10 Video Games That Killed Themselves Trying To Be Popular
It's what's on the inside that counts.
We're at a pretty polarising time in gaming right now. Your average triple-A game budget numbers into the hundreds of thousands, the vast majority of the risqué 'indie scene' is sneered at by those who strive for bigger, more traditional experiences, and somewhere in between are a handful of developers - CD Projekt RED, I'm looking at you - who manage to straddle the line between both.
Bigger project pitches require bigger investments, and bigger investments demand a return on sales. And how to you guarantee sales? Quality gameplay and writing? Of course not, formulas, son. Yes, quality control and beta testing all come later... once you've proven your desired game will make its money back.
It's why the likes of Call of Duty and Assassin's Creed die on the hill of innovation, doomed to established mechanics that tire in the long run. The fans yell for change, yet the publishers need to reign in the majority. That popular vote counts for a lot, and it's why for every Valiant Hearts or Grow Home from Ubisoft, you've got close to TWENTY Assassin's Creed games propping it up.
The sad truth is that truly unique ideas very rarely sell, and when the industry is so predicated on the flow of money greasing the wheels of progression, every idea must be 'bankable' - even if that means killing its soul in the process...
10. Binary Domain
Just look at that cover art. It didn't stand a chance.
Nobody cared that the venerable devs behind the phenomenal Yakuza series had written a story about the idea of androids infiltrating every level of our global hierarchy, the questions that arise from that and the insane plot twists that come thereafter.
Nope, Sega's marketing chaps realised it predominantly played like a cover shooter, and decided to go with what must be the single-most bland example of box art, ever. Such a plain image has nothing to do with the core themes of Binary Domain or its inherent Japanese-themed manga-weirdness.
Instead, it sold a paltry 20,000 units in its first year, and was resigned to the annals of history as 'just another Gears of War rip-off', when really, it was so much more.
9. Mass Effect 3
"But, erm, Mass Effect was already really popular"
True, but what does the person with all the money in the world want? More money. You can always be more liked, more recognised, more bankable.
To that end, EA dug their talons deep into Bioware's dev cycle, demanding not only that crucial plot-specific content be siphoned off as DLC, but that the game be more 'approachable' for wider audiences. Tons of pre-release interviews settled on how it was 'the perfect entry point in the series', as narratives be damned, somehow a concluding chapter in a personally-woven tale is the best place to 'hop on'.
This lead to an overwhelming action focus throughout, falling back on the idea of 'explosions sell' as turret sequences were added, 'defend the capture point' missions were part of the main story and Shepard was given a Gears-style dodge-roll as you spent more time mowing down enemies than ever.
Boss battles against giant Reapers, stab-happy melee attacks, portable nuclear missile-esque special weapons? It was all here, and the Mass Effect faithful wanted none of it, getting their collective keyboard warrior on and voting EA the 'Worst Company In America' in a Consumerist poll as a result.
8. Splinter Cell: Conviction
Sorry for the memory I'm about to dredge up here, but if you're anything of a Splinter Cell fan, seeing what Ubisoft wanted to do with the franchise back in 2007 was just painful.
Take a look...
Coming off the back of the phenomenal Chaos Theory and faltering slightly by releasing two versions of Double Agent that split the console generation divide in half, Conviction was expected to be their return to a suited-up Sam Fisher, assumedly embarking on more missions in the shadows.
Nope! Instead Splinter Cell was now... a brawler?! Fisher dispatched foes like something out of Dead to Rights, resulting in the worst fan-backlash that side of Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare. It resulted in that initial vision for the game being scrapped, as Conviction emerged being a strange hybrid of what Splinter Cell was and could be.
Fisher wouldn't get his trademark goggles for the majority of the campaign, and the melee sections from the above trailer transferred across into weirdly interactive 'torture events' where you grilled targets by bouncing their heads off the environment.
Clearly Ubisoft wanted to switch up the franchise's genre for that illusive 'wider appeal', but what emerged was a aimless mess, not rectified until the ace Blacklist in 2013.
7. Fuse
"The game started out with a much more stylized and campy direction. We were actually going for something on the level of Ratchet & Clank, except with humans [...] We would focus test the game in front of a lot of gamers, and get their opinion. These are people that regularly play PlayStation 3 and Xbox games. We started to discover that everyone thought this was a game for their younger brother. We would hear this from 12-year-olds. So we decided that we needed to make a game that had an older appeal." -Bryan Allgeier.
Doesn't that just break your heart a bit? Here we have the guys who made Ratchet & Clank (admittedly as a response to the rise in shooters, as Spyro was famously demoted for "not being able to carry a gun"), yet rather than have a natural progression between the two ideologies, we got this hokum.
Originally existing as Overstrike, Fuse was literally focus-tested to death. Everything from turret sequences to an arbitrary stop n' pop cover system made it in to appease the testers, and along the way, every original idea Insomniac had was cast to the wayside.
Considering the team ended up 'regressing' back to completely remaking Ratchet & Clank in 2016 - only for it to soar to spectacular heights both critically and commercially - it proves one thing; never listen to 12 year-olds. Ever.
