10 Video Game Spin-Offs That Surpass The Original

Best.Spin-Off.EVER.

By James Egan /

When a video game becomes a hit, a follow-up is practically guaranteed. If that instalment is also a success, another sequel should be on the cards. Then another. Then another. Then another.

Advertisement

But at a certain point, an IP should venture in a different direction to avoid becoming stale. In situations like this, the next logical step is a spin-off. By focusing on a different character, looking at the same story from another angle, or dropping the characters in a new genre, there are plenty of avenues a spin-off can go in.

Of course, fans might not have gravitate towards these little experiments, especially if they deviate too far from the original. Even if the premise seems great on paper, the finished product doesn't always come together.

But every once in a while, an offshoot of a popular title captures the same magic as the one that started it all. Some byproducts outgrew the source material, to the point where fans don't realise they originated from a different franchise. This is all the more impressive when the side-game was unwanted or initially sounded like a bad idea. (Seriously, it's impossible to make The Sims sound appealing to anyone who hasn't played it.)

As awesome as these games are, there's no question the spin-offs are better.

10. Apex Legends (Titanfall)

Despite having little connection with Titanfall, Apex Legends is classed as an offshoot of Respawn's mega mecha-shooter. Not only does this instalment share many features and mechanics, Apex Legends actually started off as Titanfall 3.

Advertisement

But since the project lacked core elements, including a one-player campaign, pilots, and the titular Titans, this instalment was revised into a separate entity.

Although this was a ballsy decision, it paid off (especially after Titanfall 2 suffered an abominable release). Though Apex Legends had to compete with other Battle Royales like Fortnite and PUBG, it was an instant hit. The free-to-play title won over millions with its nuanced mechanics and accessible gameplay. The "ping" system was applauded for allowing squad members to communicate with each other without relying on verbal cues.

Apex Legends brought in 25 million players in the first week, doubling that amount within a month. Two years later, it achieved one of the highest player counts of any game, and raked in over a billion dollars in revenue.

Even though Titanfall is solid, it never came close to matching its successor, critically or financially.

9. Mega Man Zero (Mega Man)

After the original Mega Man franchise grew stagnant, Capcom rejuvenated things with the rebooted Mega Man X, which was hailed as a return to form. However, this iteration inevitably fell into a slump, manifesting some of the worst titles in the series. (No Mega Man fan should play X7. It'll break your heart.)

Advertisement

Luckily, Capcom nailed it with the next reboot, Mega Man Zero. Set a century after X's timeline, the story centres around a re-activated Zero, who must stop a new global threat.

It was risky to focus on Zero rather than the Blue Bomber we all know and loved, but everything worked out with this bold direction. Customisation in weapons and armour is a big factor this time around, offering more variety in the gameplay. Rather than being shackled by the Mega Buster, Zero has an array of upgradable weapons, diversifying the combat.

Extra attention is given to developing characters, expanding the plot, and connecting each instalment, making players more invested in the overarching narrative.

Most importantly, MMZ never suffers a dramatic decline in quality, which can't be said about the original or the X saga. Boasting six solid entries, Mega Man Zero is worth anyone's time, especially if they want a platformer that invokes the spirit of the classics, while still feeling fresh.

8. Unreal Tournament (Unreal)

Just as first-person shooters were on the cusp of going stale, Unreal came onto the scene and revitalised the genre. Whether it was the graphics, music, or the enemy AI, it was hard to find fault with the epic shooter.

Advertisement

Save for one issue. Despite all the praise Unreal received, it was evident the online multiplayer was let down by lag. Recognising this flaw, Epic Games and Digital Extremes tried to fine-tune the network code, hoping to release a multiplayer expansion pack.

As the project grew, so did the companies' ambition. Believing they had enough material for a whole new game, the creators released a spin-off called Unreal Tournament, focusing more on online playing.

Rather than just chucking out the same title with a more refined multiplayer, everything was overhauled to perfection. By improving the enemy AI, polishing the character models, and balancing the weapons, the final result was unreal. (I couldn't help myself.)

Despite setting the bar through the stratosphere and beyond, Unreal Tournament's follow-ups remained just as consistent.

And when Unreal's only official sequel, The Awakening, received average reviews at best, it was further proof Tournament had outstripped the original.

