10 Times Video Game Realism Went Too Far

The weirdest video game features! - From Red Dead Redemption 2's horses to Days Gone's bikes.

By Danny Meegan /

For the most part, video games aren't meant to be realistic. The whole point is that we're escaping to a different reality or world, to have an experience that's far removed from our own day-to-day grind - fighting Norse gods with a magic axe, for example, or controlling an Italian plumber to beat up a massive turtle.

Advertisement

But even in games that are intended to be completely fantastical or escapist, some developers do like to build "realistic" features and mechanics into the experience, whether it's characters that need to be provided with food and water, or graphical touches such as lifelike fire, and visible pores on human skin.

Sometimes, these features are well thought-out, and are incorporated into the game in an unobtrusive or engaging way. But in some cases, they're either completely pointless or silly, or they actively make the game less enjoyable, demonstrating that it's often best to prioritise the entertainment factor over any sort of realism.

In other words, the developers shouldn't have bothered, because these games would've been just as good - or even better - without these touches of realism.

10. Watching An Entire Movie (The Darkness)

The Darkness is an underrated title that puts you in the shoes of a man - Jackie Estacado - who is possessed by a powerful demonic force, allowing him to wreck fools in a variety of brutal ways. But aside from all this mindless destruction, there are plenty of quiet moments throughout the game's surprisingly strong story.

Advertisement

At one point early in the game, you can sit down on the couch with your girlfriend, Jenny Romano, for a bit of Netflix and chill. She'll put on a movie - 1962's To Kill A Mockingbird - and you'll both just sit there, watching.

At this point, most games would fade to black, or find some other way of cutting the movie short. But not here. The Darkness actually plays the whole damn thing from start to end, allowing you to sit there and watch it, should you choose to do so.

While this is a really neat touch that does give the game that added dash of realism, the vast majority of players obviously aren't going to sit there and watch this two-hour black-and-white movie on a tiny TV screen, and even if you do, there are no bonus interactions between Jackie and Jenny, and the story doesn't play out any differently - so it's basically a waste of time.

Great movie, though.

9. Dynamic Beard Growth (The Witcher 3)

The Witcher 3 is a game that lets you play as a superhuman monster slayer in a mythic land full of elves, dwarves, werewolves, and other assorted creatures.

Advertisement

It's a game that screams "fantasy" in every possible way, but curiously, developers CD Projekt Red decided to go down the realism route in one particular way that a lot of players didn't expect: your character's facial hair.

In this game, protagonist Geralt Of Rivia's beard will slowly grow over time, allowing you to decide how long you want it to be. If you like, you can shave it off, but if you want those glorious facial locks to flow? Then you can just leave them be.

It's certainly an interesting mechanic, but since it doesn't have any notable impact on the game, it feels a bit needless, like a step too far in terms of character customisation. It's not like you're changing outfits or weapon skins - this is a really small detail, one that most players will barely even notice, or care about.

And look, maintaining your beard is a chore in the real world, so why on earth would you want to do it in a video game? Nobody wants to feel like an unshaven scruff when they boot up their console - that's what reality is for.

8. Lifelike Eyes (The Last Of Us Part II)

From the gunplay and climbing in Uncharted to the stealth and crafting in The Last Of Us, Naughty Dog games certainly feel good to play.

Advertisement

But generally speaking, gameplay takes a backseat when it comes to the discourse surrounding the studio's work (primarily with its recent PS4 titles), which is almost entirely dominated by two things: storytelling and graphics.

And to give Naughty Dog a lot of credit, their devotion to creating realistic character models and movie-quality stories is admirable. But when you look at how far they're pushing visual fidelity in particular, you can't help but wonder if that effort would be better spent on making gameplay that's as lauded as the graphics, rather than focusing on things that people don't notice, and have no real impact on the game.

For example, look at the insane amount of work that went into making The Last Of Us Part II's eyes look as realistic as possible. These eyes respond to light sources accurately, they have screen-space shadows for eyelashes and eyelids, and hell, Naughty Dog even beefed up their eyes just to make nocturnal animals look scarier.

