10 Video Games With Little Hope For Humanity
The ultimate feel-bad video games.
The vast majority of video games are escapism above all else, designed to help us forget our daily troubles and kick back by diving into a world quite unlike our own.
But games come in all shapes, sizes, and moods, and there are absolutely many that prefer to tackle more relatably human concerns, and in some extreme cases, remind you of humankind's worst collective traits.
As much as we are capable of so many great things, human beings are also responsible for so much suffering, both against nature and each other, such that the long-term forecast for our survival, er, isn't that encouraging.
This is palpably felt in these 10 video games, which whether examining the destructive power of guilt, our desire to watch the world burn, or our general inability to not fight one another, offer little in the way of hope or optimism for the human race.
Though there are certainly reasons to be hopeful for our future, true progress can't be made without confronting our problematic collective past and also those traits which hold us back from true peace and prosperity. These video games all stepped in to deliver some chilling reminders...
10. Silent Hill 2
Hit video game franchises don't get more oppressively bleak than Silent Hill, which in its masterful second outing delivered perhaps gaming's ultimate meditation on the destructive power of depression and guilt.
There's not a single happy or outwardly redeemable character to be found in Silent Hill 2, a game that confronts themes as cheery as euthanasia, mental illness, trauma, sexual abuse, punishment, and suicide.
To say that the game encompasses many of the ugliest aspects of human nature is an understatement, the titular town's pervasive fog serving as a metaphor for the toxic miasma from which humanity itself cannot escape.
While Silent Hill 2 does at least have multiple endings that culminate in varying degrees of "happiness" - relatively speaking, anyway - the most commonly accepted canon ending sees protagonist James drowning himself in order to be reunited with his dead wife.
Though there's no 100% canon ending, this is one that members of the game's dev team have most often pointed to being so, which is about as hopeless an ending as imaginable.
Silent Hill 2 gains much of its power through its personal, existential themes: James isn't The One or a particularly remarkable person, but simply a man going through a hellish personal odyssey.
Anyone who's ever dealt with overpowering grief or guilt will find it discomfortingly relatable.
9. The Sims
The Sims is perhaps the perfect embodiment of the idea that human beings just can't resist picking the wings off flies or burning ants with a magnifying glass.
In theory, The Sims allows players to virtually live out their most exorbitant domestic fantasies, buying a huge house, stocking it with a massive TV and swimming pool, starting a family, and you know, living the good life.
In reality, though, The Sims more often provides an opportunity for players to indulge their inner psychopaths, because why let your Sims enjoy happy, peaceful, prosperous lives when you can torture and murder them instead?
Who among us hasn't trapped Sims in a swimming pool until they've drowned, left them to burn to death in the kitchen, starved them, electrocuted them, or otherwise deprived them of a comfy death in old age?
It speaks to the notion that "this is why we can't have nice things."
Seeing others with more than we've got eventually becomes an irritation, and while in real life there's little you can legally do about that, in the world of The Sims you can vent your frustrations in a way that few psychiatrists would ever deem healthy.
The fact that developers Maxis suffered blowback from fans when The Sims 3 allowed Sims to climb out of the swimming pool even if you deleted the ladder - the traditional method for killing them - says it all, really.
8. Red Dead Redemption
In addition to being one of the most entertaining video games ever made, Red Dead Redemption is also one of the most low-key nihilistic in its portrait of the human race.
Rockstar's masterful open-world Western strips away the romantic sheen of the Old West mythologised in classic John Wayne movies and instead focuses on the ugly brutality of a lawless life.
The game's primary theme is the violent nature of people, embodied by both John Marston's actions throughout the game and his inevitably bloody demise at the end.
But this goes a level deeper with its epilogue, where John's son Jack comes of age and seeks revenge against his father's killer, ensuring the cycle of violence continues as a young man follows his father's own path of bloodshed.
The commentary across both Red Dead games seems to be that humanity has and always will be its own worst enemy, murdering for riches and sheer survival, and in the case of the player themselves, finding considerable entertainment value in it all.