7. Hyrule Warriors (Dynasty Warriors)

Starting off as a traditional fighting title, Koei Tecmo's Dynasty Warriors quickly transitioned into a crowd-combat hack-and-slash. The gameplay centred around securing besieged kingdoms and defeating armies while manoeuvring multiple military units in different locations.

Advertisement

However, what made Dynasty Warriors stand out is how easily the heroes could take on an entire legion. With a single sword slash, our nobles warriors could devastate dozens of soldiers at a time.

Despite a solid start, things eventually went downhill, with the later sequels heavily criticised for their repetitive gameplay. Looking for a fresh angle (or trying to keep things afloat), Koei joined forces with Nintendo to create a Legend of Zelda crossover called Hyrule Warriors.

Not only did this spin-off reinvigorate Dynasty Warriors, it was awesome to watch Link, Impa, Zelda and Tingle cut loose in a way never seen before in the mainstream series. On top of that, getting to play as iconic villains like Zant, Ghirahim, and Ganondorf was fan-service at its best. The success of Hyrule Warriors spawned a follow-up, which was also well-received.

Sure, these instalments had some problems, but Hyrule Warriors was more consistent, refined, and dynamic than the games it spawned from.

With Dynasty Warriors still struggling to find its footing, it's even more apparent the LoZ crossover is the best thing the franchise has ever done.

6. The Sims (SimCity)

The original SimCity may be rudimentary by today's standards, but the idea that players could construct an entire city in real-time in a game from 1980s was mind-blowing. Though the sequels tossed in new features and better graphics, the premise remained the same. After all, why change something if it's working perfectly?

Advertisement

However, the franchise went through a huge change-up after its creator, Will Wright, lost his house in a fire. Obsessing over how the fire wouldn't have spread if his home was arranged differently, Wright worked this idea into a new game that focused on a neighbourhood instead of a city.

Interestingly, the game that became 2000's The Sims wasn't meant to revolve around people. As the project took shape, Wright realised that rearranging furniture wasn't as engaging as characters building relationships, not just with each other but the player. By giving the NPCs their own routines and quirky behaviour, the gaming experience wasn't just more personal, but funnier.

At first, the higher-ups at Maxis thought The Sims sounded ridiculous, calling the project a "dollhouse". (To be fair, that was the original title.) Luckily, they changed their tune when The Sims garnered rave reviews and sold over ten million copies.

Though 2003's SimCity 4 was well-received, it didn't come close to matching The Sims sales, encouraging Maxis to focus more on the spin-off's continuation.

5. World Of Warcraft (Warcraft)

Contrary to what some believe, Warcraft: Orcs & Humans wasn't the first multiplayer game to rely on real-time strategy.

Advertisement

However, it did help popularise the genre, to the point where many RTS games imitated its structure and mechanics. Even though the sequels maintained a steady standard, it looked like Warcraft wasn't going to redefine the genre a second time.

Oh, how wrong we were. Though the original Warcraft series could be played offline, everything shifted when Blizzard turned 2004's World of Warcraft into a pure MMORPG. The mammoth-sized game expanded in every department possible, offering more varied quests, PvP battles, dungeons, raids, and boss battles.

Not only was the world bigger than ever, downtime and loading screens were kept to a minimum, keeping players immersed. Though grinding is a common problem in the best RPGs, the diversity in WoW's quests made this issue practically non-existent. With this world teeming with boundless content, WoW didn't just give RTS games a good shake-up - it revolutionised the entire industry.

World of Warcraft's best days may be behind it, but it doesn't change the fact it was a gaming juggernaut for over a decade, blowing the original out of the water.

4. Pokémon Legends: Arceus (Pokémon)

Pokemon Red/Blue wasn't just a success, but a global phenomenon. The dual RPGs kicked off a monster franchise (literally) that's collectively sold more units than Super Mario, which is a first for Nintendo.

Advertisement

Having said that, the later instalments have suffered heavy scrutiny for their glitches, lack of content, and the fact they're still following the same formula after 25 years.

For this reason, it was a breath of fresh air when Game Freak released Pokemon Legends: Arceus in 2022. Preserving the core gameplay of the mainstream titles, the Switch exclusive's immense open-world offered players an unprecedented level of freedom.

