10 Video Game Characters Who Completely Dropped The Ball

Everybody makes mistakes, everybody has those days.

By Zoë Miskelly /

At risk of saying something wild, most people like to like good people. Heroes aren't named that without doing a little bit of heroics, and making us root for them because we know they'll do the right thing - even if that sort of becomes rooting for ourselves as we control them.

Advertisement

That said, we all also love a flawed character. It's easy to love an anti-hero who struggles with knowing what is right, but who (generally) manages to do so despite these struggles.

And - even when these struggles are really, really dumb - they make some of the most engrossing parts of any game or story we come across. Even though some of these characters have colossal blunders, they only enhance the plot, as they provide further complications and barriers to be navigated.

Be they villain, hero, or something in between, seeing a character simply totally drop the ball by making some misjudgment can be the highlight of a game - as it at the least will make you feel a little bit better about getting lost with where to go for like ten minutes beforehand.

10. Groose - Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword

For all his many, many flaws, you can argue that Groose meant well, since he did plan on saving the world as the Hero of Hyrule - just, unfortunately, that happens to not be him, but Link, which makes his mistreatment of Link at the start of the game a glaring error.

Advertisement

Because Groose is straight up a bully to you at the start of the game, and coincidentally almost convinced that Zelda has a thing for "the Groosenator" and not your fine yellow headed self.

Mercifully, he goes through some pretty big character development, and eventually becomes both not a huge jerk, and one of your most trustworthy allies.

However, this doesn't change the fact that, had he not been an ass to you for like five minutes, he might have had this character development at the start of the damn game. As it is, he sucks for a good while - and has some hugely wrong presumptions - until he gets his act together.

9. Sir Galleth - Sly Cooper: Thieves Of Time

On one hand, Sir Galleth is a daring knight who is fierce, chivalrous, and noble. On the other, he's really goddamn annoying, because he will never not charge into danger whenever the opportunity presents itself.

Advertisement

Instead of taking any time to learn about his enemy, he leads The Knight of the Cooper Order into a battle against the Black Knight, which goes understandably terribly because this Knight is actually a mech with futuristic technology.

Despite losing his men, being captured, and then being turned into a jester, Galleth doesn't ever seem to reconsider looking before he leaps, despite the fact he is a talented thief and sneak like the rest of the Coopers.

Instead of proving him brave and dashing, it proves that he can be kind of a liability, as this is what causes him to power on the Moat Monster despite being warned not to mess with it - even though frankly something being named the Moat Monster is

8. Chell - Portal 2

For the most part, the silent protagonist of Portal does everything right (eventually, anyways). Every strange, confusing puzzle solved, every sassy malevolent AI taken down. In short, she's usually pretty on the ball, even while being insulted about her intelligence by GLaDOS the whole time.

Advertisement

Presumably being placed in stasis knocked a couple screws loose for her, then, because her decision to place Wheatley in control of the Aperture facility goes about exactly as well as you'd expect it to, since the little AI loses his mind with power in about two minutes.

While it's understandable to want an easy way out of the building - which presumably a sane Wheatley finding the elevator would have provided - Chell has had enough experience with the various robots she met in the first Portal to know even the nice ones probably aren't that stable. She also has the portal gun, and a seriously good knowledge of how to use it - so parkouring her way up the building might have been a better idea here.

You do get to hear Stephen Merchant threaten to kill you in increasingly unnerving ways, though, so maybe that was what she was aiming for the whole time.

7. Sasha Nein And Milla Vodello - Psychonauts

Being put in charge of a bunch of ten year old kids with psychic powers is realistically the stuff of nightmares, which is why it's such a relief that - for the most part - the teachers placed in charge of the Whispering Rock Psychic Summer Camp are so good with kids.

Advertisement

The key phrase here is for the most part, since there are some decided flaws in the staff. Most crucial is the fact that Coach Oleander - one of the main trio of teachers - is actually super evil and planning to harvest children's brains to make them into weapons.

The other flaw here is that the other two teachers - Sasha and Milla - leave this man in charge of all of the children halfway through the game.

Now, even if neither had suspected the quick-tempered man dressed in full military regalia to be evil, they certainly knew he wasn't particularly stable, or particularly good with kids. When said kids contain a kid who accidentally explodes things with his mind when he takes his hat off and gets nervous, it seems a recipe in disaster to leave them with Oleander.

6. Josh - Until Dawn

To give credit where credit is due, Josh manages to pull off a seriously impressive series of pranks over the course of Until Dawn, including an impressively elaborate one where he fakes being cut in half.

Advertisement

While he carries out this wacky schemes to punish his friends for an earlier prank they'd carried out that had (accidentally) led to his sisters' disappearances, something perhaps more important is discovered: Hannah and Beth did not die out in wilderness, they became Wendigos.

So, not only is Josh's great plan to traumatise his friends to try and get over his own trauma, he also manages to carry out a supposedly pacifistic plan that can kill literally everyone, because somebody didn't think to check out the area around his own spooky family lodge.

Again, Josh has at this point had a total mental breakdown, so it makes sense his plan isn't foolproof. But you can't help but wish that, instead of acting like a fake version of Saw and then being attacked by his Wendigo sisters, he'd just sat down with the gang and talked about his feelings.