7. Dead Space 3
If Red Dead Redemption explores humankind's violent past, then Dead Space considers its brutish prospective future.
The iconic sci-fi horror franchise takes place in the 26th century, where humanity has spread throughout the galaxy, but the outlook sure is bleak.
For starters, humanity was nearly rendered extinct by resource shortages on Earth, and they've found few truly viable planets elsewhere for long-term habitation.
But the real threat to humankind is in reality itself, the various human factions squabbling to gain control of the alien monoliths known as Markers, in turn unintentionally allowing the Necromorph plague to spread.
This grim outlook was cemented with Dead Space 3's Awakened DLC, which concluded on a cliffhanger where the Brethren Moons - basically gigantic Necromorphs - launch an attack on Earth, leaving humanity's fate up in the air ever since.
Considering that so much sci-fi comes from a place of optimism for humanity's inevitable future journey into space, Dead Space sees nothing but suffering and pestilence. Cheery.
6. Shadow Of The Colossus
As beautiful as it is, Shadow of the Colossus is also an ultimately depressing game about human nature and our attitude towards "the other."
The game is of course centered around Wander, who in order to revive his incapacitated love Mono, agrees to slay 16 mythical beasts - known as "Colossi" - for a mysterious entity named Dormin.
Neither Wander nor the player seems to much question this task even though the majority of the Colossi don't attack until aggravated, because it's a video game and killing is just part of the deal, right?
Ultimately it's revealed that the Colossi were holding the evil Dormin's soul at bay, and in killing them you've freed him. But beyond that, why is the life of Mono more valuable than that of the 16 Colossi?
This speaks to the notion of human exceptionalism or anthropocentrism, that humanity views itself as the most intelligent and worthwhile species in the universe, and we have the right to claim dominion, violently if need be, over all others.
This can be scaled down to consider the darker prejudices with which many view their fellow man still today, where anything outside of the "norm" is seen as an other to be viewed with suspicion and even treated violently.
As enlightened as we might think we are, Shadow of the Colossus is an unconventional metaphor for humanity's historic and continuing distaste for anyone or anything that looks or acts differently.
5. DEFCON
There's perhaps no more terrifying real-life example of humanity's self-destructive potential than the enormous body counts racked up by war, and the fact that so much of contemporary peace is sustained by the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction.
That is, don't nuke us and we won't nuke you, but if you do nuke us, then we'll go down swinging by firing all our nukes at you. Everybody loses.
This was superbly embodied by the 2006 Cold War RTS game DEFCON, a nuclear war simulator in which the player is tasked with obliterating as much of the enemy nation's landmass as possible for maximum destruction and human casualties, all while minimising their own losses.
A typical game will see millions of deaths incurred on both sides, serving as a brilliantly cynical commentary on how war turns mass death into a statistic, and how fighting wars with button presses and computer screens removes a lot of the basic human empathy from the situation.
In an era where drone strikes can kill hundreds of innocent civilians while piloted from thousands of miles away, it's a telling indictment of technology's ability to turn "conflict" into a glorified video game where emotion is largely a non-factor.
DEFCON highlights the utter Pyrrhic lunacy of "winning" a nuclear war, because in the immortal words of Frankie Goes to Hollywood, "When two tribes go to war, a point is all that you can score."
If humanity's future really rests on the idea that we don't blow the other side up so they don't blow us up, and we need nuclear stockpiles to really hammer the point home, then we truly are an awful, doomed lot. DEFCON captures this with horrifying exactitude.
4. Hatred
And yet, even if the concept of Mutually Assured Destruction holds firm, what's to stop some crazy, gun-totting a**hole killing a ton of people totally out of nowhere?
Hatred, to be clear, is not a good game - it's an ugly, mean-spirited isometric shooter in which players take control of a misanthropic mass murderer whose singular goal is to kill as many innocent human beings as possible.