Although the last two Pokemon Gens were criticised for their underwhelming graphics, Arceus was championed for its luscious art style. Many integral mechanics were refined, including catching and battling the titular critters.

The transitions from the Pokemon battles back into the open-world is seamless now, since it isn't constantly interrupted by experience points breakdowns and Pokemon levelling up, learning moves, or evolving.

Basically, Arceus gave fans the Pokemon experience they always craved and deserved. With the recent Gen series dwindling in quality, Pokemon Legends could become the definitive Pokemon franchise if Game Freak continue down this path.

3. Forza Horizon (Forza Motorsport)

Since Gran Turismo is a Sony-exclusive, Microsoft director, Kiki Wolfkill (awesome name) wanted the Xbox to have its own driving franchise, which led to the creation of Forza Motorsport. Though Forza received positive reviews straight out the gate, it still found itself eating GT's dust.

Advertisement

However, all that changed with the 2005 spin-off, Forza Horizon. Rather than burning rubber on locked-in racing tracks, Horizon takes place in an open world, allowing drivers to travel wherever they want (within reason).

Although there's plenty of missions, there's nothing better than going for an aimless wander, zooming through flourishing forests, urban towns, and colossal canyons.

Just when it feels like the series couldn't get any more accolades, Horizon 5 revved things up to a whole other level. The raytracing tech makes the already photorealistic graphics look truly eye-watering. No matter how fast the cars move or how much content is on-screen, it never makes a dent in the frame-rate, letting players admire every pixel.

And with 2023's Forza Motorsport receiving mostly negative reviews from Steam players, it further highlights how far this spin-off has come. Not only has Horizon surpassed Motorsport, it's set a new benchmark in what a racer can be.

2. Persona (Shin Megami Tensei)

Most of the Western world was oblivious Persona was a a spin-off for years, since it was the first instalment in the Shin Megami Tensei saga available outside of Japan. Although the original series has since been released worldwide, the wacky and hyperstylised offshoot proved more popular.

Advertisement

Though Persona is a turn-based title like its predecessor, it combines other elements including dungeon-crawling, social simulations, and a visual novel-styled story. The combat is less technical, making the battles more accessible and diverse. Social connections are crucial to boosting stats and unlocking powers, making every aspect of the gaming personal (hence the title).

Although Persona started off as a great spin-off, Persona 5 singlehandedly transformed it into a gold-standard franchise. The gorgeous art direction, Shoji Meguero's composition, the thought-provoking narrative, and the flawless fighting mechanics presented a riveting experience that Shin Megami Tensei never managed. Persona 5 was such a hit, it spawned three sidequels (with one more on the way).

Even though Shin Megami Tensei is still going strong, Persona has proven to be, not just one of the best spin-offs, but among the best RPGs ever.

1. Super Mario (Donkey Kong)

Due to Super Mario's literal star power, it's easy to forget Nintendo's moustachioed mascot wasn't always a big name. Heck, he didn't have a name at first!

Advertisement

Debuting in 1981's Donkey Kong, "Jumpman" had to dash across hazardous platforms to rescue his girlfriend, Pauline, from the titular barrel-tossing ape. After DK's success, a spin-off was created in 1983, simply called Mario Bros.

Although Mario was a popular character, the coin-collecting hero wasn't a powerhouse IP yet. That all changed upon the release of Super Mario Bros. Due to the precision of the controls, the catchy jingles, and the astoundingly addictive gameplay, Mario became a household name overnight.

SMB was such a game-changer, it'd still be considered among the most influential creations in gaming, even if the franchise never took off.

Thankfully, it did. For 40 years, Mario has consistently remained a pioneer, influencing the industry time and time again. Even though Donkey Kong held his own for a time, he hasn't maintained the same level of consistency as the Mushroom Kingdom's saviour.

Mario has become such a titan, he's fittingly spawned his own myriad of spin-offs, including Mario Kart, Paper Mario, WarioWare, Luigi's Mansion, Yoshi's Island, and countless more.

And with the glowing reviews of 2023's Super Mario Wonder, it's obvious the overall-sporting handyman is still in his element.

Advertisement