It's impressive stuff, but does the average gamer care? No. Would it affect the overall quality of the game if the eyes were a tad less detailed? No. These things look mind-blowing in still images, no doubt, but when you're grappling a mushroom zombie and stabbing it in the head with a shiv, nobody is going to be worried if Ellie's eyes aren't accurately reflecting a nearby lamp.

7. Refuelling Your Bike (Days Gone)

In the post-apocalyptic, zombie-infested wasteland of Days Gone, bikes are the new "man's best friend". Seriously, everyone in this game loves a bit of two-wheeled action, to the extent that maintaining and upgrading protagonist Deacon's ride is one of the core components of the experience.

Advertisement

You'll also have to refuel your bike's tank whenever it runs dry, which, on paper, might seem like a really immersive game mechanic. But in practice? Having to constantly worry about fuel consumption detracts from the fun of exploring the open world, while also making you repeat the same mundane refuelling task over and over again.

Most games would give the bike unlimited fuel so that players can drive around and let loose, but Days Gone doesn't do that. You can't speed around like a madman, smashing into zombies and zooming up steep ramps. Your tank runs out of juice far too quickly - even when upgraded - and as a result, you'll regularly have to put the game on hold while you hunt down a fuel canister, or travel to a camp for a refill.

This constant stopping-and-starting badly hurts the pacing of an already plodding story, forcing you to take your time and drive slowly and carefully, which absolutely nobody wants to do when they're riding a goddamn motorbike on the open road.

And while fuel is relatively easy to come by (although, on occasion, you will find yourself stranded in the wilderness with an empty tank), Days Gone would've been a much more fun ride - pun intended - if the bike was a bit less high-maintenance.

6. Malaria Pills (Far Cry 2)

To put it mildly, the modern Far Cry games are not concerned with realism. They're ridiculous and over-the-top like a playable '80s action movie, but back in those earlier entries in the series, the experience was designed to be a bit more grounded.

Advertisement

Specifically, Far Cry 2 has a whole host of "realistic" mechanics, from its jamming guns to the way that its map works, but arguably the most annoying one is the fact that you have to constantly take pills so that you don't die of an awful disease. Fun!

Early in the game, your character is infected with malaria, which causes the screen to pulse with a sickly, yellowish tint. From this point on, you'll suffer a malaria attack every so often, which not only brings back that sickly yellow tint, but prevents you from sprinting or jumping, forcing you to pop some pills to return to normal.

It goes without saying that this was a pretty annoying thing to have to deal with on a regular basis, and while Far Cry 2 is a strong game overall, it's no surprise that its sequels opted for a much more forgiving gameplay loop.

5. Weapon Durability (The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild)

The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild was met with near-universal acclaim upon its March 2017 release, but one particular element of its gameplay that wasn't completely beloved was its weapon durability.

Advertisement

The weapons in Breath Of The Wild - swords, clubs, axes, and the like - each have a certain amount of hits that they can take before becoming badly damaged, and if you continue to use them after this point, they'll soon break apart.

It's obviously not true-to-life realism - swords don't just shatter when you use them, after all - but it's trying to be more realistic than the vast majority of games, which let you hack and slash infinitely, without your weapons suffering a single scratch.

And to be frank, there's a reason why all those other games do things that way: weapon durability isn't an enjoyable mechanic.

There are those who say that it encourages players to try new weapons, and that it increases immersion, but these are both weak arguments. If the range of weapons in Breath Of The Wild was interesting enough to begin with, players would want to experiment naturally, without being forced to do so just because their sword broke.

And as for the immersion argument, well, when so many things about this game obviously aren't realistic in the slightest, it's a bit confusing that the devs chose to add some realism by infuriating their players with constant weapon breaks.

4. Encumbrance (Skyrim)

Like The Witcher 3, Skyrim is clearly set in a make-believe fantasy land full of magic and wonder, but just like CD Projekt Red, Bethesda opted to incorporate some realism in one particular area. Only, in this case, it has a much more negative impact on the gameplay experience.

