10 Video Games Critics Loved (That IMMEDIATELY Divided Fans)
Let's break down these so-called "masterpieces".
In the world of cinema, there can be a chasm-sized difference between what the critics and moviegoers enjoy. These sort of disagreements are fair, since all entertainment is subjective.
But when it comes to gaming, fans and professional reviewers usually find themselves in the same boat. I mean, have you ever met anyone who didn't instantly fall in love with Portal or Mario Kart?
Because it's clear as day whether or not a shooter or platformer's graphics or controls are up to the par, it's usually not up for debate. As a result, it's refreshing when the "experts" state that a hyped title has exceeded all expectations.
But when gamers get their hands on these "classics in the making," they may quickly realise they don't agree with the initial assessment. Over the years, many titles, once touted as the cream of the crop, are now considered overrated, average, or downright terrible. Some of these games received so much flack since their release, it's baffling to believe there was a time where anyone thought they were flawless.
Critics may have gushed over these ten video games back in the day, but the gaming community has a very different say on the matter.
10. The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword received glowing reviews across the board, and was the 16th game ever to receive a perfect score from Famitsu. Critics raved over the Wii MotionPlus peripheral, which enabled Link to perform precise movements with his sword and shield, allowing for more immersive battles and puzzles.
However, Nintendo fans couldn't see eye-to-eye with critics, especially when it came to Skyward Sword's unique controller. Many gamers found the Wii MotionPlus imprecise, impairing their ability to perform the simplest tasks. And when the controller was required for complex puzzles, players were in serious trouble.
Even if the peripheral wasn't an issue, Skyward Sword has many other issues, including filler side-quests, an infuriating final dungeon, the worst boss in the franchise's history, and a sidekick that's so vexatious, she makes Navi seem tolerable.
When Skyward Sword was remastered for the Switch, it was the perfect time to reassess it. Since the gaming community preemptively hated on Wind Waker, it was possible that some players had jumped the gun once again.
Although some issues were fixed in the remaster (Fi shuts up now), many glaring problems were still apparent, reaffirming the fact Skyward Sword was a misfire.
9. Street Fighter 6
Street Fighter 6 wasn't just a success, but a return to form for Capcom's opulent fighting saga. The franchise's latest outing boasts a detailed character creator feature, a diverse online mode, and a vast open-world to explore.
Then there's the fighting. Even though Street Fighter's combat system never needed to be reinvented, the Drive System enhanced the battles in a way nobody had seen before. SF6 also incorporates a unique arrangement that allowed blind and sight-impaired gamers to play, proving Capcom had gone above and beyond to satisfy players.
Despite boasting a Metacritic score of 92, SF6's user rating was far less positive. The PS5 version's user rating was only 6.0, while the Xbox Series X port was rated with a bafflingly low 4.5. Although it's no secret SF6 suffered the wrath of trolls, many complaints were completely fair.
The sudden texture dips make the characters momentarily look like they belong on a PS2 game. The main campaign encourages grinding, making the gameplay repetitive. Fans were disappointed by the absence of iconic fighters, such as M. Bison, Vega, and Sagat, none of which are guaranteed to be included in the future. There was such a backlash on the game's reliance on overpriced DLC, Capcom was compelled to address the issue on Twitter.
Street Fighter 6 is still a stellar title, but it looks like the critics didn't address key issues in their initial assessments.
8. Halo 4
It's difficult to criticise Halo 4 without sounding like a nitpicker. While analysing the graphics, gunplay, animations, and pacing individually, it's tough to find fault. The campaign is tightly packed and demonstrates a tremendous variety in gameplay. The development between Master Chief and Cortana's relationship deserves special mention, since their deep bond serves as the heart of the overarching narrative.
So, what's the problem? Well, Halo had been, up until this point, a franchise that managed to outdo itself over and over. But this time around, it felt like the the bar had not been raised.
For example, the music in Halo 4 is fine. But because the scores of the previous three instalments were groundbreaking, "fine" just wasn't good enough.