Hatred is framed as a riposte to political correctness and games-as-art, produced to express no wider artistic intent while wearing its edgy nihilism on its sleeve.
And yet, it's hard not to play Hatred without thinking of all the mass shootings which occur on a devastatingly frequent basis in the U.S., and consider that Hatred is, perhaps unintentionally, tapping into something real.
Obviously the violence in the game is massively exaggerated and played for crass entertainment purposes, but its people-hating protagonist doesn't exactly feel a million miles away from real-life mass shooters - that is to say, typically angry white men.
As much as you might wonder why a game like Hatred really needs to exist at all, it manages to bottle the repulsive, impotent rage felt by a certain quarter of society, which without any warning can explode into violence inflicted upon innocent people just going about their day.
The fact that Hatred quickly became a best-seller really says it all.
3. This War Of Mine
Survival strategy game This War of Mine is an examination of war's obliterative eventuality not from the perspective of soldiers or someone tasked with pressing a big red button, but the everyday person caught in the crossfire.
The game takes place in a fictional, besieged city where players control a group of civilians attempting to survive amid a war.
You must manage their health, hunger, and psychological wellbeing to keep them alive until a cease-fire - which is timed to occur randomly - is eventually declared.
This War of Mine's first-rate morality system will ask players to make extremely vexing decisions about their characters' survival, and whether they dare risk their lives to help others.
On top of this, failing to manage a character's mental health sufficiently can result in them walking off and committing suicide, and in the event a character does die, they're perma-dead.
As a result, the game is absolutely dread-infused from first minute to last, capturing the abject desperation of a wartime scenario.
Some will shed their humanity in order to survive at any cost, but whatever the outcome, the fact that conflicts can have such colossal physical and spiritual costs is a terrifying testament to our cruel potential.
2. The Last Of Us Part II
The Last of Us is a frequently terrifying and unpleasant game for sure, but it at least has major flecks of hope, centered around the surrogate familial relationship forged between Joel and Ellie.
The Last of Us Part II beats that relationship to death with a golf club, quite literally, in its opening hours, for a sequel that while a masterful feat of technical engineering, is also one of the most relentlessly miserable and upsetting video games ever made.
Sure, there are fleeting flashbacks that remind us of sunnier times, but the bulk of the game's 25 hours are defined by a never-ending cycle of vengeance-fuelled violence.
That Ellie doesn't kill Joel's murderer Abby at the end is about as optimistic as Part II gets, but the fact that Ellie only accepts the soul-destroying nature of revenge after two-dozen hours of killing people hardly makes her a portrait of human virtuousness.
The game is better defined by the aggressive suspicion with which humans view each other, inviting the usual "Who are the real monsters?" post-apocalyptic hand-wringing.
Considering that the current pandemic has laid bare the ugliest and most selfish aspects of humanity, if a far deadlier plague such as the Cordyceps brain infection ever hit the real world, it's easy to believe the outcome would be similar to, if not worse than, the one depicted in these games.
1. Soma
Frictional Games' Soma is a brilliantly atmospheric survival horror game set on an underwater remote research facility, PATHOS-II, in the year 2104.
Protagonist Simon Jarrett, a man from 2015, wakes up on PATHOS-II and comes to learn that humanity was wiped out by a comet.
His initial task appears to be to escape the facility, but Simon then discovers he is actually a digital brain scan of the real Simon, which has been uploaded into the modified body of a PATHOS-II crew member.
Ultimately Simon's true objective is to secure the ARK, a digital black box containing a simulated world and all the brain scans of the PATHOS-II's crew, and send it off into space.
Simon completes his mission, but the ending is still a hugely depressing one: the last digital remnants of humanity are hurtling through the cold vacuum of space, and though a copy of Simon's consciousness is onboard, the Simon we've been playing as is left trapped and alone in the facility with no means of escape.
The idea that the immensity of human existence could end up boiled down to a black box flying through space is enough to have you waking up in a cold sweat.
Like everything else, on a long enough timeline humanity is destined to perish - but hopefully a long, long time from now.