10 Video Games That Reward You For Being Evil - Commenter Edition
Revelling in the dark side.
Sometimes we all like being bad for a change, especially when you’re rewarded for it.
Now, this might be because the game itself is just about being an evil sumbitch or because you’re given a moral conundrum and decided to go down the dastardly route.
A little while ago we made a video full of our picks of games that give you a little something-something for being bad, but you guys came up with plenty of great ideas that we missed.
So let's take this one again with your suggestions in the hot seat.
--
10. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic
My favourite RPG of all time, Knights of the Old Republic, not only has a morality system and complex companion relationships, it has the light side and the dark side and the powers to go along with them, so what better place to start.
I think many of us would agree that one of the best powers in the game is Force Storm. Now, for the uninitiated, KOTOR’s force powers are either light or dark side assigned, and their force point cost will increase if you aren’t in their alignment. That means a light side Jedi will be able to cast Force Storm way less often than a dark side Jedi.
This does go the other way if a dark side Jedi wanted to cast a light side power but all the dark side powers are a lot cooler, anyway.
Drain Life, Death Field, Force Choke. Even just talking people into giving you their stuff and way more money. It’s a playground of useful powers and decisions for those who give their protagonist a little edge. In this way, KOTOR is absolutely a game that tempts you with the dark side, as it should since that’s narratively accurate in the context of the game and in keeping with the grander Jedi lore.
9. Bioshock
The menacing and intimidating world of Rapture has very few beings in it that don’t want to kill you on sight and the few that it does have you can kill on sight, if you want.
They’re children called Little Sisters so you might be asking why on earth you’d want to do that. Well, firstly, they’re hardly defenseless with a fearsome Big Daddy at their backs, though if you do manage to get through him you’ll have the choice to Harvest or Rescue them.
Harvesting kills the child for a large reward of ADAM, the precious resource you’ll need to acquire Plasmids, while saving the Little Sisters grants half this amount. Good guys may be inclined to save the innocent kids but you’re doing yourself a disservice in the short term as ADAM is the key to being stronger, and though you’ll be rewarded for being a Nice Guy with a teddy bar full of ADAM down the track, you may want it now.
You’ll probably feel guilty about it, especially in the game’s final moments, but there is massive short term gain in taking out the little ones early. That’s a really evil sentence, let's move on to something less horrifying.
8. Mass Effect
Sometimes being bad isn’t just about getting cool powers or more stuff, sometimes it’s about being hilarious. And for that we must give props to Renegade Shepard.
I’m two out of three games into my second Mass Effect playthrough and being nice can be a drag. You know what’s not a drag? Punching people in the face. And who deserves to be punched in the face? Honestly, half the people you run into in the Mass Effect trilogy. Usually all the things you really want to say and do to the crappiest scum of the universe are gated behind renegade actions, meaning if you do them then you’ll land yourself with evil points.
But if you want to be bad anyway, that door is fully opened to you so punch reporters and pick Morinth over Samara to your heart’s content.
Sure, you might have a bit of trouble on the war asset front and if you go all-out bad you might lose a lot of companions, but you’ll be hilarious, and isn’t that more important?
7. Goat Simulator
We’ve tried to mix things up using your suggestions of games that let you be bad and games that make you be bad. Goat Simulator, curiously, is the latter.
Commenter ido Rosenfeld Hacohen said Goat Simulator should be here and what’s a commenter edition if not a vehicle to get your suggestions into a full list. Especially if it means we get to talk about a game that casts you in the role of a trouble-making goat. Goat Simulator is designed to be a mess with janky physics, a deliberate lack of polish, and often broken animations.
But it kind of doesn’t matter since you get points for doing everything from headbutting NPCs to destroying the environment.
You can’t die so you’re basically just headbutting your way through this poor unsuspecting town, licking crap, terrorizing people, and being an all round nuisance. For points!
6. Prototype
Shifting from a very silly game to a far more serious one, you guys really wanted to see Prototype on this list.
The 2009 open-world action-adventure from Radical Entertainment pops you in the shoes of a bad guy from the outset. I mean, your power is to consume others and regain health by absorbing the biomass of your enemies. Or innocent people. Anybody will do.
You may have some good guy hesitation about taking out innocents when there are more than enough baddies to keep you souped up, but there are real advantages to consuming civilians. Absorbing people in the game worlds can give you new abilities, new memories to further the story, and/or the ability to shapeshift into them which can give you access to places that would otherwise be closed to you.
Of course, doing so would result in having to kill less people, but you can also use people as shields and projectiles so the body count is headed back up anyway.
5. Dragon Age: Origins
Dragon Age is absolutely a hero story but you have a lot of agency in how you want to act, who you want to befriend, and what kind of person you want to be.
