10 Video Game Sequels That COMPLETELY Changed Genre
Whether they worked or not, is another story.
Developing a beloved video game series is a tricky business. Changing with the times is made difficult by fan expectation, and the need to evolve is crucial in an increasingly crowded landscape for the medium.
There's nothing worse than seeing a developer's complacency shine through with each subsequent uninspired sequel, and often companies will look to shake up the series with fresh and exciting gameplay mechanics in a bid to do something different.
On more than one occasion, however, aspirations overwhelm tradition, and by altering the formula a little too much a developer's darling franchise can spill into another genre entirely. Sometimes it's for the better, forging new fans and revolutionising the way we play games moving forward, and other times it's proof that innovation has its limits.
It's the devil's own job to strike a balance between creating something fresh and maintaining the level of quality that fans expect, but without that desire to change we'd be left with a gaming outlook that offers no unique experiences and no risks taken to move the medium forward.
Tinkering with the adored game franchises of many is a dangerous game, and success is never guaranteed; quite the opposite.
10. Final Fantasy XIV
Though series mainstays like lengthy cutscenes, an epic storyline and fan favourite chocobos all make a return, Final Fantasy XIV is hugely different to the single player focused titles of previous entries, but its commitment to the MMO genre is evident.
The continent of Eorzea, while already fantastic, is made all the better by the addition of populated online servers, with each and every player on their own journey as a famed Warrior of Light. Never does the setting feel artificial, as NPC's that roam the land are real world people with their own quest to fulfill instead of statue-esque character models who simply blend into the scenery.
Cloud, Squall, Lightning and Locke are nowhere to be seen, active time battles are replaced by a simplistic --though enjoyable-- system that never feels like a chore and emphasis is placed on party progression and social connectivity. It's a huge change for the franchise, and while not every subsequent sequel should be an MMO, this offering is a wonderful change of pace for the seasoned franchise.
Sure, Final Fantasy isn't new to the MMO genre, as its eleventh instalment was the series' first foray into massive multiplayer game design, but XIV saw it done right.
9. Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures
The jump from Arcade and 8-bit home consoles was a jarring transition, with some fairing beautifully (Mega Man) and others stumbling at the first hurdle. Namco, sadly succumbed to the latter.
Creating a sequel to one of the most influential games of all time is no easy feat, so developer Namco didn't even try, as Pac-Man 2 completely does away with the fast paced gameplay of the original. Titles like Ms. Pac-Man are more often considered sequels to the 1980 arcade classic, releasing some two years later, but the thoroughly undeserved '2' plonked on the end of The New Adventures means it, sadly, qualifies as a legitimate entry in the Pac-Man series.
Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures is a point and click adventure, shepherding the Blinky-busting hero through menial day-to-day tasks as he struggles to balance his new responsibilities as husband to Ms. Pac-Man and father to Pac-Baby. Fluctuating between a smile and a frown, you're constantly wondering if Pac-Man wants the game to be over as much as the player does.
With excellent titles like Pac-Man Championship Edition proving that the formula of old still works wonderfully, there's little reason for Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures to exist.
8. Yakuza: Like A Dragon
Yakuza's popularity has grown significantly over the past few years, quickly going from untapped Japanese obscurity to one of video games' most beloved series.
The franchise has been a mainstay on PlayStation systems for a decade and a half, and part of its sustained success was its commitment to flashy, fun fight scenes that seldom get boring. Cracking a traffic cone over a goon's head before switching combat styles and pummelling the rest with your bare hands was always a delight, so it was a surprise when developer Ryu Ga Gotoku saw the opportunity to do something different after Kiryu's tale reached an end in Yakuza 6.
Switching from real-time combat that draws inspiration from classic arcade beat-em-ups, Yakuza: Like A Dragon opts instead for turn-based combat mechanics resembling JRPG titles of old.
The presentation is certainly familiar to fans, and certainly won't be confused for anything other than a Yakuza title, but implementing a combat system similar to that of Persona 5's strategic, yet stylish, gameplay was a radical change to the beloved system of previous entries, and a curious decision to say the least.
7. Fallout 3
Fallout's change to a first person perspective was so long ago that it's hard to recall a time where it wasn't the case.
What is now one of gaming's big hitters, Fallout's beginnings are far more humble than Todd Howard's grand persona would have you think, being developed by Black Isle Studios until Bethesda took the reins for its third entry.
Replacing the 2D isometric graphics with a first person perspective, Bethesda's maiden effort in the series was radically different to previous entries, as Fallout and its sequel each operated using action points, which were to be used to engage in combat scenarios.
Perhaps an attempt to future-proof the series to fit the shooter-heavy AAA landscape, Fallout 3 embraced real time action while simultaneously paying homage to its roots by including a layer of strategy by way of the V.A.T.S system, a series mainstay from here on out.
The change proved commercially vital, as Fallout 3 massively outsold its series elders on its way to becoming one of XBOX 360, PlayStation 3 and PC's most beloved titles.
Fallout would find huge success with subsequent sequels, sure, but it simply wouldn't have been so without the courageous leap that Bethesda took with the third game.
6. Assassins Creed: Origins
Clearly drawing inspiration from CDProjekt's The Witcher III, Ubisoft leaned into the open world genre and with 2017's Assassins Creed: Origins, and went all out in applying heavy RPG mechanics into the franchise.
Existing fans of the series were seemingly an afterthought by developer Ubisoft, as those who cut their teeth with Ezio Auditore's story were left wondering where eavesdropping and target-following main quests had gone.
The new assassin, Bayek, is not unlike the assassins of old and does well to keep the story intriguing with his unrelenting quest for revenge, but his playground of Egypt renders him a far smaller piece of the puzzle as the map is simply so large.
