10 Video Game Difficulty Modes That Are Utterly BROKEN

Uncharted 4's Crushing difficulty clearly wasn't playtested.

By Jack Pooley /

Player freedom is one of the most important facets of video games, and this absolutely transpires through to their difficulty.

Advertisement

Difficulty modes are almost always a good thing for developers to offer, allowing players to experience the game however they so wish, with many modern games even including a granular array of tweakable difficulty options.

But creating appropriate difficulty modes is a lot more challenging than it might at first seem: it's rarely as simple as cranking up enemy health and tweaking a few combat or AI parameters, at least when it's done well.

Yet there are many times when video games have offered difficulty settings that weren't really fit for their purpose, to the extent that many players even considered them flat-out broken.

These 10 video games are all guilty as charged, having been firmly raked over the coals by irate players who felt that these harder difficulty modes offered up an indecent level of challenge that effectively broke the central gameplay loop.

These difficulty modes transcended a brutal challenge to simply punish players for the sake of it, in turn pushing the game's mechanics to breaking point...

10. Veteran Difficulty - Call Of Duty: World At War

In the vast majority of the Call of Duty games, Veteran difficulty represents the absolute highest level of challenge, and while most entries into the series manage to offer a Veteran experience that's tough-but-fair, 2008's World at War took the concept to a level of infuriating self-parody.

Advertisement

The big problem that breaks World at War's Veteran mode is that enemy soldiers are programmed to effectively spam the player with grenades during any prolonged combat encounter, more often than not causing the player's death.

There's no attempt here by developers Treyarch to establish a convincing line-of-sight between the player and the AI: just an unrelenting shower of explosives until you need to start from the latest checkpoint.

Beyond that, AI spawns are extremely fast, ensuring that moving forward through a level feels like a near-Sisyphean feat, and your own braindead AI teammates generally won't offer up much assistance.

The infamous level "The Heart of the Reich" is by far the greatest indicator of how broken Veteran truly is - an endurance trial of raining grenades and brutally unfair checkpointing, which all but the most committed Call of Duty players never made it past.

9. Hard Riddle Difficulty - Silent Hill 3

Silent Hill is a terrific and challenging game no matter what difficulty you play it on, and offered up separate difficulty options for combat and puzzles.

Advertisement

Those who selected Hard Riddle Difficulty, however, likely weren't quite ready for the obscure knowledge required to make it through without using a guide.

This difficulty setting takes some of the game's already-tricky puzzles and renders them nigh-on impossible unless you're armed with the required knowledge - namely, the infamous Shakespeare keypad puzzle which requires players to deduce a numerical combination from pages of Shakespeare's plays.

If your English literature knowledge is lacking you're basically screwed here, for while The Bard is obviously one of the most widely-known authors in history, you need both a firm knowledge of his works and an ability to apply this to a mathematical puzzle.

To make matters worse, the Shakespeare puzzle appears extremely early in the game, and several other puzzles throughout Hard Riddle Difficulty also require players to intuit the most ridiculous and subtle clues. It is, in a word, ridiculous.

8. Nightmare Mode - Back 4 Blood

Though it was largely marketed as a casual squad-based multiplayer zombie shooter, Back 4 Blood actually offers a surprising amount of pushback even on lower difficulty levels.

Advertisement

The game's highest difficulty setting, Nightmare mode, however, proved to be so unacceptably, brutally, cheaply difficult that fans went to social media in droves to beg Turtle Rock Studios to nerf it.

Nightmare massively raises the difficulty several different ways, by having the undead spawn in far greater numbers, introducing a larger abundance of Corruption Cards which result in unfavourable gameplay modifiers, and massively boosting friendly fire damage.

Many complained that crowd control was simply impossible with this amount of enemies, especially as they now took more damage and the game's audio didn't sufficiently alert players to enemies emerging behind them.