6. Hitman: Absolution
Like a band you love making a more 'commercial' album, you can see disaster coming a mile off once the first single comes out. Sure they're going to potentially wrangle in some additional fans, but for those who love them for what they were, nothing is going to be the same for quite some time.
As was the case with Hitman: Absolution, its first appearances were a mishmash of controversial imagery (ninja-nun death squads brandishing blades and firearms) alongside playable sequences that pointed to a far more linear - and stop me if you've heard this one before - action-heavy focus.
Truth be told, the final product wasn't terrible, just broken. The new disguise system had enemies spot you from across the entire level at times, but in service of making 47 into a more brutal fighter rather like his big-screen counterpart, we got shorter levels, more story-filled cutscenes and the option to headshot groups of guards at once.
It was received so negatively, IO Interactive would take a full four years off making sure the followup was something special. Thankfully, Hitman 2016 is spectacular... it's just a shame we only get one level a month for the rest of the year.
5. Dark Void
"Okay, we've got cover shooting, we've got Nolan North, we've even got spaceships!""That's cool... kinda" said we gamers, "But what else you got?""...oh"
Such was the dialogue between the public and creatives, as Dark Void arrived at just the wrong time. By 2010 we'd seen a million and one cover shooters, and unless you were doing something fundamentally different like Uncharted or had the privilege of being the originator like Gears, nobody wanted to know any more.
Granted, Dark Void tried to have a 'vertical cover' system, meaning you'd fight enemies above, below and all around you - a neat idea, until it hit that such mechanics are incredibly jarring to keep track of. Regardless, by aping so many established and generic tropes, Dark Void didn't have any identity of its own.
Bonus gamer points if anyone can name the main character from this game in the comments, without looking him up...
4. Bulletstorm
A game whose initial footage had characters yelling they were about to "kill your dick", or referred to companions as "dicktits" was only ever going to go one of two ways.
Sadly, its own brand of 'attitude' was like some corporate reaction to memes and social media, and you can envision teams of executives throwing together random nouns and exclaiming "Random is funny, right?! That's what the kids are into?... Let's break for lunch" before flying off on their money-fuelled jetpacks.
And that was a real shame, because Bulletstorm was fun. Big, dumb, self-aware ridiculous fun. By combining a bunch of abilities, you could kill guys by lobbing a hotdog cart at them, only for "Sausage Fest!" to pop up.
Actually... yeah, it's probably best left well alone.
3. Assassin's Creed III
Getting to the top of the 'cool' and popular crowd resigns you to a plinth the size of your own feet. Even the slightest wobble or mistake and you're risking certain death, which for Assassin's Creed, came in the form of continuing the series once creator, Patrice Désilets, had left.
Having worked on the franchise from its inception all the through to Brotherhood (also known as 'the last truly great one'), Desilets departed in pursuit of smaller budgeted titles. Ubisoft weren't having any of that, and as they now had more creative control than ever over where the series could head, that meant doubling down on action set-pieces and hand-to-hand combat - essentially, the things that should only be an addendum to any stealth experience.
Suddenly Connor was a blade-swinging tank, able to cut through swathes of enemies with barely any input on your part. The entire experience was made extremely easy to play, yet threw tons of overblown setups and chase missions your way in an attempt to get pulses racing.
Throw in the Haytham Kenway intro segment that lasted way longer than it should have, and the narrative potential for AC was forever sacrificed in favour of quick-thrills and increased sales.
2. Dark Sector
Like Dark Void, Dark Sector's developers pulled together a pitch that, on paper, had promise.
A slick, throwable glaive that slices through enemies like butter in slow-motion? Check. A noted voice actor, Smallville's Michael Rosenbaum, taking up lead protagonist duties? Check. Even a tie-in comic to drum up some interest before launch? Double check, and don't spare the genetically-modified super-weapons.
Yes, Dark Sector still found something of an audience in its mashup of formulaic ideals, but like every other B-tier game on this list, it just didn't have any passion behind it. The story felt as though it had been assembled from a script torn and scattered across a room, the action was Gears of War through and through, and the awesome glaive played second fiddle when additional abilities made its use more of a fireworks display than a visceral limb-dissector.
Like Digital Extremes' other highly-anticipated title Pariah (remember that?), its subsequent parts just weren't assembled with enough confidence to leave a lasting impression.
1. Fracture
Dammit Fracture, you could've been awesome. Taking Red Faction's 'GEOmod' technology (without naming it as such) it would allow you to remix and destroy the terrain all around you, leading to any confrontation supposedly changing on the fly as you and your enemies dynamically got the drop on each other.
Inevitably, like the other games here that were 90% copycat and 10% originality, the bad far outweighed the good. Hero Jet Brody (yes really) was the embodiment of what a computer program would throw out if you typed in 'space marine', and whilst its mechanics were initially cool, once you realise only specific types of the world can be warped, it immediately loses its otherwise experimental hook.
Naturally the box art couldn't have been blander if it was Sam Worthington-endorsed vanilla yoghurt, resulting in zero impulse buys and a general reception that - despite LucasArts backing and music by the legendary Michael Giacchino - went down about as well as the new Ghostbusters reboot.
Let us know in the comments which game sacrificed it all in the pursuit of sales and popularity!