10 Video Game Villains You Hated Killing

Wheatley deserved better.

By James Egan /

In gaming, there are often many incentives to kill the bad guy. By doing so, you can unlock new powers, receive experience points, pick up new weapons, or, at the very least, access new areas.

Advertisement

But there's another factor that often drives the player to pounding enemies into the dirt: Blind hatred. After your nemesis has tortured your loved ones, kidnapped your child, or slaughtered your family, you are compelled to complete every task, wipe out every minion, and beat every level to destroy the person who caused you so much misery.

But every once in a while, you'll encounter a foe that you don't want to kill. When you realise how logical the antagonist's motivation is or see a more human side to them, you might lose all impetus to put them in the ground.

But because players often learn their enemy isn't evil incarnate very late in the game, too many factors are in motion for you to spare them. As a result, you are force to kill them, even if every fibre in your being is telling you not to.

10. The Beauty And The Beast Unit - Metal Gear Solid IV: Guns Of The Patriots

Hideo Kojima's fourth outing of his most iconic gaming franchise has Solid Snake tasked with taking down Liquid Ocelot. During his mission, our one-eyed hero will face a hit squad called The Beauty and the Beast Unit. Because this group consists of four buxom ladies, you assume they were only inserted into the plot to serve as one-dimensional femme fatales.

Advertisement

But after destroying their nano-powered armour, the B & B members reveal how they've suffered from the atrocities of war, leaving them with PTSD. Instead of receiving psychiatric help, Liquid Ocelot preyed on the women's trauma to turn them into his own Snake-hunting team.

The all-female quartet only agreed to Ocelot's terms because they were under the impression that eliminating Snake would relieve their pain.

So, these ladies aren't evil nor do they have any personal problem with Snake. They are mentally fragile, and were manipulated to become your enemy.

What's worse is that none of them can survive after their cybernetic suit is disconnected from their body. So, after each of them has their armour removed, all they can do is beg, cry, and apologise before perishing.

9. Asgore - Undertale

Despite serving as the penultimate enemy of Undertale, it's virtually impossible to dislike Asgore Dreemurr. Being the Ruler of the Underground, it's Asgore's sworn duty to break the barrier between worlds, allowing his people to gain access to the Surface.

Advertisement

To achieve this feat, Asgore must kill seven Humans and use their Souls to destroy the barrier. Basically, Asgore must kill to bring peace. Although tyrants regularly use this excuse to justify their evil intentions, Asgore takes no joy in his actions. Considering his people will be trapped in the Underground forever unless Asgore breaks the barrier, he's in a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" scenario.

Even though he's trying to kill you, you know that every aspect of his personality stems from a pure place. He brings hope to the denizens of the Underground. He loves gardening. He eats butterscotch pie. He says "golly"! Have you ever heard of an evil person say "golly?"

Asgore may be your enemy but he is far from wicked. He is a loving person who's been forced to make an impossible choice to save his people.

8. Grima - Fire Emblem: Awakening

In Fire Emblem Awakening, Robin, Chrom, and The Shepherd Army have united to prepare for the return of Grima - a Fell Dragon who awakens every millennium to ravage the world.

Advertisement

Now, winning this Nintendo 3DS exclusive takes at least 30 hours. But if you want to complete every single sidequest, you're probably looking at over a hundred hours of playtime.

And if you're playing this tactical RPG for that long, it's impossible not to get emotionally attached to the characters, especially your avatar, Robin. He/she is noble, determined, romantic, modest, and altruistic. (Robin's only real flaw is they're overcritical of their own cooking.)

That's why you are completely blindsided when you learn Grima intends to return by using Robin as a vessel. In the climax, the player is left with two options - You can send Grima back into a deep slumber, knowing he'll eventually return, or you can allow Robin to destroy the Fell Dragon, causing them both to fade to nothing. Whatever your choice may be, you can't help feeling empty inside, knowing the ramifications of your actions.

7. Wheatley - Portal 2

Throughout Portal 2, a dimwitted robot called Wheatley helps Chell traverse through the Aperture Science facility and defeat the nefarious supercomputer, GLaDOS.

Advertisement

Because Wheatley has assisted you from the very beginning, Chell believes the most sensible thing to do when she confronts GLaDOS is to swap her core for his, giving Wheatley full control of the facility.

Immediately after doing so, Wheatley goes mad with power, and attempts to kill Chell. GLaDOS then explains to Chell that Wheatley was designed to be incompetent, in a vain attempt to hinder her intelligence. Left with no choice, Chell and GLaDOS team up and agree to deactivate Wheatley before his stupidity results in the facility's destruction.

In the climax, Chell defeats Wheatley by portalling him to the moon, moments before the building goes kablooey.

And yet, you still feel bad at the idea of Wheatley floating through space forever. Even though he was trying to kill you, it was only because he was programmed act like a moron.

Until he was placed in GLaDOS' body, he was genuinely trying to help you. He betrayed you, not out of spite, but out of idiocy.

6. Handsome Jack - Borderlands 2

Normally, gamers feels bad about killing a villain because he or she had some redeemable quality.

Advertisement

But that’s not the case with Borderlands 2’s big bad, Handsome Jack. This egomaniacal dictator belittles the player every time they fail to save somebody. He constantly reminds you of all of your friends he’s murdered. Time and time again, he proves to be the most arrogant, heartless, sadistic, smug, and malevolent person on the planet.

And yet, you still don’t want him to die for one simple reason – He is so goddamn entertaining. Whether he's bragging about his pony made of diamonds or talking about the time he scooped a guy's eyeballs out with a spoon, you can't help being amused by his innovative witticism and ridiculous anecdotes.