One of the defining features of the series is the visual design. Unfortunately, Halo 4 traded the iconic, alien landscapes for more typical sci-fi environments, reducing the visual charm that Xbox owners have come to expect.
The core gameplay felt overly familiar, lacking the freshness that characterised earlier titles. The multiplayer mode was lacklustre, due to the uninspired maps and unbalanced gameplay mechanics.
Although Halo has been revolutionary since day 1, Halo 4 didn't bring a lot to the table.
7. Doom 3
Doom 3 received a Metacritic score of 88%, with reviews applauding its lifelike graphics, tense atmosphere, and focus on story.
However, many gamers had such an aversion to this threequel, it sounded like they were complaining about a completely different IP.
Players find it frustrating how our hero is unable to hold his weapon and his flashlight simultaneously. Because of this, the player often has to decide between being armed or being able to see. This mechanic is extra irritating, since nearly every level is shrouded in darkness. Gamers spend so much time whipping out and putting away their torch, it ruins the immersion.
But Doom 3's biggest problem is the fact it doesn't feel like Doom. Rather than encouraging the player to explore in an open-world, this instalment has a relatively linear level design.
Doom has always benefitted from its minimal structure, since it amplifies the chaos when the player encounters demons from all directions. But since Doom 3 has the protagonist following a set path, the unpredictable element is absent.
Even though critics were onboard with Doom 3, id Software took fans' criticism onboard, going back to basics for the follow-up.
6. Destiny 2
Fixing many issues of its predecessor, Destiny 2 was perceived as everything the first instalment should've been. The Bungie sequel had a more accessible storyline, taut gunplay, fleshed out villains, and a complete lack of Peter Dinklage. (No respect to Dinklage, but your casting wasn't right.)
Although Destiny 2 took a step in the right direction, a closer examination reveals much of the hype was unwarranted. While the gameplay mechanics are serviceable, they become routine after a while. The vast majority of missions, especially the Lost Sectors, can be boiled down to the same formula: go here, defeat enemies, and fetch an item or activate a device.
The lack of variety within the missions and objectives diminishes the overall experience, leading to a repetitive grind that quickly becomes tiresome. Overall, Destiny 2 shares so many similarities to its precursor, it feels more like a DLC or a revision. It's no wonder it earned the moniker "Destiny 1.5".
Sadly, the pay-to-win gameplay from the previous entry has been amped up, destroying any sense of skill-based progression. Because many players had a major gripe with this unbalanced system, it's bewildering the developers decided to keep it for the sequel.
5. Super Mario Sunshine
It's difficult to comprehend the impact Super Mario 64 had on the video game industry. Not only was it a marvellous game in its own right, it showcased the power of the Nintendo 64 and proved 3D platformers were the future of gaming.
So, when Nintendo released the follow-up, Super Mario Sunshine, no one was surprised by the overwhelming reception it received. Revered as "better than Super Mario 64" by multiple critics, fans couldn't wait to experience the goomba-stomping plumber's latest caper.
But Mario Sunshine is not remembered in the best light. Even though Mario's FLUDD backpack and its water mechanics were praised by critics, this was the factor many gamers took umbrage with. Although Mario has always been renowned for its simplicity and precision, using FLUDD doesn't always come easy. Ironically, the sections where Mario loses his backpack were lauded, since they focused on old-school platforming.
But that's not all. Some sections and puzzles feel rushed and unpolished (especially the final boss, who can be defeated in 30 seconds). Despite the fact Super Mario 64 pioneered the 3D camera system, it's widely inconsistent this time around.
Fortunately, Nintendo got back on track with the sequel, Super Mario Galaxy, and the overall-sporting mascot hasn't had a dip since. But because of this, Sunshine feels like a blemish in the franchise's otherwise spotless record.
4. Final Fantasy XVI
At one point, the release of the next Final Fantasy was a cause for celebration, since nearly every instalment was considered a masterpiece. Unfortunately, Square Enix has had quite a few duds recently (and not just in Final Fantasy). As such, fans have become a bit more cautionary.