Turtle Rock did eventually nerf Nightmare's difficulty to be more tolerable, though many fans nevertheless insist it's still a total mess from a design and pure entertainment perspective.

7. Unbeatable Drivatar Difficulty - Forza Horizon 5

Make no mistake, Forza Horizon 5 is a freakin' amazing game, and quite arguably one of the greatest racing games of all time.

Advertisement

It refreshingly offers up granular gameplay options to help players tailor the experience to their desired level of difficulty, though those who pick Unbeatable difficulty, the highest setting for their AI rivals (aka Drivatars), will have a nasty surprise lying in wait.

Within hours of the game's release, fans took to social media to protest the patently unfair "skills" of Unbeatable Drivatars, who beyond the rubber-banding expected from just about any racing game, are able to break the laws of physics to take corners and manoeuvre around the track in ways the player simply can't.

The Unbeatable Drivatars have always been tricky - hence the name - but Forza Horizon 5 makes little attempt to disguise how blatantly the AI is "cheating." As a result, players can play near-perfectly and still come up massively short.

If an Unbeatable AI is truly unbeatable, then is there really much point?

6. Legendary Difficulty - Halo 2

Halo 2's campaign on Legendary difficulty remains by far the toughest of the entire series, and you'll find few who've experienced it that will argue otherwise.

Advertisement

As is expected for the highest difficulty of any such game, the enemies are abundant in a much greater number, their AI routines are significantly more ruthless, and weaker enemy types are replaced by tougher ones.

Uber-dangerous Ultra Elites are now fairly common, and perhaps worst of all, Jackal Snipers will appear regularly and kill the player with a single damn shot.

Even those hoping to make the experience bearable through co-op play aren't much helped, as if one of you dies you both have to start again from the last checkpoint, as has surely wrecked more than a few friendships over the last near-20 years.

Factoring in all this in addition to Master Chief's shield resistance being halved,and Halo 2 on Legendary is basically an exercise in self-flagellation for anyone who dares attempt it.

Prevailing is as much about luck as it is skill, really, with the logic being that you throw enough Master Chiefs at a situation and eventually you must succeed.

Between the sheer absurd difficulty and some dodgy spawning issues - which see you immediately get melted by enemy fire - it's clear that Bungie didn't sufficiently test the mode, presumably due to the game's infamously rushed production.

It is the epitome of a difficulty mode that's just egregiously unbalanced and not really fun at all.

5. Ultimate Difficulty - FIFA 20

Though FIFA 20 received broadly positive reviews from most of the gaming press upon release, the response from hardcore players and especially the eSports community was decidedly more mixed.

Advertisement

Of particular note was the game's horribly unbalanced difficulty settings, particularly when playing Ultimate difficulty in FIFA 20's Career Mode after an infamous patch was released in January 2020.

Rather than have your AI opponents play smarter and more tactically in line with the greatest players on the planet, Ultimate difficulty basically just gave every member of the opposing team a total stat boost, such that they could run, shoot, and defend like the best of the best every single time.

Even if you're playing as one of the best teams in the game against an AI squad as one of the worst, you're still not beyond getting spanked 6-0.

Worse still, this created a massive chasm of difficulty between Legendary, which some players found too easy, and the new Ultimate, which many felt took things too far in the other direction and basically ruined the game for them.

4. Give Me God Of War Difficulty - God Of War (2018)

God of War 2018 may be one of the greatest games of the last generation, but its hardest difficulty mode, Give Me God of War, is a pain in the ass beyond compare, enough that it legitimately qualifies as broken.

Advertisement

Like other busted difficulty modes on this list, it's painfully apparent that it wasn't properly play-tested to be genuinely achievable by an acceptable sliver of players.

Where to begin? The start of the game is one of the hardest parts because Kratos isn't yet kitted out with good gear, and because enemies have masses more health than in lower difficulties you can spend a frankly absurd amount of time chipping away at them before they go down.

