10 Video Game Fan Theories That Became Fact

From a trigger happy Ghandi to an imaginary ninja; fan theories sometimes do come true...

By James Brigginshaw /

Nothing makes fans happier than a good old fashioned video game conspiracy theory. Ranging from subtle tweaks in gameplay, to ideas that completely turn a game on its head, fan speculation can be so intense that it gains the attention of the developers that made the game in the first place.

Advertisement

Most of the time, these sorts of rumours tend to be unfounded. Before the advent of social media, it was much more difficult to dispel or disprove something. For example, many gamers will remember for years being convinced that the Pokemon Mew could be caught in Pokemon Red and Blue.

More often that not, developers will deny or ignore rumours surrounding their video games, which usually only fuels further speculation.

But every once in a while, studios like the theory so much that they integrate it into further updates or future sequels, or go out of their way to confirm a particular theory outright.

This article will look at instances where developers, through subtle and sometimes more explicit means, confirmed video game theories, becoming part of the established culture of the franchise.

10. Civilisation - Ghandi On A Rampage

The iconic Civilisation series revolves around the idea of bringing your selected civilisation into the modern age. To give the game a layer of realism, the developers tweaked each individual civilisations stats to reflect the leaders personalities.

Advertisement

What they didn't count on, was that on reaching the modern age, serial pacifist Mahatma Gandhi, controlled by the AI, would frequently declare war on the player and 'pacify' them by nuking them from orbit.

So how could this happen? The developers programmed Gandhi's aggression level to one out of ten, the lowest value. Choosing to become a democracy in the modern age decreased a civilisations aggression level by two. But in doing this, Gandhi's aggression level couldn't be less than zero, and therefore defaulted at maximum aggression.

Although this didn't happen in every scenario, Gandhi's' itchy trigger finger became synonymous with the series. With every follow up Civilisation title, the developers would not only keep the code in, but would allude to Gandhi's aggression in various in-game events.

By Civilisation 5 & 6, players noticed that Gandhi's stats had been reduced to normal, thus concluding one of the longest running jokes in gaming history.

9. Overwatch - Symmetra Is Autistic

Overwatch is a game which prides itself on its mix of characters as much as the depth of its team focused gameplay. Symmetra was one of the base characters in a game looking to establish itself in a crowded FPS market with a diverse range of characters.

Advertisement

With an unconventional ability set, Symmetra was a character who already seemed like something of an anomaly, despite, or because of a series of high profile ability revamps.

Symmetra's backstory was explored in the "A Better World" comic, an expansion of the Overwatch universe. In it she becomes overwhelmed by crowds, as well as experiencing certain frustrations when dealing with other people.

This led fans to speculate that she had autism, but had not been explicitly confirmed by developer Blizzard.

One perceptive fan who read the comic wrote in to Blizzard, asking for confirmation that the character was autistic, based on her characteristics. The lead designer on Overwatch replied back that "Symmetra is autistic ... she does a great job of representing just how awesome someone with autism can be".

It seemed that it was the intention of the developers from release to make Symmetra autistic, and were happy to confirm fan speculation on the theory.

8. Rocket League - Egg People

Rocket League was a global phenomenon at release, with an instantly loyal and fanatic fan base. What was strange, however, was that fans not only obsessed about the cars, the physics, or the gameplay, but the ever present egg shaped figures that sat in the arena.

Advertisement

While many dismissed it as a low resolution way to fill the stadium, others were convinced that they were actually egg people (yes, really).

The developers seemed to confirm this theory in the form of a new map called 'farmstead', as part of a DLC package. This map had a few, ahem, Easter eggs, that seemed to prove this theory. A billboard shown outside the arena portrayed a band called 'Mitchell and the Gang' who were clearly eggs, with faces, playing musical instruments.

This hinted at wider implications, that the entire universe in which the game was set was populated by egg people. These same cylindrical shapes were shown in the cars, which meant egg people were driving the cars.

What made this so ingenious is that the developers took a fairly speculative theory, and decided to make a massive, egg based extended universe out of it.

7. Hearthstone - Reno Jackson Is A Dragon

Hearthstone is a card game based on the World of Warcraft series, much in the same vain as the Gwent card game made popular from The Witcher 3.

Advertisement

One such card was titled 'Reno Jackson', best described as a cut price Indiana Jones. Things took a massive left turn when fans speculated that he was in fact a dragon, and not a hapless (and crucially human) explorer.

A series of subtle hints were littered throughout the game, hidden deep within its complex lore. One featured an image of Reno reading from a book on how to "learn Draconic", the language of Dragons.

The most explicit hint given by the developers was a dragon card called "Renogos", which looked and sounded suspiciously like Reno, right down to Reno's iconic hat perched on one of his dragon's horns.

This was confirmed and revealed as part of the expansion pack 'Descent of Dragons'. In the final battle of the 'League of Explorers' campaign, Reno morphs into a dragon to defeat Rafaam and Galakrond.

While it started out as a fan theory, the developers were determined to make it work to please the fans, and after much speculation, have woven it seamlessly into the fabric of the game.

6. Super Mario 3 - It's A Play!

For fans of Super Mario Mario Bros 3, it was clear that this game was aesthetically very different from its predecessors. Fans noticed some unusual details in the background, which led to a popular belief the game was a play where all the characters were actors.

Advertisement

At the beginning of the game, a curtain lifted up like the beginning of a play. Throughout the game, blocks were bolted to background like a set prop, as well as platforms hanging from the roof. It's also worth mentioning that Mario always exits stage right at the end of a level.