That said, there’s no traditional morality metre tracking your overall saintliness or dastardliness. Your companions will approve or disapprove of your actions, but that also depends on their perspective on things. Killing a bunch of innocents will just result in losing your companions which isn’t great, but there are still substantial useful avenues being evil here.
It may be immoral to convince the werewolves to slaughter the Dalish but getting the lycans onside for the final battle is pretty freaking cool. There’s also a lot of fun you can have if you aren’t trying to be everybody’s best friend, not to mention evil choices often give you extra loot and money as well as resolving some quests faster. It is a lot easier to just leave that wounded soldier where he is than to help him get back to camp.
Anyway, it’s not evil, it’s just pragmatic. Or that’s what we can tell ourselves at least.
If you want to go full evil there’s always the Darkspawn Chronicles, an entire DLC that puts you in the certainly evil boots of a Darkspawn, aiming to decimate the good guys in an alternate version of history. Playing through it will also add powerful weapons and items to your main campaign so, there you go, rewarded for being the champion of evil itself and murdering your mates.
4. Tyranny
Obsidian Entertainment’s 2016 RPG Tyranny is all about being a not so great dude. Although, I suppose the name probably gave that away.
Essentially Tyranny has you fighting as part of an evil empire. You report to the overlord Kyros and it's your job to restore order after the world has been conquered. How you do that is up to you. You’ll basically be deciding between being murderously evil or cleverly calculated in your evilness. There are consequences for both, good and bad, so you’ll have to weigh up your options, but no matter what you do, this is a game that’s happy for you to go all out bad and make sure you get rewarded for it.
Exploring the nuance of evil is what attracted people to this game and the fact that it’s characterised beyond just ‘punch person’ or whatever choice is ‘not explicitly good’.
There’s pragmatically evil and then there’s diabolical and this game lets you go for either. In short, if you don’t feel like most games give evil paths enough of a look in this is the remedy for you.
3. Fable
You guys left me a lot of comments in the last video asking how I could leave out Fable, so I’m not going to ignore it this time. I mean it’s a game where you grow horns for being bad, it should be here.
Many commenters did bring up that you don’t really get good rewards for being evil, despite the fact that there are lots of opportunities to be evil. There are pretty equally good rewards whether you run around being a douchebag or practically Jesus.
There are some exceptions to that though, one of which is Skorm’s Bow, one of the best weapons in the game. You can only get Skorm’s Bow by earning enough evil points through sacrificing followers. Yep, you’ll have to recruit henchmen and then kill them off at the Chapel of Skorm at just the right time of day. So, not not evil.
Additionally, we need to talk about the endings of Fable 2 where you can revive a bunch of NPCs and get a statue, bring back your family and dog but leave the NPCs dead, or take a million gold.
I’m sorry, but I don’t see those NPCs coming out of that one.
2. Fallout 3
Another game where you don’t have to be evil, but you’re certainly rewarded if you’re up for it is Fallout 3.
You will be racking up good and bad karma as you go in this seminal RPG, and Bethesda appears to assume you want to be heroic so going the evil route is pretty much always easier, faster, and more rewarding. Blow Megaton sky high and live like a king at Tenpenny Tower, or grab game long perks like extra loot and caps for not worrying about people’s lives or feelings. A good handful of Fallout games will throw nice rewards your way for siding with what could certainly be considered to be the more unsavoury factions, but with enough dosh in your pocket to buy anything you want, you might not care. I mean, why bother with complicated NPC politics when you can kill them all and take their stuff?
You can also become a cannibal in, like, four different Fallout games, and engaging in cannibalism will restore HP or hunger depending on what game you’re playing. So, you know, that’s certainly one kind of reward for evil-doing.
1. The Sims
On our last video Zanotron commented “Basically the Sims should be Number 1, it's a pure evil game”, and not only is this your list, you’re right, so let’s get into it.
The Sims is an exercise in evil, and I’m not even talking about drowning your Sims in an inescapable pool or trapping them in dungeons to create endless artworks that you can sell for increasingly large amounts of money while almost entirely neglecting them. Okay, maybe I am talking about that second one. But it doesn’t stop there. Arguably the easiest way to get rich quick and land yourself a sweet mansion, if you aren’t using cheats, is to romance your way into a mansion baron’s home and then kill him off by whatever means you’d prefer.
You can assign your Sims a kleptomaniac trait and steal crap from your friends houses, there’s lucrative crime-dedicated career paths, and The Sims 4 features lifelong aspirations dedicated to deviance.
Whether in the trait makeup of your Sim, the way you treat them as a player, or the roleplaying of ‘what if I was just a huge jerk’, not many games let you be as evil for as big of a reward as The Sims, so here we are.