Advertisement

See, in Skyrim, the many items you can pick up each weigh a certain amount, a statistic you can view within your inventory. At first, this statistic isn't really important to keep track of, but as you progress and you start to gather more and more stuff, you'll likely end up becoming encumbered, which means that you've exceeded the maximum weight limit that your character can hold.

While encumbered, you won't be able to run, you won't be able to use carriages, and you won't be able to fast travel. You're essentially grounded to a snail's pace until you lose some of that weight, which is super frustrating for players who like to hoard lots of items without being forced to abandon any of them.

Encumbrance is such a drag on the experience of playing Skyrim (as well as other Bethesda titles, like the Fallout series) that players actually created mods to combat the issue, with some of them achieving over 450,000 total downloads.

3. Manual Blinking (Alone In The Dark)

2008's Alone In The Dark is a frustrating game to play through, because for every solid idea it has, there's a terrible one right around the corner.

Advertisement

On the positive side, there's its item combination system, which allows you to mix different objects together to create more powerful weapons and items - for example, a glass bottle and some sticky tape will get you an adhesive molotov. Nice.

But on the negative side... there's its manual blinking feature.

At the start of the game, a prompt will instruct you to "blink to clear your vision", leading to a sequence where you have to repeatedly hit the blink button so you can see what the hell is going on around you. Then, later on, you have to blink to clear blood and toxins out of your eyes, depending on which enemies are attacking you.

While blinking to combat enemy attacks isn't all that annoying, that initial blinking sequence is an absolute drag to play through. For one thing, it goes on forever, but more importantly, manual blinking isn't a compelling mechanic in the slightest - it's basically a dull QTE that you have to do over and over and over again.

The devs clearly intended this to increase the immersion and realism, but since Alone In The Dark is otherwise a pretty bog-standard and underwhelming horror game, its manual blinking feature just comes off as a cheap gimmick.

2. Shrinking Horse Balls (Red Dead Redemption II)

Like Naughty Dog, Rockstar spends an inordinate amount of time on small details that most other developers don't bother with, all in an attempt to make their open worlds as rich and immersive as possible.

Advertisement

With Red Dead Redemption II, all of that effort led to a game that is absolutely gorgeous to behold, but on the downside, it's also a game that tries to do far too much in the name of realism, which can make it a real chore to play.

Almost every action in the game has its own animation, whether you're skinning animals, grabbing items, or playing a tabletop game of dominoes. These are cool to notice at first, but over time, those precious seconds will start to add up, and you'll soon wish that the game just did things the old fashioned way: a tap of a button instantly picks up an item, without the need to sit through a special animation.

This aside though, by far the most ridiculous and pointless way that Rockstar added realism to Red Dead II is the fact that they coded in horse balls that actually shrink when the weather turns cold.

We probably don't need to explain why this is a step too far in the realism department (for one thing, you won't even see your horse's junk through normal gameplay), but we would like to give a shout-out to the poor developer who had to go into work on Monday morning and create some realistic horse nuts.

1. Hiking In Real-Time (Shenmue II)

In most games, moving between locations is a relatively speedy process that the developers can handle in a number of ways, whether it's a loading screen, a cutscene, or a fast travel system.

Advertisement

Shenmue II, on the other hand, decided not to bother with any of that time-saving efficiency towards the end of its story, when protagonist Ryo Hazuki is told to travel to Bailu Village in Guilin, where his father's killer is thought to be heading.

At this point, you'd expect the game to fade to black, cut directly to the village, or even play a quick cutscene that shows Ryo travelling, but instead, Shenmue II forces you to hike there in real-time, a journey that takes around two hours to complete.

There are a couple of small things for you to do along the way (like the extremely exciting task of... collecting firewood!), but for the most part, you're just walking through the wilderness, and needless to say, it's a dull affair.

Hiking is beneficial in real life because you're getting some actual fresh air and exercise, but all you're getting here are underwhelming, Dreamcast-level tree graphics, and boring dialogue. For two hours. Thanks, Shenmue II.

Advertisement