AAA games are undoubtedly shifting to more open-ended level structures (even a series as stubborn as Uncharted embraced non-linearity in places), so it was of little surprise that Ubisoft went down the well-trodden path, but for such a veteran franchise to lean into loot-based exploration and item management was a change that split audiences, despite doubling the sales of the previous entry: Assassin's Creed: Syndicate.
2020's Assassins Creed: Valhalla was a return to form in places, but still boasted an immensely detailed and rich open world brimming with RPG elements.
5. Broken Sword 3: The Sleeping Dragon
Broken Sword's delightful hand drawn aesthetics and traditional adventure game mechanics were a source of great pleasure for the dedicated fanbase that developer Revolution Software had gained on the original PlayStation.
The plucky duo of unlikely heroes --boy scout lawyer George Stobart and inquisitive reporter Nico Collard-- captured the hearts of many with their bid to unravel some of the world's great mysteries.
The pair's third adventure, and first on PS2, veered into an all new direction as developer Sumo Digital took the reins of the franchise. Drifting away from the tried and tested point and click genre proved a risky move, and subsequent sequels have since returned, but the black sheep of the series, titled 'The Sleeping Dragon' still delivered a wonderful adventure, if a little different from what we'd known before.
The gorgeous pencilled art style, brimming with colours and making your jaw drop with every scene was replaced with murky environments and blocky textures that do not stand the test of time, alongside a gameplay design that radically alters the formula in favour of a more 'natural' way to play.
Broken Sword 3 is by no means a bad game, but the franchise has certainly seen better days.
4. Kid Icarus: Uprising
Kid Icarus: Uprising was so detached --both in time between entries and in genre-- from its predecessors that you'd be forgiven for thinking it was a wholly new IP from Nintendo.
Though the series remained dormant for much of the 90's and indeed all of the 2000's, Kid Icarus' protagonist, Pit, won the hearts of fans with his inclusion in Super Smash Bros Brawl, so much so that Masahiro Sakurai rebooted Kid Icarus for the 3DS in 2012, but ditched the 2D gameplay in favour of an awkward third person perspective.
Pit's last outing, Kid Icarus: Of Myths and Monsters, released on the Game Boy in late 1991 in North America and early 1992 in Europe, and being on an underpowered handheld (even for the time) brought limitations.
Uprising was far more chaotic than the series' beginnings, and was actually made playable by support of the Circle Pad Pro. Graphics are glitzy, and gameplay is thrilling. You'll be flying through the air, peppering baddies with a smorgasbord of bullets on your way to ridding the world of the evil forces in Greek mythology.
Pit is more synonymous with Smash than his own franchise, and Uprising was a reminder that there's more to the heavenly hero.
3. The Bureau: XCOM Declassified
In the ever-expanding strategy genre, more and more franchises are finding success by the day, yet none wield a name as revered as XCOM. It's as synonymous with strategy as Peter Molyneux is with broken promises, and as such is placed under immense scrutiny whenever it decides to make a change to its winning recipie.
Other than the protagonist's superb name (though that was a personal surprise), XCOM Declassified stunned fans of the franchise with a third person shooter perspective to serve as the prequel to 2012's Enemy Unknown, a more traditional approach to gameplay that XCOM 2 later resorted back to.
That's not to say it completely ditched the strategic elements of games past, and it's not as though it'll be mistaken for Uncharted 2 any time soon, but the cover-based gunplay was certainly a startling change from the top-down perspective of most other entries in the series, and left a lot of existing fans wondering how their appetite would be satisfied.
The risk proved critically redundant, as it garnered a mixed response from reviewers. A far cry from the lofty heights of its predecessor and indeed the 2016 sequel to Enemy Unknown.
2. Castlevania: Symphony Of The Night
Ditching stage-based level design and opting to revolutionise 2D gaming using non-linear mechanics later dubbed 'MetroidVania', Symphony of the Night's switching of genre was the best decision Konami ever made with the franchise.
The original CastleVania games on the NES are some of the most revered games of the 20th century. Their tricky difficulty and stunning pixel art weaved together with fantastic level design and wonderful music to create a collection of games that still yields so much enjoyment some thirty five years and six console generations later.
Altering the formula that brought developer Konami so much success was surely a silly idea, or so we thought.
CastleVania: Symphony of the Night took inspiration from the series' second title, Simon's Quest, but went all in on its non-linear structure. Dracula's castle was the playground for Alucard to wreak havoc upon, slicing through baddies after a brush with Death renders him far less powerful than he was when he entered his fathers' domain.
The castle is the setting throughout, even when flipped at the half-way point. Adventuring through its halls, levelling up as you go, is the hook that keeps you coming back, as high score-based gameplay is left in the rear view mirror.
1. Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
If ever there was a flag-bearer for lengthy cinematic cutscenes to carry a game's narrative, it's Hideo Kojima's crowning achievement: the Metal Gear series. Born in 1987 and reaching its conclusion(?) in 2015, the convoluted story of super soldier Big Boss and his unlikely offspring was born on the NES, but found a home on Sony's flagship console, the original PlayStation, with the seminal Metal Gear Solid.
The series went from strength to strength, stopping by the PS2 generation and delivering two of the greatest experiences in the video game medium before arriving at Sony's first ever handheld system; the PSP.
While most AAA franchises deliver a half-hearted effort for handheld systems or simply forgo the portable entry all together, Kojima and co. made their title, Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker, a pivotal piece of the Metal Gear story.
Set during Big Boss' creation of Mother Base (until it's destroyed in Ground Zeroes) in 1974, Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker had to alter its otherwise linear approach to storytelling and instead opt for bitesize mission-based progression, accounting for the pick-up-put-down nature of portable gaming.
This paired with --frankly gorgeous-- comic-inspired cutscenes lost precisely none of the charm that previous entries in the series had.