5. Damon Gant - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney

Damon Gant is a very, very smart man - but you could easily not see that playing Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney, as he makes some truly dumb decisions during the time you know him.

Advertisement

After pursuing and capturing wanted killer Joe Darke, Gant worried that the evidence gathered was still not enough to convict this dangerous man, and that he would ultimately go free. When Darke broke out of interrogation and knocked Gant's colleagues unconscious - while also being knocked unconscious by them - Damon saw a gruesome opportunity.

He killed the young prosecutor Neil Marshall, and staged the the scene so it would appear as though Joe had killed him in their scuffle.

Not content with simply doing that, Gant then concocted an elaborate scheme that consisted of framing another prosecutor's sister, Lana Skye, in order to get said prosecutor to assist him. He then killed another of the detectives involved in the case, thus creating a whole other crazy plan to make that murder look as though Lana Skye had done it.

As you might imagine, the more wacky nefarious schemes Gant created, the easier it was for our heroes to spot that something was very amiss, meaning that Damon Gant essentially managed to sabotage himself

4. Mondo Owada - Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc

When you first meet Mondo Owada, it's hard to not find him a little endearing - as from his huge pompadour to his passionate desire to keep his word, he's all the tropes of a biker with a heart of gold you've no doubt seen in countless other media.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, his ardent urge to stay "honourable" is actually what leads to his downfall.

Mondo's brother - Daiya - would end up dying to try and save Mondo, after he became too daring in one of their races and almost drove straight into traffic. This became the man's darkest secret - and his most shameful.

As such, when the killing games of Danganronpa developed to the point where each of the student's worst secrets were placed in envelopes, and the students were told they'd be revealed to the world if nobody was killed within 24 hours.

When Mondo's friend Chihiro revealed his secret to the biker, it drove the pompadour-clad classmate into a rage, as he felt Chihiro had managed to do something braver and thus stronger than Mondo was able to.

In a fit of rage, Mondo would kill Chihiro, ultimately only making himself feel worse, as now two people had died because of his act-first, think-later nature.

3. Gwyn, Lord Of Cinder - Dark Souls

When you play through the Dark Souls series, it seems as though the Age of Fire is the "good" side of things - largely because shadow is commonly associated with the side of evil, and also because almost every shadowy creature you meet looks like a discount horror monster.

Advertisement

As it turns out in the Dark Souls III DLC Ringed city, though, the impending Age of Dark many of you will have been trying to evade isn't actually supposed to be an evil concept. The actually issue is because of Gwyn, who cut humans natural ties to the dark out of fear of what the end of the Age of Fire would entail for him, thus making the concept of dark grow monstrous because of this manipulation.

Had he not feared essentially the concept of change, most of the events of Dark Souls wouldn't feel so doomed, because the Age of Dark wouldn't be a concept associated with a ton of goddamn ghouls, but rather regular people.

Instead of being willing to see what would happen, Gwyn made a bunch of otherwise fine folk into monsters, and then set himself on fire for like a thousand goddamn years minimum. Learning the except change is a skill, is all we're saying.

2. Fang Ray Shin - Detention

Throughout the spooky happenings of Detention, seeing Fan Ray Shin is one of the few solaces you get. Since there's not really anyone else around the school - well, nobody living, anyways - another human face is unexpectedly reassuring.

Advertisement

Only, Ray hides a dark secret with her, that it turns out is a real doozy. It's worth prefacing this by saying the game is set in 1960s Taiwan, a time in which you could (and would) be arrested for any form of opposition to the government - or perceived opposition.

As such, when Ray discovers the counsellor who helped her through her troubled home life and began a relationship with her has moved on to be with fellow staff member Ms. Lin, she seeks revenge. Since Ms. Lin has a secret book class where she teaches students about books that have been deemed forbidden, telling officials of this leads to Lin, all of her students, and the counsellor - who turns out to have been bringing the books - being jailed or executed.

The kicker? It turns out Ms. Lin and Chiang, the counsellor, weren't even together - they were discussing the books. So, in essence, Ray got everyone killed for nothing.

1. Benny - Fallout: New Vegas

Given that Benny shoots you in the head to start out New Vegas, you sort of know in your heart that you're going to be given the chance to kill him at some stage in the game.

Advertisement

You get an especially interesting chance to kill him, though, if you have the Black Widow perk - which allows you to do ten percent extra damage against male enemies, and unlocks some extra saucy dialogue options.

One of these options is the chance to flirt and then proposition Benny - you know, the same Benny who shot you in the head and left you for dead, and who happens to be voiced by Chandler Bing. Do you want to sleep with Chandler Bing who tried to kill you?

If for some god forsaken reason you still answered yes, you're in luck, because you totally can. The Black Widow option also lets you kill Benny afterwards, in an entirely obvious moment he really, really should have seen coming.

In short, if you shoot someone in the head with a bullet and then they rock up at your place asking to bone down, it's worth considering that they're either here for vengeance, or an angry ghost looking to steal your genitals - and neither scenario is good.

Advertisement