But based on the initial impressions on Final Fantasy XVI, such concerns seemed unsanctioned. The customisable combat mechanics offer players an endlessly engaging battle system. Masayoshi Soken returns to score, once again composing yet another magnificent soundtrack. Even though it feels redundant to praise the visuals, the way FFXVI merges fantastical elements into a photorealistic aesthetic makes every frame look magnificent.
However, purists might be turned off, since FFXVI has done away with multiple staples, including MP, elemental strengths and weaknesses, and a set party. Even though the combat is bombastically creative, it feels closer to Devil May Cry than Final Fantasy.
To some gamers, these alterations shouldn't be a problem whatsoever. But because Final Fantasy XVI has made a lot of key changes, veterans of the franchise may struggle to recognise it as Final Fantasy at all.
3. Deathloop
Even though Deathloop was initially hailed as an innovative and mind-bending gaming experience, the gaming community quickly turned on Arkane Studio's chrono-weaving FPS.
Ironically, the sandbox shooter's most common criticism resides within its premise. Because the missions revolve around completing the same objectives repeatedly, it's only a matter of time (literally) before the monotony seeps in. Despite the game's attempts to maintain variety through different areas and enemy encounters, the repetitive nature of the gameplay ultimately becomes tiresome. Once players have completed the story and explored the intricacies of each loop, the game loses its appeal, leading to a lack of long-term engagement.
Although Deathloop was meant to represent next-gen tech, it suffers from quite a few technical glitches. Because of the level of precision required throughout each mission, frame-rate drops and performance issues heavily impair the immersion.
Now, that's not suggesting Deathloop isn't worth checking out. As the player memorises the enemy patterns upon each loop, it's empowering the way the player can wipe the floor with them with little effort. Also, the invasion is an ingenious mechanic that keeps players on their toes during each campaign.
Nevertheless, Deathloop is not the showstopper we were led to believe.
2. Heavy Rain
Even though critics initially acted like Quantum Dream's detective thriller, Heavy Rain, was without fault, gamers proved it was anything but. Despite the melancholic tone and tragic story, Heavy Rain has plenty of unintentionally funny moments, including Ethan's Matrix-like leap to save his son, the "Shaun" glitch, or the "Jason!" mall scene.
Though Heavy Rain focuses on creating a deeply emotional and complex narrative; multiple plot-holes, inconsistent accents, and poor voice acting stops players from getting fully invested.
Also, many flaws in the gameplay and plot are more apparent when Heavy Rain is revisited. Having to perform quick time events to execute menial tasks becomes laborious on multiple playthroughs. Watching Ethan brush his teeth or dry himself is even less interesting the second time around.
While playing the main campaign again, it's clear that some subplots have no pay-off, especially Ethan's blackouts. Because Ethan's spells are never explained, it's obvious they were inserted into the plot, solely to cast doubt over the Origami Killer's identity. Although Heavy Rain was praised by critics for its storytelling, Ethan's blackouts felt like the laziest kind of red herring possible.
1. The Last Of Us Part II
Considering The Last of Us Part II won over 320 Game of the Year awards, it seemed like the last video game to generate outrage, especially since its predecessor was universally adored.
And yet, Naughty Dog's hyped follow-up garnered an unprecedented level of hatred. Although Part II's review-bombing was deeply unfair, many of the game's criticisms were pretty justified.
The sequel tries so hard to subvert expectations, it interferes with characterisation and the flow of the narrative. As a concept, it was clever to allow gamers to play as Abby, since it let them see things from the antagonist's point of view.
However, so much time is dedicated to Abby's backstory, it takes away from Ellie, who's supposed to be the protagonist. Even though Joel's death was meant to be devastating, it felt like a betrayal, since players barely spent an hour with him.
Although flashbacks are a great tool at fleshing out details, many of the interjected sequences ended up undermining the story. Characterisation is surprisingly undeveloped, to the point where key figures perform actions that contradict their values.
Now, story and characterisation isn't everything when it comes to gaming. (I mean, look at Super Mario.) But because the first instalment put so much effort into the writing, it's disappointing to see the narrative and character development in the sequel take such a U-turn.