10 Video Games Way Darker Than Originally Advertised
None of us were ready for Bugsnax.
It's not exactly 'misleading advertising', but sometimes games can turn out a lot darker than what we initially thought.
After a slew of trailers and promo images, we usually think we have a decent idea of what a game is going to be like, and what the general vibe of it is.
After all, isn't that the purpose of a trailer?
On occasion though, these first glimpses purposefully omit the bits that are in there to shock you and turn it all around. A game that looks like it's about cute animals can suddenly be about a world-ending parasite. Something that looks like an anime-style puzzler following a dorky guy's pursuit of love can turn into a race against Hell itself.
There are downsides to this approach in that sometimes people don't like surprises, or more specifically, don't like the surprise your game has to offer. When done correctly though, a tone change or a different ending direction can pay off, lending the experience that extra emotional punch.
Because what's the point of a game if it doesn't absolutely ruin you emotionally??
10. Superhot
Starting off as a bit of meta fun, with your character being sent a cracked game file to play, things soon start to descend into madness for your in-game self.
As you progress through Superhot's rollout of levels, you are warned over and over to stop playing by mysterious text prompts. Of course, as is the nature of us humans, we continue playing despite these scary words.
By the time you reach the end of the game it has all gone to hell. The game your friend sent you in the beginning is much more than a bootlegged .exe, and it all plays out as an extended bit of commentary on the horrors of consumption.
Your player character puts themselves at increasing risk, becoming completely addicted to the game; at one point they remark that they are literally unable to stop playing. They dedicate their body, their resources and their mind to the game regardless of the cost, in the end taking the irreversible step that is killing themselves to become one with the software.
It speaks to the destructive possibilities of technology and the addictive draw of games, allowing a new title to take over your life. We don't, in real life, become one with a hive mind every time we get obsessed with a new game, but the metaphor is still poignant.
9. Catherine
It’s all fun and games being a little sheep-man climbing up a wall of blocks and cheating on your girlfriend... until you find out that your mistress isn’t what she seems.
Catherine follows main man Vincent as he struggles with his chronic indecisiveness, not knowing what (or who) he wants in life. He won’t marry his long-term girlfriend Katherine, but won’t break it off either, even when he starts sleeping with a beautiful woman he meets in a bar who also happens to be called Catherine.
This seems simple enough but then BOOM, Catherine is an ancient evil being and Vincent is her latest bit of prey.
He spends his nights trapped in a recurring nightmare in which he has to outrun the demons snapping at his heels, and if he’s unfortunate enough to fall victim to those demons in the dream he’ll die in real life.
Demons and ancient Sumerian gods certainly weren’t what we were expecting when we first looked at the trailer, laughing at a little man running up some squares and a big angry anime woman screaming at him from the summit.
8. Spec Ops: The Line
Nobody was expecting this to be a walk in the park, but the horrors and atrocities the game makes you confront still came as quite a shock to some players.
The truth behind what life is like in the game's post-disaster Dubai is just as horrifying as the decisions you're forced to make. People praised the game's ability to break away from the expected shooter bravado, instead making every kill feel as part of a larger atmosphere of horror.
The real unexpected kicker came with the revelation that our player character (Walker) has been hallucinating for a large part of the game, ever since he led a white phosphorus attack which led to the deaths of dozens of innocent civillians. Konrad, the supposed bad guy, has been dead for a long time and Walker created a version of him in his head to rationalise the terrible crimes he commits.
Whichever ending you get after this, they all come with the knowledge that you as the player were a part of the horrible decisions Walker made. This game was more than just a shoot-em-up warfare romp, it was a brutal commentary on responsibility and consequence in conflict.
7. Ecco The Dolphin
Even the name sounds nice, but those who have played this cetacean classic know to not fall for that. What you initially mistake as being a harmless, sea-faring experience has a few remarkably traumatising turns around the corner.
The experience starts as it means to go on, making you feel all cosy and safe with your fishy friends before violently sucking them all out to space whilst a hurricane rages - leaving you, you useless finny nobody of a dolphin, all alone.
In your quest to make sense of it all and bring your friends back, you encounter friends and foes alike, all of whom have the potential to make you wince.
The deep dark ocean is home to beasts of Lovecraftian nature, and if that wasn’t enough there’s also elements of space and time-travel, providing plenty of scope for more horrible creatures! Ecco’s journey is confusing and upsetting, and the pixelated graphics accompanied by droning (slightly haunting) music make the whole thing weirdly uncomfortable.
Spoiler alert, the game does have a happy ending, but that’s not the problem here. The story in itself isn’t inherently scary, but there’s some intangible nature throughout the game that makes this a real challenging trip.
6. Shadow Of The Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus is a beautiful, widely-adored game that packs a definite emotional punch.
If you isolate your knowledge to the pretty, sweeping landscapes and intricately-designed colossuses we saw in the first promos of the game you could mistake it for a simple ‘hunting monsters and getting the girl’ type deal. What you realise on playing it though is that not only do you not get the girl, you actually lead Wander to becoming somewhat of a monster himself.