In 2015, Mario's legendary creator Shigeru Miyamoto confirmed these rumours in a video entitled 'Mario Myths with Mr Miyamoto'. In the video, a statement would appear on screen, and Miyamoto would offer a thumbs up or thumbs down to confirm or deny the rumours.

To the relief of fans, when asked 'was Super Mario Bros 3 just a performance?' Miyamoto gave a sagely nod, confirming what most fans had speculated for over two decades.

However, if the video is to be entirely believed, then Miyamoto is canonically Bowser Jrs. mother, so we don't know what to think anymore.

5. Mass Effect 3 - Commander Shepard Is Canadian

This one is an anomaly, in that it doesn't concern a fan theory that changes the perception of the game, or something embedded as a game mechanic. It purely concerns the nationality of Commander Shepherd (both male and female), the protagonist of the Mass Effect series.

Advertisement

Specifically, fans thought that Commander Shepherd was a born and bred Canadian.

Developers Bioware were founded and based in Canada, and the male and female voice actors who play Commander Shepherd were both Canadian in origin. This led to a significant portion of fans who were convinced he was Canadian, with other fans stating the character was 'generically' North American.

The developers addressed this indirectly in Mass Effect 3. The prologue is set in Vancouver, albeit a nondescript version of it. If Commander Shepherd strikes up a romance with party member Samantha Traynor, at one point Shepherd tells her "I promise you, in just a few months we'll be sipping drinks back in Vancouver", suggesting that is where Shepherd calls home.

Although it is debatable whether this is a direct confirmation of Shepherd's nationality, at the very least it shows a knowing wink from the developers to this oft speculated fan theory.

4. Mortal Kombat - The Mystery Of Ermac

This is one of the best examples of a video game rumour that gained so much notoriety over time, the developers felt the only way to put it to bed was to make it a part of the series.

Advertisement

Mortal Kombat first made its mark in the arcades in the early nineties, and quickly gained notoriety for its gore and brutal fighting style. There was a limited roster of characters, in particular two ninjas who were visually only distinguishable by their colours.

Rumours swirled that a glitch called error macro, or 'Ermac' for short, would turn Sub Zero, a blue ninja, into a red ninja. In the pre-internet days, it was very easy for unfounded rumours about games to circulate, as it was much harder to validate or disprove theories.

The developers strongly denied the existence of Ermac, saying that such an error simply did not exist. However, this legendary rumour gained so much momentum over time, that the developers decided to call the fans bluff and make it real.

In Mortal Kombat 3, the warrior known as Ermac was introduced to the franchise, and he has become a fan favourite ever since.

3. Metal Gear Solid 5 - Nuclear Disarmament

Rumours were rife upon the release of Metal Gear Solid 5 that a secret cutscene would trigger if all the nukes in the in-game universe had been disarmed by all players.

Advertisement

This was a masterstroke by Hideo Kojima, as he knew it was very unlikely to be achieved. Perhaps it was a riff on humanity always looking to arm itself, and would not be able to focus their efforts on a collective strategy for the betterment of mankind.

In 2015 the rumour was confirmed as the cutscene in question triggered in the PC version. Ironically, the scene didn't trigger because of players vying for collective world peace, but because of a bug in the game.

Although some fans were happy to have the theory validated, there was also annoyance that such a powerful in-game message had not been thought through enough to make it work in practise.

What happens in this hidden cutscene? It's predominantly a monologue about how we must pass on the dangers of nuclear warfare to the next generation.

Ironically, even though this theory is now beyond doubt, it has still brought the player base no closer to achieving total disarmament.

2. Final Fantasy VI - No Bandanas In This Party

Before the landmark Final Fantasy VII which catapulted the series to super-stardom, the underappreciated Final Fantasy VI contained many elements that VII was famous for, such as a gripping story and heartbreaking main character deaths.

Advertisement

A central plot point running throughout the game was a love triangle between gambler playboy Setzer, lovable rogue Locke and love interest Celes, with Setzer and Locke regularly competing for Celes' affection.

When Setzer joins your party, he is equipped by default with a bandana. If you unequip it, the game won't allow you to reequip it. This adds an additional, if slightly unbelievable layer to their fractious relationship.

Gamers theorised that because Locke wore a bandana throughout the game, Setzer chooses not to wear it again, in a move of jealousy, as Locke permanantly sported a bandana.

As improbable as this theory might seen, this theory was confirmed by Square Enix in V-jump magazine over two decades later. There is speculation that this was a glitch which the fan theory conveniently explained away, but regardless of this, it seems to fit well with the story and the characters personalities.

1. Halo: Combat Evolved - The OP Pistol

Halo is one of the most successful gaming franchises of all time, famed in part for some of the most iconic weaponry in gaming history - Halo 2's multiplayer mode brings back both painful and joyous memories of the Energy Sword.

Advertisement

Upon release of Halo: Combat Evolved, many fans were suspicious that the pistol, the default side arm, was the most powerful weapon in the game. This was true of multiplayer as well as single player, the gun able to shred an opponents shield in only a couple of shots.

A revealing interview from Bungie's Director Jason Jones, finally put to bed what fans has been theorising for years. He admitted the studio had been having problems balancing the pistol during development, and so before release changed a "single number" in the pistols coding.

Acknowledging the controversy that befell the game as a result, he stated that "I will take the credit and blame for the pistol in Halo, I'll take the blame for everything in Halo..."

Ultimately, it was the developers passion and care for the game that inadvertently overpowered this weapon; a lesson for us all that last minute changes aren't always a good idea.

Advertisement