, and offered anyone who had bought the game a freebie from their library to make up for the wrong doing.

The problem was that the game required you to be always online - in itself annoying - but massive server disruption made the game unplayable. Those who’d gotten their hands on it early reviewed it positively, but once it came out reviewers urged players to stay away until it was fixed.

2. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided

Divided proved to be a very fitting subtitle here.

Advertisement

With Deus Ex: Human Revolution rebooting the series back to popularity, developers Eidos Montreal had ambitious ideas for the follow up. In the end, this meant the five years it took between Human Revolution and Mankind Divided was nowhere near enough.

Though the publishing issues don’t reflect as starkly on the actual gameplay here, from a narrative perspective they’re glaring. Publishers Square Enix, concerned that the wait between Mankind Divided and the sequel would be even longer, decided to lop of some of the later story and save it for next time.

This led to what was supposed to be a relatively open world being hugely restrictive in scope, while the narrative was a slow burn which finally ramped up into something good, then just stopped completely. Even without knowing the backstory, it was obvious something had gone wrong.

In the end, low sales and Eidos Montreal being moved onto the upcoming Avengers game meant that second half of the project never saw the light of day. It’s tempting to say they got what they deserved, but then it was the players who missed out more than anything else.

1. Anthem

Anthem doesn’t really feel like a BioWare game. However, it feels exactly like an EA game, which is why it tops the list.

Advertisement

We know BioWare is working on Dragon Age 4, and hopefully that will be made in their vision without too much studio meddling. However, with Anthem, we’ll probably never know what went wrong. After the Mass Effect trilogy, there didn’t seem to be a clear direction, thus Anthem was born.

Mass Effect: Andromeda was rushed out by an inexperienced team, but BioWare’s biggest hitters didn’t seem to be working cohesively either.

Casey Hudson left then returned, while long term creative director and game designer Mike Laidlaw and James Ohlen left during Anthem’s development, taking a combined 36 years of BioWare experience with them.

Reports of depression and anxiety amongst the developers due to EAs working environment surfaced in April, along with an insight into why.

EAs policy of ‘where’s your Ultimate Team’ (ie long term microtransactions baked in), as well as their insistence that the Frostbite engine be used killed Anthem before it could even be born. Frostbite was a poor pick for a game of Anthem’s scope and pace, but EA’s policy of studio uniformity meant their hands were tied.

Advertisement