You are destroying the colossuses in order to earn the assistance of Dormin, who claims he can return your love’s soul to her body, should you be able to carry out the oh-so-easy task of eliminating 16 big rocky boys.
Dormin, unsurprisingly, had ulterior motives all along, and by the time you’ve completed the challenge he has taken over, possessing your body.
In the end you lose your character as you know them, reborn as an infant, though Wander's gal pal does survive.
We'll take what we can get.
5. Undertale
Now this is an obvious one, especially because you could be forgiven for playing your whole way through Undertale without knowing that there’s a different, very unsavoury route you could’ve taken.
If you choose to do minimal to no killing of monsters, you can get the neutral or pacifist ending. Good for you, you lovely person! However, if you battle your way through the game slaughtering every monster you encounter- even seeking out more to slay for no reason other than your own sick curiosity - you have gone down the Genocide path.
You have to kill a certain amount of monsters in every location to achieve this and it is definitely a grind, but if you want a dark ending then this will deliver. Every character you meet you eventually slay, until you finally encounter Chara, the first human to fall to the monsters' world.
They talk of destroying this pointless world and moving onto the next, offering you the choice of whether to erase this one or not. Regardless of which one you choose, Chara has the ultimate control and your game is permanently marked.
Not only is it dark because it gives you the ability to commit a massacre, but because it doesn't let you forget it and move on either.
4. Fall Guys
This is yet another one of those games that lulls us into a false sense of security because the characters are cute little lumps. Their pill-shaped bodies and stubby little legs make for the perfect cover for the horrors beneath as revealed on the official Fall Guys Twitter account back in 2020.
They tweeted it out in September but really it feels like they should’ve waited until Halloween to make the big reveal, in which we see the malformed, compressed skeletal form inside the bulbous body.
The thing has no teeth and no ears, begging the question of how it eats and how it might hear fellow Fall Guys approaching?
No wonder they so often get thrown out into the abyss. There’s no way they could hear the ominous whoosh of the Big Yeetus launcher before they’re bonked into oblivion.
Considering most of the time these little guys don’t even get a crown (admit it, you’re not a good enough player to guide them there), their existence really is just one of constant suffering.
3. Bugsnax
Awww they’re little food-shaped buddies! Little friend-shaped foods! It’s all cute and lovely and a fun adventure.
WRONG. You could not be more wrong.
Playing as a journalist invited to Snaktooth island, your mission is to uncover the truth behind the disappearance of explorer Lizbert Megafig. When you look at all the cute little Bugsnax and the fuzzy, funny Grumpuses there’s no way you could foresee what would eventually become of them all.
Grumpuses consume the Bugsnax, each different ‘snax species transforming the Grumpuses’ bodies in different ways. It turns out this was a very bad thing because, as is revealed when the missing explorer is found as a horrible mutated beast, the Bugsnax are parasites.
They transform whoever consumes them in the long term into just another Bugsnax, and Lizbert can maybe consider herself lucky that she was transformed into their queen. Originally the ending was going to be even darker according to developer Kevin Zuhn; the plan was that the Grumpuses would eventually turn into ‘snax-craving zombies, devour each other and then you!
So even if this cutesy adventure turned a little more sour than expected, at least we know Zuhn spared us from a worse fate.
2. Inside
The colour palette and aesthetics of Inside alone are enough to warn you that you might be in for a rough ride, venturing through a big, scary dystopian landscape with just a small boy as your player character.
Even though most of the game revolves around a fairly dark concept, the real kicker comes at the end. After all the trials and tribulations of reaching the final chapter, there’s no happy resolution - instead our beloved little guy gets absorbed into a giant blob.
The alternate ending doesn’t provide much more hope, as instead there he ends up as one of the mindless zombies we’ve encountered throughout. How dark this ending is depends on the theory you believe about it.
Some think that the Huddle (AKA the big blob) has been controlling the boy the whole time, intending to use him as an agent for its release.
Alternatively some think that it’s all one big metaphor for agency and player control, in which we’re the malevolent force controlling the boy and to go for the alternate ending is to release him and end it all.
In truth, any way you look at it, it’s all a bit bleak.
1. Among The Sleep
What initially seemed like a fun horror romp actually turned out to be something a lot sadder when it was revealed that the whole thing was a metaphor for the child protagonist’s neglectful mother.
Initial trailers made it look like a pretty standard adventure horror: through the kid’s eyes we see a loving home, a treasured teddy bear and then, as it turns to night, an unfamiliar dark nightmare world.
Cavorting through dreams as a two year old child? Interesting! People were excited!
When the full game came out, it wasn’t too far from what was advertised. We still got our teddy bear sidekick and our nightmare traipsing, it was just that the ‘loving mother’ aspect became a bit more complicated.
Revealed in clues throughout the game, as well as one depressing yet hopeful final act, we see that the protagonist’s mother isn’t the textbook figure we expected from our first glimpses of her.
We can deduce that the child’s parents are fairly recently divorced and that the mother has one hell of a drinking problem. The monster all along has been his mum in her drunken rages, and his only salvation comes at the end of the game when he’s finally taken by the child protective services.
There are few things bleaker than child abuse, and this one really hit hard.