Even those who take joy in conquering a game's hard-as-nails difficulty may find this more of a boring slog than an entertaining challenge, so needlessly spongy are even the most standard of enemies. Oh, and they're able to level up mid-fight and negate your progress. Boo.

"Artificial difficulty" might be an overused term, but it absolutely fits for Give Me God of War, which rather than creatively scale-up enemy aggression in a tactile and interesting way just gives them a stupid amount of health for you to hack away at for 15 minutes.

And worst of all, if you make some headway in this mode before deciding to switch difficulties, Give Me God of War doesn't allow you to lower the difficulty down, so you'll have to start the entire game again.

3. I Am Death Incarnate Difficulty - Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus

Many players were taken aback by how difficult Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus was even on more "reasonable" difficulties, though the highest difficulty available at the start of the game, I am death incarnate!, somehow manages to one-up God of War in feeling like an abject chore.

Advertisement

Basically every enemy you encounter has pitch perfect aim and will make short work of you if given a nanosecond of an opportunity. Enemies will kill you in just a couple of shots while requiring a full hail of bullets to go down themselves.

It turns what should be a fun Nazi-killin' romp into a totally dull slog, where the gonzo flow of combat players want from a game like this, even on higher difficulties, is fatally interrupted.

The part of the game sure to break even the most hardened player on this difficulty is the courthouse battle, which is a car crash of grenade spam and enemies spawning seemingly out of nowhere. Making it through is far more about luck and persistence than actual skill - is that really what anyone wants?

Unsurprisingly many players simply resorted to save-scumming to make their way through it, and yet, I am death incarnate! isn't even the hardest difficulty in the game.

Those precious few who force themselves to the end of this mode will unlock Mein leben difficulty, a basically parodically insane mode which touts the same parameters as I am death incarnate!, but with the added rub that death is permanent and saves are disabled.

Basically, you have to beat the game without dying. And yet, Mein leben seems enough like a joke difficulty that it doesn't feel genuinely broken, because is anyone actually supposed to get past it? I am death incarnate! on the other hand, feels desperately in need of a polite nerf.

2. Crushing Difficulty - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Crushing difficult has always been a massive challenge in the Uncharted games, though the fourth main game took this to such absurdly punishing extremes as to suggest that Naughty Dog hadn't actually tested it much.

Advertisement

Throughout the series Crushing difficulty has made combat supremely more challenging by halving the damage Nate deals to enemies while doubling the damage he receives.

In A Thief's End this extended to the stealth meter being disabled, as well as enemy tagging, requiring players to rely entirely on their own situational awareness.

While Crushing has always represented a massive challenge to players, in Uncharted 4 it was more obvious than ever that the game hadn't been designed around such an outrageous degree of difficulty.

There are numerous levels where the sheer number of enemies will be overwhelming to about 99.98% of players, while the game is stingy with ammo to a frankly indecent degree, and those attempting to harness Nate's acrobatic abilities will be "rewarded" with a hasty death.

The exploding mummy room from the game's 19th chapter - a fairly straight-forward sequence on lower difficulties - is rendered a controller-throwingly infuriating farce on Crushing, enough that players may well give in for the sake of their skyrocketing blood pressure.

1. Hard Mode - Slave Zero

Cult classic action game Slave Zero is a relatively challenging title even on lower difficulties, though those who dare to play on Hard difficulty will find that they probably can't beat the damn game.

Advertisement

The final boss fight against SovKhan is rendered unwinnable for most players due to a baffling design oversight: his HP is higher than the damage that all the ammo in the arena, plus your own ammo stash, can possibly deal to him.

Furthermore, though there technically are extra ammo pickups on the map, due to various graphical and physics glitches they're rendered inaccessible to the player.

Only those few who still had the Valhalla missile launcher from earlier in the game - which most will have discarded - could take SovKhan down, and this being a game released in 1999 and all, it wasn't something that was simply remedied with a quick day-one patch.

Advertisement