As brilliant as Jack's dialogue is written, it's the impeccable delivery of voice actor, Dameon Clarke, that makes Handsome Jack the best character in the series by a mile.

Even when Jack is at your mercy in the game's closing moments, you’ll allow him to prattle on as long as possible, just to hear every hilarious quip before finishing him off.

5. Orphan Of Kos - Bloodborne

Being the final boss of Bloodborne's The Old Hunters DLC, the player expects The Orphan of Kos to provide a serious challenge. But this nightmarish husk is so merciless, he's hailed as one of the toughest bosses ever. Since he's sure to make the player very well-acquainted with death, you'd assume you'd be over the moon after defeating him.

Advertisement

However, you will feel nothing but remorse from The Orphan of Kos' demise after learning of his origins.

Based on the lore, it's been theorised that Kos' "poor wizened child" died after his father was desecrated by the old hunters. The child's mother cursed the hunters, and any who followed in their footsteps, to a limbo-like realm called The Hunter's Nightmare, where The Orphan resides.

Even if the player is oblivious to this backstory, it's unmistakable that this creature is suffering. (I mean, anyone who tosses their placenta around in a fight probably has issues.) When he sobs beside his father's corpse, it tugs on your heartstrings. As he gazes at the moon, paralysed by his own melancholy, you just want to leave him in peace.

After you've learned of The Orphan's backstory, you want to kill him, not just to win the DLC, but to put an end to his suffering.

4. Grey Crow - Death's Door

In Death’s Door, you play as a Reaper – a crow servant of Death who makes an honest living harvesting souls. In the beginning of your adventure, you encounter a former Reaper called Grey Crow, who asks for your assistance. If you help him locate the soul he was assigned to harvest, he can retire for good.

Advertisement

After you’ve collected all the main souls in your mission, you and Grey Crow walk through Death's Door, where his assigned soul supposedly resides.

But upon entering, Death itself appears, alerting Grey Crow that he took too long to find his assigned soul, causing it to fade away. Realising that he was spent centuries on a fool’s errand, Grey Crow is heartbroken and enraged.

Worse still, Death informs him that any soul that lives beyond their "best before date" is destined to go mad, meaning Grey Crow's lapse of sanity is inevitable.

Almost on cue, Grey Crow becomes feral, forcing you to battle him to death. Even though it’s The Reaper’s duty to harvest souls, it’s impossible to take any joy from this fight, knowing Grey Crow has wasted his life away.

3. Quelaag - Dark Souls

It's easy to perceive each enemy in Dark Souls has mindless monsters, even though many of them have detailed backstories to prove they're anything but.

Advertisement

That goes double for Quelaag the Chaos Witch, since she is half-woman, half-demon spider. With her enflamed body, pronged limbs, and her lava-belching mouth, there's no reason to believe Quelaag harbours a shred of humanity.

But this arthropodal hybrid is far more than she appears. By investigating her room, you will find Quelaag's sister, Quellan the Fair Lady. If you speak to her, you'll learn she's been left blind and gravely ill, after she attempted to heal the residents of Blighttown. Knowing her fate, Quelaag vowed to make her remaining moments as peaceful as possible.

So, when you broke into Quelaag's domain, she wasn't attacking you out of malice. She was safeguarding her sister.

Do you know what makes this more tragic? You won't know any of this unless you're wearing the Old Witch's Ring when you encounter Quellan. If you didn't equip this piece of jewellery, you were probably chuffed upon murdering Quelaag, oblivious that all she wanted to do was protect her ailing sibling.

2. Ira Hogeboom - LA Noire

In the final stages of LA Noire, Detective Cole Phelps learns of an arsonist who's burning houses down throughout the city, which has resulted in the deaths of several civilians.

Advertisement

But when Phelps learns the arsonist is a mentally ill man who's been manipulated by a deranged psychiatrist, you no longer see him as a monster, but a victim.

However, it's all the more heartbreaking when Phelps learns the man he's hunting is Ira Hogeboom – a flamethrower from Phelps' squad during World War II. During one mission, Hogeboom was ordered to incinerate a cave, under the belief the enemy was hiding within. But when he learned he had just burned a group of civilians alive, he was left traumatised.

As horrific as this revelation is, it's not the worst part. Hogeboom's orders were given by Cole Phelps, meaning our so-called hero is indirectly responsible for all the atrocities that Hogeboom committed.

When you finally confront Hogeboom in the final scene, you don't see him as an evil man. Instead, he comes across as a broken individual who’s been taken advantage of by those in power. When Phelps' partner shoots him, Hogeboom doesn't put up a fight, glad his pain has come to an end.

1. The Stranger - The Walking Dead

While Lee is trying to survive the zombie apocalypse in The Walking Dead, a mysterious man hijacks his walkie talkie signal, threatening to destroy Lee's life.

Advertisement

When this unnamed person kidnaps a girl that Lee is protecting called Clementine, it’s easy to assume the kidnapper is evil incarnate.

But when you finally meet this stranger, you learn he’s the owner of the car that Lee’s group ransacked earlier. Because they stole his food and supplies, The Stranger’s family died, compelling him to seek Lee out to exact his revenge.

Despite the fact Lee and his allies did what they needed to survive, it doesn't change the fact their actions killed a family and destroyed a man's life. Although we don't know anything about The Stranger, including his name, it's safe to assume he was a loving husband and father before his family was taken away from him.

Just before Lee enters The Stranger's room, every impulse is telling you to stomp this guy to death for kidnapping and endangering an innocent child. But after speaking to him, the players realises The Stranger isn’t the monster. You are.

Even though Lee has to murder The Stranger to save Clementine, it's clear he takes no pleasure in it, nor does the player.

Advertisement